BRENNEN

Industries / Industrial equipment and services / IoT and industrial automation / Digital twins

Use in operations

In operations the twin helps run the real asset day to day: planning changes, rehearsing procedures and training the people who run it.

4

Milestones achieved, from 1970 to 2025.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1970

    Rescue steps rehearsed first

    After the Apollo 13 accident in April 1970, flight controllers wrote new procedures for the damaged spacecraft and checked them on the ground simulators before reading them up to the crew. NASA's Mission Operations Report of 28 April 1970 records that "Data were gathered from both the Cape and Houston simulators", and that draft procedures went to the simulator team "for simulator verification". One procedure, setting up a slow roll to spread the sun's heat (passive thermal control), took the crew much longer than it had in the simulator, and one method "did not work"; the controllers "later guessed" that it "could not overcome the CSM venting and the LM sublimator venting".

    LessonThe simulators did not reproduce the venting acting on the real spacecraft; a copy is only as good as its knowledge of the real thing's present state.

    ntrs.nasa.gov

    Credit

    the Flight Control Division and simulator staff of NASA's Manned Spacecraft Center

  2. 1987

    Operators tested on their plant

    Before 1987 the US Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) held that simulator experience was not equivalent to experience on a real reactor, citing "the few plant-specific simulators in existence at the time". In 1987 it required every operating test for an operator's licence to be given in a walk-through of the plant and on a simulator approved by the Commission or certified as a "plant-referenced simulator", one modelled on the operator's own plant, and required periodic performance tests of that simulator.

    govinfo.gov

    Credit

    US Nuclear Regulatory Commission

  3. 2016

    Control code tested first

    Virtual commissioning means running a machine's or plant's control software against a simulated version of it before the real one is started up. The German engineering associations VDI and VDE published guideline VDI/VDE 3693 Part 1, which defines the model types used for it, in August 2016. A May 2025 edition replaced it and "classifies it in the life cycle of an automated plant or machine".

    dinmedia.de

    Credit

    VDI and VDE

  4. 2025

    A car plant tried virtually

    BMW says its plant at Debrecen, Hungary, was "the BMW Group's first facility to be planned and validated completely virtually", with a "virtual start of production" in NVIDIA Omniverse in March 2023, and that all its vehicle and engine plants had been 3D-scanned since 2020, more than 7 million m² indoors. Just Auto reported on 1 October 2025 that BMW had opened the plant, "designed using virtual planning methods", with series production of the iX3 due by late October. BMW's 2023 announcement gave no figure for what virtual planning saved.

    newsroom.bmwgroup.comjust-auto.com

    Credit

    BMW Group; NVIDIA

Watch for

  1. Throughput gains from factory twins

    Siemens says PepsiCo is turning "select U.S. manufacturing and warehouse facilities" into 3D twins with Siemens' Digital Twin Composer, which is built with NVIDIA Omniverse libraries and is in early access. It says this "has already delivered a 20 percent increase in throughput on initial deployment", along with "10 to 15 percent reductions in capital expenditure" and the ability to identify "up to 90 percent of potential issues before any physical modifications occur". The release gives no method for these figures.

    Achieved whenPepsiCo or an outside auditor publishes before-and-after throughput for named lines, with how it was measured.

    news.siemens.com

    Claimed by

    Siemens, January 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Predicted against measured throughput

    A public record that pairs, for each planned change to a production or packing line, the throughput the twin predicted beforehand with the throughput measured for four weeks afterwards.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Savings checked at the meter

    For buildings run with a twin, a table that pairs each recommended change (a new setpoint, schedule or control sequence) with the energy saving the twin predicted and the saving measured at the meter afterwards, corrected for weather.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Predicted against measured throughput

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public record that pairs, for each planned change to a production or packing line, the throughput the twin predicted beforehand with the throughput measured for four weeks afterwards.

Why it is still open

Siemens' throughput figure for PepsiCo comes with no published method, and BMW's announcement of its virtually planned plant gave no figure for the result.

news.siemens.comnewsroom.bmwgroup.com

Built with what exists

discrete-event simulators such as the open-source SimPy or JaamSim, or commercial ones such as Siemens Plant Simulation and FlexSim; OpenUSD for line layouts; output counts from the line's controllers read over OPC UA; a Git repository that time-stamps each prediction before the change.

  1. First step

    Ask a university learning factory, a production line kept for teaching, to log its next planned change together with a prediction made in SimPy.

  2. Done looks like

    At least ten changes at three or more sites, each prediction recorded before its change, each result measured over four weeks, and the error between them published, misses included.

Open 02 · the brief

Savings checked at the meter

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

For buildings run with a twin, a table that pairs each recommended change (a new setpoint, schedule or control sequence) with the energy saving the twin predicted and the saving measured at the meter afterwards, corrected for weather.

Why it is still open

IES says its twin of Queen Margaret University, made "by synchronising physics-based simulation with BMS data", "identified potential annual energy cost savings of around £64,000", about 11% of the site's energy spend. The university says that "As improvements are implemented, we will validate performance in operation".

iesve.comtheenergyst.com

Built with what exists

OpenEEmeter, the open-source Python package hosted by LF Energy that computes weather-corrected metered savings by the CalTRACK methods; EnergyPlus or OpenStudio models; half-hourly or hourly meter data; ASHRAE Guideline 14's methods for stating uncertainty.

  1. First step

    Ask a university estates office that runs a building twin for last year's list of changes and the meter data from before and after each one.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 30 changes across at least five buildings, each with its predicted saving recorded before the change and its metered saving after at least three months, with confidence intervals, and the ratio of measured to predicted savings published.