Industries / Transport and vehicles / Automotive / Collision repair
Insurance claims
Insurance claims work decides how a crash repair is paid for: whether the car is fixed or written off, which parts and shop are used, what labor costs, and what the owner is owed.
5
Milestones achieved, from 1999 to 2025.
1
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1999
A billion-dollar parts verdict, reversed
Parts made by companies other than the carmaker, called aftermarket or non-OEM parts (OEM: original equipment manufacturer), cost less but raised doubts about fit and quality. In Avery v. State Farm, a nationwide class of policyholders said in Williamson County, Illinois, that the insurer broke its contracts by specifying non-OEM crash parts on repair estimates. After a trial that began on 16 August 1999, the courts below entered judgments totaling $1,186,180,000, which the appellate court cut to $1,056,180,000. On 18 August 2005 the Illinois Supreme Court reversed: it held that certifying the nationwide class was an abuse of discretion, that specifying non-OEM parts did not breach the policies, and that the damages were too speculative.
LessonThe court would not treat every copy part as inferior, so the argument moved to whether each part fits and performs.
Credit
Illinois Supreme Court
2001
Repaired cars lose value
Diminished value is the loss in resale price of a car that has a crash history, even after a good repair. In State Farm v. Mabry, decided on 28 November 2001, the Supreme Court of Georgia held that an insurer's option to repair "serves only to abate, not eliminate" its liability for the difference between the car's value before and after the loss, and upheld an order that State Farm develop a method for assessing such claims.
Credit
Supreme Court of Georgia, opinion by Justice Robert Benham
2019
Shops lose the labor-rate case
In 2014 body shops in several states sued State Farm and other insurers in federal court, and the cases were combined in Florida (MDL 2557). The shops said the insurers used direct repair programs (DRPs), in which a shop accepts the insurer's terms in return for referrals, and State Farm's "market rate" survey, which they said set the rate just above the median shop's, to hold down labor rates for all shops, with other insurers matching State Farm. On 4 March 2019 the full Eleventh Circuit affirmed dismissal of the antitrust claims, and in 2020 a panel dismissed most of the related cases on the same reasoning: following a competitor's price without agreeing in advance is not an agreement.
LessonIn the US, matching the largest payer's labor rate is lawful unless shops can show an agreement, so rates are fought shop by shop and in state law.
Credit
US Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit
2025
A higher total-loss line
A car is a total loss when the insurer writes it off and pays its value instead of repairing it. Rhode Island's House Bill 6053 became law on 5 July 2025 without the governor's signature. In its Substitute A text, an insurer may not declare a car a total loss when the repair would cost less than 80% of its fair market value, up from 75%, though the owner may choose a total loss between 75% and 80%. Insurers must also pay for documented procedures that the carmaker or systems such as ALLDATA, RepairLogic, CCC Repair Methods or I-CAR list as required or recommended.
Credit
Rhode Island General Assembly
2025
One claim in four totaled
CCC counted 23.1% of US claims in its systems, across all kinds of loss, flagged as total losses in 2025, up 0.8 points and "a new high watermark", with a steady rise since 2021 in driveable cars declared total losses. Cars 7 to 12 years old made up almost 41% of total-loss valuations, up from 33.4% in 2020.
LessonAs cars age and repairs cost more, more damaged cars are written off than before, including some that can still be driven.
Credit
CCC Intelligent Solutions, from claims in its systems
Watch for
AI estimates for one country
Solera says its Qapter and Intelligent Estimating tools will be built into the platform of Najm for Insurance Services, which manages motor accident reporting and claims across Saudi Arabia, under a partnership announced on 18 August 2026.
Achieved whenNajm or Saudi Arabia's insurance regulator reports how many claims were estimated this way and how the estimates compared with final repair costs.
Claimed by
Solera and Najm, August 2026
Open
01
Part prices under the clause
An open monthly panel of carmaker list prices for the visible parts covered by the EU's new repair clause, which ends design protection for parts used to restore a car's original look (front doors, bonnets, front wings, bumper covers, headlamps, rear quarter panels) for about 30 widely sold models in at least eight EU countries, started before each country transposes Directive (EU) 2024/2823 and kept running after, so the clause's effect on prices can be measured country by country.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Test the "projected sold" discount
A public test of one disputed step in total-loss valuations. Valuation software takes the listing prices of comparable cars for sale and lowers them by a "projected sold adjustment" meant to reflect what buyers negotiate. The project follows the comparable cars named in valuation reports that owners volunteer, records each one's later listing history by VIN, and measures how often the price actually fell by the amount of the adjustment.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
Part prices under the clause
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
An open monthly panel of carmaker list prices for the visible parts covered by the EU's new repair clause, which ends design protection for parts used to restore a car's original look (front doors, bonnets, front wings, bumper covers, headlamps, rear quarter panels) for about 30 widely sold models in at least eight EU countries, started before each country transposes Directive (EU) 2024/2823 and kept running after, so the clause's effect on prices can be measured country by country.
Why it is still open
European Commission economists Benedikt Herz and Malwina Mejer estimated that design protection raised the prices of visible parts by about 5–8%, from insurance associations' annual surveys of Audatex prices for 2001–2016, with 2009 missing; the data are not public. GDV publishes yearly percentage rises from its own index, not part-by-part prices. Member states have until 9 December 2027 to transpose the clause, and those that now protect such parts may keep protecting designs filed before 8 December 2024 until 9 December 2032, so the before-and-after window is open now.
mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.deautohaus.deoeil.europarl.europa.euautorecyclingworld.com
Built with what exists
Carmakers' and dealers' public online parts catalogs that list OEM part numbers with prices; a scheduled collector in Python that keeps to each site's terms; Eurostat's harmonised index of consumer prices to remove inflation; the difference-in-differences method Herz and Mejer used, which compares price changes in countries that change the law with those that do not; a public repository.
First step
List 30 models and their part numbers for the six part types, and find which countries' dealer catalogs show prices publicly.
Done looks like
24 months of prices for at least 500 part numbers in eight countries, including at least two that already had a repair clause and two that did not, with the estimated price change after transposition and its confidence interval.
Open 02 · the brief
Test the "projected sold" discount
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public test of one disputed step in total-loss valuations. Valuation software takes the listing prices of comparable cars for sale and lowers them by a "projected sold adjustment" meant to reflect what buyers negotiate. The project follows the comparable cars named in valuation reports that owners volunteer, records each one's later listing history by VIN, and measures how often the price actually fell by the amount of the adjustment.
Why it is still open
Class actions over these adjustments have mostly turned on class certification, not the facts. In August 2025 the Seventh Circuit reversed certification in Schroeder v. Progressive, holding that using the adjustments "does not by itself establish liability" and that each owner's actual underpayment must be shown. Two searches found no public study comparing the adjustments with what comparable cars sold for; a 2026 presentation to a Montana legislative committee compared valuation methods on a single truck.
Built with what exists
Valuation reports shared by owners with their consent, personal details removed; public listing sites and dealer pages searched by each comparable's VIN; NHTSA's free vPIC service to decode VINs; Python with pandas and a regression by vehicle age and price band; a public repository.
First step
Collect 20 valuation reports from owners, with consent, and test whether their comparables' VINs can be traced in public listings.
Done looks like
At least 100 valuation reports and 500 named comparables, with the share whose final listed or reported sale price fell by at least the applied adjustment, by vehicle age and price band, and the code public.