BRENNEN

Industries / Government, education and community / Government / Courts / Arbitration

Online dispute resolution

Online dispute resolution (ODR) is settling disputes over the internet, through software that structures the exchange between the parties, sometimes with a mediator or decision-maker joining online.

7

Milestones achieved, from 1996 to 2024.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1996

    A magistrate by email

    The Virtual Magistrate, announced on 4 March 1996, offered fast decisions by email on complaints about allegedly wrongful online postings, such as messages said to be defamatory or to infringe copyright, with the American Arbitration Association as clerk and Villanova University's Center for Information Law and Practice running the website, on $75,000 from the National Center for Automated Information Research. Its own report, written that May, says it received three complaints in its first six weeks and none met its criteria: getting every party to agree to take part took more work than expected.

    LessonOnline resolution only works when both sides have a reason to show up.

    umass.edu

    Credit

    National Center for Automated Information Research; Cyberspace Law Institute; American Arbitration Association; Villanova Center for Information Law and Practice; Robert Gellman, its executive director

  2. 1998

    Blind bidding for claims

    James Burchetta and Charles Brofman of Cybersettle filed a US patent on 6 August 1998, granted on 11 December 2001, for a computerized way to settle claims in which each side submits secret offers and demands that only the software sees. A claim settles automatically when an offer and a demand come close enough, so neither side reveals its limit. The ABA Journal reported in 2007 that Cybersettle had settled claims worth more than $1 billion, mostly insurance claims, and had a contract with New York City for claims against the city.

    patents.google.comabajournal.com

    Credit

    James D. Burchetta, Charles S. Brofman, Cybersettle

  3. 1999

    eBay tries online mediation

    In 1999 eBay put a link to a dispute service run by Ethan Katsh and Janet Rifkin of the University of Massachusetts on its site; in about two weeks it received some 200 buyer-seller disputes, which one human mediator handled by email, and the trial ended early because it was overwhelming. eBay then referred disputes to SquareTrade, which gave parties structured forms and limited free text before a mediator joined. Katsh's interviewer in 2014 put the system that grew from the pilot at about 60 million disputes a year.

    LessonA mediator by email did not scale; software that guides the exchange did.

    judiciary.ukabajournal.com

    Credit

    Ethan Katsh and Janet Rifkin; eBay; SquareTrade

  4. 2000

    Domain disputes go online

    ICANN, which coordinates internet domain names, adopted the Uniform Domain-Name Dispute-Resolution Policy (UDRP) on 26 August 1999: a trademark owner can ask an approved provider to have a domain name transferred, and the provider's panelists decide. The first case at the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO), filed on 2 December 1999, was decided by a single panelist, M. Scott Donahey, on 14 January 2000. WIPO handled more than 6,200 domain cases in 2025, its most ever, and more than 80,000 in 25 years.

    icann.orgwipo.intwipo.int

    Credit

    ICANN; WIPO Arbitration and Mediation Center

  5. 2016

    A platform traders ignored

    The European Commission opened its online dispute resolution platform to the public on 15 February 2016; it passed consumer complaints about online purchases to approved out-of-court bodies, in any EU language. It received more than 24,000 complaints in its first year, but 85% were closed automatically after 30 days, mostly because the trader never agreed to a body. By 2024 only 2% of complaints received a positive reply from traders, about 200 cases a year reached an out-of-court body, and the EU shut the platform on 20 July 2025.

    LessonA referral site that traders are free to ignore resolves few disputes, however many people visit it.

    eur-lex.europa.eueur-lex.europa.eu

    Credit

    European Commission

  6. 2020

    Separating couples online

    Australia's National Legal Aid launched amica in mid-2020, a website built with $3 million of federal money where separating couples can agree on parenting arrangements and divide property; it uses artificial intelligence to suggest how to split assets, taking into account how courts generally handle similar cases, and the government says it reflects 1,300 family law scenarios; and is not meant for cases involving family violence. Australia's Attorney-General's Department said in February 2026 that it had helped more than 17,000 couples.

    lawyersweekly.com.authelawyermag.com

    Credit

    National Legal Aid; Legal Services Commission of South Australia, which runs it; Australian Attorney-General's Department

  7. 2024

    Outside review of platform decisions

    Article 21 of the EU's Digital Services Act lets users who disagree with a platform's decision about their content or account take it, free of charge, to a certified out-of-court body. Europe's first such body began work in 2024, and by June 2026 nine had been certified in eight member states. In the second half of 2025 the largest platforms reported 14,989 disputes submitted to these bodies and 7,770 decided, 85.5% against the platform, by Kieran Maynard's tally of their transparency reports. One body, User Rights, reports that for Meta's platforms only about 13% of cases ended with the content handled as it recommended, against nearly 90% at TikTok.

    LessonAn outside reviewer's non-binding decision only helps users where the platform takes part and acts on it.

    dsa-observatory.eukieranmaynard.com

    Credit

    European Parliament and Council (Digital Services Act); certified bodies including User Rights and Appeals Centre Europe

Watch for

  1. An AI runs the mediation

    Dyspute.ai, a New Hampshire company, launched version 2 of Adri, an AI mediator that interviews each side by chat, makes the first settlement proposal, rewrites hostile messages in neutral terms and drafts the settlement, working asynchronously so the parties never need to be online together. Its beta launched in March 2025, and the company is offering discounted pilots in exchange for feedback; no outcome figures were given.

    Achieved whenthe company or an outside reviewer publishes settlement rates and party ratings for completed cases.

    lawnext.com

    Claimed by

    Dyspute.ai, January 2026

  2. A portal replaces the platform

    The EU's revised consumer dispute directive, Directive (EU) 2025/2647, required the Commission to build, by 20 April 2026, a digital tool that points consumers to the right redress route and to approved out-of-court bodies, with free machine translation. The Commission has soft-launched a revamped Consumer Redress Portal with a "Solution Finder" and asked dispute bodies for feedback by 22 May 2026 before promoting it.

    Achieved whenthe Commission or an outside evaluator publishes how many consumers the portal sent to out-of-court bodies and how many of those disputes were resolved, set against the old platform's 200 or so a year.

    eur-lex.europa.eudig.watchconsumer-redress.ec.europa.eu

    Claimed by

    European Commission, April 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Accessibility audit of ODR services

    A public audit of the complaint pages of about 30 online dispute services (domain-name dispute providers, the EU Consumer Redress Portal, amica, the certified Digital Services Act bodies, commercial ODR platforms) against the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG 2.2, level AA), the standard checklist for making websites usable by disabled people, plus a reading-level score for each page.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Match the two dispute counts

    A table, by platform and half-year from the second half of 2024, that sets the numbers of Digital Services Act out-of-court disputes, outcomes and decisions carried out that each large platform reports beside the numbers the certified bodies report for the same platform and period, with every gap flagged. It uses published totals only, not any individual dispute.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Accessibility audit of ODR services

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public audit of the complaint pages of about 30 online dispute services (domain-name dispute providers, the EU Consumer Redress Portal, amica, the certified Digital Services Act bodies, commercial ODR platforms) against the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG 2.2, level AA), the standard checklist for making websites usable by disabled people, plus a reading-level score for each page.

Why it is still open

David Allen Larson, who designed an ODR process for New York's courts, has urged providers since 2019 to meet WCAG, most recently in the New York State Bar Association's journal in June 2024, but a search found no published audit of ODR services; the Commission says only that its new portal "is in line with the accessibility standards".

nysba.orgaboutrsi.org

Built with what exists

axe-core, Deque's open-source accessibility checker; Google Lighthouse; the free NVDA screen reader for manual checks; a published WCAG 2.2 checklist; a readability formula such as Flesch-Kincaid.

  1. First step

    List the 30 services and run axe-core on each one's landing page and complaint form.

  2. Done looks like

    30 services scored, with automated error counts, the result of a screen-reader walk-through of each complaint form up to (not including) submission, and reading levels, published with the raw reports and rerun six months later.

Open 02 · the brief

Match the two dispute counts

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A table, by platform and half-year from the second half of 2024, that sets the numbers of Digital Services Act out-of-court disputes, outcomes and decisions carried out that each large platform reports beside the numbers the certified bodies report for the same platform and period, with every gap flagged. It uses published totals only, not any individual dispute.

Why it is still open

Kieran Maynard totalled the platforms' side for the second half of 2025 (14,989 disputes submitted, 7,770 decided), and a June 2026 review by User Rights staff compiled the bodies' side and noted that "discrepancies between ODS reporting and platform reporting can be an avenue for regulatory scrutiny"; neither puts the two side by side. A study for the European Commission, published in November 2026, drew on desk research and interviews and did not assess the platforms' compliance.

kieranmaynard.comdsa-observatory.euieu-monitoring.com

Built with what exists

The platforms' harmonised Digital Services Act transparency reports (Table 7, on complaints and out-of-court disputes); the certified bodies' published reports, read with pdftotext and Python; pandas.

  1. First step

    Download the second-half 2025 Table 7 figures for the largest platforms and the 2025 reports of User Rights and Appeals Centre Europe, and match them for one platform.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 10 large platforms and 5 bodies for the second half of 2025 and the first half of 2026, every cell linked to its report, published as a CSV and notebook with a list of every mismatch greater than 10%.