BRENNEN

Industries / Government, education and community / Tribal enterprises

Law

The federal, state, tribal and Canadian rules that decide who may tax, regulate, sue and unionize a tribally owned business.

7

Milestones achieved, from 1980 to 2023.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1980

    Taxes follow non-member buyers

    Washington State wanted tribal smoke shops to collect state cigarette and sales taxes on sales to people who were not tribal members, although each tribe in the case already taxed cigarette sales itself. On 10 June 1980, in Washington v. Confederated Tribes of the Colville Indian Reservation, the Supreme Court upheld the state taxes on those sales, holding that federal Indian law does not let tribes "market an exemption from state taxation to persons who would normally do their business elsewhere".

    LessonThe ruling left two governments taxing the same sale, and many states now settle the overlap by agreement: Michigan's Treasury has tax agreements with ten of the state's twelve federally recognized tribes.

    law.cornell.edumichigan.gov

    Credit

    Confederated Tribes of the Colville Indian Reservation and the State of Washington, the parties

  2. 1981

    Power over non-members narrowed

    In Montana v. United States, decided on 24 March 1981, the Supreme Court held that the Crow Tribe could not regulate hunting and fishing by non-members on land within its reservation owned outright by non-Indians. It added that a tribe may regulate, "through taxation, licensing, or other means", non-members who "enter consensual relationships with the tribe or its members, through commercial dealing, contracts, leases, or other arrangements", and may keep power over non-Indians on such land whose conduct threatens "the political integrity, the economic security, or the health or welfare of the tribe".

    law.cornell.edu

    Credit

    Crow Tribe and the State of Montana, the parties

  3. 1989

    Two taxes on one well

    Cotton Petroleum, a company that is not Indian-owned, produced oil and gas under leases on the Jicarilla Apache Tribe's reservation in New Mexico and paid both the Tribe's 6% severance tax and the state's 8% severance taxes. In 1982 the Court had upheld the Tribe's own tax in Merrion v. Jicarilla Apache Tribe. On 25 April 1989, in Cotton Petroleum v. New Mexico, it held that the state may also tax the same production, and that a total burden heavier than on wells off the reservation did not by itself make the tax unlawful.

    LessonA tribe's power to tax its own resources does not stop a state taxing the same activity, so a project on tribal land can carry two taxes where one off it carries one.

    law.cornell.edu

    Credit

    Jicarilla Apache Tribe; Cotton Petroleum and the State of New Mexico, the parties

  4. 1998

    Immunity reaches commerce

    In 1990 the Kiowa Tribe's industrial development commission agreed to buy stock from Manufacturing Technologies, and the chairman of the Tribe's business committee signed a $285,000 promissory note that named no governing law and said nothing in it limited the Tribe's sovereign rights. The Tribe defaulted and was sued in Oklahoma's courts. On 26 May 1998 the Supreme Court held that tribes are immune from suits on contracts "whether those contracts involve governmental or commercial activities and whether they were made on or off a reservation", unless Congress authorizes the suit or the tribe waives its immunity.

    LessonImmunity stays the rule until Congress changes it: on 27 May 2014, in Michigan v. Bay Mills Indian Community, the Court declined to overrule Kiowa in Michigan's suit over a casino Bay Mills had opened about 125 miles from its reservation.

    law.cornell.edulaw.cornell.edu

    Credit

    Kiowa Tribe of Oklahoma and Manufacturing Technologies, the parties

  5. 2004

    Duty to consult defined

    British Columbia had replaced, and in 1999 approved the transfer to Weyerhaeuser of, a tree farm licence on Haida Gwaii without the Haida Nation's consent, while the Haida's title claim was still unproven. On 18 November 2004 the Supreme Court of Canada held that the Crown must consult, and where appropriate accommodate, Aboriginal peoples before decisions that may harm rights they claim, to a depth set by the strength of the claim and the seriousness of the harm; the Crown need not reach agreement, and companies cannot be held liable for the Crown's failure to consult. In 2014, in Tsilhqot'in Nation v. British Columbia, the Court declared Aboriginal title for the Tsilhqot'in Nation and held that, once title is established, incursions on it need the group's consent or a justification by a compelling and substantial public purpose.

    decisions.scc-csc.cadecisions.scc-csc.ca

    Credit

    Haida Nation; Tsilhqot'in Nation

  6. 2007

    Labor law reaches casinos

    Since 2004 the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB), which enforces US private-sector labor law, has claimed jurisdiction over tribal casinos. On 9 February 2007 the federal appeals court in Washington, D.C., upheld its decision to apply the National Labor Relations Act to the casino of the San Manuel Band of Serrano Mission Indians, which, the court noted, employs many non-Indians and serves mainly non-Indian customers. Tribes have asked Congress for an exemption: the House of Representatives passed the Tribal Labor Sovereignty Act by 249 votes to 177 in 2015 and again, with 239 votes in favor, in 2018; the AFL-CIO, which opposed it, said it would cover more than 600,000 tribal casino workers.

    openjurist.orgggbnews.comaflcio.org

    Credit

    San Manuel Band of Serrano Mission Indians and the NLRB, the parties; Judge Janice Rogers Brown, who wrote the opinion

  7. 2023

    Bankruptcy overrides tribal immunity

    Lendgreen, a lending business of the Lac du Flambeau Band of Lake Superior Chippewa Indians, made a payday loan to a borrower who then filed for Chapter 13 bankruptcy and said Lendgreen kept trying to collect despite the automatic stay. On 15 June 2023, in Lac du Flambeau Band v. Coughlin, the Supreme Court held that the Bankruptcy Code "unambiguously abrogates the sovereign immunity of all governments, including federally recognized Indian tribes".

    LessonCongress can override tribal immunity without naming tribes when a statute's words plainly cover every government.

    law.cornell.edu

    Credit

    Lac du Flambeau Band of Lake Superior Chippewa Indians, a party

Watch for

  1. Title over private land

    On 7 August 2025 the Supreme Court of British Columbia declared that the Cowichan Tribes, Stz'uminus First Nation, Penelakut Tribe and Halalt First Nation hold Aboriginal title to about 40% of the 1,846 acres they claimed on the Richmond waterfront, that Canada's fee simple interests in the title lands were defective and invalid, and that Crown grants of fee simple there unjustifiably infringe the title. Canada appealed four of the six findings on 8 September 2025, citing the ruling's "potential for significant nation-wide implications".

    Achieved whenthe BC Court of Appeal, and the Supreme Court of Canada if it hears the case, upholds the declarations.

    search.open.canada.ca

    Claimed by

    Cowichan Tribes, Stz'uminus First Nation, Penelakut Tribe and Halalt First Nation, and declared at trial, August 2025

Open

  1. 01

    Finding immunity waivers in contracts

    A public, labeled set of at least 200 contracts, loan agreements and bond indentures with tribal enterprises that are already filed with the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), in which two reviewers mark every clause that waives sovereign immunity, chooses a governing law, names a court (tribal, state or federal) or requires arbitration. Then test how many of those clauses current AI contract-review tools find. The set records what the clauses say; it does not judge whether any waiver is valid, and it uses public filings only.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Tribal tax agreements, tabulated

    A public table of every tribal-state tax agreement that state revenue departments post online, covering tobacco, motor fuel, alcohol and sales taxes, with the parties, dates, amendments, how revenue is split or refunded, and a link to the signed text, refreshed by a script that flags new postings. It records published terms only, not any nation's revenue, and compares agreements, not nations.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Finding immunity waivers in contracts

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public, labeled set of at least 200 contracts, loan agreements and bond indentures with tribal enterprises that are already filed with the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), in which two reviewers mark every clause that waives sovereign immunity, chooses a governing law, names a court (tribal, state or federal) or requires arbitration. Then test how many of those clauses current AI contract-review tools find. The set records what the clauses say; it does not judge whether any waiver is valid, and it uses public filings only.

Why it is still open

CUAD, the main open answer key for contract review, labels 41 types of clause and none of them is sovereign immunity. EDGAR's full-text search, the SEC's free search of filings, returns 2,077 documents containing "limited waiver of sovereign immunity". The Kiowa case shows the stakes: its note named no governing law, and the creditor could not sue.

raw.githubusercontent.comefts.sec.govlaw.cornell.edu

Built with what exists

EDGAR full-text search; pdftotext and Python; Label Studio, an open-source labeling tool; AI models such as Claude for the test (the Note "Seven more flagged" covers an AI reviewer of long documents).

  1. First step

    Pull the Mohegan Tribal Gaming Authority and Seneca Gaming Corporation filings that the EDGAR search returns (15 and 6 among its first 100 results) and mark their waiver and forum clauses.

  2. Done looks like

    200 documents, each target clause labeled by two reviewers with their agreement rate published; recall and precision for at least three AI tools on each clause type; the set released under an open licence.

Open 02 · the brief

Tribal tax agreements, tabulated

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public table of every tribal-state tax agreement that state revenue departments post online, covering tobacco, motor fuel, alcohol and sales taxes, with the parties, dates, amendments, how revenue is split or refunded, and a link to the signed text, refreshed by a script that flags new postings. It records published terms only, not any nation's revenue, and compares agreements, not nations.

Why it is still open

The fullest compilation found, a data file from Economics for Health, covers state laws on tribal tobacco sales in 20 states from 2005 to 2015. Current agreements sit on separate state pages, such as Montana's list of agreements tribe by tribe and Michigan's page noting agreements with ten of twelve tribes.

economicsforhealth.orgrevenue.mt.govmichigan.gov

Built with what exists

state revenue department websites; pdftotext and Python; an AI model to draft field values for a person to check; a CSV file under an open licence.

  1. First step

    Code Montana's posted agreements, tribe by tribe, into a draft table.

  2. Done looks like

    Every agreement posted by the revenue departments of states with federally recognized tribes on a set date, coded on at least 10 fields with page citations; two people coding a sample of 50 independently and agreeing on at least 95% of fields.