Industries / Food, farming and forestry / Tobacco
Newer nicotine products
Making nicotine products that are not smoked, from snus and nicotine pouches to e-cigarettes and heated tobacco, and getting each one authorized for sale.
7
Milestones achieved, from 2003 to 2025.
2
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
2003
An electronic cigarette patented
On 29 April 2003 Hon Lik filed a Chinese patent application (CN03111582.9) for "a flameless electronic atomizing cigarette." The device was a cigarette-shaped tube holding a battery, a control circuit, an airflow sensor and a reservoir of nicotine solution. When the user drew on it, a heated nozzle, helped by a vibrating ultrasonic plate, turned the liquid into a fine mist. The international application, WO2004095955, was filed in 2004 in the name of Best Partners Worldwide, and later US patents grew from the same family.
Credit
Hon Lik
2014
EU caps vape liquid
Article 20 of the EU's Tobacco Products Directive (2014/40/EU) requires makers to notify each e-cigarette and refill six months before sale, listing ingredients, emissions and toxicology data. Nicotine liquid may hold no more than 20 mg of nicotine per ml, refill bottles no more than 10 ml, and tanks or cartridges no more than 2 ml. Products already on sale on 20 May 2016 had six months from that date to be notified. The same directive keeps the EU ban on tobacco for oral use, such as snus, a moist tobacco placed under the lip, with an exception for Sweden (Article 17).
Credit
European Parliament and Council of the European Union
2015
Nicotine salts patented
US patent 9,215,895, granted on 22 December 2015 to Adam Bowen and Chenyue Xing, covers an e-cigarette liquid in which nicotine is paired with an acid to form a salt; its description gives nicotine at about 1% to 20% by weight. The patent passed from Ploom and Pax Labs to Juul Labs. FDA refused Juul's applications to sell its device and pods on 23 June 2022 and Juul appealed. In July 2025 FDA authorized the device and its Virginia Tobacco and Menthol pods at 3% and 5% nicotine, with marketing restrictions that take youth uptake into account.
LessonReview can trail sales by years: Juul applied in 2020 and got its orders in 2025, and in 2019 the CDC's national youth survey found 27.5% of US high school students had used an e-cigarette in the past 30 days.
Credit
Adam Bowen and Chenyue Xing; Juul Labs
2016
FDA rules reach e-cigarettes
The US Food and Drug Administration's "deeming" rule, published on 10 May 2016 and in force from 8 August 2016, extended its tobacco powers beyond the cigarettes, roll-your-own and smokeless tobacco named in the Tobacco Control Act to every product that meets the legal definition of a tobacco product. It also banned sales of the newly covered products to people under 18 and required health warnings. Since then e-cigarettes, heated tobacco and nicotine pouches have needed an FDA marketing order, most often through a premarket tobacco product application (PMTA), in which the maker must show that sale is appropriate for public health. From 14 April 2022 FDA's authority was extended to products containing nicotine from any source, which brought in nicotine made by chemical synthesis instead of taken from tobacco.
LessonRules written around tobacco left nicotine made without tobacco outside them until 2022.
Credit
US Food and Drug Administration
2019
Heated tobacco authorized
On 30 April 2019 FDA authorized IQOS from Philip Morris Products, a device that heats sticks of tobacco instead of burning them, and three kinds of Marlboro HeatSticks, through a PMTA. FDA limited marketing to adults, required regular reports on sales, users and adverse events, and stated that the order did not mean the products were safe or "FDA approved." On 7 July 2020 it let the company tell buyers that switching completely from cigarettes "significantly reduces your body's exposure to harmful or potentially harmful chemicals," a claim about exposure, not disease risk. FDA renewed those orders on 17 April 2026.
Credit
Philip Morris Products S.A.; US Food and Drug Administration
2019
A lower-risk claim for snus
On 22 October 2019 FDA issued its first modified-risk orders, for eight General snus products from Swedish Match USA. Swedish Match says it has made its snus to its own quality standard, GothiaTek, with limits on unwanted substances, since 2000. The orders let the company say: "Using General Snus instead of cigarettes puts you at a lower risk of mouth cancer, heart disease, lung cancer, stroke, emphysema, and chronic bronchitis." FDA renewed them on 7 November 2024, to 2032. On 16 January 2025 FDA authorized 20 Zyn nicotine pouches, small pouches filled with a nicotine powder instead of tobacco, the first pouches it had authorized, and on 30 June 2026 it allowed them the same lower-risk claim. In 2025, 1.7% of US middle and high school students reported using nicotine pouches (Sun and colleagues, 2026).
Credit
US Food and Drug Administration; Swedish Match
2025
UK bans single-use vapes
From 1 June 2025 it became illegal in the UK to sell or supply single-use vapes, those that cannot be refilled or recharged; a first offense brings a £200 fine. By Action on Smoking and Health's figures, the share of vapers in Great Britain mainly using single-use devices fell from 30% in 2024 to 24% in 2025. In a survey-based study published in March 2026, the recycling non-profit Material Focus estimated that 6.3 million vapes and pods were still thrown away each week, 23% fewer than a year earlier, and that 2.2 million single-use vapes were still bought each week.
LessonBanning sales cut vape waste by about a quarter but did not stop vapes and pods reaching the bin.
Credit
UK governments
Watch for
IQOS ILUMA awaits a decision
Philip Morris International says its applications to sell IQOS ILUMA, a newer version of its heated tobacco device, in the US are still under FDA review, and that its "strong application" warrants quick FDA action.
Achieved whenFDA issues marketing orders for IQOS ILUMA.
Claimed by
Philip Morris International, April 2026
Vapes sorted by camera
VP Recycling, a UK firm, says its automated plant recognizes each type of used vape from images, by size and color, against a library of models it has built, then separates plastics, metals and lithium batteries. It says the plant handles up to 1 tonne of vapes an hour, about 28,000 vapes, where a person taking them apart with pliers manages at most 200 an hour.
Achieved whena party outside the company publishes measured throughput and the share of vapes the plant identifies and sorts correctly.
Claimed by
VP Recycling, May 2025
Open
01
Footprints of newer nicotine products
An independent life-cycle assessment, a count of the greenhouse gases, water and waste from raw materials to disposal, for heated tobacco (device and sticks) and for nicotine pouches. Express it per 20 units, on the same basis as Imperial College's 2018 figure of about 14 g of CO2-equivalent per cigarette, with every input published.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Open photos of returned vapes
A public, labeled set of photos of used vapes as they arrive at take-back points, marking for each whether it is single-use or rechargeable and whether its battery can be taken out, with a table of models built from makers' published specifications and a baseline model that sorts them from a phone photo. The vape stays closed.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
Footprints of newer nicotine products
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
An independent life-cycle assessment, a count of the greenhouse gases, water and waste from raw materials to disposal, for heated tobacco (device and sticks) and for nicotine pouches. Express it per 20 units, on the same basis as Imperial College's 2018 figure of about 14 g of CO2-equivalent per cigarette, with every input published.
Why it is still open
A December 2023 letter in Public Health Toxicology states that "there are no independent research data available on the environmental impact of HTPs" (heated tobacco products), and the Tobacco Tactics site wrote in 2022 that there is little independent data on the life-cycle impact of these products. Nearby work answers other questions: Eunomia's 2025 study for the UK environment department modeled greenhouse gases for single-use vapes; FDA's environmental assessment for each order, such as the 2026 Zyn order, describes factory permits, waste streams and tonnage sold but gives no greenhouse-gas totals; and an industry study of glo heated tobacco (Kanobe and colleagues, RAI Services Company, 2024) measured indoor air, not a life cycle.
publichealthtoxicology.comtobaccotactics.orgeunomia.ecofda.govapi.openalex.org
Built with what exists
openLCA, free life-cycle software, with the ecoinvent database or the free US Life Cycle Inventory database; FDA's environmental assessments for the IQOS and Zyn orders; company sustainability reports; an AI model that reads PDFs to pull material and tonnage figures into a table, checked by hand.
First step
Download FDA's environmental assessments for the IQOS and Zyn orders and list every material, energy and waste figure they give.
Done looks like
A preprint and open spreadsheet giving kg of CO2-equivalent, liters of water and grams of solid waste per 20 heated sticks (with a share of the device) and per 20 pouches, with ranges, checked by an outside life-cycle practitioner in the critical review that ISO 14044 sets out for comparative studies.
Open 02 · the brief
Open photos of returned vapes
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public, labeled set of photos of used vapes as they arrive at take-back points, marking for each whether it is single-use or rechargeable and whether its battery can be taken out, with a table of models built from makers' published specifications and a baseline model that sorts them from a phone photo. The vape stays closed.
Why it is still open
UK retailers that sell vapes must take them back, and the official recycling guide asks whether the battery can be removed without saying how to tell. Material Focus estimated in March 2026 that 2.2 million single-use vapes were still bought each week after the ban, and suggested some users may think rechargeable vapes are single-use and bin them. VP Recycling says its plant recognizes vape types from images, but its model library is private and it has published no accuracy figures. Web, Europe PMC and GitHub searches found vape image sets made for spotting vaping in photos, and no public set labeled by device type and battery access.
recycleyourelectricals.org.ukmaterialfocus.org.ukexpressandstar.com
Built with what exists
phone cameras; Label Studio for labels; an image classifier fine-tuned from an open model such as Ultralytics YOLO11, or a vision-language model (Gemini, Claude, Qwen2.5-VL) that reads the brand and model printed on the device.
First step
Ask a council recycling center or a vape take-back scheme for permission to photograph one week's returns, unopened, and label the first 300.
Done looks like
Tested on 1,000 returned vapes photographed at a take-back point, the tool is right at least 95% of the time on single-use versus rechargeable and at least 90% on whether the battery is removable, measured against a recycler's own hand sorting, with the photos, labels and errors published.