Industries / Mining and materials / Chemicals and petrochemicals / Biofuels
Carbon accounting
Counting the greenhouse gases a biofuel causes from field to tailpipe, setting that against the fossil fuel it replaces, and proving where each batch came from.
7
Milestones achieved, from 1996 to 2025.
2
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1996
A shared fuel-cycle model
Michael Wang at Argonne National Laboratory published GREET 1.0 (Greenhouse gases, Regulated Emissions, and Energy use in Transportation) in June 1996. The spreadsheet added up emissions over a fuel's whole cycle, from well or field to the wheels, for 17 fuel cycles, including ethanol from corn, wood and grasses. Versions of it now set legal numbers: the US Treasury uses 45ZCF-GREET for the clean fuel tax credit and 40BSAF-GREET for the jet fuel credit, California's fuel standard uses CA-GREET, and ICAO uses ICAO-GREET to check the default values for jet fuel under CORSIA, its scheme to offset airline emissions.
Credit
Michael Q. Wang, Argonne National Laboratory, for the US Department of Energy
2008
Land use flips the sign
Timothy Searchinger and colleagues wrote in Science in February 2008 that earlier studies missed the carbon released when farmers elsewhere clear forest and grassland to replace grain turned into fuel, an effect now called indirect land-use change (ILUC). Counting it, they found that corn ethanol, instead of saving 20%, nearly doubles greenhouse emissions over 30 years. Later work disagrees. A 2021 review by Scully and colleagues put corn ethanol at 51.4 grams of CO2-equivalent per megajoule (gCO2e/MJ), 46% below gasoline, with land-use change only 3.9 g of that. A 2022 study by Lark and colleagues found that ethanol made under the US Renewable Fuel Standard is no less carbon-intensive than gasoline and likely at least 24% more.
LessonThe land-use term is a model estimate large enough to decide whether a fuel counts as cleaner, so every program has to choose a number for it.
Credit
Timothy Searchinger, Ralph Heimlich, Richard Houghton and colleagues
2011
Every fuel gets a score
The California Air Resources Board (CARB) approved its Low Carbon Fuel Standard in 2009 and started it on 1 January 2011. Each fuel pathway, meaning one fuel from one feedstock at one plant, gets a certified carbon intensity (CI) in gCO2e/MJ, counting production, transport, use and indirect land-use change; fuels below a falling yearly benchmark earn credits. CARB's pathway workbook, updated 16 November 2026, lists 3,822 applications and pathways, 1,113 of them not retired. The 286 active pathways for fuels made from dairy-manure biogas all score below zero, from −1,887 to −60 gCO2e/MJ with a median of −255 (computed for this file from CARB's workbook), because the method credits the methane a digester keeps out of the air.
LessonA score that credits avoided emissions can go far below zero, so the assumed baseline, what would have happened without the project, drives the result.
Credit
California Air Resources Board
2015
Europe caps crop fuels
Directive (EU) 2015/1513 of 9 September 2015 limited biofuels from cereals, sugars, oil crops and energy crops to 7% of the energy used in transport in 2020 for EU targets. A 2019 Commission regulation, 2019/807, rated palm oil a high-ILUC-risk feedstock: it found that 45% of palm's expansion since 2008 went into forest and 23% into wetlands including peat, and its share is to fall to 0% by 2030, starting from 31 December 2023. Malaysia challenged both at the World Trade Organization. The panel report of 5 March 2024, adopted 26 April 2024, upheld the 7% cap and the palm phase-out as environmental measures, but found that the EU discriminated by not reviewing its data in time and through flawed criteria for low-risk certification.
LessonA counting rule that moves trade has to keep its data current, or it can be ruled discriminatory.
Credit
the European Parliament and Council; the European Commission; WTO dispute panel DS600
2023
Waste labels under audit
In 2023 up to half a million tonnes of biodiesel said to be made from wastes reached Europe from China, and ISCC was told the surge had driven European biodiesel prices down sharply. ISCC (International Sustainability and Carbon Certification), a scheme the EU recognizes to certify such fuels, ran unannounced audits at Chinese biodiesel and hydrotreated vegetable oil plants and by 27 July 2023 had withdrawn or suspended seven certificates, while saying this did not prove crime; Germany's Federal Office for Agriculture and Food (BLE) filed charges with prosecutors in Bonn. In December 2024 Transport & Environment (T&E), a campaign group, reported that only 9% of ISCC-certified used-cooking-oil collecting points in China, Malaysia and Indonesia had any of their restaurants and other sources audited; a source supplying under 5 tonnes a month needs only to sign a self-declaration.
LessonUsed cooking oil and fresh palm oil are chemically alike and the checks are mostly on paperwork, so certificates alone cannot prove what a batch was made from.
Credit
a failure, investigated by ISCC and BLE
2024
A storage well leaks
At Decatur, Illinois, the Illinois Basin–Decatur Project injected about 1 million tonnes of CO2 from ADM's ethanol fermentation plant into the Mt. Simon Sandstone between November 2011 and November 2014, under one of the first EPA permits for wells built to store CO2 (Class VI). ADM's storage there later passed 4.5 million tons, by Capitol News Illinois's count. In 2024 a corroded deep monitoring well leaked about 8,000 tonnes of CO2 and other underground fluid into zones the permit did not allow, about 5,000 feet down and far below the groundwater, and EPA said in August 2024 that ADM had violated its permit and the Safe Drinking Water Act.
LessonA capture project's carbon saving depends on wells that stay sealed for decades, so the monitoring wells are part of the accounting.
Credit
ADM and the Illinois State Geological Survey for the project; the leak is a failure that EPA cited
2025
US credit drops land use
The US Clean Fuel Production Credit (section 45Z of the tax code) pays for transport fuel made in the US from 2025 through 2029, scaled by the fuel's lifecycle emissions. The One Big Beautiful Bill Act of 4 July 2025 changed the count for fuel made after 31 December 2025: emissions from indirect land-use change are left out, manure-based gas needs a rate for each kind of animal, and feedstocks must come from the US, Mexico or Canada. The Treasury's proposed rules of 4 February 2026 and the Department of Energy's 45ZCF-GREET model apply these changes.
LessonWhether land-use change counts is set by law as well as by science, so the same fuel can score differently in California's program, which counts it, and in the federal credit, which does not.
Credit
US Congress; the Treasury and IRS; Argonne National Laboratory and the Department of Energy
Watch for
Farm practices lower scores
The September 2026 revision of 45ZCF-GREET, the model behind the US clean fuel credit, adds a calculator called the 45ZCF FD-CIC that lowers a fuel's carbon intensity when its feedstock is grown with certain "regenerative agricultural practices".
Achieved whenmeasurements of soil carbon and nitrous oxide on farms that claim the adjustment, made by a party outside the program, show cuts at least as large as the model credits.
Claimed by
the US Department of Energy, for the Treasury, September 2026
Negative scores from stored CO2
On 10 April 2026 EPA issued Kansas's first Class VI permit to PureField Carbon Capture, allowing up to 150,000 tonnes a year of CO2 from ethanol making at Russell, Kansas, to be stored in the Arbuckle formation for 12 years, 1.8 million tonnes in all. PureField says the capture plant is fully running and that it targets "negative or near zero" GREET carbon-intensity scores for its fuels.
Achieved whena regulator certifies a CI or emissions rate for the plant's ethanol at or below zero, and EPA's greenhouse gas reporting shows a full year of injection with no leak found.
Claimed by
PureField Ingredients, July 2026
Open
01
Re-run posted pathway scores
An outside check of California's certified fuel scores. Take a sample of Tier 2 pathways, the custom pathways built on a plant's own data, enter the inputs CARB posts for each into the same CA-GREET calculator, and compare the result with the certified CI. Publish each match, each gap and each input withheld as confidential.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Used cooking oil versus kitchens
An open, monthly check of used-cooking-oil exports. For each exporting country, set customs export figures against a stated range for how much used oil its restaurants and food plants could collect, and flag the months and routes where exports exceed it.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
Re-run posted pathway scores
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
An outside check of California's certified fuel scores. Take a sample of Tier 2 pathways, the custom pathways built on a plant's own data, enter the inputs CARB posts for each into the same CA-GREET calculator, and compare the result with the certified CI. Publish each match, each gap and each input withheld as confidential.
Why it is still open
For each Tier 2 pathway, CARB posts a staff summary, a lifecycle report and a PDF listing the site-specific inputs and approved changes to the calculator, while some supporting documents stay confidential; for dairy-gas application B0901, certified 27 August 2026, the herd-count and manure calculations are confidential. The workbook links 666 such cover sheets. Fingerman and colleagues (Energy Policy, 2025) argue that crediting avoided methane turns dairy biomethane into an offset without the safeguards of offset markets, but they assess the policy rather than recompute pathways. A November 2026 search found work comparing GREET-based models and standards, but no published study that re-ran certified LCFS pathways from CARB's postings.
Built with what exists
CA-GREET and CARB's simplified Tier 1 calculators (Excel workbooks CARB publishes); CARB's Current Fuel Pathways workbook, which links each application; a document-reading AI model to copy input tables from the PDFs into a spreadsheet, with every value checked by a person (see the Note "Seven more flagged").
First step
Download the workbook, pick five dairy-gas pathways certified in 2026, and re-run one from its posted inputs.
Done looks like
30 Tier 2 pathways across at least four fuel types re-run, published as a table of certified CI, reproduced CI, the difference in gCO2e/MJ and the inputs that could not be reproduced, with the spreadsheets attached and sent to CARB for comment.
Open 02 · the brief
Used cooking oil versus kitchens
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
An open, monthly check of used-cooking-oil exports. For each exporting country, set customs export figures against a stated range for how much used oil its restaurants and food plants could collect, and flag the months and routes where exports exceed it.
Why it is still open
The comparisons so far are one-offs. The International Council on Clean Transportation (ICCT) estimated in February 2022 how much used cooking oil six Asian exporters (China, India, Indonesia, Japan, Malaysia and South Korea) could collect and did collect, and set that against their 2019 exports (Kristiana, Baldino and Searle). Stratas Advisors, working for T&E, estimated from paid data in June 2024 that Malaysia exports three times more used cooking oil than it collects. The stakes keep growing: EASA reports that used cooking oil made up 80% of the SAF supplied at EU airports in 2025. A November 2026 search found campaign and research reports but no open monitor that is updated as new trade data arrive and that anyone can rerun.
Built with what exists
Monthly trade data from UN Comtrade and Eurostat's Comext, using the customs codes each country files used cooking oil under (finding them is part of the work); ICCT's collection-potential method (all urban restaurants, half of urban households, all food processing) as the starting range; FAO food balance data for vegetable oil use per person; Python; a published table of assumed collection rates with their sources.
First step
Pull 2020–2025 used-cooking-oil exports for Malaysia, China and Indonesia from UN Comtrade and set them beside ICCT's 2022 collection estimates.
Done looks like
The ten largest exporters covered monthly from 2020, each with a stated collection range and its sources, and a public table of flagged country-months; each flag later compared against certificate withdrawals and enforcement news, with hits and misses counted.