Industries / Figureheads
Edward F. Knipling
He worked out how to wipe out an insect pest by releasing sterile males of its own kind.
1909–2000
What they changed
1937
A weak point in mating
Working on the screwworm, a fly whose maggots feed in the wounds of living animals, Knipling saw that a female mates once in her life while a male mates many times. He reasoned that if enough sterile males were released, most wild females would lay eggs that never hatch, and he built probability models of how many males it would take.
1954
Sterile flies clear an island
On Curaçao, off Venezuela, the team released about 150,000 sterilized flies a week over 176 square miles, and within about three months the screwworm was gone from the island. The Golden Goose Award's account calls it the first demonstration of the technique.
1966
Screwworm cleared from the US
Florida was clear by mid-1959, with a plant at Sebring turning out 50 million sterile flies a week. In 1966 the Secretary of Agriculture declared the screwworm eradicated from the country. Mexico followed in 1991, and a barrier of sterile flies was later held at the border of Panama and Colombia.
1980
The method reaches fruit flies
Chile used sterile releases to rid the whole country of the Mediterranean fruit fly by 1980, and Japan used them to clear the melon fly from Okinawa. The National Agricultural Library's 2013 account says sterile fruit flies were being released continuously over Los Angeles, Tampa and Miami to stop the pest settling in.
Life
Knipling was born on 20 March 1909 in Port Lavaca, Texas, and grew up on his parents' farm. One of his chores was treating calves that had screwworms in their navels and wounds. He took a degree in entomology at Texas A&M in 1930, joined the US Department of Agriculture that year and stayed for 41 years. Iowa State gave him a doctorate in 1947.
The idea came at the department's laboratory in Menard, Texas, where he worked from 1937 with Raymond C. Bushland. Other entomologists laughed at it. "You just can't castrate enough flies," they said, and the plan sat for more than ten years. During the Second World War Knipling ran the department's laboratory in Orlando, Florida, which developed DDT and other insecticides and repellents for the armed forces. The United States cancelled DDT in 1972 for its effects on wildlife and its possible risks to health.
The missing piece was a way to sterilize flies, and it was not his. The geneticist H. J. Muller had shown that X-rays make fruit flies sterile. In 1950 a colleague, Arthur Lindquist, showed Knipling an article of Muller's, and Knipling wrote to him. Bushland, in Kerrville, Texas, then did the proof. With no equipment of his own he used the X-ray machine of an army hospital, and showed that flies irradiated as pupae grew into healthy, sterile adults that still competed for mates. He later switched to gamma rays from cobalt-60 and worked out how to rear the flies by the million.
A first trial on Sanibel Island, Florida, in late 1951 cut the screwworm population, but flies kept arriving from the mainland two miles away. In 1953 a veterinarian on Curaçao, Benjamin Bitter, wrote asking for help, and Knipling proposed a joint experiment while warning that the method was only a theory. After Curaçao, Florida's governor pressed for a state-wide program before Knipling thought the technology was ready, and it worked.
The 1966 declaration was not the end. Screwworms came back across the border in a heavy influx from Mexico in the 1970s, and a joint commission with Mexico took the releases south, country by country. Members of Congress went on citing "the sex life of the screwworm" as wasteful research. The National Academy of Sciences memoir puts the benefit to livestock producers at well over $1 billion a year.
Knipling directed the department's Entomology Research Division from 1953 to 1971 and retired in 1973. He and Bushland shared the World Food Prize in 1992. He kept publishing on pest control over whole regions with little insecticide until he died on 17 March 2000 in Arlington, Virginia.
Read more
5 accounts
Edward F. Knipling, 1909–2000, Perry Adkisson and James Tumlinson, 2003.
The National Academy of Sciences memoir: his life, the screwworm work and the later campaign against the boll weevil.
nasonline.org
Edward Fred Knipling Papers: biographical sketch, National Agricultural Library, 2013.
Ten pages on his career and the eradication program, written with his colleague Waldemar Klassen.
nal.usda.gov
STOP Screwworms: selections from the Screwworm Eradication Collection, National Agricultural Library, undated. The program's letters, memos and photographs by decade, including the 1953 letters between Knipling and the Curaçao veterinarian.
nal.usda.gov
Comments by Dr. Edward F. Knipling, National Agricultural Library, 2000.
A filmed interview from January 2000 in which he looks back on the program.
nal.usda.gov
The sex life of the screwworm fly, Josh Shiode for the Golden Goose Award, 2016.
An account written for an award given to federally funded research that once sounded odd, with the ridicule the work drew.
goldengooseaward.org
