Industries / Food, farming and forestry / Food and beverage processing / Confectionery
Molding and coating
Molding and coating gives chocolate its final form: tempering it, which means cooling and stirring it so that the fat sets in its one desirable crystal form and the chocolate comes out glossy and snaps; filling molds and hollow shells; coating centers such as creams and biscuits in a curtain of chocolate, called enrobing; and printing shapes.
5
Milestones achieved, from 1903 to 2012.
2
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1903
Machines that coat centers
Centers such as creams and caramels were first covered by hand. At Cadbury's Bournville works, women dipped each center on a fork into a small bowl of chocolate held at 88 °F (31 °C), Knapp described in 1920. Covering machines "invented in 1903", called enrobers, carried centers on a wire belt through a small curtain of liquid chocolate. Knapp doubted that their chocolates ever looked quite as good as hand-dipped ones, and in 1923 he still wrote that the best covering was done by hand.
Lessoneven with enrobers, covering and boxing chocolates remained the most labor-heavy part of the industry in 1923, by Knapp's account.
Credit
Knapp names no inventor; his picture of an enrober came from Savy Jeanjean & Co. of Paris
1966
Six crystal forms named
By 1923 tempering machines held the temperature of chocolate going into molds within narrow limits to give gloss, color and snap, Knapp wrote, but why this worked was not known. In 1966 Wille and Lutton, mainly by X-ray diffraction, identified six crystal forms of cocoa butter, numbered I to VI by rising melting point, and found that chocolate is normally in form V. They noted that bloom, the gray-white film on old chocolate, had not been seen without form VI, but called it premature to say that form VI is bloom.
Credit
Wille and Lutton, in the Journal of the American Oil Chemists' Society
1992
Shells set by cold stamps
Hollow shells for filled chocolates were made by shaking out: a mold was filled with at least twice the chocolate needed, shaken and turned over, and the excess drained off and reused, so the shell's thickness depended on how runny and how well tempered the chocolate was. Lars Aasted of Aasted-Mikroverk in Denmark patented in 1992 a stamp cooled to between −15 °C and −30 °C that is lowered into a small dose of chocolate in each mold cavity for 2 to 3 seconds and sets a shell of even thickness, using about 10% more chocolate than the shell holds. A 1994 patent removed the need to scrape excess chocolate off the shell rims. Google Patents counts 59 patent families citing the 1994 patent, and lists the 1992 European patent as revoked. The food technology chair of TU Dresden, with the Fraunhofer Institute for Process Engineering and Packaging and German industrial research funding, later studied how cold-formed praline shells keep in storage.
Credit
Lars Aasted, Aasted-Mikroverk
1999
Seeding with stable crystals
Ordinary tempering cools and reheats chocolate until enough stable crystals form in it. Erich Windhab of ETH Zurich and Yuantong Zeng filed a patent in May 1999 for instead mixing in a prepared suspension of very small cocoa butter crystals of form VI, dosed at 0.01 to 0.2% of the chocolate's mass. The patent says seeded chocolate can be worked at about 34 °C, against about 31 °C for chocolate tempered the usual way, and reports better resistance to bloom; Bühler now holds it. In 2013 Lisa Svanberg and colleagues in Sweden, with Windhab as a co-author, found that well-done seeding gave a dense, even structure that best slowed fat bloom.
Credit
Erich Windhab and Yuantong Zeng; Bühler
2012
Chocolate printed in layers
Liang Hao, an engineer at the University of Exeter, founded Choc Edge in April 2012 to sell printers that build chocolate shapes layer by layer from a digital design, after research funded by the UK's Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council. ConfectioneryNews calls it the first firm to launch a 3D chocolate printer. By 2014 its Choc Creator V2 cost £3,888 and took 5 to 15 minutes per praline, and Hao said the printers were not meant to compete with mass production by molding. In February 2020 Barry Callebaut's Mona Lisa decorations brand opened a 3D printing studio that it says prints thousands of pieces at a time in real chocolate.
Lessonprinting has found its place in short runs of personalized pieces, while molding still makes the volume.
news-archive.exeter.ac.ukconfectionerynews.comconfectionerynews.com
Credit
Liang Hao, University of Exeter; Choc Edge; Barry Callebaut
Watch for
Molding lines changed in minutes
Bühler says modules of its ChocoX molding line, which can make solid and filled bars, pralines, one-shot products (shell and filling deposited together) and aerated chocolate, can be added or exchanged within 30 minutes, and that the line cuts the time to bring a new product to market by four to five months.
Achieved whena confectioner running a ChocoX line publishes its measured changeover times and product launch times, or an outside party measures them.
Claimed by
Bühler (András Somfai, head of product management for confectionery), May 2026
Enrobers that adjust themselves
Sollich, a German maker of tempering machines and enrobers, says it is extending the self-analysis it gave its tempering machines in 2023 to its enrobers, with the aim of adjusting process settings automatically to cut operator effort and keep quality steady. It published no results.
Achieved whena user or an outside tester reports measured coating-weight variation and operator interventions before and after the change.
Claimed by
Sollich, May 2026
Open
01
An open temper meter
An open-hardware temper meter: a small sample cup cooled at a fixed rate, a temperature probe, and software that reads the sample's cooling curve and reports how well tempered the chocolate is, published with plans, code and a comparison against a commercial meter.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Robot dipping by demonstration
A low-cost robot arm that dips chocolate centers on a fork the way a skilled hand dipper does and marks the top, taught from a few dozen recorded demonstrations instead of being programmed.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
An open temper meter
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
An open-hardware temper meter: a small sample cup cooled at a fixed rate, a temperature probe, and software that reads the sample's cooling curve and reports how well tempered the chocolate is, published with plans, code and a comparison against a commercial meter.
Why it is still open
Temper is how much of the fat has already set in the stable form before the chocolate goes into molds, and machine makers sell meters that read it from a cooling curve; Sollich calls its Tempergraph "a proven solution for automatic measurement of the tempering degree" and publishes no method. When Thomas Hocker's group at the Zurich University of Applied Sciences modeled chocolate cooling with the chocolate maker Felchlin and ETH Zurich, it found that commercial inline measuring products did not meet its needs and built its own logger. In a 2016 thread on The Chocolate Life, a forum for chocolate makers, members described how a cheap meter could be built from a thermocouple and a cooled cup, but nobody posted a working design or results. A GitHub search on 18 November 2026 found home tempering machines and thermometers, not a meter.
Built with what exists
a Peltier cooling block; a fast thermocouple or thermistor; a microcontroller such as a Raspberry Pi Pico; Python for fitting the curve.
First step
Log the cooling curves of well-tempered, under-tempered and untempered chocolate in a cooled cup, and check that the three curves differ.
Done looks like
on 50 samples tempered to different degrees, the open meter ranks them in the same order as a commercial temper meter (a rank correlation of at least 0.9), and the design is published under an open hardware license.
Open 02 · the brief
Robot dipping by demonstration
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A low-cost robot arm that dips chocolate centers on a fork the way a skilled hand dipper does and marks the top, taught from a few dozen recorded demonstrations instead of being programmed.
Why it is still open
Enrobers have coated centers since 1903, yet Knapp judged hand-dipped chocolates to look better. Searches of arXiv on 18 November 2026 found no robot that dips or hand-finishes chocolates. Hugging Face holds recordings of low-cost arms picking up and placing chocolates and chocolate pies, such as skkuprism/SO101-single-distribute_chocolatepies (March 2026), but none of dipping. The nearest build found, a student poster hosted at Worcester Polytechnic Institute, describes a programmed arm of LEGO parts made to dip skewered strawberries in chocolate. Robot models that learn a task from a handful of demonstrations became openly available in 2026.
Built with what exists
a desktop arm such as the SO-101 with Hugging Face's LeRobot software (see the Note "No download"); an open robot model such as NVIDIA's GR00T 2 (see the Note "Five demonstrations per task") or Runway's Praxis-1 (see the Note "Open robot model weights"); a small heated bowl of tempered chocolate; a kitchen scale.
First step
Record 50 demonstrations of a person steering the arm to dip centers, train a policy on them, and test it on 20 centers.
Done looks like
200 centers dipped in filmed runs, at least 90% with a coating weight within 10% of target, and the appearance of the pieces scored blind against hand-dipped ones by ten people.