BRENNEN

Industries / Media, arts and recreation / Professional sports

Officiating

Officiating is the work of applying a sport's rules during play: referees, umpires, line judges and scoring judges make the calls, and cameras, sensors and video rooms now check many of those calls or make them outright.

6

Milestones achieved, from 1986 to 2026.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1986

    NFL replay tried, dropped, rebuilt

    On 11 March 1986 NFL team owners voted 23–4–1 to let officials check calls on video for one season. That year replay averaged 1.6 reviews per game and reversed about 10% of the rulings it looked at. Owners renewed it until 1991, when 17 voted against it. It returned in 1999 in a new form: a coach could challenge a call but lost a timeout if wrong, and a replay assistant started every review in the last two minutes of each half.

    Lessonthe version that lasted gave the challenge to coaches and charged them for a wrong one.

    profootballhof.com

    Credit

    NFL team owners; Art McNally, the NFL director of officiating whom the Pro Football Hall of Fame calls the "Father of Instant Replay"

  2. 2006

    Players challenge, cameras decide

    From 1980 Wimbledon used Cyclops, an infrared beam that judged only whether serves were in or out. In 2006 the USTA, ATP and WTA let players challenge line calls using Hawk-Eye, whose cameras rebuild the ball's flight in 3D; the result went up on the scoreboard and was final. Each player had two challenges per set and kept any that proved right. The Nasdaq-100 Open in Miami was the first tour event to use it, and the US Open in August was the first Grand Slam, one of the four biggest tournaments.

    LessonHawk-Eye proved itself first as a TV graphic, which Hawkins called "the perfect training ground" for accuracy.

    sportsvideo.orgsi.comnzherald.co.nz

    Credit

    Hawk-Eye Innovations and its founder Paul Hawkins; the International Tennis Federation, which signed off on the system in October 2005 with the ATP and USTA

  3. 2009

    Cricket's Decision Review System launches

    Cricket first used a TV replay umpire, the "third umpire", for a run-out decision in a 1992 Test (a multi-day international match) between South Africa and India at Kingsmead. After a trial in a 2008 India–Sri Lanka Test, the International Cricket Council (ICC) formally launched the Decision Review System (DRS) in a New Zealand–Pakistan Test in Dunedin in November 2009. Under DRS a team can ask the TV umpire to re-check an on-field decision using replays and Hawk-Eye ball tracking, which predicts where the ball would have gone. India's board refused DRS in Test series from 2008 until it agreed to a trial in November 2016, after Hawk-Eye added faster cameras, the UltraEdge sound tool and recording of every ball in case an operator forgot to switch tracking on.

    LessonIndia came back only after Hawk-Eye fixed the specific faults its board had raised.

    icc-cricket.commillenniumpost.in

    Credit

    the ICC; Hawk-Eye; the Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI)

  4. 2018

    Video referees join football's laws

    In July 2012 the IFAB approved goal-line technology, which tells the referee's watch within one second whether the whole ball crossed the line, and the 2014 World Cup was the first World Cup to use it, by Guinness World Records' account. On 3 March 2018 the IFAB voted unanimously to write video assistant referees (VARs) into the Laws for 2018/19, after a two-year trial in several countries and an independent analysis by KU Leuven, a Belgian university. A VAR watches replays in a video room and can advise the referee to correct a "clear and obvious error" about goals, penalties, red cards or mistaken identity.

    downloads.theifab.comespn.comaljazeera.comguinnessworldrecords.com

    Credit

    the IFAB (its 2018 meeting was chaired by FIFA president Gianni Infantino); KU Leuven; GoalControl, whose system served the 2014 World Cup

  5. 2025

    Wimbledon retires its line judges

    In October 2024 the All England Club said that, after testing in 2024, electronic line calling would make the "out" and "fault" calls at Wimbledon from 2025; the US Open had gone without line judges since 2021. On 6 July 2025, during Anastasia Pavlyuchenkova's fourth-round match with Sonay Kartal on Centre Court, someone running the system switched ball tracking off by mistake for three points. A clearly long shot went uncalled, the chair umpire ordered the point replayed, and the club then removed the operators' ability to switch tracking off by hand.

    Lessontaking people off the lines did not take people out of the system, and one manual off switch became the point of failure.

    ksl.comnews4jax.com

    Credit

    the All England Lawn Tennis Club (chief executive Sally Bolton); Hawk-Eye

  6. 2026

    Baseball's ball-strike challenges arrive

    In September 2025 MLB's Joint Competition Committee (six owners, four players and one umpire) approved the Automated Ball-Strike (ABS) Challenge System for 2026, after testing in the minor leagues since 2021. Umpires still call every pitch, but the pitcher, catcher or batter can tap his cap or helmet to challenge, and twelve Hawk-Eye cameras then compare the pitch with a strike zone set from each batter's measured height. Each team starts with two challenges and keeps any it wins. Over the 2026 regular season Baseball-Reference counted 10,557 challenges and 5,685 overturned calls (53.9%); catchers won 58.6% of their challenges and batters 48.8%.

    LessonMLB chose challenges over having the machine call every pitch because of what Commissioner Rob Manfred called the players' "strong preference" for challenges.

    mlb.combaseball-reference.com

    Credit

    Major League Baseball and its Joint Competition Committee; Hawk-Eye; season counts by Baseball-Reference

Watch for

  1. FIFA's cheaper video review

    Football Video Support (FVS) is for competitions that cannot afford VAR. It uses a pitchside screen with one or two operators and no video referee or video room, and each head coach gets two cards to ask for a review of a goal, a penalty, a straight red card or mistaken identity, keeping the card if the call changes. FIFA says FVS is "rapidly gaining traction"; Italy's Serie C and Spain's Liga F and Primera Federación began using it full time in August 2025. At its 2026 annual meeting the IFAB kept FVS as an ongoing FIFA-led trial and did not write it into the Laws.

    Achieved whenthe IFAB writes FVS into the Laws of the Game, or an outside party publishes a full season's counts of FVS reviews, changed calls and stoppage times for at least one competition.

    inside.fifa.comtheifab.comilpost.it

    Claimed by

    FIFA (with Pierluigi Collina, chairman of the FIFA Referees Committee), October 2025

  2. NBA's automatic out-of-bounds calls

    NBA Commissioner Adam Silver said out-of-bounds calls will be made by "an AI, automated system with cameras lined around the court", taking these "objective calls" away from referees "fairly quickly", with no date given. The NBA already uses camera tracking to help decide sideline, baseline and goaltending plays (AP, October 2025).

    Achieved whenregular-season NBA games have out-of-bounds calls made by the automated system without a referee's call or a replay review, and an outside party reports how often it was right.

    thestar.com.mynews4jax.com

    Claimed by

    Adam Silver, on ESPN's Pat McAfee Show, May 2026 (reported by Reuters)

Open

  1. 01

    Public log of FVS reviews

    A public, match-by-match record of every Football Video Support review in one competition's 2025–26 season, for example Spain's Liga F (the women's top division) or one group of Italy's Serie C. Each review gets these fields: match, minute, who asked (a coach's card or the officials after a goal), incident type (goal, penalty, straight red card, mistaken identity), the call before and after, and how long play was stopped. Publish it as an open CSV with season totals, the way Baseball-Reference publishes ABS challenge counts.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    A two-phone goal-line check

    A goal-line decision kit for one goal at a lower-league or youth ground. Two phones film along the goal line from raised positions on each side, software decides whether the whole ball crossed the line, and an alert goes to the referee's phone or watch.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Public log of FVS reviews

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public, match-by-match record of every Football Video Support review in one competition's 2025–26 season, for example Spain's Liga F (the women's top division) or one group of Italy's Serie C. Each review gets these fields: match, minute, who asked (a coach's card or the officials after a goal), incident type (goal, penalty, straight red card, mistaken identity), the call before and after, and how long play was stopped. Publish it as an open CSV with season totals, the way Baseball-Reference publishes ABS challenge counts.

Why it is still open

FIFA and the IFAB still describe FVS as a trial, and neither has published counts of reviews, changed calls or stoppage times. In November 2026, after a year of FVS, Serie C clubs were still complaining about reviews that stop play for "cinque o sei minuti" (five or six minutes), and there is no public timing data to check that against. The Serie C referee designator called the first months "estremamente positivo" (extremely positive) without figures. Searches in English and Italian found no such log.

tuttomercatoweb.comtuttomercatoweb.comtheifab.com

Built with what exists

full-match video where the competition or clubs make it available; official match reports; a spreadsheet; open speech recognition such as Whisper to find review moments in commentary audio; a second person to re-check entries.

  1. First step

    Pick one Serie C matchday or one Liga F round, have two people log every FVS review on their own, and compare the two logs to settle the field definitions.

  2. Done looks like

    Every match of the chosen season logged, with stoppage start and restart to the nearest second. A second person re-logs a random 10% of matches and agrees on at least 95% of fields. Published totals give reviews per match, the share of calls changed, and the median and longest stoppage, split by incident type.

Open 02 · the brief

A two-phone goal-line check

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A goal-line decision kit for one goal at a lower-league or youth ground. Two phones film along the goal line from raised positions on each side, software decides whether the whole ball crossed the line, and an alert goes to the referee's phone or watch.

Why it is still open

FIFA-licensed goal-line systems use seven cameras per goal, mounted as high as possible in the stadium, and FIFA's Innovation Programme is still asking for systems that meet most of its standard "with significantly lower resource requirements". Attempts exist but none has published test results: an Android app on GitHub aimed at the same problem says "This project is finished and no longer being maintained" and gives no accuracy figures; FIFA said in September 2025 that VBSV Ouigoal "is attempting to implement a low-cost alternative" with cameras in the goal frame; and FIFA lists a German league (DFL) and federation (DFB) project on basic goal-line technology that ran to mid-2025 with no published outcome found.

inside.fifa.cominside.fifa.comgithub.cominside.fifa.com

Built with what exists

two current smartphones recording high-frame-rate slow-motion video, on tripods or clamps; OpenCV for camera calibration; an open object detector such as Ultralytics YOLO trained on ball frames; a laptop; a messaging link to the referee's phone.

  1. First step

    On a local pitch, mark the goal line and roll a ball across it in measured 1 cm steps with both phones recording, then score how often the software gets "goal" or "no goal" right.

  2. Done looks like

    The kit passes the test thresholds the IFAB published in 2011 for goal-line technology, with raw video and results published: every free shot on goal, near miss and side-netting shot recognized correctly; in a slow "sled" test, at least 90% of goal situations correct to within 3 cm either side of the line; in shots against a goalkeeper-sized impact wall, at least 90% correct to within 3 cm before the line or 5 cm past it; and the alert delivered within one second.

    keithlyons.me