BRENNEN

Industries / Transport and vehicles / Automotive / Car rental

Damage

Damage work is finding new dents, scratches and chips when a rental car comes back, deciding who pays for them, and settling the renter's disputes about the bill.

5

Milestones achieved, from 1988 to 2025.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1988

    New York bans the waiver

    A collision damage waiver (CDW) is the rental company's promise, sold by the day, not to bill the renter for damage to the car. A New York law of 1988 capped a renter's liability for damage at $100 and ended the sale of these waivers, which made rental companies carry the main cost of repairs. In June 2002 the legislature voted to lift the ban, and the law now lets companies sell "optional vehicle protection" at capped prices: $9 a day for cars listed at up to $20,000, $12 up to $35,000 and $15 up to $50,000. It also requires that a damage claim be based on a "physical survey" when the car is returned, or be made within ten days when the car is returned "by automation" or after hours, and limits repair charges to "actual and reasonable costs."

    LessonThe outright ban did not last; New York moved to capping the waiver's price and setting rules for how damage is claimed.

    insurancejournal.comautorentalnews.comcodes.findlaw.com

    Credit

    New York State Legislature

  2. 2015

    Europe sets a dispute rule

    Complaints about car rental to the European Consumer Centres had risen sharply, so in summer 2014 the European Commission and national consumer authorities opened talks with Avis Budget, Enterprise, Europcar, Hertz and Sixt, in a project led by the UK's Competition and Markets Authority. In July 2015 the five agreed to give renters "a reasonable opportunity to challenge any damage and associated repair charges before any payment is taken" from their card, and to explain inspections at pickup and return in advance. The same commitments put mandatory charges, such as young-driver surcharges, into the headline price and showed optional extras early in the booking. In March 2019 the authorities found that Enterprise and Sixt had made all the required changes, while Avis, Europcar and Hertz had remaining changes due by May 2019, June 2019 and early 2020. The five firms handle two out of three private car rentals in the EU, by the Commission's count.

    LessonThe agreed changes took up to five years to land, and brokers and smaller firms were outside the deal.

    gov.ukkkv.ficommission.europa.eu

    Credit

    UK Competition and Markets Authority; European Commission and the Consumer Protection Cooperation network

  3. 2016

    Australia acts on damage bills

    On 5 April 2016 the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) accepted a court-enforceable undertaking from Hertz Australia. From 2013 to August 2015 Hertz had charged some customers for damage that was already on the car, and told some that their charge was Hertz's actual repair cost when Hertz had received discounts it did not pass on. Hertz agreed to refund them, to confirm before charging that suspected new damage was not old damage or fair wear and tear, and to appoint an independent auditor to monitor its compliance. On 19 April 2016 the Federal Court declared terms in Europcar Australia's rental contract unfair and void, including terms that made a renter fully liable after any breach of the contract, however trivial, and ordered Europcar to pay a penalty of A$100,000 for misleading statements about the most a renter could owe.

    accc.gov.auaccc.gov.aujudgments.fedcourt.gov.au

    Credit

    ACCC; Federal Court of Australia (Justice Gilmour)

  4. 2018

    Garages quote the same damage

    Which? Travel, a UK consumer group, collected photographs of damage from 12 renters across Europe who believed they had been overcharged, and asked garages it approves to quote the same repairs. Only 8 of the 36 quotes were equal to or higher than the rental company's charge; Which? said the comparison was not exact, because the repairs would have been done in different countries. In its survey, 59% of renters charged for damage said they never received supporting documents, and Avis Budget and Hertz said they do not always carry out the repairs that customers pay for.

    LessonA damage charge is a price the rental company sets, not always a repair bill, so it needs its own evidence.

    travelweekly.co.uk

    Credit

    Which? Travel

  5. 2025

    Scanners send the bill

    In April 2025 Hertz said it would install UVeye's scanners, drive-through camera systems that inspect a car's body, glass, tires and underside in seconds, across major US airports, starting at Atlanta. The system compares images taken at pickup and return and sends any damage report to the renter's phone. In one case The Drive reported, a renter was billed minutes after return: $250 for a 1-inch scuff on a wheel, plus a $125 processing fee and a $65 administrative fee. By late August 2025 Hertz told CBS News it used the system at 10 US airports; Sixt said it used such technology at select locations, Avis said its process remains "human-led", and Enterprise said it did not use it. That month US Senator Richard Blumenthal and a House Oversight subcommittee chaired by Nancy Mace wrote to Hertz; Mace's letter said Hertz appeared to be the only US rental company that bills renters for scanner findings without human review.

    LessonA scanner that finds more marks than a person brings more disputes, so how a renter reaches a human matters as much as the camera.

    newsroom.hertz.comthedrive.comyahoo.comyahoo.comblumenthal.senate.gov

    Credit

    Hertz; UVeye

Watch for

  1. Most scans find nothing

    Hertz says that of more than 675,000 rentals scanned by its UVeye system, over 97% showed no billable damage.

    Achieved whenAn outside auditor or a regulator publishes how many of the remaining damage bills were disputed, and how many of those were withdrawn or found wrong.

    yahoo.com

    Claimed by

    Hertz, to CBS News, August 2025

  2. Five times more damage

    UVeye's marketing says its scanners "detect 5X more damage than manual checks" and capture "6X higher total value of damage."

    Achieved whenAn independent test on cars with known, measured marks reports how many marks the scanner and a trained human inspector each find, and how many each flags wrongly.

    blumenthal.senate.gov

    Claimed by

    UVeye, in marketing quoted by Senator Blumenthal on 26 August 2025

Open

  1. 01

    A pickup-and-return test set

    A public set of photo pairs of the same cars taken at pickup and at return, under different light, weather and dirt. Half the pairs show new damage that was measured and logged by hand; the other half show none, but include common false alarms such as water drops, dust, shadows and reflections. Any damage-finding system can then be scored on how often it reports new damage when nothing changed, and how often it misses a real new mark.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    A public tally of disputes

    A count of complaints about rental-car damage charges, built from the complaint files that consumer regulators release on request, such as US state attorneys general. Each complaint is sorted by company, location, whether a scanner was involved, the amount billed, the share of it that was fees, and the outcome.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

A pickup-and-return test set

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public set of photo pairs of the same cars taken at pickup and at return, under different light, weather and dirt. Half the pairs show new damage that was measured and logged by hand; the other half show none, but include common false alarms such as water drops, dust, shadows and reflections. Any damage-finding system can then be scored on how often it reports new damage when nothing changed, and how often it misses a real new mark.

Why it is still open

The best-known public set of car damage photos, CarDD (2023), labels single photos gathered from the web, not pairs of the same car before and after. A 2024 preprint by Hanxiao Chen aligns pre-trip and post-trip photos but used its own custom images. In August 2025 Senator Blumenthal asked Hertz what "minimum accuracy benchmark" it accepted for its scanners, and no public test of these systems turned up in this research.

arxiv.orgarxiv.orgblumenthal.senate.gov

Built with what exists

Phone cameras or Raspberry Pi High Quality Cameras with LED light panels; open detection and segmentation models such as Ultralytics YOLO and Meta's Segment Anything (SAM 2); vision-capable AI models such as Claude and Gemini as further systems to score; scrap body panels from a salvage yard for marks made on purpose.

  1. First step

    Photograph five cars twice, at noon and at dusk, with nothing changed in between, and count how many "new damage" flags one open model raises.

  2. Done looks like

    500 photo pairs from at least 20 cars, published under an open license, and for at least three systems the share of no-change pairs wrongly flagged and the share of logged new marks missed.

Open 02 · the brief

A public tally of disputes

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A count of complaints about rental-car damage charges, built from the complaint files that consumer regulators release on request, such as US state attorneys general. Each complaint is sorted by company, location, whether a scanner was involved, the amount billed, the share of it that was fees, and the outcome.

Why it is still open

In 2025 a US senator and a House subcommittee asked Hertz how its scanner charges and appeals work; the figure Hertz has given in public is its own share of scans with no billable damage. The largest outside test of damage charges found in this research, by Which? in 2018, rested on 12 renters' cases.

blumenthal.senate.govyahoo.comtravelweekly.co.uk

Built with what exists

Public records requests; an AI model such as Claude to read and sort the complaint text into fixed fields (see the Note "The jobs agents repeat"), with a person checking a sample; Python with the pandas library.

  1. First step

    Send records requests to three state attorneys general for rental-car complaints from 2023 to 2026 that mention damage.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 1,000 damage-charge complaints from at least three states, published with personal details removed, with counts by company and year and the share resolved in the renter's favor.