BRENNEN

Industries / Mining and materials / Cement and concrete

Grinding and blending

Grinding and blending is the last step at the cement plant: clinker, the hard nodules that leave the kiln, is milled to a fine powder with a little gypsum to control setting, and is often mixed with other powders that take the place of part of the clinker.

6

Milestones achieved, from 1891 to 2024.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1891

    The tube mill

    Through most of the 1800s, plants ground clinker between flat millstones, which wore quickly and left coarse, slow-reacting cement. Meyer Joseph Davidsen, a Dane living in Paris, patented the tube mill in 1891: a long steel drum, turned on its axis and part-filled with flint pebbles, that grinds by tumbling. F.L. Smidth (FLS) began making it in 1893. By 1910 most new cement mills in Britain were a short ball mill for the coarse work feeding a tube mill, and from about 1930 the two were built as one drum, the ball mill still used today.

    cementkilns.co.uk

    Credit

    Meyer Joseph Davidsen; F.L. Smidth

  2. 1949

    Fly ash in a dam

    Fly ash is the fine ash caught in the flues of coal power plants. It is a pozzolan, a powder that reacts with the lime released as cement hardens, so it can take the place of some cement. The US Bureau of Reclamation used it in the concrete of Hungry Horse Dam in Montana, first poured in 1949. Robert F. Blanks wrote in 1950 that it was used for its benefits, including lower cost, and discussed its effects on workability, strength, heat of hydration and the reaction between alkalis in cement and the aggregate. A 2024 microscope study by A. Montgomery and colleagues calls it the first dam built with coal fly ash, and found reaction damage in a core from the dam without fly ash but none in a core with it.

    LessonAn ash chosen partly to save money also protected the concrete for decades against a reaction that was barely understood when the dam was poured.

    concrete.orgebi.ac.uk

    Credit

    US Bureau of Reclamation; Robert F. Blanks

  3. 1974

    High-alumina cement fails

    High-alumina cement is made mainly of calcium aluminates rather than the calcium silicates of Portland cement, and it gains strength very quickly. It was used widely in the UK for about 20 years, including in factory-made prestressed roof beams. In 1973 part of a roof at Camden School for Girls in London collapsed, and in February 1974 a roof beam over the swimming pool of the Sir John Cass School in Stepney gave way. The Building Research Establishment found the beams had lost strength through "conversion", a change in the cement's crystals that warmth and moisture speed up, made worse by chemical attack. The government told councils not to approve the concrete for structural use, and by May 1975 about 22,650 buildings containing it had been identified.

    LessonHigh early strength did not show how the concrete would age; the 1964 guidance allowed the cement only with strict mixing, placing and curing, and those conditions were not always met.

    api.parliament.ukapi.parliament.uk

    Credit

    Investigated by the Building Research Establishment for the UK Department of the Environment

  4. 1994

    Roller mills grind cement

    A vertical roller mill crushes material under heavy rollers on a turning table instead of tumbling it with steel balls. Ernst Curt Loesche patented one in 1927 and sold a first cement mill to Brazil in 1935, but for decades such mills could not hold a steady bed of fine cement powder under the rollers. Loesche's design with separate rollers to prepare the bed went into service at Fos-sur-Mer, France, in 1994, and by 2018 the company counted more than 400 sold for clinker and slag. A Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory energy guide gives 30–42 kWh per ton of clinker for finish grinding in ball mills and 20–30 kWh for roller mills and roller presses.

    LessonCheap electricity kept the ball mill in place; Loesche says roller mills took about 50 years after its first cement mill sale to spread widely, and cementkilns.co.uk dates serious work on them in Britain and the US to after the 1973 energy crisis.

    mining.comosti.govcementkilns.co.uk

    Credit

    Loesche; other mill makers followed

  5. 2023

    A standard for LC3

    Limestone calcined clay cement (LC3) replaces about half the clinker with clay heated to a modest temperature and with ground limestone; the project's usual recipe is 50% clinker, 30% calcined clay and 15% limestone. Karen Scrivener of EPFL in Switzerland and Fernando Martirena of UCLV in Cuba began the research in 2005, and IIT Delhi and IIT Madras joined in 2014. The project says the first permanent large-scale production began in Colombia between 2017 and 2020. In 2023 the Bureau of Indian Standards published IS 18189 for this cement, granted the first licence under it to J.K. Cement's Mangrol works in Rajasthan on 30 May 2024, and J.K. Cement reported commercial dispatch in August 2025. The CO2 cut of up to 40% is the project's own figure.

    lc3.chservices.bis.gov.inconstructionworld.in

    Credit

    Karen Scrivener (EPFL); Fernando Martirena (UCLV); IIT Delhi; IIT Madras; Bureau of Indian Standards

  6. 2024

    Limestone cement takes over

    Portland-limestone cement, sold in the US as Type IL under ASTM C595, may hold up to 15% limestone by mass, against 5% for ordinary Type I/II cement. It had been used for more than twenty years in Canada and parts of Europe. In April 2024 Connecticut's transportation department approved it, so all 50 US states and the District of Columbia had adopted it. By the US Geological Survey's figures, blended cement was 63% of US cement shipments in the first nine months of 2025, and about 95% of that was Type IL.

    LessonThe swap was not one-for-one; about half the contractors in an American Society of Concrete Contractors survey reported problems such as changed setting times and less bleed water, which the article ties partly to differences between makers' cements.

    pubs.usgs.govpubs.usgs.govtilt-up.org

    Credit

    US cement makers, state transportation departments and the Portland Cement Association

Watch for

  1. Calcined clay at plant scale

    Heidelberg Materials and CBI Ghana say their flash calciner at Tema, Ghana, the largest of its kind, can make more than 400,000 t of calcined clay a year and was already supplying cement with less clinker in May 2025; the company says calcined clay can cut the product's carbon footprint by up to 40%. Holcim says its new line at Čížkovice, Czech Republic, opened in September 2026, makes more than 115,000 t of calcined clay a year for 580,000 t of cement, and cuts that cement's footprint by about 30% compared with ordinary CEM I cement.

    Achieved whenan outside party, such as a verifier of an environmental product declaration or a national statistics office, reports a full year's output and the clinker share of the cement sold.

    heidelbergmaterials.comworldcement.comholcim.com

    Claimed by

    Heidelberg Materials, May 2025; Holcim, September 2026

Open

  1. 01

    A shared clay reactivity table

    One open, versioned table of published tests of calcined clay reactivity, with fixed columns: where the clay came from, its minerals (kaolinite, illite, smectite, mica, quartz), the calcination temperature, the fineness, and the R3 result. R3 (ASTM C1897) is a standard lab test that measures the heat a powder gives off when it reacts with lime. Then test the rule proposed in 2026 by Ilda Tole and colleagues, that clays with at least 40 wt% clay minerals and less than 60% mica in the clay fraction react moderately to highly once calcined at 800 °C, on clays that were not in their study.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Compare Type IL mill reports

    A public, plant-by-plant comparison of US cement before and after each plant switched to Type IL, built from mill test reports. A mill test report is the monthly sheet a cement plant issues for its product, giving limestone content, Blaine fineness (surface area in m²/kg), setting time and the strength of standard mortar cubes at 3, 7 and 28 days.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

A shared clay reactivity table

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

One open, versioned table of published tests of calcined clay reactivity, with fixed columns: where the clay came from, its minerals (kaolinite, illite, smectite, mica, quartz), the calcination temperature, the fineness, and the R3 result. R3 (ASTM C1897) is a standard lab test that measures the heat a powder gives off when it reacts with lime. Then test the rule proposed in 2026 by Ilda Tole and colleagues, that clays with at least 40 wt% clay minerals and less than 60% mica in the clay fraction react moderately to highly once calcined at 800 °C, on clays that were not in their study.

Why it is still open

Tole and colleagues write that the lack of rapid screening and selection criteria limits the use of common clays, and that neither chemistry nor kaolinite content predicted reactivity across their 73 clays from 27 geological formations. A 2024 machine-learning study by Yoon and colleagues found that of 12 papers with R3 results, only five reported the material properties needed, which left 46 data points across all kinds of clinker substitutes. RILEM's technical committee TC 267-TRM ran the R3 test on 52 materials of every kind in 2022 to propose reactivity classes, not to build a table of clays. Searches of GitHub and Hugging Face for this brief found no open table of calcined clay results.

eprints.whiterose.ac.ukijcsm.springeropen.comdoi.org

Built with what exists

The Tole data on Zenodo (doi 10.5281/zenodo.18406772, CC BY); the Crossref and Europe PMC APIs to find papers; a language model to pull values from paper tables, with a person checking every value (see the Note "Seven more flagged"); Python with pandas and scikit-learn.

  1. First step

    Download the Zenodo record, enter its 73 clays as the first rows, and list every paper since 2018 that reports R3 results for a calcined clay.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 150 calcined clays from at least 25 papers and 10 countries, each row linked to its source, and a published count of how often the 2026 rule puts a clay in the right reactivity class.

Open 02 · the brief

Compare Type IL mill reports

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public, plant-by-plant comparison of US cement before and after each plant switched to Type IL, built from mill test reports. A mill test report is the monthly sheet a cement plant issues for its product, giving limestone content, Blaine fineness (surface area in m²/kg), setting time and the strength of standard mortar cubes at 3, 7 and 28 days.

Why it is still open

The American Society of Concrete Contractors' August 2025 field guide says Type IL performance varies with limestone content and fineness, and that changes in performance have been tied "with differences in product from different cement mills". Individual reports are public, such as Kosmos Cement's September 2023 report for its Type IL(10). The nearest study found, by Tim Cost of Holcim with Heidelberg Cement and Mississippi State University engineers, tested trial limestone cements from five southeastern US plants against each plant's ordinary cement in the lab, before the national switch, and found them to perform "almost without distinction". Searches for this brief found no comparison across plants of the cement actually sold since.

ascconline.orgkosmoscement.comintrans.iastate.edu

Built with what exists

Mill test reports that cement makers post as PDFs; state transportation departments' approved-product lists; pdftotext, with a language model and a person checking to read scanned sheets; Python; the USGS cement statistics for context.

  1. First step

    Collect the posted mill test reports of the five largest US cement makers and list which plants have published both kinds.

  2. Done looks like

    Reports from at least 30 US plants, each with a Type I/II report from before its switch and a Type IL report after, and a published table of the change in limestone content, Blaine fineness, setting time and 3-, 7- and 28-day strength.