BRENNEN

Industries / Food, farming and forestry / Tobacco

Tracking and illegal trade

Marking, counting and tracing tobacco products so that tax is paid and smuggled or fake goods can be found, and measuring how much of the market is illegal.

7

Milestones achieved, from 1860s to 2025.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1860s

    Stamps show tax paid

    To help pay for the Civil War, the US Treasury taxed tobacco and alcohol and issued stamps for them, so that a stamp on the product showed the tax had been paid.

    ttb.gov

    Credit

    US Treasury Department

  2. 1994

    Smuggling forces a tax cut

    After Canada doubled tobacco taxes in 1991, as many as one in three cigarettes sold in Canada was contraband, by the account of the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists (ICIJ), and the smuggling ended in February 1994 when governments cut taxes back to earlier levels. In July 2008 Imperial Tobacco Canada and Rothmans, Benson & Hedges each pleaded guilty to one count of helping people sell or hold tobacco that was not properly packaged or stamped, from 1989 to 1994, and with civil settlements agreed to pay governments C$1.15 billion.

    LessonThe settlement made supply control a duty of the makers, who agreed to run programs "to control the movement of tobacco products" and to give governments information on contraband.

    icij.orgcanada.ca

    Credit

    Government of Canada and the provinces (2008 settlement); ICIJ (investigation)

  3. 2004

    A deal with one maker

    On 9 July 2004 Philip Morris International (PMI) signed an agreement with the EU and its member states to fight smuggling and counterfeiting of its brands. The European Commission's assessment credited it with a fall of about 85% in seizures of genuine PMI cigarettes from 2006 to 2014, but questioned whether the agreement caused the fall and noted that other products had replaced PMI's in the illegal market. On 9 March 2016 the European Parliament voted 414 to 214 to ask the Commission not to renew it beyond 9 July 2016.

    LessonCutting one company's share of contraband did not shrink the illegal market.

    oeil.europarl.europa.eu

    Credit

    European Commission and EU member states; PMI

  4. 2007

    Counting every pack made

    Brazil's tax agency, the Receita Federal, required every cigarette factory to install Scorpios, a set of production counters fitted by the national mint, Casa da Moeda do Brasil, on each packing line, which record the number of packs made and send it to the tax agency; each pack also carries a control stamp that tears when the pack is opened (Normative Instruction 769 of 21 August 2007).

    normasbrasil.com.brgov.br

    Credit

    Receita Federal do Brasil; Casa da Moeda do Brasil

  5. 2018

    A treaty against illicit trade

    The Protocol to Eliminate Illicit Trade in Tobacco Products, adopted under the WHO tobacco treaty in Seoul on 12 November 2012, entered into force on 25 September 2018. It requires Parties to set up a tracking and tracing system (Article 8) and lets customs, police and courts in different countries share information and give each other legal help. It had 74 Parties in November 2026, by the UN treaty record.

    fctc.who.inttreaties.un.org

    Credit

    Parties to the WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control

  6. 2019

    A code on every pack

    From 20 May 2019 every pack of cigarettes and roll-your-own tobacco made in or imported into the EU must carry a unique identifier, a code generated by an independent "ID issuer" appointed by each member state, and each pack's movements are recorded in data stores run by independent providers; other tobacco products followed on 20 May 2024 (Commission Implementing Regulation 2018/574).

    LessonAn independent check in Lithuania found that after full implementation in May 2020, 32.0% of discarded packs collected still had no identifier, including 5.8% of legal packs (Liutkute-Gumarov and Ross, 2023).

    eur-lex.europa.euebi.ac.uk

    Credit

    European Commission; EU member states

  7. 2025

    Record seizure of illegal vapes

    In September 2025 the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and Customs and Border Protection announced the seizure of 4.7 million unauthorized e-cigarettes, worth an estimated $86.5 million at retail, from incoming shipments in Chicago earlier that year, which they called the largest seizure of its kind; almost all came from China. By their count the two agencies had stopped more than 6 million unauthorized e-cigarettes, worth over $120 million, that year.

    LessonMany shipments carried vague product descriptions and wrong values, so the paperwork alone did not reveal them.

    naquitline.org

    Credit

    FDA; US Customs and Border Protection

Watch for

  1. Industry-funded estimates keep rising

    A KPMG report commissioned by PMI, presented on 3 June 2026, estimates that 42 billion illicit cigarettes were smoked in the EU in 2025, about 10% of consumption, with France the largest market at 20.5 billion and a 41.4% share, and counterfeits 44% of the illicit total. Independent reviews have found such figures run high: of 35 published assessments of industry-funded illicit-trade data, 31 found industry estimates higher than independent ones (Gallagher and colleagues, 2019), and in Warsaw in 2011 an industry pack collection put packs not meant for the Polish market at 22.9%, against 14.6% and 15.6% from two academic methods (Stoklosa and Ross, 2014).

    Achieved whenan estimate made without industry funding reports a similar share for the same countries and year.

    eunews.itebi.ac.ukebi.ac.uk

    Claimed by

    KPMG for PMI, June 2026

  2. The EU's own estimate

    The European Court of Auditors reported on 8 September 2026 that the Commission has no independent and reliable estimate of the EU's illicit tobacco market, and recommended one by 2029; the Court notes that the Commission has launched a study on estimating the tobacco excise gap, the tax due but not collected.

    Achieved whenthe Commission publishes country-by-country estimates with its method.

    eca.europa.eu

    Claimed by

    European Commission, as reported by the European Court of Auditors, September 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Read discarded packs by phone

    a phone app or script that, from two or three photos of a discarded cigarette pack, records what an empty pack survey records by hand: brand, the language and country markings of the health warning, whether a local tax stamp is present, and, in the EU, whether a unique identifier is printed and which country's ID issuer its code names, then flags packs not meant for the local market.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    An open illicit-market estimate

    open code and data that estimate, for each EU country and year, the share of cigarettes smoked that were not taxed there, built only from public sources and published next to KPMG's figures.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Read discarded packs by phone

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

a phone app or script that, from two or three photos of a discarded cigarette pack, records what an empty pack survey records by hand: brand, the language and country markings of the health warning, whether a local tax stamp is present, and, in the EU, whether a unique identifier is printed and which country's ID issuer its code names, then flags packs not meant for the local market.

Why it is still open

Empty pack surveys, a main independent way to estimate the illegal share of a market, are coded by hand. In Lithuania fieldworkers walked at least 1,074 km to collect 5,727 packs (Liutkute-Gumarov and Ross, 2023), and a 2024 survey in six Indonesian cities collected 8,179 (CISDI). Government apps exist that verify a single tax stamp's code, such as the TransAct app used in a 2026 Pakistan pack survey, and hobby projects on GitHub name the brand from a pack photo (one YOLOv8 model knows six brands), but no tool was found that codes the markings a survey needs, such as warning language, tax stamp and pack code, from photos.

ebi.ac.ukeconomicsforhealth.orgebi.ac.ukgithub.com

Built with what exists

phone cameras; open barcode and Data Matrix readers such as ZXing; vision-language models such as Gemini, Claude or GPT for reading text and markings; the coding rules of a published survey; the issuer codes defined under EU Implementing Regulation 2018/574.

  1. First step

    with gloves, collect and photograph 100 discarded packs along one public route, code them by hand with a published codebook, and test a vision model on the photos.

  2. Done looks like

    on 1,000 discarded packs coded separately by two people, the tool agrees with their consensus on "meant for the local market or not" for at least 95% of packs, in under 30 seconds per pack, with code, photos and coding rules published.

Open 02 · the brief

An open illicit-market estimate

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

open code and data that estimate, for each EU country and year, the share of cigarettes smoked that were not taxed there, built only from public sources and published next to KPMG's figures.

Why it is still open

The European Court of Auditors found in September 2026 that "there is currently no independent and reliable estimation" of the EU's illicit tobacco market: only four member states have official data, others rely on industry-funded studies such as KPMG's, and the Commission has not applied the independent method its own 2020 study proposed; its excise-gap study is not yet published. Earlier independent work was a one-off: a survey in 18 European countries found 6.5% of packs illicit (Joossens and colleagues, 2014).

eca.europa.euebi.ac.uk

Built with what exists

the European Commission's Taxes in Europe Database, which holds each country's releases for consumption of cigarettes and fine-cut tobacco; national health and smoking surveys for the number of cigarettes smoked; HM Revenue and Customs' published method for the UK tobacco duty gap as a template; Python or R.

  1. First step

    download releases for consumption for France, the Netherlands and Lithuania from the Taxes in Europe Database, pair them with each country's latest survey of cigarettes smoked, and compare the gap with KPMG's 2025 figures.

  2. Done looks like

    estimates with uncertainty ranges for all 27 member states for 2015 to 2025, reproduced from scratch by someone outside the team, with a table of every country-year where they differ from KPMG's by more than 5 percentage points and the reason.