Industries / Health / Healthcare / Direct primary care
Rules
The laws that decide whether a membership is insurance, and what public payers and tax rules let members and doctors do.
7
Milestones achieved, from 2004 to 2025.
1
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
2004
Extra fees for covered care
Since the Balanced Budget Act of 1997, a US doctor may sign private contracts with Medicare patients only after filing an affidavit promising to claim nothing from Medicare for two years; since a 2015 amendment the opt-out renews every two years unless the doctor gives notice. A doctor who stays in Medicare may charge a membership fee only for things Medicare does not pay for. In March 2004 the Office of Inspector General of the Department of Health and Human Services warned that "charging extra fees for already covered services abuses the trust of Medicare patients", citing a Minnesota physician who paid a settlement and agreed to stop selling $600-a-year contracts; in October 2004, 21% of the concierge physicians GAO surveyed had opted out of Medicare.
Lessonfor patients over 65, a membership practice must either leave Medicare altogether or sell only what Medicare does not cover.
Credit
US Congress; HHS Office of Inspector General; Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services
2007
Not insurance, by law
Washington's 2007 law (chapter 48.150 of the Revised Code of Washington) says registered practices that charge a monthly fee for primary care are not insurers, health carriers or health maintenance organizations; before 2007 they fell under the state's law for health care service contractors, by the Insurance Commissioner's account. The law requires a monthly fee, holds any fees paid more than a month ahead in trust and refunds them pro rata on cancellation, bars fees that vary by health status or sex, requires 60 days' notice of a fee change and allows one change a year, bars turning away or dropping patients solely for their health, and makes every agreement say "This agreement does not provide comprehensive health insurance coverage." Garrison Bliss says the law was passed so that Qliance could open and that it created the term "direct primary care". DPC Frontier now marks 33 states as having enacted such laws, and the law firm McDermott Will & Emery counts about half the states, many following a model act.
Lessona short state law settled whether a membership is insurance, the question that had put these practices under rules written for insurers.
app.leg.wa.govinsurance.wa.govblog.hint.comdpcfrontier.commcdermottlaw.com
Credit
Washington State Legislature; Qliance's founders
2010
Exchange plans may include it
Section 1301(a)(3) of the Affordable Care Act directs the Secretary of Health and Human Services to let a health plan sold on the new insurance exchanges provide coverage through a "qualified direct primary care medical home plan", as long as the plan meets every other requirement and the medical home's services are coordinated with the insurer. HHS's rule repeats the provision. Bliss says the Direct Primary Care Coalition was set up to get this provision into the law.
Credit
US Congress; the Direct Primary Care Coalition, by Bliss's account
2015
NHS practices may not charge
In England, the regulations for general medical services contracts say a practice "must not, either itself or through any other person, demand or accept from any of its patients a fee or other remuneration" for "the provision of any treatment whether under the contract or otherwise", apart from listed exceptions. An NHS family practice therefore cannot sell a membership for treatment to the patients on its own NHS list.
Credit
Department of Health, England (SI 2015/1862)
2023
Canada calls memberships charges
In March 2023 the federal health minister, Jean-Yves Duclos, wrote to every province that Canadians "must be able to access these services without having to pay out of pocket" and that federal transfers would be clawed back if charges continued. In July 2023, after Marda Loop Medical Clinic in Calgary announced memberships of $2,200 a year for one adult and $4,800 for a two-parent family, Health Canada said membership fees at private clinics are patient charges under the Canada Health Act and that "the ability for patients to purchase preferential access" runs contrary to it; Alberta ordered an investigation.
Lessonunder a single public payer, a fee that buys faster access to insured primary care counts as a charge the public system forbids.
Credit
Health Canada; Government of Alberta
2024
No fee for bulk billing
In Australia a doctor who bulk bills accepts the Medicare benefit as full payment. In April 2024 data from Cleanbill, a clinic-search company, showed 98 medical centres offering bulk billing to all adults only to those who paid a membership fee, averaging A$77.94 a year and ranging from A$60 in South Australia to A$167 in Tasmania. The Department of Health and Aged Care told the Royal Australian College of General Practitioners' newsGP that practices charging an annual administration or registration fee to guarantee bulk-billed services breach the Health Insurance Act, and the College warned that Medicare would recover the rebates from the doctors who billed them.
Lessonwhere a public payer pays per visit, a membership fee to get that visit is treated as an extra charge on it.
Credit
Cleanbill (count); Department of Health and Aged Care; RACGP
2025
HSA owners may join
A health savings account (HSA) is a tax-free medical savings account for people with a high-deductible health plan, and its owner may have no other health plan that pays before the deductible. In June 2020 the Treasury and the IRS proposed to treat membership fees as deductible medical expenses, but said a typical direct primary care arrangement "would constitute a health plan", so its member "generally is not eligible to contribute to an HSA". Public Law 119-21 of 4 July 2025, section 71308, changed the tax code: from January 2026 a direct primary care arrangement is not a health plan for this test, and HSA money may pay its fees, if the fees total no more than $150 a month for one person or $300 for an arrangement covering more than one, an amount indexed after 2026. The care must be primary care paid only by a fixed periodic fee, and procedures needing general anesthesia and prescription drugs other than vaccines do not count. The average fee Washington's practices reported for 2025, $185.65 a month, is above the single-person limit.
Lessonthe barrier for workers with HSA plans was a tax definition that treated a membership as a second health plan.
Credit
US Congress; Treasury and IRS (2020 proposal)
Watch for
Fees for nurse practitioner care
Health Canada's Canada Health Act Services Policy, in effect from 1 April 2026 and based on Health Minister Mark Holland's January 2025 letter, treats charges to patients for medically necessary services from other regulated professionals, such as nurse practitioners, as extra-billing or user charges when the same services are insured if a physician gives them. Health Canada's 2026–27 departmental plan, released on 13 March 2026, says it will help provinces implement the policy, and provinces are expected to report such charges from December 2028. The law firm BLG notes that many of Canada's large virtual care providers charge patients or employers for nurse practitioner services.
Achieved whena province changes its rules so that fee-charging nurse practitioner clinics stop charging for insured services, or Health Canada deducts transfer payments for such charges.
Claimed by
Health Canada, January 2025 and March 2026
Open
01
An open law table
A free, machine-readable table (CSV and JSON) of every US state's law on membership primary care, coded field by field: who may offer it, whether employers or plans may pay the fee, fee and refund rules, notice periods, required disclaimer wording, limits on visits or services, registration and reporting, and the regulator. Each cell cites the section it comes from, and a change log records every new law. Add the rules on membership fees for Canada's provinces, Australia and the four UK nations.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Agreements checked against law
A public study of at least 300 membership agreements that practices post on their websites, from at least 10 states with laws on membership primary care. Code each one for the terms its state's law requires and for what it says happens to prepaid fees and medical records if the practice closes. Publish the coding manual, the coded table and the rate at which each required term appears, state by state. The study describes documents; it gives no legal advice.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
An open law table
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A free, machine-readable table (CSV and JSON) of every US state's law on membership primary care, coded field by field: who may offer it, whether employers or plans may pay the fee, fee and refund rules, notice periods, required disclaimer wording, limits on visits or services, registration and reporting, and the regulator. Each cell cites the section it comes from, and a change log records every new law. Add the rules on membership fees for Canada's provinces, Australia and the four UK nations.
Why it is still open
The most detailed 50-state survey, McDermott Will & Emery's, is available only on request, and it notes that "disclaimers vary by state". DPC Frontier links each state's law and marks which have one, but codes no provisions.
Built with what exists
State legislature websites and Cornell's Legal Information Institute for statute text; CanLII and Australia's Federal Register of Legislation; an AI model to draft codes from the text, and a model that scores fixed-answer questions, such as Gemini Decision 1 (see the Note "A thousand questions, one pass"), for yes-or-no fields; a law student or lawyer to verify every cell.
First step
Code the 33 states DPC Frontier marks as enacted on five fields (who may offer it, employer payment, refund rule, notice period, disclaimer text) and publish the draft with citations.
Done looks like
All 50 states and DC coded on at least 12 fields with citations; a 10% sample recoded independently with at least 95% agreement; the table updated within 30 days of each new law during a test year.
Open 02 · the brief
Agreements checked against law
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public study of at least 300 membership agreements that practices post on their websites, from at least 10 states with laws on membership primary care. Code each one for the terms its state's law requires and for what it says happens to prepaid fees and medical records if the practice closes. Publish the coding manual, the coded table and the rate at which each required term appears, state by state. The study describes documents; it gives no legal advice.
Why it is still open
Most state laws regulate the content of agreements and many require specific disclaimers that differ from state to state, McDermott Will & Emery notes. Washington, for example, requires a set disclaimer sentence, 60 days' notice of fee changes and refunds of unearned prepaid fees. Washington's regulator received no complaints in 2025, so complaints do not show whether agreements comply, and no study checking posted agreements against the law was found. Forward's members learned how to get their records only after its clinics had shut.
mcdermottlaw.comapp.leg.wa.govinsurance.wa.govfiercehealthcare.com
Built with what exists
Agreements saved from practice websites with their dates; the statute text for each state; an AI model to tag clauses, checked by two human coders; Cohen's kappa for agreement between coders.
First step
Collect the agreements posted by the Washington practices in the Insurance Commissioner's 2025 appendix and code them against sections 48.150.030,.050 and.110.
Done looks like
At least 300 agreements coded; agreement between the two coders (Cohen's kappa) of at least 0.8 on a double-coded sample of 50; for each state, the share of agreements carrying each required term, and the share that say anything about records and prepaid fees on closure.