Industries / Finance and business services / Legal and professional services / Accounting
Audit
An audit is an independent accountant's examination of a company's financial statements, ending in a written opinion on whether they give a fair picture.
7
Milestones achieved, from 1900 to 2025.
2
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1900
Every company needs an auditor
Britain's Companies Act 1900 required every registered company to appoint an auditor each year, barred its own directors and officers from the job, and gave the auditor the right to see all books and vouchers. The auditor had to tell shareholders whether the balance sheet showed "a true and correct view" of the company's affairs. An act of 1844 had already required auditors for the joint-stock companies registered under it.
Credit
UK Parliament, Companies Act 1900
1933
US law demands independent accountants
The Securities Act of 1933 required companies registering securities for sale to the public to file financial statements certified by "an independent public or certified accountant". An outside audit became a condition of raising money in US public markets.
Credit
US Congress, Securities Act of 1933
1939
Fake inventory fools the auditors
McKesson & Robbins' 1937 balance sheet overstated its assets by about $19 million: some $10 million of inventory and $9 million of customer debts did not exist, backed by forged papers from dummy firms. The auditors had checked the stock against company records and supplier letters and never wrote to customers to confirm their debts. In September 1939 the American Institute of Accountants approved a report called "Extensions of Auditing Procedure".
LessonRecords that pass through the client's hands can be forged, which is why the SEC hearings asked whether auditors should check inventory themselves and confirm debts directly with customers.
3197d6d14b5f19f2f440-5e13d29c4c016cf96cbbfd197c579b45.r81.cf1.rackcdn.comegrove.olemiss.edu
Credit
US SEC, 1939 hearings; American Institute of Accountants
2002
Andersen falls with Enron
Arthur Andersen, Enron's auditor, was indicted in March 2002 and convicted by a jury of obstructing justice after it told staff to destroy Enron documents, and the firm dissolved that year. The US Supreme Court overturned the conviction in May 2005 because the jury instructions were flawed. By 2003, the US Government Accountability Office (GAO) found, the four firms left, the "Big 4", audited over 78% of US public companies.
LessonAn audit firm lives on trust, and the court's reversal came three years after the firm had gone.
Credit
US Supreme Court, Arthur Andersen LLP v. United States; GAO
2014
EU caps audit tenure
EU Regulation 537/2014 limits how long one audit firm may audit a public-interest entity, such as a listed company, to 10 years. Member states may extend this to 20 years after a public tender or 24 with a joint audit, followed by a four-year break, and the rules applied from 17 June 2016.
Credit
European Parliament and Council
2018
Carillion's auditor called complicit
After the UK contractor Carillion collapsed in January 2018, a parliamentary report found that KPMG had audited it for 19 years, been paid £29 million and never once qualified its opinion, that is, added reservations to it. The report called KPMG "complicit" in the company's accounting judgements, and in December 2018 Sir John Kingman's review recommended replacing the regulator, the Financial Reporting Council, with a new statutory body.
LessonReform can stall: in January 2026 the UK government dropped the bill that would have created the new regulator, by ICAEW's account.
Credit
House of Commons Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy and Work and Pensions Committees; Sir John Kingman
2025
Inspection failure rates fall
The US audit regulator, the Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (PCAOB), found a "Part I.A" deficiency, meaning the firm lacked enough evidence for its opinion, in 46% of the public-company audits it reviewed in its 2023 inspections, 38% in 2024 and 23% in 2025; for the Big Four the 2025 rate was 8%. Inspectors pick the audits and areas they judge complex or risky, so the rates do not come from a random sample.
LessonA falling number needs a second look; a September 2026 post on Columbia Law School's Blue Sky blog asked whether the gains reflect better audits or a regulator weakened by cuts to its budget and staff.
assets.pcaobus.orgjournalofaccountancy.comclsbluesky.law.columbia.edu
Credit
PCAOB
Watch for
Quality-control rule takes effect
The PCAOB's QC 1000, adopted in 2024, is a new standard for how audit firms design and run their systems for keeping audit quality up, built around each firm's own risks. In August 2025 the board moved its start back a year, to 15 December 2026, because some firms reported problems putting it in place.
Achieved whenthe rule takes effect on 15 December 2026 without another delay and PCAOB inspections begin checking firms against it.
Claimed by
PCAOB, August 2025
AI across the whole audit
Shawn Panson, who leads changes to PwC's US audit work, said end-to-end AI-driven automation of the audit should arrive within calendar 2026, from planning and risk assessment to matching evidence, testing and checking the final statements. At the time some pieces, such as a tool that reviews financial statements, were still in pilot.
Achieved whenan outside party, such as PCAOB inspections or an independent study, confirms the tools run across PwC's audits for a full cycle without a fall in audit quality.
Claimed by
PwC, October 2025
Open
01
Catch the invented entry
Ledgers in which an AI bookkeeping agent has made up transactions, or pulled in unrelated ones, to force a reconciliation to pass, mixed with clean ledgers, and a test of whether standard journal-entry tests and AI reviewers find the invented entries. Journal-entry tests are the filters auditors run over a ledger, such as round amounts, weekend postings and unusual pairs of accounts.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Trace every AI-made entry
An open record format, and a checker, for books kept by AI agents. For each entry the agent makes, the record holds the source documents it read, the model and its version, the instructions it ran under and the person who approved it, in a log that cannot be changed without trace. The checker rebuilds each entry from the record, so that an auditor can follow it back to its sources and redo it.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
Catch the invented entry
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
Ledgers in which an AI bookkeeping agent has made up transactions, or pulled in unrelated ones, to force a reconciliation to pass, mixed with clean ledgers, and a test of whether standard journal-entry tests and AI reviewers find the invented entries. Journal-entry tests are the filters auditors run over a ledger, such as round amounts, weekend postings and unusual pairs of accounts.
Why it is still open
Penrose saw AI agents invent transactions to pass reconciliation checks. A December 2025 study, AuditCopilot, tested AI models against journal-entry tests on ledgers with anomalies, not on entries made by AI agents. I found no test aimed at agent-made entries, which matter more as auditors start to apply the revised international fraud standard, ISA 240, to periods beginning on or after 15 December 2026.
Built with what exists
ledgers from runs of AI agents on made-up companies, such as the open year of books under Bookkeeping; journal-entry tests written in Python; AI reviewers built on models such as Claude, set up like the record reviewer in the Note "Seven more flagged".
First step
Run one agent on a made-up month that cannot be reconciled honestly, save every entry it makes, and run five standard journal-entry tests over the result.
Done looks like
200 ledgers, half with agent-made entries, and for each method the share of invented entries caught and the share of clean entries wrongly flagged.
Open 02 · the brief
Trace every AI-made entry
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
An open record format, and a checker, for books kept by AI agents. For each entry the agent makes, the record holds the source documents it read, the model and its version, the instructions it ran under and the person who approved it, in a log that cannot be changed without trace. The checker rebuilds each entry from the record, so that an auditor can follow it back to its sources and redo it.
Why it is still open
The chief executive of FloQast, a close-software company, wrote in May 2026 that auditors will ask "Show me what the AI saw" and "Is this the same AI that ran last quarter?", and that chat histories and spreadsheet tabs fail because they can be edited without a trace. His post names no standard format, and I found no open one that works across products.
Built with what exists
an append-only log in which each record carries a cryptographic hash of the one before, so any change shows; OpenTelemetry, an open standard for recording what software does; the made-up companies from the open year of books as test data.
First step
Log every step of one agent closing one made-up month, and have someone else try to trace ten entries back to their sources.
Done looks like
1,000 agent-made entries in which a second person traces every one to its sources and redoes a random 100 with the same result, and in which every deliberately altered record is caught.