Industries / Consumer goods / Consumer electronics
Software and updates
This work writes the software that runs phones, computers, TVs and speakers, keeps it updated after the sale, and decides what it collects about the people using it.
7
Milestones achieved, from 2007 to 2025.
2
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
2007
An update breaks modified iPhones
On 27 September 2007 Apple released iPhone software 1.1.1, a 152.3 MB download installed through iTunes, and warned that phones altered to work on networks other than AT&T's might become inoperable after installing it. Fortune reported that some of those phones stopped working, others lost programs their owners had added, and some phones that had never been modified failed too.
LessonAn update can disable a device as well as improve it.
Credit
Apple
2017
Android splits into two layers
On 12 May 2017 Google announced Project Treble, a fixed "vendor interface", checked by a Vendor Test Suite, between Android's operating system and the low-level code that chip makers write for each phone. A phone maker can then move a phone to a new Android release without waiting for the chip maker to rework its code, and Google said every new device launched with Android O, its 2017 release, or later would use it.
LessonIn May 2011 ten phone makers and carriers, among them HTC, Samsung, Motorola, Verizon and Vodafone, had promised updates for 18 months after a phone's release; seven months later PC Magazine asked each of them how it was going and called the answers "not at all good." A promise did not shorten the chain of companies every update passed through, so Google changed the software's structure.
Credit
Iliyan Malchev and Google's Project Treble team
2017
Consent for TV viewing data
In February 2017 Vizio, a TV maker, agreed to pay $2.2 million to settle charges by the US Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and New Jersey that its TVs had recorded what owners watched, "second-by-second", since February 2014 without on-screen notice, and that it sold the data to advertisers and data brokers. The software doing this was automated content recognition (ACR), which matches what is on the screen against a library of known programs; the complaint quoted Vizio saying it captured up to 100 billion data points a day from more than 10 million TVs. Vizio had to delete data collected before 1 March 2016 and get consent in future.
LessonVizio's general counsel said the case made clear that "all smart TV makers should get people's consent before collecting and sharing television viewing information.".
Credit
US Federal Trade Commission and New Jersey Division of Consumer Affairs
2018
Patch dates that skipped patches
On 13 April 2018 Security Research Labs (SRLabs) presented a study of Android phones showing that some makers' monthly updates left out security fixes that the phone's stated "security patch level" said it had; it counted, maker by maker, the missing critical and high-severity patches, using tests built into its SnoopSnitch app. After talks with phone makers SRLabs removed faulty tests and said its first results had shown the gap as larger than it was.
LessonA patch date on a settings screen is a claim that only an outside test can confirm; Google answered by adding scans of device images for missing fixes to its approval of each Android build.
Credit
Stephan Zeisberg and Ben Schlabs, SRLabs
2024
Other app stores on iPhone
In January 2024 Apple said that, to comply with the EU's Digital Markets Act (DMA), iPhone users in the 27 EU countries could install apps from "alternative app marketplaces" from iOS 17.4 in March 2024, with every app still passing a baseline Apple review it calls notarization. AltStore PAL, one such marketplace, lists itself as available in the EU, Japan and Brazil. On 23 April 2025 the European Commission fined Apple €500 million for App Store rules that kept developers from steering buyers to cheaper offers elsewhere, one of its first two fines under the DMA.
LessonThe law opened the iPhone to other stores, and the terms of that opening became the next dispute.
Credit
European Commission; Apple; AltStore
2024
An app rebuild removes features
On 7 May 2024 Sonos, which makes wireless speakers, soundbars and headphones, replaced its control app with a rebuilt one. The new app lacked sleep timers, alarms and queue editing, and owners reported speakers that worked only some of the time. Chief executive Patrick Spence apologized in July with a schedule for restoring features; on its third-quarter earnings call he put the cost at $20 million to $30 million and said two products ready for launch were delayed.
LessonSpence said his "push for speed backfired": an app released before it could do what the old one did took functions away from hardware owners already had.
Credit
Sonos
2025
Windows 10 support ends
Microsoft stopped regular security updates for Windows 10 on 14 October 2025. Windows 11 requires newer processors and a TPM 2.0 security chip, so many working PCs cannot move to it: Canalys, a market analyst, estimated in December 2023 that about 240 million PCs, roughly a fifth of those running Windows 10, could become waste, and US PIRG, a consumer group, put the figure at up to 400 million. As read in November 2026, Microsoft's page offers home users security-only updates until 12 October 2027, free if the PC syncs its settings, or for 1,000 Microsoft Rewards points or US$30.
LessonThe hardware a new system requires decides how long older machines get security fixes.
Credit
Microsoft
Watch for
Apps use the phone's model
Apple's Foundation Models framework, announced on 9 June 2025, lets app developers call the language model of about 3 billion parameters that runs on iPhones, iPads and Macs as part of Apple Intelligence, offline and with no charge per request. Apple's researchers say they compressed the model to 2 bits per weight (each of its numbers stored in two bits) with small losses in quality, and they compare its scores with those of similar models, all on Apple's own tests.
Achieved whenan independent party publishes measured quality, speed and battery use for the on-device model on shipping devices, and the results match Apple's.
Claimed by
Apple, June 2025, with figures revised in July 2025
Texas makes TVs ask first
On 15 December 2025 the Texas Attorney General sued Sony, Samsung, LG, Hisense and TCL, saying their TVs used ACR to record what owners watched, including through cable boxes and other HDMI-connected devices, without informed consent. Samsung settled first, agreeing to stop collecting ACR data from Texans without explicit, informed consent and to rewrite its on-screen prompts (reported 2 March 2026); LG agreed in May 2026 to a pop-up disclosure and a clear opt-out. The cases against Sony, Hisense and TCL were pending in May 2026.
Achieved whenan outside traffic test shows Samsung TVs on Texas connections sending no ACR data until the owner agrees, and LG TVs sending none once the owner opts out.
Claimed by
Samsung and LG, in settlements with Texas, March and May 2026
Open
01
ACR tests across TV platforms
A public, repeated test of when smart TVs send ACR data. For eight TV brands and platforms, the five makers Texas sued plus Vizio, Roku TV and Amazon Fire TV, record the TV's network traffic while it plays the same test reel from an antenna, a streaming app and an HDMI input, with ACR switched on and then off, and repeat after every firmware update.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
What works when servers vanish
A public table, for 30 popular TVs, soundbars, wireless speakers and headphones and their phone apps, of which advertised features still work in three states: online, with no internet at all, and with only the maker's own servers blocked, which stands in for the day a maker shuts its servers down. Repeat after each firmware update.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
ACR tests across TV platforms
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public, repeated test of when smart TVs send ACR data. For eight TV brands and platforms, the five makers Texas sued plus Vizio, Roku TV and Amazon Fire TV, record the TV's network traffic while it plays the same test reel from an antenna, a streaming app and an HDMI input, with ACR switched on and then off, and repeat after every firmware update.
Why it is still open
The one independent audit of TV makers' own ACR traffic found, by Gianluca Anselmi and colleagues (IMC 2024), tested only Samsung and LG, in the UK and the US; it found that ACR ran even when the TV was used as a plain screen over HDMI, and that opting out stopped traffic to ACR servers. An earlier study (2019) measured third-party trackers in TV apps on Roku and Fire TV, not the makers' ACR. Texas's suits named three more makers, and the 2026 settlements promise changes that no one outside has measured.
Built with what exists
A Raspberry Pi 5 set up as a Wi-Fi access point (hostapd) that logs every DNS lookup and connection with tcpdump and Wireshark; the IMC 2024 paper's black-box method for finding ACR traffic; a laptop as the HDMI source playing public-domain video; Android Debug Bridge (ADB) or an infrared blaster to step through each TV's menus the same way on every run; new test accounts and no one's personal data. An AI agent can drive the menu script and label each capture, checked by a person; the Note "All twenty times" covers testing whether an agent does the same task the same way every time.
First step
Set up the access point, connect one second-hand TV, and log a week of DNS lookups with ACR on and then a week with it off.
Done looks like
Eight brands and platforms, each tested in three input modes with ACR on and off, published as bytes sent to ACR servers per hour of viewing, with the scripts and capture summaries; every test rerun after each firmware update for 12 months; the Samsung and LG settlement terms checked from a Texas internet connection.
Open 02 · the brief
What works when servers vanish
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public table, for 30 popular TVs, soundbars, wireless speakers and headphones and their phone apps, of which advertised features still work in three states: online, with no internet at all, and with only the maker's own servers blocked, which stands in for the day a maker shuts its servers down. Repeat after each firmware update.
Why it is still open
Owners learn which features depend on a maker's servers only when something breaks. Sonos's May 2024 app rebuild left alarms and sleep timers missing for months on speakers that had offered them before. US PIRG keeps a running tally, in pounds of e-waste, of devices it says companies retired by ending software support or cutting off features, but it does not test what keeps working. A search for published offline tests of TVs, soundbars or headphones found none; the nearest was a maker's list of soundbars that have no internet connection at all.
Built with what exists
An OpenWrt router with per-device firewall rules and Pi-hole to block chosen domains; an Android test phone with each companion app; a checklist taken from each product's box and manual; an AI agent that drives each companion app through ADB and records the screen, so every run repeats the same steps (see the Note "All twenty times"); a camera for the device itself.
First step
Block one soundbar's maker domains at the router, try each feature in its manual, and film the results.
Done looks like
30 devices from at least 10 brands, each listed feature scored works, partly works or fails in each of the three states, every result backed by a short video, and the whole set rerun after two firmware updates.