BRENNEN

Industries / Food, farming and forestry / Agriculture and farming / Dairy

Manure and water

Storing the dung and urine that cows produce, spreading it back on fields as fertilizer, capturing the gas it gives off, and keeping its nitrogen, phosphorus and germs out of streams, lakes and groundwater.

5

Milestones achieved, from 1991 to 2019.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1991

    EU caps manure per field

    The European Union's Nitrates Directive (Council Directive 91/676/EEC), in force since 12 December 1991, makes member states mark the farmland that drains into waters holding more than 50 mg of nitrate per liter, or at risk of it. In those zones, livestock manure may add at most 170 kg of nitrogen per hectare per year. The European Commission's first full evaluation of the directive, published on 15 July 2026, found it "overall effective and relevant".

    environment.ec.europa.eu

    Credit

    the Council of the European Communities, which adopted it; the evaluation is the Commission's own

  2. 2003

    Dairy farmers sign stream accord

    In May 2003 the dairy company Fonterra signed the Dairying and Clean Streams Accord with central and local government. About 12,000 farmers, 99% of Fonterra's suppliers, had their farms assessed in the first year. Its targets included bridges or culverts at half of regular stock crossings by 2007 and 90% of waterways on dairy farms protected from stock by 2012. By December 2011 the crossings had reached 99%, but three of the five targets were still unmet, and an independent survey commissioned by the Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry gave different figures from the accord's own count of 84% of farms keeping dairy cattle out of waterways (RNZ).

    LessonA voluntary agreement that counted its own progress missed most of its targets, and an outside survey disputed its numbers.

    scoop.co.nzrnz.co.nz

    Credit

    Fonterra, with the New Zealand government and regional councils

  3. 2011

    A lake caps farm nitrogen

    To protect the water of Lake Taupō in New Zealand, Waikato Regional Council's 2011 Regional Plan Variation 5 gave each farm in the catchment a yearly nitrogen allowance that it can trade, and a public trust funded with NZ$81.5 million by central, regional and local government buys and retires allowances to bring the total 20% below 2001–2005 levels. Motu, a New Zealand research institute, calls it "the world's first agricultural non-point-source water-quality cap and trade scheme" (non-point means the pollution seeps from whole fields rather than leaving through one pipe).

    LessonA cap holds the total but moves nitrogen to its most profitable use: in the early market, seven trades were one expanding dairy farmer buying allowances from others.

    econpapers.repec.orgageconsearch.umn.edu

    Credit

    Waikato Regional Council and the Lake Taupō Protection Trust; evaluated by Duhon, McDonald and Kerr (Motu, 2015)

  4. 2016

    California targets dairy methane

    California's Senate Bill 1383 of 2016 set a target to cut methane from dairy and livestock 40% below 2013 levels by 2030, a cut of 9 million tonnes of CO2e a year (carbon dioxide equivalent, a common scale for the warming caused by different gases). The state chose grants over rules: the California Department of Food and Agriculture (CDFA) has funded 142 digester projects with $228.2 million through its Dairy Digester Research and Development Program; a digester covers a manure lagoon or tank and captures the gas for fuel. A University of California, Riverside study of 98 dairies, using eight years of satellite and aircraft data, found fewer strong methane plumes after digesters were installed (Environmental Research Letters, March 2026).

    LessonGrants alone were not enough: CARB estimates that current programs could reach about 5 million tonnes a year by 2030, at least 4 million short, and in January 2026 began collecting input for a first livestock methane rule, with a Board vote planned by 2028.

    ww2.arb.ca.govcdfa.ca.goveurekalert.org

    Credit

    the California Legislature (SB 1383, by Lara); CDFA; the California Air Resources Board (CARB)

  5. 2019

    Dutch court halts nitrogen permits

    Most Dutch ammonia, a nitrogen gas that harms nature when it settles, evaporates from livestock manure in barns and on fields (RIVM, the Dutch public health and environment institute). On 29 May 2019 the Council of State, the country's highest administrative court, ruled that the national nitrogen program (PAS) broke the EU Habitats Directive, in a case brought by the nature group Werkgroep Behoud de Peel against six permits for farms in Noord-Brabant. The program had granted permits against nitrogen cuts that were expected in future. RIVM reports that permits for housing, infrastructure and farm expansion were in effect put on hold.

    LessonA permit system cannot spend pollution cuts that have not yet happened.

    raadvanstate.nlrivm.nlrivm.nl

    Credit

    the Council of State (ECLI:NL:RVS:2019:1603); Werkgroep Behoud de Peel

Watch for

  1. Digesters' full methane cut

    CDFA says the 142 projects it has funded will cut 24.8 million tonnes of CO2e over their expected lifetimes. The UC Riverside study found that digesters usually work, but that leaks of around 1,000 kg of methane an hour, against 20–100 kg an hour typical of an open manure lagoon, plus spikes during construction, are at times large enough to offset the gains.

    Achieved whenmeasurements by someone outside the program, covering the funded dairies and counting leaks and venting, confirm the estimated cut.

    cdfa.ca.goveurekalert.org

    Claimed by

    California Department of Food and Agriculture, October 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Log home biogas use

    Small temperature loggers fixed to the stoves of smallholder dairy households that feed their animals' dung into a home biogas plant (a sealed tank where dung rots without air and gives off gas for cooking). The logs show, day by day, whether the stove was lit and for how long. Set three months of logs beside each household's survey answers and a monthly look at the plant, and publish how often the survey and the logger disagree.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Satellite leak search in Idaho

    Run an open methane-mapping method over every scene that NASA's EMIT instrument, an imaging spectrometer on the International Space Station, has taken over southern Idaho's dairy region. List every candidate methane plume within 1 km of a dairy or manure digester with its estimated rate, and state for each scene how small a leak it could have shown.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Log home biogas use

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

Small temperature loggers fixed to the stoves of smallholder dairy households that feed their animals' dung into a home biogas plant (a sealed tank where dung rots without air and gives off gas for cooking). The logs show, day by day, whether the stove was lit and for how long. Set three months of logs beside each household's survey answers and a monthly look at the plant, and publish how often the survey and the logger disagree.

Why it is still open

Counts of working home biogas plants come from interviews and inspection. A face-to-face survey of 2,559 Nepali households with biogas plants found 54% of the plants abandoned, judged from a questionnaire and visual inspection (Lohani, Shrestha, Jeuland and Kammen, November 2025). Temperature loggers have measured how often wood stoves are used for more than a decade: one study logged 80 Guatemalan homes for 2.6 years and told days of use from days without use with 0.97 sensitivity (Ruiz-Mercado, Canuz and Smith, Biomass and Bioenergy, 2012). A search found no study that has logged biogas stoves this way.

energyaccess.duke.edupmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

Built with what exists

Stand-alone temperature loggers of the kind used in cookstove studies, such as Thermochron iButtons, fixed to the stove body away from the flame, so nothing on the gas line is touched; the peak-detection method of Ruiz-Mercado and colleagues, written in Python; KoboToolbox, a free survey app that works offline, for the household questions.

  1. First step

    Fix loggers to five biogas stoves for two weeks and compare the logged cooking events with a simple cooking diary kept by each household.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 50 households in at least two districts, each logged for 90 days; for each household, the share of days the stove was used; and the share of households whose survey answer (working or abandoned) disagrees with the logger, with all data released under an open license.

Open 02 · the brief

Satellite leak search in Idaho

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

Run an open methane-mapping method over every scene that NASA's EMIT instrument, an imaging spectrometer on the International Space Station, has taken over southern Idaho's dairy region. List every candidate methane plume within 1 km of a dairy or manure digester with its estimated rate, and state for each scene how small a leak it could have shown.

Why it is still open

Plume surveys of dairies have centered on California. The California Air Resources Board's flights from 2016 to 2024 found 879 plumes at dairy and livestock operations, and CARB says digester leaks are "more concentrated and localized and therefore easier to detect" than a dairy's spread-out emissions. Idaho was the third-largest US milk state in 2025, with 350 dairy operations centered in the Magic Valley (Idaho Farm Bureau, citing USDA data). In November 2026, NASA's own EMIT methane plume product, which covers August 2022 to August 2026 and lists only plumes confirmed by human review, held no plumes over the Magic Valley, although EMIT had taken 366 scenes there; Carbon Mapper's public plume catalog held none either; and a search found no published satellite or aircraft study of Idaho dairies. EMIT can see dairy plumes: Carbon Mapper's catalog holds eight manure plumes from EMIT over California's Central Valley.

ww2.arb.ca.govidahofb.orgearthdata.nasa.gov

Built with what exists

EMIT radiance data, free from NASA Earthdata; JPL's open emit-ghg code (Apache 2.0 license) for mapping methane; the US EPA's AgSTAR Livestock Anaerobic Digester Database, whose downloadable file lists digester projects and their sites; Carbon Mapper's public catalog to compare with; Python.

  1. First step

    Download ten EMIT scenes over the Magic Valley from NASA Earthdata, run emit-ghg on one, and mark the digester sites from AgSTAR's file on the result.

  2. Done looks like

    Every EMIT scene over the region from August 2022 onward processed, and the scene list, the code, a detection limit for each scene and every candidate plume (date, place, estimated rate and uncertainty, nearest dairy or digester) all published; each candidate checked by a second analyst before it is tied to a site.