BRENNEN

Industries / Government, education and community / Tribal enterprises

Gaming

Running bingo halls, casinos and betting under tribal ownership, mostly on tribal lands and under rules agreed with states, to fund tribal governments.

7

Milestones achieved, from 1979 to 2024.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1979

    Bingo hall tests state law

    In December 1979 the Seminole Tribe of Florida opened a bingo hall on its Hollywood reservation, built and run under contract by a private partnership for a share of the profits. It paid prizes far above the $100 a game that Florida allowed charity bingo and ran up to seven days a week. When Broward County's sheriff, Robert Butterworth, said he would make arrests, the Tribe sued, and on 5 October 1981 the federal appeals court for the Fifth Circuit held that Florida's bingo law regulated the game rather than banning it, so the state could not enforce it on the reservation. The Tribe's tourism site calls the hall the country's first large-scale bingo hall.

    floridaseminoletourism.comopenjurist.org

    Credit

    Seminole Tribe of Florida, under Chairman James E. Billie

  2. 1988

    Congress sets three classes

    On 25 February 1987, in California v. Cabazon Band of Mission Indians, the Supreme Court held that California could not apply its bingo rules to games run by the Cabazon and Morongo Bands on their reservations, because the state regulated gambling rather than prohibiting it. On 17 October 1988 Congress passed the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act (IGRA). It sorts games into Class I (social and ceremonial games, left to tribes alone), Class II (bingo, pull-tabs and similar games, and card games the state permits that players play against each other rather than against the house) and Class III (everything else, including banked card games such as blackjack and slot machines of any kind), which is lawful only under a tribal-state compact, an agreement between a tribe and its state approved by the Secretary of the Interior. The act created the National Indian Gaming Commission (NIGC) and limits the use of net revenue to tribal government, members' welfare, economic development, charity and local government. For fiscal year 2025 the NIGC counted $46.2 billion in gross gaming revenue (the amount wagered minus winnings paid out) from 545 operations run by 246 tribes in 29 states; about 9% of operations took in more than $250 million each and together made 56% of the total, while 54% took in less than $25 million each and made about 5%.

    LessonThe act let a tribe sue a state that would not negotiate a compact in good faith, but in Seminole Tribe v. Florida (27 March 1996) the Supreme Court held that states are immune from such suits, and in 1999 the Interior Department adopted rules under which it can set gaming procedures itself when a state claims that immunity.

    law.cornell.edulaw.cornell.edulaw.cornell.edunigc.govnigc.govlaw.cornell.edulaw.cornell.edulaw.cornell.edu

    Credit

    Cabazon and Morongo Bands of Mission Indians; US Congress

  3. 1992

    Foxwoods and the slot deal

    The Mashantucket Pequot Tribe opened a 2,100-seat bingo hall on its reservation in southeastern Connecticut in 1986, and in February 1992 Foxwoods High Stakes Bingo & Casino, with 170 game tables. The Tribe operates under federal gaming procedures that the Interior Department issued after Connecticut refused to negotiate a compact. Under a 1993 agreement the state let the Tribe run slot machines in return for 25% of its gross slot revenue each month, for as long as no one else in Connecticut may run slot machines or other commercial casino games; the Mohegan Tribe signed its own agreement for Mohegan Sun in May 1994.

    LessonGrowth paid for with borrowing can turn: after a costly 2008 expansion, new competition and the recession, the Tribe agreed with its lenders in 2012 to restructure $2.2 billion of debt, by the Associated Press's account.

    encyclopedia.comprdext3.cga.ct.govportal.ct.govhartfordbusiness.com

    Credit

    Mashantucket Pequot Tribe, under Chairman Richard "Skip" Hayward; State of Connecticut

  4. 2007

    A tribe buys Hard Rock

    On 5 March 2007 the Seminole Tribe of Florida completed its $965 million purchase of Hard Rock International, with its cafes, hotels, casinos and music memorabilia, from the UK's Rank Group. Jim Allen, chief executive of Seminole Gaming, said the deal combined a $525 million bond offering with a $500 million equity contribution from the Tribe. The Associated Press reported that it took the Tribe into the worldwide hospitality business.

    archive.hotelbusiness.comictnews.org

    Credit

    Seminole Tribe of Florida; Jim Allen, Seminole Gaming

  5. 2008

    Ontario shares 1.7 percent

    In 2008 the Ontario Lottery and Gaming Corporation (OLG), the province's gaming agency, signed a Gaming Revenue Sharing and Financial Agreement with the Ontario First Nations (2008) Limited Partnership. It requires OLG to pay First Nations 1.7% of its "aggregate gross revenues", which include non-gaming revenue such as hotels and food, as Ontario's Auditor General described it in 2022.

    LessonA share written against one agency's revenue can lapse when the work moves to private operators: OLG paid no non-gaming share from January 2016 to March 2021, and after a court ruling for the First Nations on 31 March 2020 it paid $7.4 million in missed payments and interest in November 2021.

    auditor.on.ca

    Credit

    Ontario First Nations (2008) Limited Partnership; Ontario Lottery and Gaming Corporation

  6. 2024

    Statewide betting from tribal servers

    Florida's 2021 compact with the Seminole Tribe, read with a state law that treats an online bet as placed where the server receiving it sits, lets the Tribe take sports bets from anywhere in Florida on servers on its lands. The compact took effect by operation of law when the Interior Secretary did not act on it. Two Florida casinos sued; on 30 June 2023 the federal appeals court in Washington, D.C., ruled for the Secretary, holding that a compact may allocate jurisdiction between a tribe and a state, and in June 2024 the Supreme Court declined to hear the case.

    deanmead.combhfs.com

    Credit

    Seminole Tribe of Florida; State of Florida

  7. 2024

    A tribal resort abroad

    The Mohegan Tribal Gaming Authority built INSPIRE Entertainment Resort in Incheon, South Korea, a $1.6 billion development whose non-gaming operations opened in November 2023 and whose casino, open only to foreign visitors, opened in February 2024.

    LessonDebt raised abroad is enforced abroad: after Mohegan defaulted on a $275 million Korean term loan, by missing financial targets rather than payments in its own account, the lenders accelerated the debt and in February 2025 Bain Capital took control of the resort by appropriating the shares of its operating company, as AGB reported.

    agbrief.com

    Credit

    Mohegan Tribal Gaming Authority

Watch for

  1. Tribal online casinos in Maine

    In January 2026 Maine's governor, Janet Mills, said she would let LD 1164 become law. It gives the four Wabanaki Nations (the Mi'kmaq Nation, the Houlton Band of Maliseet Indians, the Penobscot Nation and the Passamaquoddy Tribe) exclusive rights to run online casinos in the state, one licence each, alone or with a commercial partner, taxed at 18%. Tribal Gaming notes that under a 1980 land-claims settlement these nations have not held the gaming rights most tribes have under IGRA, and reported in August 2026 that no online casino had yet launched while regulators were still writing the rules.

    Achieved whenthe nations' online casinos are taking wagers and Maine's Gambling Control Unit publishes their revenue.

    igamingbusiness.comtribalgaming.com

    Claimed by

    Governor Janet Mills and the Maine Legislature, January 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Compact payment terms as data

    A public table of the revenue-sharing terms in every Class III compact and amendment that the Interior Department's Office of Indian Gaming posts: what revenue the share is taken from (net win, slot win or another base), floors and rate tiers, credits the tribe may deduct, the exclusivity triggers that stop payments, and the term, each field with a page citation. Add an open calculator that runs each compact's formula on made-up revenue figures, so a reader can see how the headline rate and the amount paid differ. It uses only compacts the government already publishes and invented numbers, so no nation's revenue is estimated or compared.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Class II or III, tested

    A public test set made from the NIGC's game classification opinions, in which each game's description is separated from the NIGC's conclusion, and a script that asks AI models to classify each game as Class II or Class III under 25 U.S.C. 2703 and scores both the answer and the stated reason against the NIGC's. The set tests models; it does not classify any game for use.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Compact payment terms as data

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public table of the revenue-sharing terms in every Class III compact and amendment that the Interior Department's Office of Indian Gaming posts: what revenue the share is taken from (net win, slot win or another base), floors and rate tiers, credits the tribe may deduct, the exclusivity triggers that stop payments, and the term, each field with a page citation. Add an open calculator that runs each compact's formula on made-up revenue figures, so a reader can see how the headline rate and the amount paid differ. It uses only compacts the government already publishes and invented numbers, so no nation's revenue is estimated or compared.

Why it is still open

Interior's compact page lists 1,196 documents as PDFs, not data. GAO counted in 2015 that 169 of the 276 compacts then in effect shared revenue with states, at maximum rates from 3.5% to 25%, but reported only the maximum rate, not the base, tiers or credits. The American Gaming Association's By the Book database "culls the most important details" from compacts in 28 states, at the level of each state. In May 2026 Tribal Gaming wrote that the percentage on a compact's front page "almost never matches what a tribe actually pays", because bases, tiers and credits differ.

gao.govbia.govcdcgaming.comtribalgaming.com

Built with what exists

Interior's compact PDFs; pdftotext and Python; an AI model such as Claude to draft field values for a person to check (the Note "Seven more flagged" covers an AI reviewer of long documents); a CSV file and a small web calculator.

  1. First step

    Download Arizona's 2021 and 2022 compact amendments from the Interior page and code their revenue-sharing sections into a draft schema.

  2. Done looks like

    Every compact and amendment listed by Interior on a set date, coded on at least 12 fields with page citations; two people coding a random sample of 50 independently and agreeing on at least 95% of fields; the calculator checked by hand against the formula text of 20 compacts.

Open 02 · the brief

Class II or III, tested

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public test set made from the NIGC's game classification opinions, in which each game's description is separated from the NIGC's conclusion, and a script that asks AI models to classify each game as Class II or Class III under 25 U.S.C. 2703 and scores both the answer and the stated reason against the NIGC's. The set tests models; it does not classify any game for use.

Why it is still open

The NIGC lists about 120 advisory opinions, dated from 1992 to 2024, only as separate PDF letters, and no published test of AI models on them was found. Studies of AI on law show why one is needed: Matthew Dahl and colleagues found that models gave wrong answers between 58% (GPT-4) and 88% (Llama 2) of the time to specific, checkable questions about federal court cases.

nigc.govarxiv.org

Built with what exists

the NIGC opinion PDFs; pdftotext; current models from Anthropic, OpenAI and Google through their APIs; Python for scoring.

  1. First step

    Download the 20 most recent opinions and write the masked description and the NIGC label for each.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 100 opinions in the set with their NIGC labels; accuracy and reason-match rates published for at least four models, with the opinions from 2018 onward, the least likely to be in older training data, scored separately.