BRENNEN

Industries / Government, education and community / Government / Emergency services / Ambulance and medical transport

Billing

This is the work of setting prices for ambulance and medical transport and deciding who pays them: public insurers, private insurers, local taxes or the patient.

7

Milestones achieved, from 2002 to 2026.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 2002

    A national ambulance price list

    Since 2002 Medicare, the US public insurer for people 65 and over, has paid for ground ambulance rides by a national fee schedule: a base payment that depends on the level of care, plus a payment per mile. Ambulance services must accept Medicare's allowed amount as payment in full and bill patients only for the deductible and coinsurance. The schedule was set mainly by negotiated rulemaking, talks between the government and the industry, not from cost data. MedPAC, which advises Congress on Medicare payment, found in 2026 that its weights for the level of care had not changed since 2002 and its urban and rural adjustments since 2008. In 2024 about 10,600 ambulance organizations made 11.3 million trips for Medicare fee-for-service patients and were paid $5.3 billion.

    Lessonwithout cost data the price weights could not be checked against the work, and they stayed as first set.

    cms.govmedpac.gov

    Credit

    Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS)

  2. 2014

    Approval before dialysis rides

    Ambulance rides that repeat on a schedule, mostly to dialysis, had long been cited as a source of waste and abuse in Medicare. From 2014 in New Jersey, Pennsylvania and South Carolina, and from 2016 in five more states and Washington, D.C., CMS asked ambulance companies to get approval before giving such rides, called prior authorization, or face review of each claim. The evaluation found that rides fell 63% and spending on them 72% among patients with kidney failure or severe pressure ulcers over four years, and Mathematica, the evaluator, found no sign of lost access or worse care. CMS said the model had saved about $650 million and extended it to every state between December 2021 and August 2022.

    cms.govmathematica.orgcms.gov

    Credit

    CMS; Mathematica

  3. 2018

    States cannot cap air prices

    Air ambulance companies are registered as air carriers, and the Airline Deregulation Act of 1978 bars states from regulating air carriers' prices. From 2011 West Virginia had capped what its public employees' insurer and its workers' compensation system paid air ambulances, at or near Medicare rates. On 7 December 2018 the US Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit, in Air Evac EMS v. Cheatham, upheld an order stopping the state from enforcing those caps, because federal law preempted them.

    Lessonbecause an airline law put air ambulance prices out of the states' reach, protection from surprise air ambulance bills had to come from Congress, which covered them in the No Surprises Act.

    caselaw.findlaw.competrieflom.law.harvard.edu

    Credit

    US Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit; Air Evac EMS

  4. 2023

    Treatment without transport ends

    Medicare paid ambulances only when they carried a patient to a hospital or another covered place. From January 2021 CMS's Emergency Triage, Treat, and Transport (ET3) model also paid participating services, after a 911 call, to take Medicare patients to places such as urgent care clinics or to have a qualified clinician treat them where they were, in person or by video. CMS ended it on 31 December 2023, two years early, citing low participation. The final evaluation found that only 70 of 185 participants delivered any such care, 3,161 treatments in place and 257 alternative trips, under 1% of their Medicare ambulance trips; treatment in place was linked to a higher risk of hospital admission within five days.

    Lessona new payment changed little when crews, partner clinics and other payers did not take part.

    cms.govcms.gov

    Credit

    CMS Innovation Center

  5. 2024

    A fee for unneeded trips

    Ambulances in Japan are free. From 1 June 2024 the city of Matsusaka, in Mie Prefecture, began charging ¥7,700 (about $50) to patients brought by ambulance to one of its three core hospitals who were then judged not to need admission. Using district dispatch records and a statistical comparison with similar areas (the synthetic control method), economists estimated that calls fell 12%, about 165 a month.

    japantimes.co.jpconfit-sfs.atlas.jp

    Credit

    City of Matsusaka and its core hospitals; measured by Kenshi Koyama, Tomoka Oki, Taiki Susa and Yuta Takahashi (2026)

  6. 2024

    Ground ambulances left to states

    A study of a large national insurer's members in 2013–2017 found that 71% of ambulance rides could bring a surprise bill from an ambulance outside the patient's plan network, with median amounts of $450 by road and $21,698 by air. The No Surprises Act of 2022 covered air ambulances but not ground ones, and set up an advisory committee instead. Its report, dated 29 March 2024 and published on 28 August 2024, asked Congress to ban such bills for emergency ground ambulance rides and to cap what patients pay; it listed 14 states with their own laws. By June 2026 the Commonwealth Fund counted 24 states, though state laws do not reach employers' self-funded plans.

    Lessonhow the payment is set matters; New York's 2015 law, which tied out-of-network payment to "usual and customary" rates, was followed by emergency ambulance prices 13 percentage points higher than in comparison states, by Xu and colleagues' estimate.

    ebi.ac.ukcms.govelevancehealth.comebi.ac.uk

    Credit

    Advisory Committee on Ground Ambulance and Patient Billing; state legislatures

  7. 2026

    The first ambulance cost count

    Congress told CMS in the Bipartisan Budget Act of 2018 to collect costs and revenues from ground ambulance organizations, with a 10% payment cut for those that did not report. CMS collected data for 2022 and 2023 from four groups covering 10,581 organizations, the first time most of them had reported costs. MedPAC found in June 2026 that cost per trip ran from $367 at the 10th percentile to $4,136 at the 90th, that it fell as volume rose, from $2,878 a trip in the quarter of organizations with the fewest trips to $918 in the quarter with the most, and that it averaged $563 for for-profit, $830 for nonprofit and $1,626 for government services.

    medpac.gov

    Credit

    CMS; MedPAC

Watch for

  1. A fee across Ibaraki

    Ibaraki Prefecture, northeast of Tokyo, says some large hospitals there now charge an extra fee when calling an ambulance is judged not to have been urgent, with exceptions such as heat stroke or a child's fever fit and for callers sent by the #7119 and #8000 advice lines. It says 3.8% of people taken to a large hospital from December 2024 to May 2025 were charged.

    Achieved whenan outside study measures the change in ambulance calls and in serious cases, as Koyama and colleagues did for Matsusaka.

    pref.ibaraki.jp

    Claimed by

    Ibaraki Prefectural Government, August 2025

  2. Charges up, payments flat

    Elevance Health, a large insurer, says that in its claims from all 50 states and Washington, D.C., charges for emergency ground ambulance rides rose 30% above medical inflation from 2012 to 2025, while the amounts insurers allowed rose only 3% to 6%, and that 44% to 51% of rides each year were out of network. It proposes that states base out-of-network payment on in-network allowed amounts. Insurers have a stake in that answer.

    Achieved whenan independent analysis of other claims data, such as the Health Care Cost Institute's, which found employer plans paying 2.0 times Medicare in 2022, reproduces the trend.

    elevancehealth.comhealthcostinstitute.org

    Claimed by

    Elevance Health Public Policy Institute, July 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Local ambulance rates, one place

    A public table of the ground ambulance rates set by US cities, counties and fire districts for the 300 largest service areas: base rates for basic and advanced emergency care, the charge per mile, any resident discount, and the date. Show each rate as a multiple of Medicare's fee schedule for the same ZIP code, and update the table every year.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    State ambulance laws as code

    Open software that reads an invented ambulance trip, with its state, type of health plan, whether it was an emergency, ground or air, and the billed charge, and returns the most the patient can be billed and the least the plan must pay under each state's law and under the advisory committee's options. Each law comes with test cases that cite the clause they check.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Local ambulance rates, one place

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public table of the ground ambulance rates set by US cities, counties and fire districts for the 300 largest service areas: base rates for basic and advanced emergency care, the charge per mile, any resident discount, and the date. Show each rate as a multiple of Medicare's fee schedule for the same ZIP code, and update the table every year.

Why it is still open

The 2024 advisory committee would let state or locally set rates count as the minimum payment only if they are set in public and reported "in one central place that the public and regulators can easily find"; Congress has not acted and no such place exists. Rates sit on separate local pages: Madison, Wisconsin, posts $1,410 per trip for 2022–2026 plus $16.00 a mile. National studies use insurers' claims, not posted rates: the Health Care Cost Institute found employer plans paid 2.0 times Medicare in 2022. A search in November 2026 found no national table of posted local rates.

cms.govcityofmadison.comhealthcostinstitute.org

Built with what exists

CMS's Ambulance Fee Schedule public use files for 2004 to 2026 and its ZIP code files; city and county fee ordinances and public records requests; a web agent such as Browser Use to collect rate pages (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over"); a spreadsheet and a public repository.

cms.gov

  1. First step

    Collect posted rates for the 25 largest US cities and work out each one's Medicare multiple.

  2. Done looks like

    300 service areas, each rate linked to its page and dated, the Medicare multiple worked out for a 5-mile basic and advanced emergency trip, a random 10% rechecked by hand, and the table repeated a year later.

Open 02 · the brief

State ambulance laws as code

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

Open software that reads an invented ambulance trip, with its state, type of health plan, whether it was an emergency, ground or air, and the billed charge, and returns the most the patient can be billed and the least the plan must pay under each state's law and under the advisory committee's options. Each law comes with test cases that cite the clause they check.

Why it is still open

The laws differ in kind. Louisiana caps payment at 325% of Medicare, West Virginia has considered 400%, and New York uses "usual and customary" rates set by the insurer and open to challenge. The Commonwealth Fund's map of 24 state laws is a summary for reading, not a calculator. A GitHub search in November 2026 for "ambulance surprise billing" found no repository.

petrieflom.law.harvard.eduelevancehealth.com

Built with what exists

state statutes and insurance department bulletins; a rules-as-code framework such as Catala or OpenFisca; CMS's ambulance fee schedule files for the Medicare base; an AI model to draft rules and test cases, with each one checked by a person against the statute text.

  1. First step

    Encode Louisiana, New York and Colorado with 10 test cases each.

  2. Done looks like

    all 24 state laws encoded, at least 10 test cases each with the clause cited, two reviewers agreeing on every expected answer, and the code and tests published under an open license.