Industries / Energy, water and waste / Environmental services / Asbestos and lead abatement
Containment
Containment is the work of sealing off the place where asbestos or lead paint is disturbed, with plastic sheeting, air pressure and careful cleaning, so the dust stays inside and people outside are protected.
7
Milestones achieved, from 1994 to 2024.
1
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
3
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1994
Enclosures get set numbers
The asbestos standard for construction that the US Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) issued in August 1994, and has amended since, sets numbers for enclosures. A negative pressure enclosure is a plastic room whose fans pull air out through high-efficiency (HEPA) filters, so that leaks draw air in instead of letting dust out. It requires such an enclosure to keep at least 4 air changes per hour and a pressure at least 0.02 inches of water (about 5 pascals) below the outside, shown on a manometer, and to be smoke-tested for leaks before work and at the start of each shift. It also sets rules for glove bags, sealed plastic bags fitted around a pipe so its insulation can be cut away inside: 6-mil plastic, smoke-tested before use, used once and never moved. The same rule cut the exposure limit (see Air monitoring).
Credit
OSHA
1996
Tarps trapped the lead
Steel bridges coated with lead paint are stripped by abrasive blasting, which fires steel grit at the paint. Crews blast inside plastic tarpaulins to keep the dust out of the neighborhood. On one bridge, Conroy and colleagues measured airborne lead inside the enclosure at 219 times OSHA's permissible exposure limit, and cadmium at 3.1 times, and concluded that supplied-air blasting helmets could not bring workers' exposure down to the limit at those levels. A companion paper measured 196 to 31,410 micrograms of lead per cubic meter in 13 enclosed work areas on a bridge and viaduct.
LessonA containment that protects the public can concentrate the hazard on the workers inside it.
Credit
L. M. Conroy, R. M. Menezes-Lindsay, P. M. Sullivan, S. Cali and L. Forst (Archives of Environmental Health, 1996)
2006
Smoke tests before stripping
The Health and Safety Executive (HSE), Great Britain's workplace safety regulator, published its guide for licensed asbestos removal contractors, HSG247, in 2006. It says that extracting about 0.2 cubic meters of air per second for each 100 cubic meters enclosed, roughly 8 air changes per hour, has given satisfactory results, which is twice the US minimum. Before work starts, the enclosure is filled with smoke with the fans off, and every area outside it, including the floors above and below, is checked for escaping smoke. The guide also lists signs of poor control, such as a dusty viewing panel, a heavily loaded prefilter, or sheeting that shows little sign of negative pressure.
LessonA test done once is not enough, because HSE's own scientists, watching eight licensed removals in 2016 to 2019, found smoke tests were not consistently repeated after work breaks or leak repairs (research report RR1217, 2024).
Credit
HSE
2008
Lead-safe rules for renovators
The US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) issued its Renovation, Repair and Painting (RRP) rule on 22 April 2008, and it applied in full from 22 April 2010. Firms paid to disturb paint in homes and in places used regularly by children under 6, such as day care centers, built before 1978, must be certified, seal the work area with plastic, clean by set methods and then check the cleaning. Open-flame burning, heat guns above 1,100 °F, and power sanding, grinding or blasting without a HEPA exhaust are banned. The rule rested on EPA's Dust Study: power planing left a geometric mean of 32,644 micrograms of lead per square foot on the floor before cleaning, while containment, the set cleaning and the check together left 5 to 148, depending on the job. The check compares a wiped cloth with a printed "cleaning verification card". In 2010 EPA removed an opt-out that had let owner-occupants with no child under 6 or pregnant woman at home waive the rule.
Credit
EPA
2019
Watchdog faults the enforcement
EPA's Office of Inspector General found that EPA had no effective strategy to implement and enforce the RRP rule. The two EPA offices responsible could not identify or estimate the current number of renovators or renovations in any region. The last estimate, from 2010, was about 320,000 firms doing about 18 million renovations a year.
LessonA rule enforced by site inspections needs a count of the firms and jobs it covers.
Credit
EPA Office of Inspector General, report 19-P-0302, 9 September 2019
2021
Air changes are not enough
Researchers at VTT, Finland's state technical research center, built an L-shaped asbestos enclosure in a laboratory and compared six ways of ventilating it using a tracer gas. A high air change rate alone did not reach every corner. Extra air inlets far from the exhaust, recirculating air with a pressure controller, or an exhaust extended into the dead zones did. They recommend a pressure difference of at least 10 pascals, about twice the US minimum, to leave a margin of safety when people walk in and out.
Credit
I. Kulmala and colleagues, VTT Technical Research Centre of Finland (Annals of Work Exposures and Health, 2021)
2024
Leaky barriers spread fibers
At the Building Research Institute (ITB) in Warsaw, A. Obmiński measured removals in buildings in Poland where the work zone was sealed off but not kept under negative pressure. Fibers leaked through the barriers. Removing asbestos-cement sheets raised the air outside the work zone to as much as 3,000 fibers per cubic meter, and removing friable asbestos raised it to 18,000 to 28,900, against under 300 to 400 in such buildings in normal use. For a short time the air outside the building was polluted up to 15 m away.
LessonBarriers without negative pressure can leave fibers in the rest of a building after the removal is finished.
Credit
A. Obmiński, Building Research Institute, Warsaw (Scientific Reports, 2024)
Watch for
More certified renovators in Maine
EPA says that in 2025 its work in Maine raised the number of RRP-certified firms by over 130% and of certified renovators by over 21%, with 72 onsite inspections, and that it will continue in 2026 and 2027.
Achieved whenan outside party, such as Maine's public health agency or EPA's Inspector General, reports fewer violations found on inspection or fewer lead-poisoned children in the targeted counties.
Claimed by
EPA (Boston regional office), May 2026
Open
01
Enclosure test on clean plastic
A full-size test enclosure of plastic sheeting on a timber frame, with no asbestos or lead anywhere near it, fitted with a rented negative air machine (a fan with HEPA filters) and logging pressure gauges. Run it through the conditions crews meet: different room sizes, cut leaks of known area, doors opened by people walking in and out, and filters loaded until airflow drops. Publish the data and a calculator that tells a crew, before setup, whether their machines and enclosure will hold a chosen pressure.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Code every lead-safe case
A public table of every federal RRP enforcement case since 2010, coded by what went wrong on the job (no certification, no containment, no cleaning check, missing records, an uncertified subcontractor), with the penalty, the kind of firm, the state and a link to each case document.
The briefCredit · unclaimed03
Phone reads the cleaning card
A phone app that photographs a used cleaning cloth next to EPA's cleaning verification card and says pass or fail, tested against certified renovators on cloths wiped with clean test dust (a commercial standard dust that contains no lead).
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
Enclosure test on clean plastic
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A full-size test enclosure of plastic sheeting on a timber frame, with no asbestos or lead anywhere near it, fitted with a rented negative air machine (a fan with HEPA filters) and logging pressure gauges. Run it through the conditions crews meet: different room sizes, cut leaks of known area, doors opened by people walking in and out, and filters loaded until airflow drops. Publish the data and a calculator that tells a crew, before setup, whether their machines and enclosure will hold a chosen pressure.
Why it is still open
The rules disagree. OSHA asks for 4 air changes per hour and about 5 pascals, HSE's guide for about 8 air changes per hour, and the VTT study for at least 10 pascals. The nearest prior work, VTT's 2021 laboratory study, tested one L-shaped enclosure and reported its results in a paper, and a Zenodo search found no shared dataset of enclosure pressure tests. Equipment makers' online calculators, such as Abatement Technologies', count the machines needed from room volume and air changes alone; they do not estimate the pressure an enclosure with leaks and foot traffic will hold.
Built with what exists
6-mil polyethylene sheeting and tape, a rented HEPA negative air machine, two or three digital differential pressure gauges that log to a phone (for example the Testo 510i), a theatrical fog machine for smoke tests, and Python for the model.
First step
Build a 3 m by 3 m by 2.5 m enclosure in a garage, run one machine for an hour, and log the pressure with the door shut and with someone walking through the airlock every five minutes.
Done looks like
Forty logged runs published under an open license, and a calculator that predicts the pressure held within 2 pascals on ten runs it was not built from.
Open 02 · the brief
Code every lead-safe case
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public table of every federal RRP enforcement case since 2010, coded by what went wrong on the job (no certification, no containment, no cleaning check, missing records, an uncertified subcontractor), with the penalty, the kind of firm, the state and a link to each case document.
Why it is still open
EPA's ECHO database lists federal cases with the law sections cited and the penalties, and EPA posts yearly lists of RRP actions as web pages, but which work practice failed is written only in the case documents. EPA's Inspector General found in 2019 that EPA did not know how many renovators or renovations its rule covered, and a search found no coded table of cases.
Built with what exists
ECHO's ICIS-FE&C case download, the consent agreements in EPA's administrative enforcement dockets, an AI model that reads long documents and fills a fixed form (see the Note "The jobs agents repeat"), and a person who checks a sample.
First step
Download the ICIS-FE&C files, keep the cases that cite the lead-based paint rules at 40 CFR part 745, and count them by year.
Done looks like
Every federal lead-paint case under the Toxic Substances Control Act in ECHO from fiscal 2010 onward coded, with 10% coded twice by different people at 95% agreement or better, published as a CSV file.
Open 03 · the brief
Phone reads the cleaning card
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A phone app that photographs a used cleaning cloth next to EPA's cleaning verification card and says pass or fail, tested against certified renovators on cloths wiped with clean test dust (a commercial standard dust that contains no lead).
Why it is still open
When it issued the rule in 2008, EPA agreed that comparing a cloth with the card "has an element of subjectivity", after commenters said results could depend on eyesight, room lighting and judgment. A search found no study of how often renovators agree with one another, and no app that reads the card.
Built with what exists
The EPA card from an accredited renovator training provider, disposable cleaning cloths, ISO 12103-1 test dust, a printed color reference chart, OpenCV, and if needed a small vision model fine-tuned on one GPU (see the Note "One GPU to fine-tune").
First step
Get the card and cloths, wipe 30 cloths across a range of dust loads on a clean test board, and have three people grade them in daylight, warm indoor light and dim light.
Done looks like
300 cloths graded by five certified renovators and by the app under three kinds of lighting, with the app agreeing with the renovators' majority at least as often as the renovators agree with one another, and the photos and grades published.