Industries / Food, farming and forestry / Food and beverage processing / Bakeries
Letting dough rise
Before baking, shaped dough is kept warm and humid so that its yeast fills it with gas, a step bakers call proofing (or proving); cabinets that chill the dough slow or pause the rise, and freezing or part-baking moves it to another day or place.
4
Milestones achieved, from 1949 to 1993.
1
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1949
Rise finished before sale
On 29 September 1949 Joseph A. Gregor of Avon Park, Florida, filed a patent, assigned to General Mills and granted in 1951, for rolls and bread that the buyer finishes in a home oven. It notes that earlier chilled or frozen doughs left the buyer to "supervise and control the yeast action and final raising of the dough". In his process the baker completes the rise and then stops it with a first bake, at a lower oven temperature and for longer than usual, so that the crumb is set but the crust has not browned; the buyer browns it later. Part-baked (par-baked) bread is now a standard trade product: Verbeke and colleagues (Foods, 2024) write that bread sold from one business to another is often 95% par-baked, that freezing is the main way of keeping it, and that it lets bakers, restaurants and shoppers bake off to demand.
Credit
Joseph A. Gregor; General Mills
1980
Cold cabinets answer night bans
Laws have kept bakers from working at night: Britain's Baking Industry (Hours of Work) Act, the "Night Baking Act", came into force in 1954 and was repealed in 1986 (Federation of Bakers). A European patent filed in German by Gerd Lohner in August 1980 says a ban on night baking allowed preparation only from 3:30 a.m. and baking from 4:00 a.m., too late to proof rolls in the usual way. Its answer is the retarder-proofer, which it calls a Gärunterbrecher, or "fermentation interrupter": shaped rolls are chilled to −5 to −7 °C and held for up to 50 hours or more, then warmed to about 30 °C at up to 90% relative humidity to finish rising, so they are ready when baking may begin. A New Zealand patent from June 1980 describes retarder-prover cabinets, with cooling, heating and humidifying equipment, as already used in commercial bakehouses.
LessonHolding shaped dough cold overnight lets a bakery sell fresh morning bread without a night shift, a reason researchers at Lodz University of Technology still give for slow, cool fermentation (Liszkowska and colleagues, 2024).
fob.uk.compatents.google.compatents.google.compmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
Credit
Gerd Lohner; Walker Nyland Refrigeration; no first maker was found
1986
Yeast bred for the freezer
Frozen dough lets a bakery make dough in one place and bake it fresh in another, but typical baking yeasts "fail to retain leavening ability following freezing" (Lahue and colleagues, 2020). In Japan, Y. Oda, K. Uno and S. Ohta of Kyowa Hakko's Tokyo Research Laboratory screened more than 300 Saccharomyces yeast strains and in 1986 reported 11 suited to frozen dough; the chosen cells stored more trehalose, a sugar that protects cells against freezing, than commercial baker's yeast. In 1990 Japan's National Food Research Institute compared five freeze-tolerant strains with ordinary commercial yeast and linked their tolerance partly to trehalose (Hino and colleagues). Yeast makers now sell yeasts for frozen dough, among them Angel Yeast of China.
pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.govpmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.govpmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.goven.angelyeast.com
Credit
Y. Oda, K. Uno and S. Ohta (Kyowa Hakko); A. Hino and colleagues (National Food Research Institute)
1993
Names for never-frozen bread
A French decree of 13 September 1993 reserved the name "pain maison" (house-made bread) for bread kneaded, shaped and baked where it is sold, and "pain de tradition française" for bread that has had no freezing at any stage of its making and contains no additives. The decree does not ban frozen dough or part-baked bread; it governs which names a loaf may carry, so buyers can tell bread made start to finish without freezing from the rest.
Credit
Government of France (Décret n° 93-1074)
Watch for
Yeast evolved to survive freezing
Researchers at Jiangnan University's Science Center for Future Foods in Wuxi, China, report a baker's yeast strain developed by what they call "hybrid fusion evolution". In dough frozen at −20 °C for 4 days, bread made with it kept more than 80% of its specific volume (volume per gram), against 52–54% with the parent strains, and its crumb hardened less. The test covered only 4 days of frozen storage.
Achieved whenanother laboratory, or a yeast maker selling the strain, shows the same advantage in dough stored frozen for at least 8 weeks and baked into bread.
Claimed by
T. Qu, C. Pan, J. Chen, J. Li and A. Chen (Food Research International, online November 2025)
Open
01
Sensing when dough has risen
A small sensor kit for a shop's proofer or retarder-proofer (a depth camera or distance sensor over a tray, plus temperature and humidity) that tracks how much shaped pieces have grown and calls "ready to bake", tested against experienced bakers' calls, which they usually make by pressing the dough with a finger, and against the baked loaves.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Frozen-dough yeasts tested together
A side-by-side test of the yeasts that makers sell for frozen dough, against an ordinary instant yeast, in the same lean and sweet doughs frozen for set times, with gas production and baked volume measured and all raw data published.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
Sensing when dough has risen
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A small sensor kit for a shop's proofer or retarder-proofer (a depth camera or distance sensor over a tray, plus temperature and humidity) that tracks how much shaped pieces have grown and calls "ready to bake", tested against experienced bakers' calls, which they usually make by pressing the dough with a finger, and against the baked loaves.
Why it is still open
Patents describe pieces of the idea: Thomas Atzinger's (filed 1998) puts an ultrasonic detector on a tripod in the proofing chamber that signals when the dough reaches a set height, and Kaak Groep's (filed 2018) aims a jet of air at a dough piece and measures the distance to that spot with a sensor in the nozzle, for analysis without touching the dough. A 2026 University of Padua thesis by Giuseppe Labate measured dough-ball volume with a depth camera on an industrial bread line, but not during proofing. Lee, Kim and Kim (Foods, 2023) built an adaptive bread maker that predicts its own baking stages from sensor and camera data. Hobby builds watch sourdough starters in jars or stream a camera from a home proofing box. None of these publishes a test of a sensor's "ready" call against bakers' calls and baked volume for shaped dough in shops.
patents.google.compatents.google.comthesis.unipd.itebi.ac.ukgithub.com
Built with what exists
A Raspberry Pi 5 with a Camera Module 3, or an Intel RealSense D405 depth camera; ST VL53L1X time-of-flight distance sensors; a Sensirion SHT45 temperature and humidity sensor; Ultralytics YOLO to find and outline dough pieces; Python.
First step
Mount a distance sensor and a camera over one rack in a shop's retarder-proofer for a week, logging heights every minute alongside the time the baker judges each tray ready.
Done looks like
300 trays of at least three products, such as rolls, baguettes and croissants, in three shops, with the sensor's call within 10 minutes of the agreed call of two bakers on at least 80% of trays, loaves baked at the sensor's call no smaller by volume than those baked at the bakers' call, and the data, photos and code published.
Open 02 · the brief
Frozen-dough yeasts tested together
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A side-by-side test of the yeasts that makers sell for frozen dough, against an ordinary instant yeast, in the same lean and sweet doughs frozen for set times, with gas production and baked volume measured and all raw data published.
Why it is still open
Sellers describe these yeasts in general terms. Angel Yeast says a yeast designed for frozen dough "can significantly enhance stability during freezing, thawing, and fermentation" and sells FrozDo instant dry, semi-dry and fresh yeasts for the purpose, but gives no figures (2024). The strain comparisons found are of laboratory strains, not products on sale: Japan's National Food Research Institute in 1990, Jiangnan University in 2025. A 2024 review of ways to make baker's yeast tolerate freezing describes laboratory methods. A search of Europe PMC on 18 November 2026 found no independent comparison of commercial frozen-dough yeasts after frozen storage.
Built with what exists
Commercial yeasts bought through distributors; a −18 °C freezer with a temperature logger; a Chopin Rheofermentometer, which measures the gas a dough makes and holds, at a university cereal laboratory; a standard pan-bread bake; loaf volume by rapeseed displacement.
First step
Buy small packs of every yeast sold for frozen dough in one country and freeze the first set of doughs.
Done looks like
At least four frozen-dough yeasts and one ordinary instant yeast, each in a lean and a sweet dough, stored for 0, 4, 8 and 12 weeks in triplicate, with gas production, loaf volume and the share of week-0 volume kept published for each, by a laboratory that the yeast makers do not pay.