Industries / Government, education and community / Government / Emergency services / Ambulance and medical transport
Non-emergency rides
This is the work of getting patients who are not in an emergency to and from care, such as dialysis, clinic visits and the trip home from hospital, by stretcher van, wheelchair van, taxi, ride-share car or a refund for their own travel.
5
Milestones achieved, from 1966 to 2022.
1
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1966
Medicaid promises a ride
Medicaid, the US public health insurance for people with low incomes, must make sure its enrollees can get to covered care, a duty now called the assurance of transportation (42 CFR 431.53). Federal guidance listed transport to and from medical services as early as the 1966 Handbook of Public Assistance, and the federal health department wrote it into regulation in the late 1960s, as an administrative rule rather than a benefit named in law. In 1974 Smith v. Vowell, in a federal court in Texas, was the first case to test whether the duty could be enforced, by MACPAC's account. Rides go by taxi, van, bus, ambulance or a family car paid by the mile.
Credit
US federal health department (then the Department of Health, Education, and Welfare)
2018
Free rides, same no-shows
In West Philadelphia, 786 Medicaid patients of two primary care practices were split by the day of their reminder call: on even weekdays they were offered a free ride-share trip to the appointment, on odd weekdays they were not. The trial ran from October 2016 to April 2017. Of the 288 offered a ride who answered the call, 85 used one, and the share of missed appointments was 36.5% with the offer and 36.7% without.
Lessona cheaper, faster ride did not cut missed visits when few patients took it up.
Credit
Krisda H. Chaiyachati and colleagues, Philadelphia, in JAMA Internal Medicine
2019
German taxi rides pre-approved
German statutory health insurers had to approve every ride to outpatient treatment, such as dialysis or chemotherapy, before it took place. Since a nursing staff law (the Pflegepersonal-Stärkungsgesetz) came into force on 1 January 2019, a prescribed taxi or hire-car ride counts as approved for people whose mobility is permanently limited: those with the severe disability marks aG, Bl or H, care grade 3 with a lasting mobility limit, or care grade 4 or 5. A ride in a patient transport ambulance, with trained staff on board, still needs the insurer's approval.
Credit
German Bundestag; Federal Joint Committee (G-BA), which wrote the rule into its patient transport directive on 19 December 2019
2020
Rides written into law
By 2020 some US states, among them Iowa, Indiana, Kentucky and Utah, had federal permission (waivers) to drop non-emergency medical transportation (NEMT) for some adults, and the federal government had considered making the benefit optional. In December 2020 Congress put the duty to provide NEMT into the Social Security Act through the Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2021. The same law requires states to set minimum standards for drivers, including ride-share drivers, and ordered reports from the GAO, the auditor that reports to Congress, and from the health department.
Credit
US Congress
2022
England sets national transport rules
NHS non-emergency patient transport makes more than 11 million journeys a year in England: almost half to outpatient clinics, about a third to kidney dialysis and a fifth for discharges and transfers. Since 2007 local areas had written their own detailed criteria from national guidance, and a Healthwatch Northumberland report of 2018 found that about 70% of appeals against refusals succeeded. On 31 May 2022 NHS England published national criteria: most people should travel on their own or with family, transport is for medical, mobility, cognitive or safeguarding needs, and every patient on in-centre haemodialysis is offered support, by specialist vehicle, other transport or a refund.
Credit
NHS England and NHS Improvement
Watch for
Checks on every ride
Electronic visit verification records by phone or device when and where a Medicaid-paid home visit took place. In September 2026 Republicans on the House Energy and Commerce Committee introduced the STOP Medicaid Fraud Act, which would extend the same checks to NEMT trips, after a committee staff report named NEMT among Medicaid services with "high rates of fraud". CMS has also classed NEMT as a high-risk service in letters to California, New York and Minnesota.
Achieved whenthe bill or a rule takes effect and CMS or states report the share of NEMT trips with an electronic record of pickup and drop-off.
Claimed by
House Energy and Commerce Committee Republicans, September 2026
Open
01
One table of missed rides
A public table, updated every month, of how NEMT brokers perform in every US state that publishes their reports: trips requested, scheduled and completed, missed trips by cause (driver no-show, driver too late, no driver assigned, rider cancelled), complaints per 1,000 trips and phone answer times. Each figure links to its source, and a definitions sheet maps each state's terms to common ones.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Local transport rules, compared
A public table comparing the patient transport eligibility policy of each of England's 42 integrated care boards, the NHS bodies that buy local services, with NHS England's national criteria of 31 May 2022. For each board: the date of its policy, which national criteria it keeps, adds or drops, whether it states the dialysis offer, its rules for escorts and carers, how often it reviews a patient's eligibility, and how to appeal. Refresh it every six months.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
One table of missed rides
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public table, updated every month, of how NEMT brokers perform in every US state that publishes their reports: trips requested, scheduled and completed, missed trips by cause (driver no-show, driver too late, no driver assigned, rider cancelled), complaints per 1,000 trips and phone answer times. Each figure links to its source, and a definitions sheet maps each state's terms to common ones.
Why it is still open
States publish in their own formats and no cross-state table was found. Indiana posts monthly reports from its broker, Verida, set by state law: in August 2026 it scheduled 33,683 trips and completed 26,986 (79.92%), with missed trips split by cause. Rhode Island's dashboard counts complaints by type, such as early or late pickups and provider no-shows, as a share of scheduled trips. MACPAC was told in 2021 that brokers often refuse to give states complete data on complaints and on-time pickups. Washington's Health Care Authority compared its program with Oregon, Idaho and Colorado in December 2024, but on cost per trip and per member, not on missed rides, and Arkansas publishes quarterly profiles of each broker's on-time pickups. KFF's November 2026 analysis covers spending and riders, not ride quality.
in.goveohhs.ri.govmacpac.govhca.wa.govmedicaid.afmc.orgkff.org
Built with what exists
state Medicaid websites and public records requests; pdfplumber or Camelot to pull tables from PDFs, with a person checking each table, since text extraction can shift columns; a web agent such as Browser Use to fetch new reports each month (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over"); a public GitHub repository.
First step
Download Indiana's last 12 monthly reports and Rhode Island's dashboard, and build the two-state table with its definitions sheet.
Done looks like
at least 10 states with 12 months each, every number linked to its page, a random 5% checked by a second person with at least 98% agreement, and the definitions sheet published.
Open 02 · the brief
Local transport rules, compared
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public table comparing the patient transport eligibility policy of each of England's 42 integrated care boards, the NHS bodies that buy local services, with NHS England's national criteria of 31 May 2022. For each board: the date of its policy, which national criteria it keeps, adds or drops, whether it states the dialysis offer, its rules for escorts and carers, how often it reviews a patient's eligibility, and how to appeal. Refresh it every six months.
Why it is still open
Local variation was the problem the national criteria were written to fix, by NHS England's own account in 2021, and local boards still publish their own policies one by one. Coventry and Warwickshire's policy, revised in October 2025, says it is based on the national criteria and adds its own rule that patients other than those on haemodialysis are reviewed every three months. No published comparison of the boards' policies since 2022 was found.
Built with what exists
the boards' websites and Freedom of Information requests for policies not posted; the national criteria document; an AI model that answers fixed questions about each policy, such as Gemini Decision 1 (see the Note "A thousand questions, one pass"), with two people checking every answer; a spreadsheet.
First step
Collect five boards' policies and fill in the dialysis, escort and review columns by hand.
Done looks like
all 42 boards in the table, every cell linked to the policy page it came from, two readers agreeing on at least 95% of cells, and a count of boards whose dialysis or escort rules differ from the national criteria.