Industries / Media, arts and recreation / Media and entertainment / Publishing
Selling books and magazines
Selling is getting copies from publishers to readers through wholesalers, shops, websites and subscriptions, and getting money, and unsold copies, back.
6
Milestones achieved, from 1997 to 2020.
1
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1997
Britain ends fixed book prices
From 1 January 1900 the Net Book Agreement let British publishers fix the price at which shops sold their books, and a shop that discounted could lose its supply. A court upheld it in 1962, accepting that without it booksellers would lose their margins. Publishers, booksellers, supermarkets and British and EU competition authorities pushed against it in the 1980s and 1990s; the Publishers Association suspended it in September 1995, and the Restrictive Practices Court abolished it in March 1997.
LessonA price agreement that a court had judged worth keeping in 1962 did not survive once large sellers stopped wanting it.
Credit
Publishers Association; Restrictive Practices Court
2000
One data format for books
ONIX is an XML format, a structured text file computers can read, for sending book information such as titles, contributors, prices, formats and availability from publishers to wholesalers and shops. The Association of American Publishers, EDItEUR and others wrote the first guidelines in 1999 and published them in January 2000; ONIX for Books Release 1.0 followed a few months later. It is free to use, and in 2019 Amazon said it would stop accepting the older Release 2.1 for print books after December 2020.
Credit
EDItEUR; Association of American Publishers
2009
A magazine wholesaler goes dark
US newsstand magazines pass through wholesalers. By the account in Anderson News's complaint, as a court summarized it, wholesalers bought copies at 50 to 60% of the cover price, sold them to shops at 70 to 80%, and collected and destroyed unsold copies, and four wholesalers held 90% of the trade, Anderson 27%. In early 2009 Anderson demanded a surcharge of 7 cents a copy; about 90% of publishers refused, and Anderson stopped business on 7 February 2009 and was forced into liquidation on 2 March. Its suit claiming that publishers had conspired to put it out of business was dismissed, and an appeals court upheld the dismissal in 2018.
LessonWhen four wholesalers carry nearly all newsstand copies, the failure of one cuts a large share of the route to readers at once.
Credit
Anderson News; magazine publishers including Time Inc. and Hearst
2011
Borders closes its stores
Borders Group, then the second-largest US book retailer, was liquidated in 2011, closing its last 399 stores and ending about 10,700 jobs. It had expanded and refurbished its stores and handed its online sales to Amazon, while Barnes & Noble built its own website and later its own e-reader.
LessonA bookseller that let a rival run its online store had no web business of its own when book buying moved online.
Credit
Borders Group
2013
Ebook price pact ruled illegal
Amazon sold many new ebooks at $9.99, close to what it paid publishers. In 2010, as Apple opened its ebook store, five large publishers, with 48.8% of US trade ebook sales, moved to the agency model, in which the publisher sets the retail price and the shop takes a commission. A government expert found that their new-release ebook prices rose 24.2% on average in the following year. In July 2013 Judge Cote of the US District Court in New York found that Apple had organized a conspiracy among the publishers to raise ebook prices, and the Second Circuit affirmed in June 2015.
LessonPublishers may set their own ebook prices, but they may not agree among themselves to do it.
Credit
US Department of Justice and state attorneys general; the federal courts
2020
Online sales shared with indies
Bookshop.org opened in January 2020 as an online shop for readers who want to support independent bookstores. The wholesaler Ingram fills the orders, stores that join as affiliates earn 25% of the sales they bring in, and 10% of other sales goes into a pool shared among stores. It sold $51 million of books in its first year, when the pandemic closed shops, and by its own running count it has raised more than $52 million for bookstores.
Credit
Andy Hunter, its founder; the American Booksellers Association, which backed it
Watch for
AI-planned reorders in Japan
PubteX, a company owned by the publishers Kodansha, Shueisha and Shogakukan and the trading house Marubeni, says it will cut both returns and sold-out shelves by using AI demand forecasts to recommend how many copies to send at launch, then refilling shops in small batches as they sell. Its three owner publishers and six bookstore companies joined as first partners, with deliveries due to begin in October 2026. PubteX gives no target figure.
Achieved whenAn outside party, such as a distributor or a trade research body, publishes return and stock-out rates for titles handled this way against comparable titles handled the usual way, over at least a year.
Claimed by
PubteX, September 2026
Open
01
AI reading lists, checked
A repeated public test of the book suggestions AI assistants give readers. Put 1,000 everyday requests ("a funny novel for a 12-year-old", "a recent history of the Ottoman Empire") to at least four assistants, and check every title they name against catalogue records: whether the book exists, whether the named author wrote it, whether it can be bought new, and whether any link or price given points to the right edition.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Fixed book prices, checked online
A repeated public measure of how often new books are offered online below the price the law fixes, starting with Germany, broken down by kind of seller (large retailer, marketplace seller, small shop) and never naming individual sellers. Only public offer pages are read; nothing is bought.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
AI reading lists, checked
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A repeated public test of the book suggestions AI assistants give readers. Put 1,000 everyday requests ("a funny novel for a 12-year-old", "a recent history of the Ottoman Empire") to at least four assistants, and check every title they name against catalogue records: whether the book exists, whether the named author wrote it, whether it can be bought new, and whether any link or price given points to the right edition.
Why it is still open
In May 2025 the Chicago Sun-Times and at least one edition of The Philadelphia Inquirer printed a syndicated "Summer reading list for 2025" from King Features that recommended books by real authors that do not exist, such as an Isabel Allende novel called Tidewater Dreams; the writer, Marco Buscaglia, told NPR it was partly generated by AI. Junichiro Niimi (October 2025) checked 100 references that GPT-4.1 generated for computer-science papers and found that accuracy rose with how often a paper had been cited; that study covered research papers, not books for general readers. This research found no repeated public test of AI assistants' book suggestions.
Built with what exists
The assistants' public apps or programming interfaces; Open Library's free search interface and data dumps for title, author and edition records; a web agent such as Browser Use to follow shop links (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over"); each request asked five times, since answers change between runs (see the Note "All twenty times"); Python for matching and tallies.
First step
Write 50 requests, put them to two assistants, and look up every suggested title by hand in Open Library.
Done looks like
1,000 requests across fiction and nonfiction, for adults and children, put to at least four assistants five times each; the share of named books that do not exist, are credited to the wrong author or cannot be bought new, by assistant and by kind of request, with 200 matches checked by hand; data and code released and the test rerun every six months.
Open 02 · the brief
Fixed book prices, checked online
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A repeated public measure of how often new books are offered online below the price the law fixes, starting with Germany, broken down by kind of seller (large retailer, marketplace seller, small shop) and never naming individual sellers. Only public offer pages are read; nothing is bought.
Why it is still open
German law requires anyone who sells new books commercially to buyers in Germany to charge the price the publisher sets, and leaves enforcement to private claims by booksellers, trade bodies and lawyers whom publishers jointly appoint as price trustees. The trustees act on single offers: in February 2022 one sent a formal warning, at a cost of €208.25 to the seller, over a book offered on Amazon 5 cents below its fixed price, by the online retailers' association Händlerbund's account. A search found such cases but no published rate of breaches across online sellers.
gesetze-im-internet.degesetze-im-internet.deohn.haendlerbund.de
Built with what exists
Publishers' new-release lists with their fixed prices; a web agent such as Browser Use to read public offer pages (see the Note "Deleting 80% to start over"); Python to compare offers with fixed prices and save dated screenshots.
First step
Take the current top 100 German bestsellers, record their fixed prices from the publishers' sites, and check the offers on three platforms on one day.
Done looks like
1,000 new titles checked weekly for eight weeks at five or more online sellers, each below-price offer saved as a dated screenshot, and breach rates by seller type published with the method and code.