BRENNEN

Industries / Transport and vehicles / Automotive / Car rental

Buying and selling the fleet

This is the work of deciding which cars to buy, how to pay for them, and when and where to sell them again, usually after one to two years in rental service.

7

Milestones achieved, from 2005 to 2025.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 2005

    A carmaker sells its renter

    On December 21, 2005, Ford sold Hertz, in which it had first bought a stake in 1987, to investment funds of Clayton, Dubilier & Rice, The Carlyle Group and Merrill Lynch Global Private Equity, for $4,379 million in cash plus $10,116 million of debt refinanced or assumed. That year about 77% of the cars Hertz bought were "program" cars: the carmaker agrees to buy them back at a set price, or guarantees how fast they lose value. The rest are "risk" cars, whose resale price the renter carries. Hertz warned that it expected fewer program cars, because carmakers had announced plans to sell fewer cars to rental companies.

    LessonBuybacks let a renter shrink its fleet in a downturn without loss, so as they fade, used-car price risk moves to the renter.

    sec.gov

    Credit

    Ford Motor Company; Hertz

  2. 2009

    Buybacks meet carmaker failure

    In 2009 about 55% of the cars Avis Budget bought for its US fleet were program cars, down from 58% in 2008, and more than 60% of the cars it bought from General Motors, Ford and Chrysler were program cars. General Motors and Chrysler both filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy that year, and Avis Budget warned that a carmaker's default could leave it with unpaid buyback claims. It bought about 15% fewer cars than in 2008 and kept cutting the share of its fleet bought from US carmakers.

    LessonA buyback promise is only as good as the carmaker that makes it.

    sec.gov

    Credit

    Avis Budget Group

  3. 2015

    Recalled rentals must stay parked

    The Raechel and Jacqueline Houck Safe Rental Car Act, passed as part of a federal transportation law signed on December 4, 2015, bars a US rental company from renting or selling a car under a safety recall until it is repaired. The company must comply within 24 hours of receiving the recall notice, or 48 hours if the notice covers more than 5,000 of its cars; where no repair exists yet but the carmaker specifies a temporary fix, the car may be rented but not sold. The rule took effect 180 days after signing. The law is named for two sisters killed in 2004 while driving an unrepaired rental car recalled for a power-steering hose defect; the car caught fire and collided head-on with a semi-trailer truck, and Enterprise later conceded its negligence. Before the law, rental companies told the Government Accountability Office they ran their own "hard hold" and "soft hold" systems.

    LessonLeft voluntary, the decision of which recall was "a true safety recall" stayed with each company, in a Hertz executive's words; the law turned it into a deadline.

    law.cornell.edugovinfo.gov

    Credit

    US Congress; Senator Charles Schumer introduced the Senate bill in December 2012

  4. 2020

    Lenders force a fleet sale

    Hertz leased most of its US cars from a financing company that raised money through asset-backed securities, bonds repaid from the cars' lease payments and sale proceeds. When travel stopped with COVID-19, Hertz missed its April 2020 lease payment, and from May 5 the proceeds of car sales had to go to the bondholders. Hertz filed for Chapter 11 on May 22, 2020. A court order of July 24 required it to dispose of at least 182,521 leased cars by the end of the year, and it disposed of about 198,000. It spent $8.2 billion, or 60%, less on new cars than in 2019, and emerged from bankruptcy on June 30, 2021.

    LessonA fleet financed against its own resale value can be pushed onto the used-car market just when rentals stop.

    sec.govsec.gov

    Credit

    Hertz; US Bankruptcy Court for the District of Delaware

  5. 2021

    No new cars to buy

    A shortage of computer chips made carmakers delay production in 2021, and Hertz told investors it could not be sure of buying enough new cars at competitive prices. Renters paid for the gap. The US Bureau of Labor Statistics' consumer price index for car and truck rental, not adjusted for season, stood at 236.8 in July 2021, against 141.2 in July 2019, a rise of 68%.

    LessonA renter that sells down its fleet in a slump depends on carmakers' output to rebuild it.

    data.bls.govsec.gov

    Credit

    price index by the US Bureau of Labor Statistics

  6. 2024

    Hertz reverses its EV order

    In October 2021 Hertz placed an initial order for 100,000 Tesla Model 3 electric cars, about 22% of its global fleet. On January 11, 2024 it said it would sell about 20,000 electric vehicles from its US fleet, a third of its electric fleet worldwide, and take about $245 million of extra depreciation. It said collision and damage costs, mostly on electric cars, had stayed high, and that used-car values had fallen. Avis Budget cut the expected service life of some US electric rental cars in late 2025 and booked a $518 million charge.

    LessonAn electric fleet's cost turned on repair bills and resale prices, not only on the price paid.

    sec.govsec.govsec.gov

    Credit

    Hertz; Avis Budget Group

  7. 2025

    Risk cars are the norm

    In 2025 about 84% of Avis Budget's average rental fleet were risk cars, and only about 16% were program cars or cars on fixed-term leases. Hertz says the "significant majority" of its fleet is non-program. It held its cars in the Americas for about 18 months before selling them, more than a quarter less than in 2024. It sells the cars that carmakers do not take back through its own Hertz Car Sales lots, which it calls its main channel, wholesale to dealers, and at auction. To lower its fleet's age, Avis Budget sold cars sooner than planned and took a $2.3 billion charge in late 2024.

    LessonWithout buybacks, a renter's profit turns on when and where it sells each car.

    sec.govsec.gov

    Credit

    Avis Budget Group; Hertz

Watch for

  1. Rental cars sold on Amazon

    On August 20, 2025, Hertz began selling used rental cars on Amazon Autos, where buyers within 75 miles of Dallas, Houston, Los Angeles or Seattle can buy online, sign the papers electronically and collect the car at a Hertz location. It planned to grow to 45 locations, and Hertz Car Sales is Amazon Autos' first fleet dealer. In its annual report of February 2026, Hertz said it had launched on Amazon Autos nationwide and now treats retail as its main way to sell cars.

    Achieved whenHertz or an outside party publishes how many cars Hertz sold through Amazon Autos, and what share of its disposals went to retail buyers rather than dealers and auctions.

    nbcnews.comsec.gov

    Claimed by

    Hertz, August 2025 and February 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Open recalls on ex-rental cars

    A public check of whether cars that rental companies sell from their own fleets still carry unrepaired safety recalls. Collect the vehicle identification numbers (VINs) shown on rental companies' used-car listings, check each one for open recalls, and publish the share by seller, model and age of recall.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    A public fleet-cost table

    An open, quarter-by-quarter table since 2005 of each listed rental company's fleet size, holding period, share of program cars, share of electric cars and depreciation per car per month, each number linked to the page it came from. Then use it to forecast next quarter's depreciation per car from public used-car price indexes, and post the forecasts before each results date.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Open recalls on ex-rental cars

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public check of whether cars that rental companies sell from their own fleets still carry unrepaired safety recalls. Collect the vehicle identification numbers (VINs) shown on rental companies' used-car listings, check each one for open recalls, and publish the share by seller, model and age of recall.

Why it is still open

US law has barred rental companies since 2016 from selling a recalled car before it is repaired, except as junk. Enforcement still starts from complaints: NHTSA opened an audit of NU Car Rentals on June 9, 2026 after two complaints to NHTSA that it had rented cars with recall repairs not done. Carfax counts unrepaired recalls across all US vehicles, more than 2.5 million of them under "Do Not Drive" or "Park Outside" recalls on May 1, 2023, but not by who sells them. No study of open recalls on the cars rental companies themselves sell turned up in this research.

static.nhtsa.govlaw.cornell.eduautorentalnews.com

Built with what exists

Listing pages of rental companies' used-car arms, such as Hertz Car Sales; NHTSA's free vPIC VIN decoder and recalls-by-vehicle web services to shortlist cars whose model has a recall; NHTSA's VIN recall lookup to confirm each shortlisted car; Python.

  1. First step

    Copy 50 VINs from one seller's listings in one city and run them through the vPIC and recalls services.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 500 VINs from at least three sellers checked, every positive confirmed by hand, and a published share with open recalls and its 95% confidence interval.

Open 02 · the brief

A public fleet-cost table

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An open, quarter-by-quarter table since 2005 of each listed rental company's fleet size, holding period, share of program cars, share of electric cars and depreciation per car per month, each number linked to the page it came from. Then use it to forecast next quarter's depreciation per car from public used-car price indexes, and post the forecasts before each results date.

Why it is still open

The figures are spread across hundreds of filings and defined differently: Hertz counts program cars as a share of cars bought, Avis Budget as a share of its average fleet including fixed-term leases. Hertz's 2025 annual report prints its program-car table as a picture rather than text. No public table comparing the companies over time turned up in this research.

sec.govsec.gov

Built with what exists

SEC EDGAR full-text search and its structured financial data service; a PDF and image table reader such as pdfplumber with optical character recognition; the US Bureau of Labor Statistics' used-car price index; Python with pandas.

  1. First step

    Extend the program-car shares already quoted here for 2005, 2009 and 2025 to every year for Hertz and Avis Budget.

  2. Done looks like

    The table for Hertz and Avis Budget from 2005 to 2026, plus any European renters that report the same figures; and forecasts for four quarters posted before results, with the average error in dollars per car per month.