Industries / Retail, hospitality and personal services / Beauty salons and spas / Tattoo studios
Inks
This work is making the colored liquids a tattooist puts into the skin, which are pigments ground into water and other carriers, and setting and checking the rules on what they may contain.
7
Milestones achieved, from 1957 to 2024.
1
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
3
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1957
Red mercury inflames skin
Some red tattoo inks were made with cinnabar, a mercury sulfide. From the 1950s dermatologists reported rashes in tattoos and traced some of them to mercury: F. E. Keiller and R. P. Warin treated one such case in 1957 with dimercaprol, a drug that binds mercury, and R. G. Davis described two cases of sensitization to cinnabar in 1960. A 2016 review by E. Forbat and F. Al-Niaimi still names red as the color that most often causes tattoo reactions. In a 2020 review, Wolfgang Bäumler of the University of Regensburg describes today's black inks as almost all carbon black and nearly every other color as an azo or polycyclic pigment, two families of industrial organic pigments.
Credit
F. E. Keiller and R. P. Warin; R. G. Davis
2008
Car-paint pigments, measured in skin
E. Engel, W. Bäumler and colleagues at the University of Regensburg noted that modern tattoo colors are often azo pigments made for car paint and consumer goods, with many impurities. They tattooed excised pig skin and human skin with Pigment Red 22 and extracted it again: the skin held 0.60 to 9.42 mg of pigment per square centimeter, 2.53 mg/cm² on average, depending on crystal size, ink strength and technique. The authors argued that a risk assessment of tattooing should start from such a dose. The FDA says that many pigments in tattoo inks are not approved for skin contact at all, and some are industrial grade colors suitable for printers' ink or automobile paint.
Credit
E. Engel, W. Bäumler and colleagues, University of Regensburg
2012
Ink contaminated before sale
Between October and December 2011, 19 people in Rochester, New York, developed a lasting rash in new tattoos, all from one artist using a premixed gray ink. Monroe County health officials, with the CDC and the FDA, grew Mycobacterium chelonae, a bacterium related to the one that causes tuberculosis, from 14 of them and found the same strain in an unopened bottle. By the artist's account the maker had diluted the ink with distilled water before shipping, and the label carried no lot number. The maker recalled the ink. FDA scientists then tested sealed inks bought in the US: 42 of 85 (49%) held microbes in a 2018 survey, and only one of the four companies whose labels claimed sterility had none. Pooling four FDA surveys of 259 unopened inks, a 2026 analysis put contamination at 35.4%, with no link to the sterility claim. In October 2024 the FDA issued guidance, which does not bind makers, listing insanitary conditions in ink plants.
LessonEarlier outbreaks were traced to ink diluted in the studio; this one began at the factory.
Credit
B. S. Kennedy and colleagues, Monroe County Department of Public Health; FDA National Center for Toxicological Research
2017
Pigment found in lymph nodes
Lymph nodes are the small filters that drain fluid from tissue. Using skin and lymph nodes from tattooed corpses and X-ray beams at the European Synchrotron Radiation Facility in Grenoble, a team from Germany's Federal Institute for Risk Assessment (BfR) showed organic pigments, heavy metals and titanium dioxide, a white pigment, traveling together from skin to the nearest lymph nodes, with the smallest pigment particles most likely to arrive. A 2024 study in pigs from the Medical University of Graz found tattoo elements in the nearby lymph nodes 28 days after tattooing, but not in the liver, spleen, kidney or brain.
Credit
I. Schreiver, A. Luch and colleagues, BfR, with the ESRF
2019
Denmark logs every bottle
A Danish law of 6 June 2018, in force from 1 January 2019, requires tattooists to record the brand, color name, maker, lot number, Color Index number (the code that names a pigment), date of use and expiry of every ink used on a client, and to keep the record for five years. Studios commonly keep the record in InkBase, an electronic register. From March 2018 to 2019, 108 studios logged 39,687 clients, 50,604 sessions and 109,720 bottles. By the study's count 98.1% of the inks were made in the US, and only 10,833 bottles carried a Color Index number.
LessonNine inks that Denmark had banned by lot number in 2011 were back in use under other lot numbers.
Credit
Danish parliament; InkBase, built by Bjørn Severin and Esben Hammershøy; J. Serup and colleagues for the analysis
2022
Europe caps ink chemicals
Commission Regulation (EU) 2020/2081 of 14 December 2020 added tattoo inks to REACH, the EU's chemicals law. From 4 January 2022 an ink may not contain a substance classed as causing cancer or genetic damage at 0.00005% by weight or more, or one classed as toxic to reproduction or as a skin allergen at 0.001% or more, and its label must list the ingredients, the batch number and any nickel or chromium(VI). Pigment Blue 15:3 and Pigment Green 7, the usual blue and green, followed on 4 January 2023, because no safer alternatives were ready. The rule built on Council of Europe resolutions of 2003 and 2008, which did not bind anyone; the regulation says seven member states made them law, and a 2025 paper by J. Serup and colleagues says ten. In 2020 the BfR had found both pigments of comparatively low toxicity, saw no acute need to act and warned they might be replaced by less studied substances.
LessonWhen Nordic inspectors checked 211 inks from 64 businesses in 2023 and 2024, 46 (22%) held restricted substances and only 14 (7%) met every requirement checked.
Credit
European Commission; European Chemicals Agency with Italy, Denmark and Norway
2024
Labels miss what is inside
John Swierk's laboratory at Binghamton University, New York, analyzed 54 inks from nine brands common in the US: 45 contained additives or pigments not on the label, among them polyethylene glycol, propylene glycol and higher alkanes. The same group then tested ten blue and green inks from five brands sold in Europe as meeting REACH: nine did not, and four contained the banned Pigment Green 7. Raman spectroscopy, which identifies a substance by how it scatters laser light, could not reliably tell the banned form of Pigment Blue 15 from its permitted forms on three different instruments.
Credit
K. Moseman, John Swierk and colleagues, Binghamton University
Watch for
Tattoos and melanoma
In a Swedish case-control study of people aged 20 to 60, those tattooed before their index date had a relative risk of melanoma, the most dangerous skin cancer, of 1.29 (95% confidence interval 1.07 to 1.56) after adjustment, against those without tattoos. The same Lund group reported in 2024 a lymphoma risk of 1.21 (0.99 to 1.48) for tattooed people, and a Danish twin study in January 2025 found higher hazards of skin cancer and lymphoma for tattoos larger than the palm of a hand. Against this, a French cohort of 111,074 adults run by the International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) found no link between tattoos and any skin cancer, and IARC researchers have published a letter on the Swedish paper. In all of these studies people were asked about their tattoos after many of the cancers had been diagnosed.
Achieved whena study that recorded tattoos before any diagnosis, such as the French cohort's continuing follow-up, finds a raised risk of melanoma or lymphoma among tattooed people.
Claimed by
Emelie Rietz Liljedahl, C. Nielsen and colleagues, Lund University, November 2025
Open
01
Tell the blue twins apart
A laboratory method, tested blind in several labs, that tells the banned Pigment Blue 15:3 from the permitted Pigment Blue 15:1 and 15:6 in a finished tattoo ink. All three are the same copper phthalocyanine molecule packed into different crystal forms, so the method pairs X-ray powder diffraction, which reads crystal packing directly, with Raman spectroscopy, and spells out how to separate the pigment from the ink first.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Sealed bottles, named by brand
A public test of unopened tattoo inks for bacteria and fungi, repeated each year, that reports every result by brand, product and lot number next to what the label claims about sterility. Bottles are bought sealed at retail and tested by an accredited microbiology laboratory using the FDA's own methods for cosmetics; nobody involved in the project opens or cultures them.
The briefCredit · unclaimed03
Before and after the ban
A count, from Denmark's legally required studio ink records, of which pigments, brands and countries of manufacture went into clients in 2018 and 2019, before the EU rules, and in 2024 to 2026, after them. It uses only totals of bottles and sessions by Color Index number, brand and origin, never data on any client.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
Tell the blue twins apart
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A laboratory method, tested blind in several labs, that tells the banned Pigment Blue 15:3 from the permitted Pigment Blue 15:1 and 15:6 in a finished tattoo ink. All three are the same copper phthalocyanine molecule packed into different crystal forms, so the method pairs X-ray powder diffraction, which reads crystal packing directly, with Raman spectroscopy, and spells out how to separate the pigment from the ink first.
Why it is still open
REACH bans only the 15:3 form. In 2024 Swierk's group could not reliably tell the forms apart with Raman on three instruments, could not name the form in four inks, and called for a standard protocol that works across instruments; Binghamton University's account says manufacturers have no easy way to confirm which form they are receiving. No method published since was found.
Built with what exists
Reference pigments of the three forms, sold by Kremer Pigments, which the Binghamton study used; a benchtop X-ray powder diffractometer of the kind university chemistry departments keep; Raman spectrometers at 532 and 785 nanometers; a laboratory centrifuge to separate pigment from the carrier liquid; Python to match patterns against the reference forms.
First step
Record X-ray diffraction patterns of the three reference forms and of the pigment spun out of one commercial blue ink.
Done looks like
Thirty coded samples, made of pure reference forms, known mixtures and commercial blue inks, sent blind to at least three laboratories; each names the form correctly in at least 27 of the 30, and the method states the smallest share of the 15:3 form it can detect in a mix.
Open 02 · the brief
Sealed bottles, named by brand
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public test of unopened tattoo inks for bacteria and fungi, repeated each year, that reports every result by brand, product and lot number next to what the label claims about sterility. Bottles are bought sealed at retail and tested by an accredited microbiology laboratory using the FDA's own methods for cosmetics; nobody involved in the project opens or cultures them.
Why it is still open
The FDA's surveys show that about a third of sealed inks carry microbes, but its 2018 paper names its 13 makers only as Company 1 to 13, and its 2026 analysis of 259 inks reports results by ink type, sterility claim and country of origin. Brands are named only when the FDA issues an alert, as it did for two Sacred Tattoo Ink products in May 2025.
Built with what exists
Sealed retail bottles; a contract laboratory accredited to ISO/IEC 17025 for cosmetics microbiology, testing by Chapter 23 of the FDA's Bacteriological Analytical Manual, aerobic and anaerobic, as the FDA's 2024 survey did; a public spreadsheet with a photo of each label and lot number.
First step
Get quotes from two accredited laboratories for Chapter 23 testing and buy ten sealed bottles from brands named in past FDA recalls.
Done looks like
At least 100 sealed bottles from at least 20 brands, each with brand, product, lot, sterility claim and result in colony-forming units per gram or "none detected", and the same brands tested again with new lots a year later.
Open 03 · the brief
Before and after the ban
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A count, from Denmark's legally required studio ink records, of which pigments, brands and countries of manufacture went into clients in 2018 and 2019, before the EU rules, and in 2024 to 2026, after them. It uses only totals of bottles and sessions by Color Index number, brand and origin, never data on any client.
Why it is still open
Serup and colleagues published the 2018 to 2019 figures in 2025 as a benchmark, saying Denmark can serve as the index country for watching how the EU rules change what goes into skin. No later count from the same records was found. The Nordic inspection project of 2023 and 2024 checked 211 inks offered by 64 businesses, not what was used on clients.
Built with what exists
Totals exported from InkBase with the agreement of its operators and the Danish authorities; the lists of restricted substances in REACH Annex XVII, entry 75; Python and pandas.
First step
Write to InkBase's operators and the Danish Environmental Protection Agency asking for 2024 totals in the layout of the 2025 paper's tables.
Done looks like
For 2019 and for each year from 2024 to 2026, the share of sessions using each Color Index number for blue and green, the share of inks made in the US, the share of bottles that carry a Color Index number, and a list of any banned pigment still logged after 4 January 2023, all published in the same tables as the 2025 paper.