BRENNEN

Industries / Industrial equipment and services / Industrial services / Process safety consulting

Audits

Auditing checks that a plant's safety program works in practice, not only that it exists on paper.

5

Milestones achieved, from 1993 to 2024.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1993

    Offshore audits must be independent

    The UK's Offshore Installations (Safety Case) Regulations 1992 were made on 16 November 1992 and took effect on 31 May 1993. From then on, no fixed installation could operate until HSE had accepted its safety case, which must show "adequate arrangements for audit." The regulations define an audit as a systematic assessment by persons "sufficiently independent of the system (but who may be employed by the duty holder)," and audit reports and records of what was done about them must be kept for three years.

    legislation.gov.uk

    Credit

    UK government; Health and Safety Executive

  2. 1999

    A yearly visit from inspectors

    The UK's Control of Major Accident Hazards (COMAH) Regulations took effect on 1 April 1999, carrying out the EU's Seveso II Directive, 96/82/EC. Inspections must not depend on reports from the operator and must examine technical, organisational and managerial systems. Sites with the most hazardous material get at least one on-site inspection every 12 months, unless the inspection program is based on a systematic appraisal of each site's hazards, and each operator's safety management system must include audit and review.

    legislation.gov.uk

    Credit

    UK government, carrying out Seveso II

  3. 2007

    Audits that checked paperwork

    In January 2007 an 11-member panel chaired by James A. Baker III reported on BP's five US refineries. It found BP had no effective process safety audit system, and named concerns about auditor qualifications, audit scope, reliance on internal auditors and limited review of findings. The audits, required every three years, checked that the legally required systems were in place, not whether they delivered safety. The panel's eighth recommendation was an effective audit system.

    LessonAn audit that only confirms a procedure exists cannot tell whether it works.

    csb.gov

    Credit

    BP U.S. Refineries Independent Safety Review Panel

  4. 2009

    Same gaps, refinery after refinery

    OSHA started its refinery inspection program (a National Emphasis Program) in June 2007. In its first year, teams inspected 14 refineries in 6 of OSHA's 10 regions and issued 348 citations under the process safety standard. OSHA wrote that it was "particularly concerned" that inspectors kept "seeing many of the same problems repeatedly," including failures to find and correct deficiencies in critical equipment promptly.

    osha.gov

    Credit

    OSHA

  5. 2024

    Outside auditors after an accident

    EPA's 2017 changes to its Risk Management Program (RMP) rule added third-party compliance audits. The provisions were paused, most never took effect, and a 2019 rule rescinded them. EPA's 2024 Safer Communities rule restored them and required an outside audit after a single RMP-reportable accident, where its 2022 proposal had set the trigger at two.

    epa.govgovinfo.gov

    Credit

    US Environmental Protection Agency

Watch for

  1. Outside audits may be cut

    On 24 February 2026 EPA proposed two options: rescind third-party audits, or keep them only for facilities with two reportable accidents in five years, require the audit data to be sent to EPA, and end the requirement after 10 years. EPA says it "has not been able to extrapolate a dataset" to show which facilities need such audits or what they achieve. The CSB objected on 5 May 2026, saying internal audits "often fail to identify systematic deficiencies," and cited Honeywell Geismar, which audited itself in 2014, 2017, 2020 and 2023.

    Achieved whenEPA publishes a final rule.

    govinfo.govcsb.gov

    Claimed by

    EPA, February 2026; comments closed on 11 May 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Measure what outside audits do

    A public study of the US facilities that EPA enforcement settlements required to hire third-party auditors, each compared with similar facilities that had no such audit, by counting RMP-reportable accidents in the five years before and after.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    A rule crosswalk that updates

    A machine-readable table that links each of the 14 elements of OSHA's process safety standard to the matching clauses of EPA's RMP Program 3, the EU's Seveso III Directive and the UK's COMAH regulations, with a link to the official text for every pairing. It is rebuilt whenever one of those texts changes and lists what changed.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Measure what outside audits do

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public study of the US facilities that EPA enforcement settlements required to hire third-party auditors, each compared with similar facilities that had no such audit, by counting RMP-reportable accidents in the five years before and after.

Why it is still open

EPA says it has required these audits in settlements but cannot show from data what they achieve. Earlier analyses of RMP accident histories, such as Kleindorfer and colleagues (2003), studied accident frequency, not audits.

govinfo.govideas.repec.org

Built with what exists

The Data Liberation Project's RMP spreadsheets of facilities, submissions and accidents, obtained from EPA by public records request and released in February 2023; public EPA settlement documents; Python with pandas; R's MatchIt package for matching.

buttondown.com

  1. First step

    List the Clean Air Act 112(r) settlements since 2010 that require a third-party audit, and find each facility in the RMP data.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 30 facilities with audits required by settlement, each matched to three similar facilities, with accident rates before and after published with confidence ranges and the code released.

Open 02 · the brief

A rule crosswalk that updates

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A machine-readable table that links each of the 14 elements of OSHA's process safety standard to the matching clauses of EPA's RMP Program 3, the EU's Seveso III Directive and the UK's COMAH regulations, with a link to the official text for every pairing. It is rebuilt whenever one of those texts changes and lists what changed.

Why it is still open

OSHA's own PSM–RMP comparison page says its RMP information "has not yet been updated" since EPA's 2019 rule, and EPA has changed or proposed changes to the rule twice since. A 2024 Purdue comparison of six regions is a prose report.

osha.govengineering.purdue.edu

Built with what exists

The official online texts (eCFR for 29 CFR 1910.119 and 40 CFR 68, EUR-Lex, legislation.gov.uk); a language model to draft the pairings; two people to check them.

  1. First step

    Map the management of change and compliance audit elements across the four texts by hand.

  2. Done looks like

    All 14 elements mapped and checked by two reviewers, released as CSV and JSON, plus a change report generated for the 2024 rule and the 2026 proposal that lists every clause each one touched.