BRENNEN

Industries / Technology / Social media / Creator economy

Subscriptions and tips

Subscriptions and tips are payments that fans send straight to a creator, by the month, by the post or during a live stream, with the platform and the payment system each taking a share.

7

Milestones achieved, from 2013 to 2024.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 2013

    Fans pay creators monthly

    The musician Jack Conte had millions of people watching his YouTube videos but, in Patreon's words, "only hundreds of dollars" reaching his bank account, so in 2013 he and his friend Sam Yam started Patreon, where fans pledge a small amount each month or each time a creator releases a new work. By December 2017 NPR reported that more than 50,000 artists were supported by more than 1 million patrons.

    patreon.comnpr.org

    Credit

    Jack Conte and Sam Yam (Patreon)

  2. 2016

    Paid messages in live chat

    On 27 June 2016 Twitch introduced Cheering: chat messages that carry Bits, animated emotes that viewers buy, so that a viewer can support a streamer and be seen doing it in the chat. YouTube's Super Chat and Super Stickers work the same way: viewers buy chat messages that stand out in color and can stay pinned at the top of a live chat, and YouTube's help pages say the payments are non-refundable.

    blog.twitch.tvsupport.google.comsupport.google.com

    Credit

    Twitch; YouTube

  3. 2017

    A per-pledge fee, withdrawn

    Until late 2017 Patreon grouped a patron's pledges into one charge, and of a $1 pledge Patreon kept 5 cents, a payment company 2 to 10 cents, and the artist 85 to 93 cents. In December 2017 Patreon announced that each pledge would be charged separately, with a fee of 35 cents plus 2.9% added on top, so a $1 pledge would cost the patron $1.38 and someone giving $1 a month to 15 podcasts would pay over $20 instead of $15. After protests from creators and patrons, founder Jack Conte wrote "We messed up" and withdrew the change.

    LessonA fixed charge on each payment falls hardest on the smallest pledges.

    npr.org

    Credit

    Patreon

  4. 2017

    Newsletters behind a paywall

    On 18 July 2017 Chris Best and Hamish McKenzie announced Substack, a service that lets a writer publish a newsletter and charge readers for it, arguing that "the time has again come for journalists to thrive on payments from readers". They cited earlier one-person publications such as Andrew Sullivan's The Dish, which had 30,000 subscribers paying $20 a year in 2013. Substack said in March 2025 that it had passed 5 million paid subscriptions, up from 2 million in 2023, and in July 2025 it raised $100 million at a valuation of about $1.1 billion, as reported by TechCrunch and The New York Times.

    on.substack.comtechcrunch.com

    Credit

    Chris Best and Hamish McKenzie (Substack)

  5. 2021

    Banks set the content rules

    On 19 August 2021 OnlyFans, a subscription site where creators keep 80% of what fans pay, said it would ban sexually explicit content from 1 October, citing pressure from "banking partners and payout providers". Its founder, Tim Stokely, told the Financial Times "the short answer is banks" and named BNY Mellon, Metro Bank and JPMorgan Chase, as Time reported. Six days after the announcement OnlyFans suspended the ban, saying it had "secured assurances" from its banking partners and payout providers.

    LessonWhoever moves the money can decide what creators may sell.

    time.comeff.org

    Credit

    OnlyFans; its banks

  6. 2022

    No tipping for minors

    In May 2022 four Chinese bodies, the Central Civilization Office, the Ministry of Culture and Tourism, the National Radio and Television Administration and the Cyberspace Administration of China, ordered live-streaming platforms to stop selling minors any top-ups, virtual gifts or payments used for tipping. Platforms were also barred from letting anyone under 16 stream, had to remove tipping leaderboards within a month, could no longer rank or promote streamers by tips alone, and could allow each streamer no more than two head-to-head "PK" contests between 20:00 and 22:00. In April 2026 the Cyberspace Administration issued a further notice requiring platforms to offer tipping limits and reminders, bars on tipping for children under eight, and separate rules for older age groups.

    LessonOnce tips are a main source of a platform's income, regulators treat them as consumer spending.

    news.cnnews.cn

    Credit

    Central Civilization Office; Ministry of Culture and Tourism; National Radio and Television Administration; Cyberspace Administration of China

  7. 2024

    Apple's cut of fan pledges

    In August 2024 Apple told Patreon to bill memberships bought in its iPhone app through Apple's in-app purchase system by November 2025 or risk removal from the App Store. Apple takes 30% of in-app purchases, and 15% once a subscription has run more than a year, and creators could raise their prices on iPhone or absorb the fee. After a US court ruled on 30 April 2025 that Apple could no longer stop apps linking to other ways to pay, Patreon's US app added a web checkout and dropped the 2025 deadline. In December 2025 an appeals court ruled that Apple may in future charge a reasonable commission on such linked purchases and sent the amount back to the district court, MacRumors reported, citing Reuters. In January 2026 Apple set 1 November 2026 as the new deadline for the creators still on Patreon's older billing, which Patreon called "the third such change from Apple in the past 18 months". Under Japan's Mobile Software Competition Act, Apple announced different terms in December 2025: a commission of 15%, or 10% for small developers and older subscriptions, on purchases made on a website linked from an app.

    LessonWhat a creator keeps depends on the phone and the country the fan pays from.

    techcrunch.commacrumors.comtechcrunch.commacrumors.comengadget.comapple.com

    Credit

    Apple; Patreon; the US District Court in Epic v. Apple

Watch for

  1. Ten billion dollars from fans

    Patreon says that "since 2013, fans have sent $10 billion to creators on Patreon".

    Achieved whenthe total is confirmed in audited accounts or by an independent study of payments.

    patreon.com

    Claimed by

    Patreon, on its About page as read in November 2026

  2. Half earn beyond ads

    YouTube says that of the channels in its Partner Program that earned five figures (US dollars) or more in 2024, over half also earned money from sources other than ads and YouTube Premium, such as Super Chat and channel memberships.

    Achieved whenan outside survey of creators or an independent study of payments finds a similar share.

    youtube.com

    Claimed by

    YouTube, citing its internal data, 2025

Open

  1. 01

    Fan checkout, country by country

    A recorded record of how a fan pays a creator on an iPhone under different rules: in the US, where apps may now link to a web checkout; in Japan, under the terms Apple set in December 2025; and in one country where Apple's standard terms apply. Cover five apps that sell memberships or tips (for example Patreon, Substack, YouTube, Twitch and Discord), using test accounts and a test creator page you own, and stop before the final payment so that no money moves.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Tipping limits, tested

    A check of the spending protections around tips and paid chat on eight live-streaming apps (for example Twitch, YouTube, TikTok LIVE, Kick, Facebook, Bilibili, Douyin and SOOP): whether an adult user can set a daily or monthly cap, whether the app warns before a large tip, what it says about refunds for mistaken tips, and how this compares with the limit and reminder functions China required in April 2026. Use only your own adult test accounts and send no tips.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Fan checkout, country by country

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A recorded record of how a fan pays a creator on an iPhone under different rules: in the US, where apps may now link to a web checkout; in Japan, under the terms Apple set in December 2025; and in one country where Apple's standard terms apply. Cover five apps that sell memberships or tips (for example Patreon, Substack, YouTube, Twitch and Discord), using test accounts and a test creator page you own, and stop before the final payment so that no money moves.

Why it is still open

Patreon's iPhone rules changed three times in 18 months, a US appeals court said in December 2025 that Apple may charge a reasonable commission on linked purchases, and Japan's terms charge different commissions for in-app purchases and for purchases on a linked website. Searches found Apple's announcements and press reports about single apps, but no side-by-side record across apps and countries.

engadget.comapple.comtechcrunch.commacrumors.com

Built with what exists

an iPhone with an Apple account in each country (held by volunteers there); a test creator page with a $1 tier; iOS screen recording; Apple's published commission terms; a spreadsheet.

  1. First step

    Record the US flow in the Patreon and Substack apps for your own test page.

  2. Done looks like

    A table for 5 apps in 3 countries showing whether a web option is offered, how many taps it takes to reach the pay button, the price shown, and the share Apple's published terms would take on each path, with the recordings, repeated every three months.

Open 02 · the brief

Tipping limits, tested

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A check of the spending protections around tips and paid chat on eight live-streaming apps (for example Twitch, YouTube, TikTok LIVE, Kick, Facebook, Bilibili, Douyin and SOOP): whether an adult user can set a daily or monthly cap, whether the app warns before a large tip, what it says about refunds for mistaken tips, and how this compares with the limit and reminder functions China required in April 2026. Use only your own adult test accounts and send no tips.

Why it is still open

China's 2026 notice requires tipping limits and reminders, while YouTube's help pages say Super Chat payments are non-refundable. A search of arXiv found papers on recommending streams to raise gifts, such as MMBee in 2024, but no audit of spending controls; a GitHub search was rate-limited and returned nothing.

news.cnsupport.google.comarxiv.org

Built with what exists

test accounts on each app; the apps' own settings and help pages; iOS and Android screen recording; a checklist built from the items in China's notice; a spreadsheet.

  1. First step

    Go through the settings of YouTube, Twitch and TikTok with one test account and list which offer any spending cap.

  2. Done looks like

    A published table of 8 apps against 5 checks (cap available, cap default, warning before a large tip, refund route, age gate on tipping), with a recording for each cell, repeated after six months.