BRENNEN

Industries / Media, arts and recreation / Art galleries

Sales

This is the work of pricing and selling works, both new work sold for the first time (the primary market) and works resold by their owners (the secondary market), and of checking who the buyers are.

5

Milestones achieved, from 1540 to 2025.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1540

    A hall for selling paintings

    Antwerp's city government opened the schilderspand, 100 stalls around the second floor of the city's new exchange, where painters and dealers sold paintings all year. The painter-dealer Jan van Kessel had more than 610 paintings in stock there in 1581. Earlier sale halls in the city go back to the Dominican pand of 1445.

    hnanews.org

    Credit

    the city of Antwerp; Filip Vermeylen, whose 2003 study reconstructed the market

  2. 2017

    Galleries sell online

    David Zwirner launched its online viewing room, a web page selling a set of works for a limited time, in January 2017. By August 2018 its online sales had "surged", and it appointed its first online sales director.

    theartnewspaper.com

    Credit

    David Zwirner

  3. 2020

    Dealers must check buyers

    From 10 January 2020, UK firms that trade in or broker art in deals of €10,000 or more had to check their buyers and sellers under the EU's fifth Money Laundering Directive, and register with the tax authority HMRC by 10 June 2021. HMRC fined almost 50 UK art businesses between January and September 2024, with penalties averaging above £3,000 and up to £13,000, all for failing to register. The UK set the threshold at £10,000 in regulations made on 9 June 2026.

    LessonYears after the rules began, HMRC's 2024 fines were still all for failing to register at all.

    theartnewspaper.comtheartnewspaper.comlegislation.gov.uk

    Credit

    HM Treasury and HMRC; the European Union

  4. 2022

    The US holds off

    On 4 February 2022 the US Treasury published a study of illicit finance in the high-value art market, required by the Anti-Money Laundering Act of 2020. It found "some evidence of money laundering risk" and limited evidence of terrorist financing risk. Rather than new rules, it set out options, one of which was to apply anti-money-laundering duties to certain art market participants. It named art-backed lenders outside those rules, and high-turnover dealers, as higher risk, and small galleries as lower risk.

    home.treasury.gov

    Credit

    US Department of the Treasury

  5. 2025

    Online sales fall back

    Online art sales fell to $9.2 billion in 2025, their lowest level since 2019, while art fairs brought in 35% of dealers' sales and dealers' total sales rose 2% to $34.8 billion.

    LessonSelling online became a lasting extra channel, but it did not replace selling in person.

    artbasel.com

    Credit

    Arts Economics (Clare McAndrew) for Art Basel and UBS

Watch for

  1. AI price estimates

    Artscapy offers free AI price estimates, and MyArtBroker uses machine learning on data from 400 auction houses, with a person checking each step. Beowolff Capital, which took over Artnet in 2025 and bought a controlling stake in Artsy, plans AI valuation tools, with "the exact details to be determined". No independent test of accuracy was reported.

    Achieved whenan outside test compares estimates made before sale with the prices later paid, for a published list of works.

    thestar.com.my

    Claimed by

    Artscapy, MyArtBroker and Andrew Wolff of Beowolff Capital, February 2026, as reported by Bloomberg

Open

  1. 01

    An observed price count

    A public tally, every three months, of how many works on gallery websites and fair sales pages show a price, a price range or only "price on request", broken down by region and price level.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    An AML test set

    AML means anti-money-laundering. The test set is 200 made-up customer files, each with buyer, seller, payment route, artwork and delivery, built from HMRC's published risk indicators for art dealers. Half carry planted warning signs, and a compliance professional labels them all. It would test the checklists and AI tools that small dealers use. No real customers or payments are involved.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

An observed price count

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public tally, every three months, of how many works on gallery websites and fair sales pages show a price, a price range or only "price on request", broken down by region and price level.

Why it is still open

In an Artsy survey of more than 1,600 galleries and collectors, reported in April 2025, 44% of galleries said they show prices online for all works and 25% give prices only on request. That is what galleries said, not what their pages show. This research found no published count made by checking the listings themselves.

en.ilsole24ore.com

Built with what exists

Browser Use 1.0 to visit the pages (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over"); Gemini Decision 1 to put each listing in one of the categories (see the Note "A thousand questions, one pass"); a Wayback Machine snapshot of each page checked, so that anyone can recheck.

  1. First step

    Take the exhibitor list of one fair, check 50 gallery websites by hand to settle the categories, then run the agent on the same 50 and compare.

  2. Done looks like

    1,000 galleries checked each quarter, a 300-listing hand check that agrees at least 98% of the time, and the data and code published.

Open 02 · the brief

An AML test set

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

AML means anti-money-laundering. The test set is 200 made-up customer files, each with buyer, seller, payment route, artwork and delivery, built from HMRC's published risk indicators for art dealers. Half carry planted warning signs, and a compliance professional labels them all. It would test the checklists and AI tools that small dealers use. No real customers or payments are involved.

Why it is still open

HMRC rates the art market a medium risk for money laundering and lists warning signs such as anonymity, off-record sales and unusual buying, but small firms still fall foul of the basics: almost 50 were fined in 2024 for failing to register. This research found no public test set for checking dealers' tools.

gov.uktheartnewspaper.com

Built with what exists

HMRC's guidance, published under the Open Government Licence; Claude Fable 5.2 to draft the files (see the Note "Three working devices"); Gemini Decision 1 for flag-or-no-flag answers (see the Note "A thousand questions, one pass"); every file run 20 times (see the Note "All twenty times").

  1. First step

    Turn HMRC's list of risk indicators into 30 yes-or-no checks, each citing its paragraph, and write the first 20 files.

  2. Done looks like

    A published catch rate and false-alarm rate for each tool tested on the 200 files. A tool passes only if it catches at least 95% of planted warning signs on 20 of 20 runs.