BRENNEN

Industries / Finance and business services / Records management

Legal holds

A legal hold is an instruction, usually from an organization's lawyers, to stop destroying records that may matter to a lawsuit or investigation that has started or can be expected. It overrides the retention schedule until the matter ends.

5

Milestones achieved, from 2004 to 2025.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 2004

    Lawyers must watch holds

    In 2004 Judge Shira Scheindlin of the US District Court for the Southern District of New York issued the fifth pretrial ruling in Zubulake v. UBS Warburg, Laura Zubulake's employment discrimination suit, known as Zubulake V. By the ABA Journal's account, the Zubulake rulings put companies on notice that they had to preserve data once they reasonably expected to be sued, and lawyers learned it was not enough to start a hold: they had to oversee whether it was followed. Because UBS "failed to preserve relevant emails, even after receiving adequate warnings from counsel", she let the jury infer that the lost emails would have hurt UBS, a sanction called an adverse inference. The jury awarded Zubulake $29.2 million in 2005.

    LessonZubulake's lawyers later said jurors told them the adverse inference "didn't really drive the train"; the ruling's larger effect, by the ABA Journal's account, was on how companies and their lawyers preserve data.

    abajournal.com

    Credit

    Judge Shira A. Scheindlin

  2. 2012

    No automatic gross negligence

    In January 2010, in Pension Committee v. Banc of America Securities, Judge Scheindlin held that failing to issue a written litigation hold was gross negligence. On 10 July 2012, in Chin v. Port Authority of New York & New Jersey, the US Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit rejected that rule. It held that failing to institute a hold "does not constitute gross negligence per se", and it treated the failure as one factor in deciding sanctions.

    LessonCourts judge a hold case by case, by what was reasonable, not by a fixed checklist.

    natlawreview.comabajournal.com

    Credit

    US Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit

  3. 2015

    Sanctions need intent

    Rule 37(e) of the US Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, amended with effect from 1 December 2015, applies when electronic information that should have been preserved "is lost because a party failed to take reasonable steps to preserve it". A court may then order "measures no greater than necessary to cure the prejudice". It may tell a jury to presume the lost information was unfavorable, or dismiss the case, "only upon finding that the party acted with the intent to deprive". The committee note says federal circuits had set "significantly different standards", which led litigants "to expend excessive effort and money on preservation".

    law.cornell.edu

    Credit

    US federal courts' civil rules process

  4. 2023

    Messaging apps in scope

    On 3 March 2023 the Criminal Division of the US Department of Justice (DOJ) revised its Evaluation of Corporate Compliance Programs, the guide prosecutors use to judge a company's compliance efforts. The revision added guidance on personal devices and messaging apps, including ephemeral apps, which delete messages automatically. The current version tells prosecutors to consider whether a company's policies ensure that business communications "are accessible and amenable to preservation by the company".

    mofo.comjustice.gov

    Credit

    US Department of Justice, Criminal Division

  5. 2025

    AI chat logs held

    In May 2025, in the New York Times' copyright lawsuit against OpenAI, a federal court ordered OpenAI to "preserve and segregate all output log data that would otherwise be deleted on a going forward basis". The order covered ChatGPT Free, Plus, Pro and Team users and API customers without zero-data-retention agreements, and the court clarified that ChatGPT Enterprise was excluded. An order filed on 9 October 2025 ended the duty going forward as of 26 September 2025. OpenAI keeps the logs already saved, except those from the European Economic Area, Switzerland and the UK, and still preserves logs of accounts tied to web domains the newspapers named.

    LessonA hold can reach data that a company has promised users it will delete; OpenAI argued the request "conflicted with our privacy commitments".

    blogs.duanemorris.comopenai.com

    Credit

    Magistrate Judge Ona T. Wang, US District Court for the Southern District of New York

Watch for

  1. Finding custodians faster

    Insight Optix says the April 2026 release of its Legal Hold Evolve software builds "a comprehensive view of employee job history" to "quickly and more accurately identify potentially relevant custodians". Custodians are the people whose records a hold must cover. It also shows each custodian's data sources before interviews. The release gives no figures.

    Achieved whena customer or outside reviewer publishes how many custodians the tool found and missed, compared with a hold drawn up by hand for the same matter.

    ediscoverytoday.com

    Claimed by

    Insight Optix, April 2026

  2. Holds on AI conversations

    Arctera's January 2026 release added ChatGPT "as new content source for search, review, legal hold or export", with a collector that captures conversations between users and the assistant. Microsoft says the permanent deletion of Copilot messages is suspended while a mailbox is under Litigation Hold or an eDiscovery hold.

    Achieved whenan outside test shows that held AI conversations, deleted by their users, can still be found and produced complete.

    assets.arctera.iolearn.microsoft.com

    Claimed by

    Arctera, January 2026; Microsoft, 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Holds that leak, tested

    A public test of how well legal holds stop deletion in common workplace software. In test accounts on Microsoft 365, Google Workspace and Slack, place holds on test custodians, then try every deletion route a user or administrator has: deleting and editing messages, emptying bins, removing a user, deleting a shared drive or channel, changing retention settings, and clearing AI assistant history. Record what can still be found and produced afterwards.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Choosing custodians, measured

    A test of AI tools that propose who must receive a hold and which systems to preserve. Build a synthetic company with an organization chart, job histories, email, chat and file shares; write 30 fictional disputes; have experienced e-discovery practitioners draw up the hold for each; then score tools against their answers.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Holds that leak, tested

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public test of how well legal holds stop deletion in common workplace software. In test accounts on Microsoft 365, Google Workspace and Slack, place holds on test custodians, then try every deletion route a user or administrator has: deleting and editing messages, emptying bins, removing a user, deleting a shared drive or channel, changing retention settings, and clearing AI assistant history. Record what can still be found and produced afterwards.

Why it is still open

Holds depend on each vendor's internal design, and the details sit in documentation. Microsoft's, for example, says held Copilot messages live in hidden mailbox folders and that messages visible in the app "are not an accurate reflection" of what is kept. This site's LegalTech entry describes a 2023 case in which Google employees under a hold had chat history turned off. Searches found no independent, published test of hold coverage across vendors.

learn.microsoft.com

Built with what exists

test accounts; synthetic custodians and messages; each vendor's hold and eDiscovery tools, such as Microsoft Purview and Google Vault; Browser Use 1.0 to carry out deletion routes in web pages (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over"); a shared table of routes and results.

  1. First step

    Place a hold on one test user in a Microsoft 365 account and try ten deletion routes taken from Microsoft's documentation.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 30 deletion routes on each of 3 platforms, each run three times, with a published table of which routes left the held item findable and complete, rerun every quarter.

Open 02 · the brief

Choosing custodians, measured

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A test of AI tools that propose who must receive a hold and which systems to preserve. Build a synthetic company with an organization chart, job histories, email, chat and file shares; write 30 fictional disputes; have experienced e-discovery practitioners draw up the hold for each; then score tools against their answers.

Why it is still open

Custodian-finding features now ship without published accuracy, such as Insight Optix's job-history view. Casepoint's first two AI agents, released in alpha to a handful of customers in September 2026, handle relevance determination and issue coding in document review, not holds.

ediscoverytoday.comlawnext.com

Built with what exists

EnterpriseRAG-Bench's open generator, which creates linked synthetic company data across sources such as Slack, Gmail and Jira; a language model such as Claude or Gemini given each dispute and the company's records; Gemini Decision 1 to give a probability that each employee belongs on the hold (see the Note "A thousand questions, one pass").

  1. First step

    Generate a 200-person synthetic company and write five disputes.

  2. Done looks like

    30 disputes, each with a hold drawn up by at least two practitioners, and published recall of custodians and data sources for at least 3 tools, with every missed custodian listed.