BRENNEN

Industries / Media, arts and recreation / Media and entertainment / Streaming

Subscriptions and ads

Subscriptions and ads cover how streaming services charge: monthly fees, free tiers paid for by advertising, free channels with ads, extra charges for sharing an account, and the rules on signing up and cancelling.

7

Milestones achieved, from 2008 to 2025.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 2008

    Free TV episodes with ads

    Hulu, "a joint venture between News Corp.'s Fox and NBC Universal," opened to the public on 12 March 2008 with "more than 250 television shows and 100 full-length feature films." It was free to watch in a web browser and paid for by ads, with its own ad network working from launch. The technology columnist Walt Mossberg called it "free, ad-supported streaming directly within a Web browser."

    fortune.comheraldnet.com

    Credit

    NBC Universal and News Corp

  2. 2011

    A price split, reversed

    In 2011 Netflix split its DVD-by-mail and streaming plans into two, at "$7.99 per month for unlimited streaming" and the same again for DVDs, a rise of about $6 a month for members who kept both, by PBS's account. It then announced a separate DVD brand, Qwikster, and dropped it on 10 October 2011. In the third quarter its US subscribers fell by about 805,000, to 23.8 million.

    LessonNetflix told shareholders, "We compounded the problem with our lack of explanation about the rising cost.".

    sec.govpbs.orgsec.gov

    Credit

    Netflix (Reed Hastings)

  3. 2019

    Free channels bought

    On 22 January 2019 Viacom agreed to buy Pluto TV, founded in 2013, for $340 million in cash. Pluto TV offers free streaming channels with ads, which the trade calls FAST (free ad-supported streaming TV). In March 2020 Fox agreed to buy Tubi, a free on-demand service with ads that streamed "over 160 million hours per month," for about $440 million. By Nielsen's measurement, Pluto TV, The Roku Channel and Tubi together had 5.7% of all US TV viewing in May 2025.

    sec.govsec.govnielsen.com

    Credit

    Viacom; Fox Corporation; measured by Nielsen

  4. 2022

    Netflix adds ads

    In the first quarter of 2022 Netflix's paid memberships fell by 200,000, after a loss of 700,000 from suspending its service in Russia. It estimated that its accounts were being shared with "over 100m additional households." On 3 November 2022 it launched Basic with Ads at $6.99 a month in the US, in 12 countries, with "an average of 4 to 5 minutes of ads per hour," using Microsoft as its ad technology and sales partner. Netflix reported ad revenue of more than $1.5 billion for 2025, more than 2.5 times its 2024 figure.

    s22.q4cdn.coms22.q4cdn.comabout.netflix.coms22.q4cdn.com

    Credit

    Netflix; Microsoft

  5. 2023

    Paying to share

    Netflix began charging for people outside a member's household in Canada, New Zealand, Portugal and Spain in February 2023, at C$7.99 a month for each extra member in Canada, and in the US and more than 100 other countries on 23 May 2023. It reported 5.9 million paid net additions in the second quarter of 2023 and 8.8 million in the third, against 2.4 million a year earlier.

    LessonUnlike the 2011 price split, the charge was introduced in stages and explained, and Netflix reported that "The cancel reaction continues to be low.".

    about.netflix.coms22.q4cdn.coms22.q4cdn.com

    Credit

    Netflix

  6. 2024

    Ads by default

    On 29 January 2024 Amazon began showing ads in Prime Video in the US and charged "an additional $2.99 per month" for an ad-free option, without changing the price of Prime itself. Amazon said it aimed "to have meaningfully fewer ads than linear TV."

    aboutamazon.comfoxbusiness.com

    Credit

    Amazon

  7. 2025

    Click-to-cancel struck down

    In October 2024 the US Federal Trade Commission adopted a rule to "make it as easy for consumers to cancel their enrollment as it was to sign up." On 8 July 2025, days before the rule was to take full effect, the US Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit vacated it because the FTC had skipped a required preliminary analysis, writing that "the procedural deficiencies... are fatal here." In September 2025 Amazon agreed to pay $2.5 billion to settle the FTC's case over Prime sign-ups and cancellations under an existing law, and the FTC began a new rulemaking in March 2026. Earlier, a 2021 report by the Norwegian Consumer Council had found Amazon Prime "unreasonably cumbersome to unsubscribe" from, and in 2022 Amazon agreed with the European Commission to let EU members unsubscribe "with just two clicks."

    LessonThe broad national rule fell on procedure, while cases under existing laws, and laws such as Germany's required cancel button of 2022, stayed in force.

    ftc.govecf.ca8.uscourts.govftc.govcooley.comstorage02.forbrukerradet.noec.europa.eugesetze-im-internet.de

    Credit

    the FTC; the Eighth Circuit; the Norwegian Consumer Council (Forbrukerrådet); the European Commission

Watch for

  1. Netflix's ad reach

    Netflix said in May 2026 that its plan with ads "now reaches more than 250M global monthly active viewers." It counts members who watch at least a minute of ads in a month and multiplies by its own estimate of how many people watch in each household. Variety reported that the figure "is derived from Netflix's own research, not a third-party measurement entity." In October 2026 Netflix lowered its expected 2026 ad revenue to about $2.7 billion from about $3 billion, "due to slightly slower than expected rollout of some ad product capabilities," and said the plan with ads would reach 15 more countries in 2027.

    Achieved whenNielsen or another outside measurer publishes a reach figure for the plan that matches Netflix's.

    about.netflix.comau.variety.coms22.q4cdn.com

    Claimed by

    Netflix, May and October 2026

  2. AI agents that buy ads

    Netflix said in May 2026 that it is "testing AI agents to manage, optimize, and purchase ads on Netflix" and testing "personalized ad loads," meaning a different number of ads for different viewers. The same month Amazon launched Dynamic TV Creative for Prime Video, which uses "AI-driven creative optimization" to change ads, and supported its results with an internal Amazon study.

    Achieved whenAn outside party, such as an advertiser publishing its own data or an independent measurer, reports how these tools perform against ordinary campaigns.

    about.netflix.comadvertising.amazon.com

    Claimed by

    Netflix and Amazon, May 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Time the cancel button

    A filmed, repeatable audit of the steps and screens it takes to cancel each major streaming service, on the web, phone and TV apps, in several countries. Each flow is scored against the rules that now apply there.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Measure ad loudness

    A published measurement of how loud the ad breaks on each ad-supported streaming plan are, compared with the program around them, using the standard loudness measure (ITU-R BS.1770, in loudness units), for services watched in California.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Time the cancel button

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A filmed, repeatable audit of the steps and screens it takes to cancel each major streaming service, on the web, phone and TV apps, in several countries. Each flow is scored against the rules that now apply there.

Why it is still open

The Swedish Consumers' Association reviewed 20 subscription services in autumn 2024, eight of them streaming services, in Sweden only. Two people documented each step: Netflix took 5 steps, Disney+ and SkyShowtime 8, Max 10, Amazon Prime and TV4 Play 11, and Viaplay 14, and "superfluous steps occurred in 17 out of 20 cancellation processes." The report itself notes that "the services may have changed their flows" since. The Norwegian and EU actions of 2021 and 2022 covered Amazon only, the FTC's national rule was struck down, and the UK's new subscription rules are due to come into force in January 2027, so each country now has different rules.

sverigeskonsumenter.segov.uk

Built with what exists

Ordinary monthly subscriptions, bought and cancelled by the testers; screen recording on phones, TVs and browsers; the Swedish study's method of counting steps; a browser agent such as Browser Use (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over") to repeat the web flows on a schedule; a checklist built from Germany's cancel-button rule (section 312k of the Civil Code), the UK's regulations and the FTC's Amazon order.

  1. First step

    Subscribe to three services for one month in one country, record each cancellation on the web and on a phone, and count the steps by the Swedish method.

  2. Done looks like

    Eight services in four places (California, the UK, Germany and Sweden), on web and app, with recordings, step counts and scores against each place's rules published, and re-run every three months, including once before and once after the UK rules start.

Open 02 · the brief

Measure ad loudness

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A published measurement of how loud the ad breaks on each ad-supported streaming plan are, compared with the program around them, using the standard loudness measure (ITU-R BS.1770, in loudness units), for services watched in California.

Why it is still open

Since 1 July 2026 California's SB 576 has barred video streaming services serving Californians from transmitting "the audio of commercial advertisements louder than the video content the advertisements accompany," consistent with the federal rules under the CALM Act, which cover broadcast and pay TV; US industry groups have told the FCC that the Act does not reach streaming services. The California law "does not create a private right of action" and names no agency to check it. A March 2026 article by Telos Alliance, which sells audio-processing equipment, notes that where ads are sent straight to the viewer's device, "platforms may have limited control over the audio characteristics of the ad itself." This research found no published measurement of US services since the law took effect.

calmatters.digitaldemocracy.orgbroadbandbreakfast.comstreamingmedia.com

Built with what exists

Ordinary ad-supported subscriptions; the analog or optical audio output of a TV or streaming device, fed to a USB audio interface; open-source loudness meters that follow BS.1770, such as ffmpeg's ebur128 filter or the pyloudnorm Python library; a script that marks where each ad break starts and ends. Only the loudness readings are kept, not the recordings.

  1. First step

    Measure 10 ad breaks on one free service with ads using ffmpeg's loudness filter, and compare each with the program before it.

  2. Done looks like

    For each of six ad-supported services, at least 50 ad breaks in programs of several kinds, each with the difference in loudness units between the break and the five minutes of program before it, published with the method and repeated every three months.