Industries / Figureheads
Robert Shiller
With Karl Case he built repeat-sales house price indexes that the US housing market and its regulators still measure prices by, and he argued that home prices could run far ahead of their worth.
born 1946
What they changed
1987
Repeat sales, weighted
Case and Shiller measured price change by comparing each house with itself at two sales, in 39,210 homes drawn from 952,606 sales in Atlanta, Chicago, Dallas and San Francisco. Their weighted repeat-sales method changed the 1963 method of Bailey, Muth and Nourse by giving less weight to pairs of sales far apart in time, whose prices are noisier.
1991
Indexes made to order
Shiller, Case and Allan Weiss, Shiller's former student at Yale, started Case Shiller Weiss, Inc. to produce home price indexes. By Shiller's account the firm also built an automated valuation model called CASA and was the first to put automated home valuations before the public on the internet. It was sold to Fiserv in 2002 and to CoreLogic in 2013.
2003
Testing for a bubble
In a Brookings paper with Case he defined a housing bubble as a time when "excessive public expectations of future price increases cause prices to be temporarily elevated" and asked whether US home prices were in one. Their surveys of homebuyers, begun in 1988, found that buyers in boom cities expected much larger price gains than buyers elsewhere.
2006
Indexes the market trades
Shiller had proposed new financial markets in his 1993 book Macro Markets and named a company, MacroMarkets, after it. In 2006 MacroMarkets licensed the indexes to Standard & Poor's, which publishes them as the S&P/Case-Shiller Home Price Indices, and worked with the Chicago Mercantile Exchange to launch home price futures on ten US cities and the nation.
2013
A Nobel for asset prices
Shiller shared the Nobel Memorial Prize in Economic Sciences with Eugene Fama and Lars Peter Hansen "for their empirical analysis of asset prices". The US Federal Housing Finance Agency builds its house price index on "a modified version of the Case-Shiller® index methodology".
Life
Robert J. Shiller was born in Detroit, Michigan, on 29 March 1946; his father was an engineer. In 1960, as he started high school near Detroit, he read his brother's copy of Paul Samuelson's textbook Economics, which he says launched his interest. He studied at Kalamazoo College and the University of Michigan, and took his doctorate at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology in 1972. He taught at the University of Minnesota from 1972 to 1974 and later at the University of Pennsylvania, and has been at Yale University since 1982.
His first field was econometrics, the statistics of economic data. He came to doubt the models that held markets to be efficient, in which prices always reflect what is known, and his work showing that stock prices moved far more than later dividends could justify met what he called "considerable hostile criticism" for at least a decade. In his Nobel lecture he set that work beside his surveys of investors from 1989 and of homebuyers with Case from 1988.
Karl Case of Wellesley College brought the housing side. After Case's death in 2016 Shiller told the Wall Street Journal that what got them going was "a widespread belief in market efficiency" and a willingness to extend it to housing. Their first index paper, of 1987, credited the repeat-sales idea to Bailey, Muth and Nourse, and the firm they founded in 1991 was a three-way partnership with Allan Weiss.
Not everything he launched lasted. MacroMarkets also tried to sell MacroShares, paired securities that rose and fell with an index, and the company is no longer active. Shiller wrote that he "was quite disappointed" that his plan for new markets did not do better.
The Nobel Foundation gives Yale University as his affiliation when he won the prize in 2013. In July 2017 he met Taiwan's president, Tsai Ing-wen, to give his views on housing.
Read more
4 accounts
Speculative asset prices, Robert J. Shiller, Nobel lecture, 8 December 2013.
His own account of why prices of stocks and homes move as they do, with the surveys behind it.
nobelprize.org
Robert J. Shiller: biographical, Robert J. Shiller, Nobel Foundation, 2013.
His autobiography, including the founding and sale of Case Shiller Weiss and the launch of the futures.
nobelprize.org
Prices of single family homes since 1970: new indexes for four cities, Karl E.
Case and Robert J. Shiller, NBER Working Paper 2393, 1987. The paper that set out the weighted repeat-sales method.
nber.org
Is there a bubble in the housing market?, Karl E. Case and Robert J. Shiller, Brookings Papers on Economic Activity, 2003.
Their test of the 2000s boom, with its discussants' comments.
brookings.edu
