Industries / Figureheads
Elias Howe
He patented a machine that sewed a lockstitch with a needle and a shuttle, and the courts made every American sewing machine maker pay him for it.
1819–1867
What they changed
1846
A patent on the lockstitch
US patent 4,750, issued on 10 September 1846, covered a machine in which a needle with the eye near its point pushed a loop of thread through the cloth and a shuttle passed a second thread through the loop. The two threads lock inside the cloth, so the seam does not unravel as a chain of single-thread loops can. Howe did not claim the eye-pointed needle itself.
1852
The patent holds in court
Makers who sold shuttle machines refused to pay him, and Howe sued. The first case to reach trial was decided for him on 12 July 1852. The defense had shown that Walter Hunt of New York built a needle-and-shuttle machine in the 1830s, but Hunt had never patented it, and the Patent Commissioner later ruled that he had abandoned it.
1854
Singer pays
Isaac Singer's firm fought Howe longest, using a rebuilt Hunt machine as evidence. After a court barred three firms from selling Singer machines while the suit ran, Singer settled on 1 July 1854, paid $15,000 and took a license. Other makers had agreed to pay Howe $25 on every machine sold.
1856
A seat in the pool
Howe joined three manufacturers in the Sewing Machine Combination, which licensed their overlapping patents for one fee. He took $5 on each machine sold in the United States and $1 on each exported, besides an equal share of the profits, until his patent ran out in 1867. The law scholar Adam Mossoff calls the Combination "the first privately formed patent pool."
Life
Elias Howe Jr. was born on 9 July 1819 on his father's farm in Spencer, Massachusetts. A lameness from birth made heavy work painful. At sixteen he went to Lowell and learned the machinist's trade in a shop that built and repaired cotton-spinning machinery, and after the panic of 1837 he moved to Boston and worked for Ari Davis, a maker of scientific instruments. By the account of Grace Rogers Cooper, the Smithsonian curator who wrote the standard history, he first heard there that a sewing machine would make its inventor rich.
In 1843 illness kept him from work and his wife took in sewing. A friend, George Fisher, boarded the family and put up $500 for a half share in any patent. Howe sewed his first seam by machine in April 1845, and that July he stitched two wool suits. In a public trial at a Boston clothing factory he finished five seams a little sooner than five seamstresses each finished one. He got no orders: tailors objected, and the machine cost too much.
He went to England in 1847 to adapt the machine for William Thomas, a corset and umbrella maker, who had bought the machine and, with it, the British rights for 250 pounds. The work ended badly. Howe pawned his first machine and his patent papers to pay his passage and landed in New York in April 1849 with almost nothing; his wife died soon after. He found that sewing machines were by then being made and sold in the United States.
The credit is disputed, and the record is clear on why. Cooper wrote that Hunt's machine of the 1830s had "all the essential devices" of Howe's and that the ruling against Hunt "was not a question of invention" but of who held the right. Howe never built a machine that sold well, and the makers he sued could not build theirs without his patent, nor he a practical one without theirs. Mossoff describes him as a patent owner who made no product and lived on license fees won by injunction, the kind of owner now called a patent troll. The judge who granted those injunctions saw it differently: for the sewing machine, he wrote, "the public are indebted to Mr. Howe."
The patent made him rich. When he asked for a second extension in 1867 he stated that it had paid him $1,185,000, and the request was refused. In the Civil War he enlisted as a private in the 17th Connecticut Volunteers. He opened a factory of his own only shortly before he died in Brooklyn, New York, on 3 October 1867.
Read more
4 accounts
The Sewing Machine: Its Invention and Development, Grace Rogers Cooper, Smithsonian Institution Press, 1976.
The standard history, with the patent claims quoted and a biographical sketch of each inventor.
archive.org
The Rise and Fall of the First American Patent Thicket: The Sewing Machine War of the 1850s, Adam Mossoff, Arizona Law Review, 2011.
The lawsuits and the patent pool, from the court records.
laweconcenter.org
Elias Howe, William B. Ashworth Jr., Linda Hall Library, 2021.
A short illustrated account of the machine and what the patent did and did not cover.
lindahall.org
Elias Howe, Jun., inventor of the sewing-machine, Harper's Weekly, 1867.
The engraved portrait published in the year he died, as held by the Library of Congress.
loc.gov
