BRENNEN

Industries / Technology / Social media / Creator economy

Brand deals

Brand deals are the payments, gifts and free products that companies give creators to feature what they sell, and the rules on telling viewers about them.

7

Milestones achieved, from 2016 to 2024.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 2016

    A label for paid promotion

    On 4 October 2016 YouTube added an optional setting that puts a line of text on a video, for the first few seconds anyone watches, saying it contains a paid promotion. Creators could add it to old videos without losing their view counts. YouTube said "there is no global disclosure standard" and told creators to follow the law where they are. A 2026 study by Chen Sun and three co-authors, covering 2 million YouTube videos from nearly 540,000 creators, found most videos with affiliate links failed the FTC's disclosure standards, and found standardized platform disclosure features "highly associated with improved compliance".

    blog.youtubearxiv.org

    Credit

    YouTube

  2. 2017

    Owners who posed as fans

    Trevor Martin and Thomas Cassell, two gaming YouTubers whose channels each had millions of subscribers, posted videos of themselves winning on CSGO Lotto, a site where people gambled with what the FTC called "in effect a virtual currency" of items from the game Counter-Strike: Global Offensive. They did not say they were its president and vice president and each owned 42.5% of it. The company also paid other influencers $2,500 to $55,000 each to promote it. In September 2017 they settled with the US Federal Trade Commission (FTC), in what PC Gamer reported the FTC called its "first-ever complaint" against individual social media influencers; the FTC also sent warning letters to 21 influencers, after 90 "educational letters" earlier that year.

    LessonOwning the brand is a connection that has to be disclosed, just like being paid.

    ftc.govftc.govpcgamer.com

    Credit

    US Federal Trade Commission

  3. 2019

    Sixteen celebrities sign pledges

    On 23 January 2019 the UK's Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) said it had secured formal commitments from 16 celebrities, among them the singers Ellie Goulding and Rita Ora, to say clearly when they had been paid, or given or lent products, for what they endorse. The investigation began in August 2018. The CMA counts gifts and loans as payment, sent warning letters to other celebrities, and published a quick guide for influencers, agents and brands.

    gov.uk

    Credit

    Competition and Markets Authority

  4. 2019

    Fake followers ruled deception

    Devumi sold followers, likes and views from bot accounts and "sock-puppet" accounts, in which one person poses as many, some copying real people's photos and profiles. In January 2019 New York's attorney general settled with the company and said it was "the first finding by a law enforcement agency that selling fake social media engagement and using stolen identities to engage in online activity is illegal." In October 2019 the FTC sued its owner, German Calas Jr., alleging more than 58,000 sales of fake Twitter followers, more than 4,000 of fake YouTube subscribers and more than 32,000 of fake YouTube views. Devumi had stopped trading in mid-2018.

    LessonThe follower counts that set a creator's price can be bought, so brands need ways to check them.

    ag.ny.govftc.gov

    Credit

    New York Attorney General Letitia James; US Federal Trade Commission

  5. 2021

    A livestream seller's tax bill

    Livestream selling is a live video show in which a host demonstrates products that viewers buy on the spot. On 20 December 2021 tax authorities in Hangzhou, China, fined Huang Wei, the host known as Viya, 1.34 billion yuan (about US$210 million) in back taxes, late fees and fines for hiding income and declaring personal pay as income of several sole proprietorships in 2019 and 2020. China Daily reported that she typically drew 10 million viewers to one show; Al Jazeera, carrying Bloomberg's report, called it the biggest fine yet for an online seller.

    LessonA creator who sells at the scale of a store is taxed and checked like one.

    chinadaily.com.cnaljazeera.com

    Credit

    Hangzhou Taxation Bureau; State Taxation Administration of China

  6. 2023

    A law for paid influence

    France's law n° 2023-451 of 9 June 2023 requires the words "Publicité" (advertising) or "Collaboration commerciale" (commercial collaboration) on promotions, and "Images retouchées" (retouched images) or "Images virtuelles" (virtual images) where they apply. It requires a written contract between an influencer and an agent or advertiser, and it targets promotion of cosmetic surgery, financial products, alcohol and gambling. A March 2024 report by the National Assembly's economic affairs committee says the DGCCRF, France's consumer protection agency, checked 212 influencers in 2023 against 94 in 2022 and found 96 in breach, a rate it gives as 46.8%, mostly for not saying a post was commercial. Only one of the five decrees the law called for had been adopted by 13 March 2024.

    LessonThe European Commission told the committee that the fixed wording goes beyond the EU's 2005 Unfair Commercial Practices Directive, so a national influencer law has to fit EU consumer law.

    assemblee-nationale.fr

    Credit

    French Parliament; DGCCRF

  7. 2024

    One in five disclosed

    On 14 February 2024 the European Commission and consumer authorities from 22 EU member states, Norway and Iceland published a sweep, a coordinated check, of posts by 576 influencers. By their count 97% posted commercial content but only 20% systematically disclosed it as advertising, and 38% did not use platform labels such as Instagram's "paid partnership" toggle, writing words such as "collaboration" (16%) or "partnership" (15%) instead. They earmarked 358 influencers for further investigation.

    ec.europa.eu

    Credit

    European Commission and national consumer authorities, with Belgium's Directorate General for Economic Inspection

Watch for

  1. Sponsorships up by half

    Gospel Stats, an analytics firm, reported YouTube sponsorships up 54% year over year, and agencies told Digiday the average partnership had roughly doubled in a year.

    Achieved whena second tracker, or YouTube's own disclosures, report a comparable rise with a published method.

    digiday.com

    Claimed by

    Gospel Stats, as reported by Digiday, November 2025

  2. Labels added by machine

    YouTube's branded content policy says that if its systems detect a video with branded content the creator has not disclosed, "we may automatically apply a branded content label to your video and notify you," and that a creator who thinks the label is wrong "may have the option" to certify that the video holds no branded content and override it. An agency blog, Relevant Audience, reports that YouTube announced the change on 3 September 2026 with no launch date and no list of countries.

    Achieved whenan outside test with sponsored videos left undeclared, or YouTube's own published counts checked by someone else, shows the labels being applied.

    support.google.comrelevantaudience.com

    Claimed by

    YouTube, September 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Test clips for hidden ads

    A public test set of at least 1,000 short vertical videos, made for the purpose, in at least five languages, about half of them sponsored. Every person shown is a consenting actor or a generated face that resembles no real person, and every brand is invented. Each clip is labeled with whether it is sponsored and how (paid, gifted, affiliate link, own brand), how it discloses (spoken, on-screen text and at what second, a caption hashtag, a platform tag, or not at all), and whether that disclosure meets each of three rule sets: the FTC's, the UK's as the CMA and the advertising code apply it, and France's 2023 law. The set scores AI models on two jobs: finding sponsored clips with the disclosure cut out, and judging whether a disclosure meets each country's rule.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Disclosure built into the edit

    An open-source step in the editing workflow, run before upload, in which a creator marks a project as paid, gifted, affiliate or own brand and picks the countries where it will be seen. The tool burns in the wording and placement each country's rules ask for, such as "Publicité" or "Collaboration commerciale" for France, reminds the creator where a spoken disclosure is needed, and writes a report listing each rule applied and the regulator text it comes from.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Test clips for hidden ads

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public test set of at least 1,000 short vertical videos, made for the purpose, in at least five languages, about half of them sponsored. Every person shown is a consenting actor or a generated face that resembles no real person, and every brand is invented. Each clip is labeled with whether it is sponsored and how (paid, gifted, affiliate link, own brand), how it discloses (spoken, on-screen text and at what second, a caption hashtag, a platform tag, or not at all), and whether that disclosure meets each of three rule sets: the FTC's, the UK's as the CMA and the advertising code apply it, and France's 2023 law. The set scores AI models on two jobs: finding sponsored clips with the disclosure cut out, and judging whether a disclosure meets each country's rule.

Why it is still open

Published test sets are posts, not videos. Haoyang Gui and colleagues tested AI models on 1,143 Instagram posts in 2025, and CHASM, released in 2026, holds 4,992 posts from the Chinese app Rednote. The largest video study, of 2 million YouTube videos, measures real channels rather than offering a shared test set. Regulators still check by hand: the EU's 2024 sweep covered 576 influencers.

arxiv.orgarxiv.orgarxiv.orgec.europa.eu

Built with what exists

phone cameras and signed releases, or a video generator with invented faces; OpenAI's Whisper or ElevenLabs Scribe v3 to transcribe speech (the Note "Fewer word errors" covers Scribe v3); open multimodal models such as Qwen2.5-VL and hosted models through their APIs; Label Studio for labeling.

  1. First step

    Script and film 20 clips, 10 sponsored and 10 not, in English and French, and label them under the FTC's rules and France's 2023 law.

  2. Done looks like

    at least 1,000 clips in at least five languages, each labeled by two annotators with their agreement reported; precision and recall for at least three models on each job and each rule set; clips, labels and scoring code published under an open license.

Open 02 · the brief

Disclosure built into the edit

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An open-source step in the editing workflow, run before upload, in which a creator marks a project as paid, gifted, affiliate or own brand and picks the countries where it will be seen. The tool burns in the wording and placement each country's rules ask for, such as "Publicité" or "Collaboration commerciale" for France, reminds the creator where a spoken disclosure is needed, and writes a report listing each rule applied and the regulator text it comes from.

Why it is still open

When YouTube added its on-screen label in 2016 it said "there is no global disclosure standard" and left creators to follow local law. The EU's 2024 sweep found 38% of influencers skipped platform labels and used words such as "collaboration" instead. A search for editing tools that apply country-specific disclosure at export found guidance pages but no such tool.

blog.youtubeec.europa.eu

Built with what exists

FFmpeg and its drawtext filter for burned-in text; the Python scripting interface of DaVinci Resolve, or a standalone FFmpeg step for any editor; a rule table drawn from the FTC's guidance, the UK advertising code and France's 2023 law; a language model to draft wording, with every rule checked by a person.

  1. First step

    Write the rule table for the US, the UK and France, then burn a French label into one test clip with FFmpeg's drawtext filter.

  2. Done looks like

    rules for at least five jurisdictions, each tied to a regulator's text; 40 made-up projects exported through the tool and checked by two people who know the rules, with at least 95% passing every rule for every country chosen; the tool and rule table published.