Industries / Finance and business services / Staffing and recruiting / Background checks
Criminal records
Searching court and police records for a person's convictions, or, in many countries, asking a state agency to issue a certificate that lists them.
7
Milestones achieved, from 1974 to 2021.
3
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1974
Old convictions become spent
Britain's Rehabilitation of Offenders Act 1974, given Royal Assent on 31 July 1974 and in force from 1 July 1975, lets a conviction become "spent" after a set period without reoffending. A spent conviction generally need not be disclosed, and the Act says it is not a proper ground for dismissing or excluding a person from a job. It did not apply to Northern Ireland.
Credit
UK Parliament
2002
A national bureau, overwhelmed
The Criminal Records Bureau (CRB), set up under Part V of the Police Act 1997, began issuing certificates for England and Wales in March 2002, run by the outsourcing firm Capita under a ten-year contract valued at about £400 million. In October 2002 a member of Parliament told the House of Commons that thousands of applications were outstanding. In February 2004 the minister said that since June 2003, 92% of standard and enhanced applications had been processed within two and four weeks respectively, and that Capita had settled for about £3.5 million over its earlier performance. The CRB issued 2.5 million certificates in 2004–05.
Lessonwhen a law makes a check compulsory, the service has to be ready for the demand on the day it opens.
assets.publishing.service.gov.ukapi.parliament.ukapi.parliament.uk
Credit
Home Office; Criminal Records Bureau; Capita
2012
Europe links its registers
ECRIS, the European Criminal Records Information System, began operating in April 2012 under Framework Decision 2009/315/JHA, so that one member state's register can ask another's for a person's convictions. All 27 member states were fully connected in 2022. The European Commission counted nearly 4.8 million messages in 2024, about 400,000 a month; 56% of requests were for purposes other than criminal cases, and requests for recruiting people to work with children rose to 233,400, from 115,000 in 2019. Of all requests sent from 2020 to 2024, 317,000 (5.8%) got no reply.
Lessona shared network is only as complete as its least responsive member, and the Commission calls the rise in unanswered requests "alarming".
Credit
European Commission; the member states' criminal record authorities
2012
Seven million certificates a year
The Disclosure and Barring Service (DBS) began on 1 December 2012, merging the CRB with the Independent Safeguarding Authority, which decided who is barred from working with children and vulnerable adults. In 2025–26 it issued 7,433,877 certificates for England and Wales, 2,918,134 of them basic certificates, the lowest level; basic checks rose 9.1%, a rise DBS puts down largely to the gig economy. Scotland replaced its basic disclosure with a Level 1 disclosure on 1 April 2025.
Credit
Home Office; Disclosure and Barring Service; Disclosure Scotland
2015
Many arrests lack outcomes
An FBI record lists arrests, and whether a case ended in conviction, dismissal or acquittal depends on courts and states sending the outcome. The National Employment Law Project (NELP), a workers' advocacy group, estimated in 2013 that about 17 million FBI checks were run for jobs and licenses in 2012 and that 1.8 million workers a year get checks with faulty or incomplete information. The Government Accountability Office (GAO), Congress's audit office, counted about 120 million FBI checks for non-criminal purposes in fiscal years 2009 to 2013, and found that 20 states recorded outcomes for more than 75% of arrests in 2012, up from 16 in 2006, while 10 recorded half or fewer. A survey for the Bureau of Justice Statistics (BJS), published in 2024, found that state databases held outcomes for an average of 73% of arrests in 2022, and that states processed 15.5 million fingerprint sets for licensing, jobs and regulation against 8.5 million for criminal justice.
Lessonan arrest with no outcome on file reads as guilt, and the cost of the gap falls on the worker.
Credit
NELP (Madeline Neighly and Maurice Emsellem); GAO; SEARCH (Becki Goggins and Dennis DeBacco) for BJS
2019
Court trims the disclosure rules
Until 29 May 2013, standard and enhanced certificates in England and Wales showed every conviction and caution on the Police National Computer, spent or not, and a system for filtering old and minor ones began after the courts found that incompatible with the right to private life. On 30 January 2019 the UK Supreme Court found two parts of the filtering rules disproportionate: the rule that disclosed all of a person's convictions if they had more than one, and the disclosure of reprimands and warnings given to young people. Both were removed from 28 November 2020.
Lessona rule that counts convictions instead of weighing their relevance failed the courts' test of proportionality twice.
Credit
UK Supreme Court (lead judgment by Lord Sumption); Home Office; Disclosure and Barring Service
2021
Birth dates leave court searches
On 26 May 2021 California's Court of Appeal ruled, in All of Us or None v. Hamrick, that a state court rule bars the Riverside Superior Court from letting the public search its online criminal index by date of birth or driver's license number, and the state Supreme Court declined to review it that September. The screening industry's trade groups, CDIA and PBSA, told the Supreme Court that 22.3 million Californians lived in counties that had already removed the birth-date filter, by their members' reports. Michigan's new rules protecting personal identifiers, including birth dates, in court records took effect on 1 January 2022.
Lessonscreening had come to rely on a search feature that the courts' own rule did not allow, and one ruling turned it off.
courts.ca.govsupreme.courts.ca.govcdiaonline.orgcourts.michigan.gov
Credit
California Court of Appeal (Fourth District, Division One); Supreme Court of California; Michigan Supreme Court
Watch for
Non-EU convictions shared
ECRIS-TCN is an EU register that shows which member states hold convictions of people who are not EU citizens. In 2024, 7% of ECRIS requests, about 88,000, concerned such people. Sources disagree on when it starts: the Commission's ECRIS page says the first quarter of 2026, eu-LISA, the EU agency that runs it, lists its entry into operation among its objectives for 2026, and the Commission's report of 19 June 2026 refers to entry into operation in 2027.
Achieved whenThe start date is published in the EU's Official Journal and a Commission or eu-LISA report shows member states exchanging records through it.
commission.europa.eueulisa.europa.eudata.consilium.europa.eu
Claimed by
European Commission and eu-LISA, 2026
Japan checks child workers
Japan's Act No. 69 of 2024, passed on 19 June 2024, takes effect on 25 December 2026. It requires schools and licensed nurseries to confirm through the government whether staff have certain past convictions, and lets cram schools, sports clubs and similar businesses join through certification. Until now Japan's police have issued a criminal record certificate only where a foreign country legally requires one, according to UK government guidance.
Achieved whenThe law is in force and the agency, or an outside body, reports how many confirmation documents have been issued.
Claimed by
Children and Families Agency (Japan), with guidance updated in November 2026
Court searches by machine
First Advantage says that about 90% of its US criminal searches use "intelligent automation" and that 90% of its US criminal screens are finished within one day, as of 31 December 2025.
Achieved whenAn independent audit, a regulator or a client publishes turnaround and accuracy figures with a stated method.
Claimed by
First Advantage, 2026
Open
01
Map what court portals show
A public, dated table of what US court search portals show and accept, starting with all 58 California superior courts and the court for each state's most populous county. For each: whether searching is free, whether a login is needed, whether a birth date is shown in full, by year only or not at all, whether it can be used to narrow a search, whether a license number or address is shown, whether bulk data can be bought, the rule cited, and the date checked. Build it from help pages, court rules and the fields of the search forms, without searching for anyone.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Record checks, country by country
A public table, from official pages, of how 20 countries handle criminal record checks for jobs: the issuing body, who may apply (the applicant, the employer or both), the levels of check, whether old or minor records are left out, the fee, the law it rests on, and the date checked, with every cell linked to its source.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
Map what court portals show
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public, dated table of what US court search portals show and accept, starting with all 58 California superior courts and the court for each state's most populous county. For each: whether searching is free, whether a login is needed, whether a birth date is shown in full, by year only or not at all, whether it can be used to narrow a search, whether a license number or address is shown, whether bulk data can be bought, the rule cited, and the date checked. Build it from help pages, court rules and the fields of the search forms, without searching for anyone.
Why it is still open
Sarah Lageson, Elizabeth Webster and Juan Sandoval coded about 200 state websites in late 2019 and found that 44% of states posted the full birth dates of arrested people, but their data are available only on request and predate the California and Michigan changes. The only chart found from after those changes, sent by CDIA and PBSA to California's Supreme Court in August 2021, covers California counties and rests on members' reports.
Built with what exists
Browser Use 1.0, an open-source browser agent, to reach each portal's help pages within the site's terms (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over"); Python with requests and Beautiful Soup to record form fields; the Wayback Machine for dated copies; the Frictionless Data table schema and validator; GitHub.
First step
Fill the 58 California rows from Rule 2.507 and each court's help pages, and compare them with the 2021 chart.
Done looks like
About 108 rows, each with a source link and the date checked, published under an open license, and a second person who rechecks a random 10% agreeing on at least 90% of cells.
Open 02 · the brief
Record checks, country by country
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public table, from official pages, of how 20 countries handle criminal record checks for jobs: the issuing body, who may apply (the applicant, the employer or both), the levels of check, whether old or minor records are left out, the fee, the law it rests on, and the date checked, with every cell linked to its source.
Why it is still open
The nearest comparisons are old or not public. A European Commission annex of January 2005 compared member states' registers from answers to a questionnaire sent in April 2004. A 2013 study for the Commission by ACRO, the UK police criminal records office, gathered each member state's rules into a reference guide sent to member states, and found employment vetting "too varied" and in need of "greater standardisation". The UK government's guidance on checks for overseas applicants, updated in January 2025, explains how to apply in each country but not what the certificate contains, and some of its country entries were last updated in 2016.
Built with what exists
Official law portals such as legislation.gov.uk, gesetze-im-internet.de and service-public.fr; the EU's e-Justice Portal; a long-document AI model such as Claude Fable 5.2 to draft each cell with the clause it rests on (see the Note "Three working devices"), with a person checking every cell; a CSV file with a JSON schema on GitHub.
First step
Fill England and Wales, Scotland, Germany, France and Japan from the official pages already cited in this file.
Done looks like
20 countries by 9 fields, every cell citing an official page, and a reviewer who spot-checks 40 cells agreeing with at least 95% of them.