BRENNEN

Industries / Technology / Social media

Messaging

Messaging is private conversation between two people or within a group, carried by a platform that, more and more often, encrypts it so that the platform itself cannot read it.

6

Milestones achieved, from 1988 to 2026.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1988

    Group chat across universities

    Jarkko Oikarinen, who looked after a server in the Department of Information Processing Science at the University of Oulu in Finland, wrote Internet Relay Chat (IRC) in the summer of 1988 to add real-time discussion among many users to a public bulletin board he ran. He dates its "birthday" to the end of August 1988. When it began to have more than 10 users at a time, friends ran servers at universities in Tampere and Helsinki, and users and servers at US universities, among them Oregon State and the University of Denver, followed.

    irc.org

    Credit

    Jarkko Oikarinen

  2. 2018

    Forwarding capped after killings

    Rumors about supposed child abductors spread on WhatsApp in India and led to a series of mob lynchings. On 19 July 2018 WhatsApp said it would test a limit on forwarding for everyone; Fortune, citing TechCrunch, reported the limit as 20 chats at once worldwide and five in India, where the quick forward button beside photos and videos was also removed. India was then WhatsApp's largest market, with 200 million of its 1.5 billion monthly users. WhatsApp later set five as the limit. In 2019 Philipe de Freitas Melo and colleagues modeled the spread of misinformation with data gathered from WhatsApp in Brazil, India and Indonesia and found the limits "can offer significant delays" but are "ineffective in blocking the propagation of misinformation campaigns through public groups when the content has a high viral nature".

    LessonFriction slows a rumor but does not stop one that is already spreading through large groups.

    fortune.comarxiv.org

    Credit

    WhatsApp; de Freitas Melo, Vieira, Garimella, Vaz de Melo and Benevenuto

  3. 2022

    Apple drops photo scanning

    In August 2021 Apple announced a plan to check photos stored in iCloud against known child sexual abuse material, and it paused the plan that September after criticism from digital rights groups and researchers. In October 2021, 14 security researchers, among them Hal Abelson, Ross Anderson, Whitfield Diffie, Ronald Rivest and Bruce Schneier, argued that client-side scanning, which inspects content on the phone before it is encrypted, "creates serious security and privacy risks for all society" and "can fail, can be evaded, and can be abused". In December 2022 Apple told WIRED it had "decided to not move forward" and would put its effort into Communication Safety, opt-in warnings that parents can turn on for children's accounts. In 2023 Erik Neuenschwander, Apple's director of user privacy and child safety, wrote that scanning every user's iCloud data "would create new threat vectors for data thieves to find and exploit".

    LessonA scanner built into the phone for one kind of content can later be pointed at others, which is why researchers opposed it.

    arxiv.orgwired.comwired.com

    Credit

    Apple; the authors of "Bugs in our Pockets"

  4. 2024

    Telegram's founder charged in Paris

    Pavel Durov, Telegram's chief executive, was questioned by French police for four days after arriving in Paris in August 2024. On 28 August 2024 the Paris prosecutor's office announced charges against him over crimes committed on the app, saying Telegram had "almost completely failed" to respond to its legal requests for user data in cybercrime cases; he was released on €5 million bail and barred from leaving France while the case goes on. On 23 September 2024 Telegram changed its terms and privacy policy to make clear that the IP addresses and phone numbers of people who break its rules can be disclosed to authorities "in response to valid legal requests". Durov says Telegram could already do so in most countries since 2018, and gives his own figures: 2,461 requests met in India in the first quarter of 2024.

    nbcnews.comt.met.metelegram.org

    Credit

    Paris prosecutor's office; Telegram

  5. 2026

    Encrypted texts between phone brands

    Messaging Layer Security (MLS), published by the Internet Engineering Task Force as RFC 9420 in July 2023, lets groups "ranging from two to thousands" of members agree on and update shared encryption keys at a cost that grows with the logarithm of the group's size. With "sender keys", the usual earlier method, recovering security after a key is stolen takes a number of messages that grows with the square of the group's size. Its authors came from Cisco, Inria and Mozilla, Phoenix R&D, Meta and the University of Oxford. The GSMA's RCS Universal Profile 3.0, the standard for the texting system that replaces SMS, uses MLS for end-to-end encryption. Apple added RCS to the iPhone in iOS 18 in 2024, and on 11 May 2026 iOS 26.5 began rolling out encrypted RCS in beta between iPhones and Android phones running Google Messages, where the carrier supports it.

    rfc-editor.orgeff.orghelpnetsecurity.com

    Credit

    R. Barnes, B. Beurdouche, R. Robert, J. Millican, E. Omara and K. Cohn-Gordon (RFC 9420); GSMA; Apple; Google

  6. 2026

    EU rules spare encrypted chats

    The European Commission's 2022 proposal for a law on child sexual abuse online included detection orders, which critics said would mean scanning private and encrypted messages. On 26 November 2025 the Council of the EU agreed a position without mandatory detection orders. A temporary EU rule letting messaging services scan voluntarily lapsed on 3 April 2026, after the European Parliament voted down an extension on 26 March 2026, by 228 votes to 311. Regulation (EU) 2026/1881 of 24 July 2026 restored it until 3 April 2028, but it does not apply to conversations that are end-to-end encrypted and does not allow client-side scanning of them. Negotiations on the permanent law continue.

    eucrim.eueucrim.eu

    Credit

    European Parliament; Council of the EU

Watch for

  1. Chats with other apps

    Under the EU's Digital Markets Act, Meta says WhatsApp users in Europe who opt in will be able to exchange messages, images, voice messages, videos and files with users of BirdyChat and Haiket, the first two outside apps to connect, after "successful small scale tests". It says end-to-end encryption is kept "as far as possible", that a notice in WhatsApp's Settings will roll out "over the coming months", and that groups with outside users will come later.

    Achieved whenan outside test shows opted-in WhatsApp users across the EU exchanging end-to-end encrypted messages with a third-party app in routine use.

    about.fb.com

    Claimed by

    Meta, November 2025

Open

  1. 01

    Test the WhatsApp bridge

    A public, repeatable test of WhatsApp's third-party chats in the EU. From the team's own accounts on WhatsApp and on each connected app (BirdyChat, Haiket and any later partner), run a fixed script of about 30 actions, among them text, photo, voice note, video, file, reply, reaction, edit, delete, block and report, and record which arrive intact, how long each takes, and whether the encryption notice and safety-number check work at both ends.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    What a report hands over

    A side-by-side record of what happens when a user reports a conversation in about ten encrypted messaging apps, such as WhatsApp, Messenger, Signal, iMessage, Google Messages, Telegram secret chats, Threema, Wire, Element and Snapchat. Two of the team's own accounts hold a scripted, harmless conversation carrying unique marker phrases; one reports the other. Record how many messages and which media the report sends, whether the reported account is told, whether the reporter hears back, and, from a data-access request under the EU's General Data Protection Regulation, what the provider kept and for how long.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Test the WhatsApp bridge

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public, repeatable test of WhatsApp's third-party chats in the EU. From the team's own accounts on WhatsApp and on each connected app (BirdyChat, Haiket and any later partner), run a fixed script of about 30 actions, among them text, photo, voice note, video, file, reply, reaction, edit, delete, block and report, and record which arrive intact, how long each takes, and whether the encryption notice and safety-number check work at both ends.

Why it is still open

Meta announced the first two partners in November 2025 and said the option would reach users "over the coming months", with groups to follow; no outside test of what actually crosses the bridge was found, on the web or on GitHub, where the projects are unofficial bridges.

about.fb.com

Built with what exists

Two Android phones and one iPhone with EU numbers; WhatsApp and the partner apps; screen recording; Appium or Android's UI Automator to replay the script; a spreadsheet of results.

  1. First step

    Opt one test phone into third-party chats from WhatsApp's Settings and send ten scripted messages to the team's own BirdyChat account, timing each.

  2. Done looks like

    A table of every scripted action for each partner app, run three times on Android and three on iOS, with recordings, published and repeated every three months as features change.

Open 02 · the brief

What a report hands over

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A side-by-side record of what happens when a user reports a conversation in about ten encrypted messaging apps, such as WhatsApp, Messenger, Signal, iMessage, Google Messages, Telegram secret chats, Threema, Wire, Element and Snapchat. Two of the team's own accounts hold a scripted, harmless conversation carrying unique marker phrases; one reports the other. Record how many messages and which media the report sends, whether the reported account is told, whether the reporter hears back, and, from a data-access request under the EU's General Data Protection Regulation, what the provider kept and for how long.

Why it is still open

Leijie Wang and colleagues at the University of Washington and Cornell interviewed 16 users of encrypted apps about how they think reporting works (SOUPS 2023) and noted from the apps' documents that a WhatsApp report forwards the last five messages while Signal and Matrix do not show reported messages to moderators. No measured comparison across apps was found.

arxiv.org

Built with what exists

Two phones per app with the team's own accounts; the apps' report buttons; GDPR Article 15 access requests; a spreadsheet; screen recording.

  1. First step

    Report one scripted conversation between two of the team's own WhatsApp accounts and file an access request for the reporting account.

  2. Done looks like

    A table for at least ten apps with the same columns, each report repeated twice, the access-request replies summarized, and the providers' comments invited before publication.