BRENNEN

Industries / Consumer goods / Baby products

Safety standards and recalls

Safety standards and recalls are the system that sets what a baby product must withstand before it is sold, checks it in test laboratories and at the border, and pulls it back from shops and homes when it turns out to be dangerous.

6

Milestones achieved, from 1973 to 2024.

3

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1973

    A US product safety agency

    The Consumer Product Safety Act of 27 October 1972 created the US Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) as an independent agency, and it began operating in May 1973. In November 1973 it published mandatory rules for full-size cribs (see Sleep products). Car seats are regulated separately, by the highway safety agency NHTSA (see Car seats).

    archives.govgovinfo.gov

    Credit

    US Congress; CPSC

  2. 1976

    Industry seal on ASTM standards

    In 1976 the Juvenile Products Manufacturers Association (JPMA), the US trade group of baby-product makers, started a voluntary certification program. A product may carry its seal once it is tested to standards written by committees of ASTM International on which manufacturers, consumer groups and CPSC staff sit, and voluntary standards written this way later became the base of US federal rules (see 2008). In June 2025 the association renamed itself the Baby Safety Alliance; its program covers more than 3,200 products in more than 30 categories, tested every year to the latest standards.

    news-medical.nethomenewsnow.com

    Credit

    JPMA, now the Baby Safety Alliance; ASTM International

  3. 2008

    A law named for Danny

    On 12 May 1998, 16-month-old Danny Keysar was strangled at his licensed day care in Chicago when a Playskool Travel-Lite portable crib collapsed. The crib had been recalled in 1993, and neither the day care nor the state inspectors who had visited a week earlier knew. The Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act (CPSIA), signed on 14 August 2008, carries his name in section 104: the CPSC must set mandatory standards for durable infant and toddler products, at least two product types every six months, as strict as the voluntary standards or stricter, and makers must pack a postage-paid registration card with each product so they can reach owners in a recall, required from June 2010. Section 102 made testing by an outside laboratory mandatory for children's products; the CPSC has accepted more than 600 laboratories worldwide, and the maker must issue a Children's Product Certificate based on their results. Section 212 created SaferProducts.gov, a public database of reports of harm, which went live on 11 March 2011.

    Lessona card reaches only the first buyer, as Representative Stearns warned in the 2007 debate, and in 2024 Kids In Danger, reviewing the reports on children's product recalls from 2022, found that only 22% of recalled items had been returned, repaired or destroyed.

    govinfo.govrecalls.justia.comgovinfo.govlaw.cornell.edugovinfo.govcpsc.govdwt.comwpxi.com

    Credit

    US Congress, from a bill by Representatives Jan Schakowsky and Fred Upton; Danny's parents, Linda Ginzel and Boaz Keysar, who founded the advocacy group Kids In Danger

  4. 2012

    One portal for recalls

    The OECD (Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development) and the European Union opened the GlobalRecalls portal in Brussels on 19 October 2012, so that product recalls from countries such as the US, Australia and Canada can be searched in one place.

    Lessona shared list does not by itself take products off sale, and in an October 2021 sweep across 21 jurisdictions, 87% of the 1,196 banned or recalled products checked were still available to buy online.

    toybook.comproductsafety.gov.auideas.repec.org

    Credit

    OECD; European Union

  5. 2024

    EU duties for marketplaces

    The EU's General Product Safety Regulation (EU) 2023/988, which applies from 13 December 2024, replaced the 2001 directive on which Safety Gate, the EU's rapid alert system for dangerous non-food products (formerly called RAPEX), was built. Online marketplaces must register in the Safety Gate portal and name a single contact point for product safety, act on a regulator's order to remove a listing within two working days, and directly notify every buyer of a recalled product, who must be offered a remedy. The first coordinated check under the new law, from 1 April to 15 May 2025, covered 1,741 offers of childcare articles on 47 marketplaces: 48% lacked full information on the maker, 16 offers were for products already flagged in Safety Gate, authorities sent 252 orders, and 10 removed listings reappeared.

    Lessononly 25 of the 47 marketplaces had registered in Safety Gate as the law requires, so a new duty still has to be checked.

    oeil.europarl.europa.eubmluk.gv.atdsca.gob.es

    Credit

    European Parliament and Council of the EU; the European Commission and the national authorities of the Consumer Safety Network

  6. 2024

    Amazon made to recall

    On 29 July 2024 the CPSC ruled that Amazon acted as a distributor, a business bound by US product safety law's recall duties, when it received, stored and delivered goods that other sellers sold through its Fulfilled by Amazon service. The case covered more than 400,000 items, among them children's sleepwear that failed flammability rules. A January 2025 order told Amazon to email buyers, show the recall on their order pages, keep recall notices posted for at least five years, refund buyers who prove they destroyed the product and report progress monthly for five years. Amazon sued the CPSC in federal court in Maryland in March 2025 to overturn the orders.

    Lessonthe commission found that Amazon's own notices had not done enough to get the products out of homes, and that without a required remedy such products can go on being sold and resold.

    cpsc.govconsumerfed.orgfoley.com

    Credit

    CPSC

Watch for

  1. Product safety inside HHS

    The President's budget for fiscal year 2026 proposes to move the CPSC's work into the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) under an Assistant Secretary for Consumer Product Safety, with USD 135 million and 459 full-time staff, about USD 16 million less than the CPSC's 2025 funding; the CPSC stays a separate agency until Congress passes a law. The commission itself has changed: the President fired its three Democratic members in May 2025, Acting Chairman Peter Feldman was for a time its only member, two new commissioners were sworn in in August and September 2026, and in September 2026 an appeals court upheld the firings.

    Achieved whenCongress passes the transfer into law and an outside body, such as the Government Accountability Office (GAO), reports how recalls and new rules for nursery products changed after it.

    cpsc.govkhlaw.comcpsc.govbicycleretailer.com

    Claimed by

    the President's Budget, as set out in the CPSC's own budget request, May 2025

  2. Certificates filed at the border

    Since 8 July 2026, importers of consumer products that must be certified, children's products among them, have had to file the certificate data electronically with US Customs and Border Protection before the goods enter the country. The CPSC says it will use the data to score shipments in the system that picks imports for inspection, so that it can stop high-risk shipments earlier and hold up compliant importers less, and its 2026 budget request plans machine learning to read incident reports for new hazard patterns.

    Achieved whenthe CPSC, its Inspector General or the GAO publishes before-and-after figures on the share of inspected children's product shipments found to break the rules and on clearance times.

    govinfo.govcpsc.govcpsc.gov

    Claimed by

    CPSC, May 2025 and July 2026

  3. Australia's recall overhaul

    On 19 September 2026 Australia's government opened a consultation, running to 18 October 2026, on reforms to improve recall and reporting processes, strengthen regulators' powers to intervene and enforce, and help regulators spot and respond to safety risks more quickly. It names mandatory safety requirements for online marketplaces, and general safety protections covering all consumer goods, as further reforms that remain a priority.

    Achieved whenParliament passes the changes and the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) publishes recall response rates measured under them.

    ministers.treasury.gov.au

    Claimed by

    Andrew Leigh, Assistant Minister for Productivity, Competition, Charities and Treasury, September 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Recalled baby gear resale count

    A public monthly count of second-hand listings for recalled or banned durable baby products (cribs, play yards, high chairs, strollers, infant sleepers, carriers and the like) on resale platforms in at least five countries, for example the US, Canada, the UK, Germany and Australia. A pipeline pulls each regulator's recall list, searches listings through the platforms' official interfaces or by recorded manual searches, flags likely matches by brand, model and photo, and has a person confirm each one before it is counted and reported to the platform. Only listing IDs are kept, no data about sellers.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Recall response rates compared

    A public, machine-readable table of how many recalled units were actually returned, repaired or destroyed, for at least 150 recalls of durable infant products in at least three countries, each figure linked to the page of the document it comes from. Each recall is coded for how owners were told (registration cards or email to known buyers, marketplace order-page notices, or press release and social media only), so that the effect of direct notice can be measured.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Recalled baby gear resale count

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public monthly count of second-hand listings for recalled or banned durable baby products (cribs, play yards, high chairs, strollers, infant sleepers, carriers and the like) on resale platforms in at least five countries, for example the US, Canada, the UK, Germany and Australia. A pipeline pulls each regulator's recall list, searches listings through the platforms' official interfaces or by recorded manual searches, flags likely matches by brand, model and photo, and has a person confirm each one before it is counted and reported to the platform. Only listing IDs are kept, no data about sellers.

Why it is still open

The CPSC says its staff continually monitor several online marketplaces for recalled products, which it is illegal to sell, but it publishes no counts. Published counts are one-off and one-country: Kirschman and Smith (2007) tracked 141 recalled children's products on eBay for 30 days, found 190 auctions and found that the items were sold most of the time; Consumer Reports (October 2026) found banned baby products on Craigslist, eBay, Facebook Marketplace and Mercari and stopped counting in-bed sleepers on Facebook Marketplace at 50, without a published method. The EU's 2025 sweep found 16 offers of already-flagged products among 1,741 shop listings, once. Existing tools do part of the job: CatalogRecall, a pilot service, screens resale listings against CPSC recalls only and publishes no tally, and recall-radar, an open-source site, gathers CPSC, EU Safety Gate and other recall feeds but does not check listings.

cpsc.govpmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.govnews4jax.comdsca.gob.escatalogrecall-api.pages.devgithub.com

Built with what exists

The CPSC's public recall web service (JSON); Health Canada's Recalls and Safety Alerts open data (JSON and CSV, updated daily); EU Safety Gate and the OECD GlobalRecalls portal; eBay's public Browse API for listings on its US, UK, German, Canadian and Australian sites; manual searches recorded by volunteers on platforms whose terms forbid automated collection, such as Facebook Marketplace; Meta's Muse Ember to pull brand and model from listing text (see the Note "The jobs agents repeat"); Gemini Decision 1 to answer "is this listing photo the recalled product, yes or no" for many listing and recall pairs in one pass (see the Note "A thousand questions, one pass"), with every yes checked by a person.

saferproducts.govopen.canada.ca

  1. First step

    Pull every CPSC recall since 2016 in the 18 product types that must carry registration cards, and search eBay's US site for the 25 with the most units recalled.

  2. Done looks like

    Twelve consecutive monthly counts, by country, platform and recall, covering every recall of durable infant products in the five countries since 2016; on a hand-checked sample of 200 counted listings, at least 95% confirmed as the recalled model; for each platform, the share of reported listings removed within seven days; code, method and counts published.

Open 02 · the brief

Recall response rates compared

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public, machine-readable table of how many recalled units were actually returned, repaired or destroyed, for at least 150 recalls of durable infant products in at least three countries, each figure linked to the page of the document it comes from. Each recall is coded for how owners were told (registration cards or email to known buyers, marketplace order-page notices, or press release and social media only), so that the effect of direct notice can be measured.

Why it is still open

After a US recall the firm must send monthly progress reports to the government. Kids In Danger reviewed the reports for children's product recalls from 2022 and found that only 22% of recalled products were returned, replaced or repaired, and that only 36% of the reports were sufficient; that work covers the US only. The CPSC says direct notice is the most effective way to get a response, yet in the 2007 debate on Danny's law a sponsor could cite only an estimate that recalls reach "a mere 16 percent", and the 2009 rule that created registration cards gives no figures on how many come back. The OECD's 2018 report on recall effectiveness describes measuring it as a challenge for regulators and businesses alike.

6abc.comwpxi.comgovinfo.govgovinfo.govideas.repec.org

Built with what exists

Freedom of Information Act requests to the CPSC; Access to Information Act requests to Health Canada; freedom of information requests to Australia's ACCC and the UK's Office for Product Safety and Standards; the CPSC's recall web service for the list of recalls and units; Meta's Muse Ember to pull unit counts out of the released reports (see the Note "The jobs agents repeat"); Python and a public Git repository.

  1. First step

    Use the CPSC web service to list 2025's recalls in the 18 product types that must carry registration cards, and file Freedom of Information Act requests for their progress reports.

  2. Done looks like

    Response rates for at least 150 recalls from at least three countries, each with a page reference; a second person rechecks a random 10% of rows and disagrees on fewer than 2%; a published comparison of median response rates with and without direct notice, with confidence intervals.