Industries / Media, arts and recreation / Media and entertainment / Ticketing
Resale
Resale is the market where tickets change hands after the first sale: brokers (professional resellers, called touts in Britain and scalpers in the US), fan-to-fan exchanges and platforms such as StubHub and viagogo.
7
Milestones achieved, from 1927 to 2025.
2
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1927
A resale cap struck down
On 28 February 1927 the US Supreme Court held, in Tyson & Brother v. Banton, that a 1922 New York law forbidding resale of theatre tickets at more than 50 cents above the printed price violated the Fourteenth Amendment, holding that an owner's right to set the price at which property is sold is protected by due process. New York's attorney general wrote in 2016 that the state nonetheless capped resale markups until 2007, when it made all resale for profit legal.
LessonNew York's attorney general wrote in 2016 that the 2007 repeal had turned savings meant for fans into profits for "a handful of savvy middlemen", and asked for a limit again.
Credit
US Supreme Court; Tyson & Brother
2007
A marketplace bought by eBay
StubHub, a marketplace where fans and brokers list tickets and the platform charges a fee on each sale, was launched in 2000 and is based in San Francisco. In January 2007 eBay agreed to buy it for about $310 million, by eBay's filing with the US Securities and Exchange Commission.
Credit
StubHub (Jeff Fluhr, founder and chief executive); eBay
2019
Japan bans resale for profit
Japan's Act No. 103 of 14 December 2018 bans the unauthorized resale of "specified show and event tickets", and buying them in order to resell them, ahead of the 2019 Rugby World Cup and the Tokyo Olympics. In force from June 2019, it makes it illegal to resell such tickets above face value without the promoter's consent, with penalties of up to a year in prison or a ¥1 million fine. Several resale platforms, Ticket Camp and Ticket Street among them, closed, and in 2019 a nursery school teacher in Osaka was arrested and fined for reselling Arashi concert tickets at more than five times face value, IQ magazine reported.
Credit
National Diet of Japan
2020
Viagogo fined in Australia
On 2 October 2020 the Federal Court of Australia ordered viagogo to pay A$7 million for false or misleading claims, in a case brought by the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC): the court had found in 2019 that viagogo told buyers it was the "official" seller of tickets to some events, that tickets were scarce, and that tickets could be bought at a stated price when they could not.
Credit
ACCC; Federal Court of Australia
2021
A merger partly undone
Viagogo bought StubHub in February 2020. On 2 February 2021 the CMA found that the two, with a combined share of more than 90%, competed closely in UK resale with no significant rival, and required viagogo to sell all of StubHub's business outside North America to an owner the CMA approved.
Credit
Competition and Markets Authority
2021
Ireland caps at face value
From 31 July 2021 Ireland's Sale of Tickets Act has banned selling tickets above face value for designated events and for events at designated venues, which must hold 1,000 people or more, with fines of up to €100,000 or up to two years in prison; amateur sports clubs and registered charities raising funds are exempt.
Credit
Government of Ireland (Leo Varadkar, Minister for Enterprise, Trade and Employment)
2025
A reseller goes public
StubHub Holdings priced its initial public offering at $23.50 a share on 16 September 2025, selling 34.04 million shares to raise $799.94 million, and its shares began trading on the New York Stock Exchange the next day, IPOScoop reported.
Credit
StubHub Holdings
Watch for
A UK ban on markups
The UK government announced on 19 November 2025 that reselling live-event tickets above their original price, including unavoidable fees, would be made illegal, that resale platforms' service fees would be capped and that they would have to enforce the cap, and that no one could resell more tickets than they were allowed to buy; the CMA could fine businesses up to 10% of global turnover. The government estimates fans would save £112 million a year and that the average resale ticket would be £37 cheaper. The King's Speech of May 2026 listed a draft Ticket Tout Ban Bill, to be published for scrutiny before it is formally introduced.
Achieved whenthe law is passed and in force, and the CMA or an outside study reports resale prices against face value afterwards.
Claimed by
UK Department for Business and Trade and Department for Culture, Media and Sport, November 2025 and May 2026
Brokers fed by the seller
The FTC and seven states sued Live Nation and Ticketmaster on 18 September 2025, alleging bait-and-switch pricing and deceptive claims about ticket limits that brokers routinely exceeded, and that tickets bought past those limits were resold through Ticketmaster. The complaint quotes a senior executive's internal email saying the companies "turn a blind eye as a matter of policy", and says an internal review found five brokers controlling 6,345 accounts holding 246,407 tickets to 2,594 events. The FTC's case page lists an order denying the companies' motion to dismiss on 30 September 2026.
Achieved whena court rules on the claims or the companies settle with binding terms.
Claimed by
FTC and the states of Colorado, Florida, Illinois, Nebraska, Tennessee, Utah and Virginia, September 2025
Open
01
A before-and-after resale record
An open dataset of monthly snapshots of resale listings against face value for 200 UK and Irish events, starting before the UK ban takes effect, with Ireland, where a ban has applied since 2021, as a comparison.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Count speculative listings
A tracker that records when each resale listing first appears and compares it with the time the tickets first went on sale, to measure speculative listings: seats offered by sellers who do not yet hold them.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
A before-and-after resale record
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
An open dataset of monthly snapshots of resale listings against face value for 200 UK and Irish events, starting before the UK ban takes effect, with Ireland, where a ban has applied since 2021, as a comparison.
Why it is still open
The government's £112 million saving is an estimate from its own analysis. Which?, the UK consumer group, collected listing and face-value prices on StubHub and viagogo for 66 artists between October 2025 and February 2026 and estimated resellers could make almost £24 million on 190,475 tickets, but published totals, not a dataset, and viagogo responded that listing prices are not sale prices.
Built with what exists
Scheduled captures of public listing pages, within each platform's terms; face values from primary sellers' pages; a vision-capable model to read prices from screenshots; Python and PostgreSQL; an open data repository such as Zenodo.
First step
Apply Which?'s method to 10 artists touring the UK this winter and publish the first snapshot.
Done looks like
Twelve consecutive monthly snapshots of 200 events, at least six of them before the ban starts, with the share of listings above face value for each platform and country, and a check that the method reproduces Which?'s totals within 10% for artists both cover.
Open 02 · the brief
Count speculative listings
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A tracker that records when each resale listing first appears and compares it with the time the tickets first went on sale, to measure speculative listings: seats offered by sellers who do not yet hold them.
Why it is still open
New York's attorney general warned in 2016 that speculative tickets confuse and put fans at risk. In October 2024 the National Independent Venue Association counted at least 9,000 speculative tickets listed for Oasis's US shows before any ticket had been sold, a count for one tour. The TICKET Act, before the US Senate, would ban speculative sales. No systematic measure across many events was found.
Built with what exists
Daily captures of public listing pages from the day a tour is announced, within each platform's terms; on-sale times from artists' and venues' announcements; Python and SQLite.
First step
Track five tours announced this month from announcement to on-sale.
Done looks like
One hundred events in the US and UK, with the number and share of listings for each that appeared before the primary on-sale, by platform, and 50 of them checked by hand.