Industries / Food, farming and forestry / Agriculture and farming / Beekeeping
Honey and wax harvest
Taking honey and wax out of the hive, separating and cleaning them, and checking that what is sold as honey is honey.
7
Milestones achieved, from 1857 to 2023.
2
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1857
Wax sheets with printed cells
Mehring, a German beekeeper, cast thin sheets of beeswax in wooden molds that pressed the six-sided pattern of the bees' cells into them. Bees accepted the sheets, now called comb foundation, and built their comb on them. The 1911 Encyclopaedia Britannica calls Mehring the originator of comb foundation and says it gained little notice for nearly twenty years, until Samuel Wagner, editor of the American Bee Journal, promoted it.
Credit
Mehring; promoted by Samuel Wagner
1865
Spinning honey out of comb
Franz von Hruschka, an army officer living near Venice, built a machine that spins frames of comb so that the honey is thrown out by centrifugal force and the wax comb stays whole. Beekeepers could then give the empty combs back to the bees to refill instead of crushing or cutting them. The 1911 Encyclopaedia Britannica says the extractor was "first brought to public notice in 1865"; Wyatt Mangum, writing in the American Bee Journal, dates the invention to the winter of 1864 to 1865 and says historians doubt the popular story that Hruschka's son gave him the idea by swinging a basket of comb.
LessonLiquid honey was easier to fake than sealed comb, and Mangum notes that buyers distrusted it until laws against adulteration were passed.
Credit
Franz von Hruschka
1978
An isotope test for syrup
Sugars from corn and cane carry a larger share of the heavy carbon isotope carbon-13 than nectar sugars do. White and Doner measured 119 honeys at an average of −25.4 parts per thousand on this scale (written δ13C) and high-fructose corn syrups at −9.7; in a collaborative study, six laboratories correctly identified four honey and syrup mixtures and one pure honey, and AOAC International, a standards body for lab methods, adopted the method. In 1989 White and Winters made it sensitive to additions of 7 to 20% by comparing each honey with its own protein.
LessonIn the EU's 2021–22 border checks the same isotope test "was not effective" at catching honey that other methods flagged (see the 2023 entry).
Credit
White and Doner (Journal of AOAC, 1978); White and Winters (1989)
1981
A world standard for honey
The Codex Alimentarius Commission, the joint food standards body of the UN's FAO and WHO, adopted a standard for honey in 1981 and revised it in 1987 and 2001. It defines honey as made by honey bees from nectar or from honeydew (sugary secretions of sap-sucking insects), forbids adding any other ingredient, caps moisture at 20% for most honeys, and forbids removing pollen except where that cannot be avoided when filtering out foreign matter.
Credit
Codex Alimentarius Commission
2013
Honey laundering prosecuted
Groeb Farms of Onsted, Michigan, admitted in a deferred prosecution agreement that from February 2008 to about April 2012 it bought about 1,578 container loads of Chinese honey that had been falsely declared as coming from Indonesia, Malaysia, Mongolia, Thailand or Vietnam, or as sugars and syrups, to avoid US anti-dumping duties. The agreement puts the loss to the United States at no less than $78,866,216.
LessonGroeb's own supplier audits had raised concerns, and it kept buying while advertising those audits to customers, so audits a buyer runs on its own suppliers did not stop the fraud.
Credit
US Attorney's Office for the Northern District of Illinois
2021
Fake wax kills brood
Beeswax is sometimes cut with cheaper paraffin or stearin, a mix of fatty acids from animal or plant fat. A survey of wax sampled across Belgium in 2016 found adulteration in 9 of 98 samples from beekeepers and 3 of 9 from commercial suppliers (El Agrebi and colleagues, PLOS ONE, 2021). In trials by Magdalena Chęć and colleagues (Apidologie, 2021), brood survival fell significantly on foundation made with 10%, 30% or 50% stearin, while paraffin did not reduce brood survival but weakened the comb.
LessonChęć's team concludes that even a small amount of stearin "makes it useless for apiculture", and the Belgian authors call for purity criteria, routine testing and traceability for beekeeping wax.
Credit
El Agrebi and colleagues; Chęć and colleagues
2023
Half of imports suspicious
In an action coordinated by the European Commission, EU countries sampled 320 consignments of imported honey at the border between November 2021 and February 2022, and the Commission's Joint Research Centre found 147 of them (46%) suspected of not complying with EU honey rules, against 14% in a 2015–17 exercise; its tests looked for added sugar syrups. The results were published in March 2023. The EU then revised its honey law: from 14 June 2026, labels on blended honey must list every country of origin with its percentage share.
LessonThe Commission found that the standard isotope test "was not effective" here, and that exporters had tested their honey in accredited labs to avoid detection, so it combined several lab methods with on-site inspections.
Credit
European Commission (DG SANTE), Joint Research Centre and the EU anti-fraud office OLAF
Watch for
EU-wide tests for syrup
The European Commission says its Joint Research Centre is in a three-year arrangement to harmonize the tests used to detect honey adulterated with sugar, and that an expert group, the Honey Platform, advises it on an EU traceability system and a Union reference laboratory. The 2024 directive requires the Commission to adopt rules on traceability and on how to determine where honey was harvested by 14 June 2029.
Achieved whenthe Commission adopts a delegated act naming harmonized methods, and a Union reference laboratory begins testing honey with them.
Claimed by
European Commission, on its honey page as read in November 2026
Portable honey fingerprinting
University of Verona researchers report that a portable near-infrared scanner, with models built for Italian honeys, estimates selected adulterants with an error below 15% and tells Italian honey from foreign honey with about 80% accuracy, in seconds and with no sample preparation.
Achieved whena laboratory outside the project tests the scanner on blind samples it prepares itself and publishes the results.
Claimed by
Marco Ciulu and colleagues (MISTRAL project), May 2026, in an abstract for the BeSafeBeeHoney conference in Tirana
Open
01
Cheap scanner for fake wax
A handheld infrared test that tells a beekeeper or wax buyer, in about a minute and without a lab, whether a sheet of foundation or a block of wax contains paraffin or stearin above a set level.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Shelf audit of blend labels
A public tally of honey jars on EU supermarket shelves, photographed and read by software, that checks whether blends list each country of origin with its percentage, as required since 14 June 2026, and compares the declared shares with each country's actual honey imports.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
Cheap scanner for fake wax
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A handheld infrared test that tells a beekeeper or wax buyer, in about a minute and without a lab, whether a sheet of foundation or a block of wax contains paraffin or stearin above a set level.
Why it is still open
Chatzipanagis and colleagues (Foods, 2024) detected paraffin down to about 5% and stearic acid down to about 1% with a benchtop ATR-IR instrument (attenuated total reflectance infrared, which reads a sample pressed against a crystal), and Belgium's national survey used the same kind of lab instrument. A Europe PMC search for beeswax adulteration with the terms portable, handheld, smartphone or near-infrared (40 results) and a web search found portable near-infrared models for honey, such as Verona's, but none for beeswax. %20AND%20(adulter*)&resultType=core&format=json&pageSize=15)
Built with what exists
A handheld near-infrared spectrometer such as Si-Ware's NeoSpectra Scanner or Viavi's MicroNIR; pure beeswax, paraffin and stearin from suppliers to make calibration mixtures; the scikit-learn library for partial least squares models, the standard statistics for reading spectra.
First step
Mix 30 calibration samples of pure beeswax with 0 to 50% paraffin and 0 to 20% stearin, scan each with a borrowed handheld spectrometer, and check whether the groups separate.
Done looks like
On 100 wax samples also tested blind by a laboratory using ATR-IR or gas chromatography, the handheld test flags at least 95% of samples containing 5% or more stearin or 10% or more paraffin, with false alarms on no more than 5% of pure samples, and all spectra are published.
Open 02 · the brief
Shelf audit of blend labels
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public tally of honey jars on EU supermarket shelves, photographed and read by software, that checks whether blends list each country of origin with its percentage, as required since 14 June 2026, and compares the declared shares with each country's actual honey imports.
Why it is still open
The rule took effect on 14 June 2026, and honey already on the market may be sold until stocks run out. In November 2026 the Spanish farmers' association ASAJA Extremadura warned that Chinese honey is being routed through Portugal with its origin obscured, citing trade figures, not a count of labels. Searches found no published survey of shelf labels under the new rule.
Built with what exists
Phone cameras; an open vision-language model such as Qwen2.5-VL to transcribe label text, with a person checking each reading; Eurostat's Comext trade database for honey imports (customs code 0409) by partner country.
First step
Photograph every honey product at three supermarkets in one city and code each label against the directive's wording in a spreadsheet.
Done looks like
At least 500 distinct honey products from at least five EU countries photographed and coded, with the share that comply, the share still on old-style labels, and declared country shares set against Comext import shares; all photos and codes published under a CC-BY license.