BRENNEN

Industries / Industrial equipment and services / Industrial services / Non-destructive testing

Ultrasound

Ultrasonic testing sends sound far above the range of hearing into a part and listens for what comes back or gets through, to find cracks and holes inside it and to measure how thick its wall is.

6

Milestones achieved, from 1929 to 2021.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1929

    Sound sent through metal

    Sergei Sokolov, a physicist at the Electrotechnical Institute in Leningrad, proposed passing ultrasound through a metal part from a transmitter on one side to a receiver on the other, so that a flaw in the path shows up as an interruption in the sound. He published on how ultrasound travels through different solids in 1929, and in 1935 gave designs for quartz transmitters and ways to couple them to the part. Echo methods, which time a short pulse's return from a flaw, came in the early 1940s from Donald Sproule in Britain, with separate sending and receiving probes, and Floyd Firestone in the United States, with one probe that both sends and listens, as most inspectors use today; they worked separately and in secret.

    ob-ultrasound.netob-ultrasound.netnde-ed.org

    Credit

    Sergei Y. Sokolov, Leningrad Electrotechnical Institute

  2. 1975

    Timing the crack tips

    M. G. Silk and B. H. Lidington described in June 1975 how ultrasound scattered by the tips of a crack can be used to measure its depth. The method that grew from this, time-of-flight diffraction (TOFD), places a sending probe and a receiving probe on either side of a weld. The tips of a crack give off weak signals, and their arrival times give the depth of each tip by simple geometry. The older way of sizing, by the strength of the echo, depends heavily on which way a crack faces; travel time does not. TOFD is now covered by standards that include ASTM E2373 and ISO 10863.

    api.crossref.orgen.wikipedia.org

    Credit

    M. G. Silk and B. H. Lidington, UK

  3. 1989

    Inspectors must prove it

    ASME's 1989 Addenda to Section XI of its Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code, the rules for inspecting nuclear plants in service, added Appendix VIII. It qualifies ultrasonic equipment, procedures and examiners together, by blind tests on flawed samples like the real parts, with pass marks set by statistics, in place of rules that only prescribed how to scan. US nuclear utilities formed the Performance Demonstration Initiative (PDI) in 1991 to run the tests, with EPRI's NDE Center as administrator. The NRC reported that in a sample of PDI piping tests, retests included, 22% of examiners failed the screen for detecting flaws, 41% for measuring their length and 67% for measuring their depth. At Browns Ferry Unit 3 in 1993, an examination qualified this way found 15 flaws in reactor vessel welds that needed evaluation; only 3 would have been recorded under the old rules. An NRC rule effective 22 November 1999 made Appendix VIII mandatory, phased in over three years.

    LessonFollowing a written procedure does not show that a team can find flaws; testing the people, equipment and procedure together on flawed samples does.

    govinfo.govgovinfo.gov

    Credit

    ASME Section XI committee; the Performance Demonstration Initiative and EPRI; the US Nuclear Regulatory Commission

  4. 1999

    Sound sent along pipes

    Guided wave testing sends sound along the wall of a pipe, so that one transducer position screens a long stretch of pipe for corrosion. Conventional ultrasound checks only the steel directly under the probe. Research at Imperial College London began in the early 1990s, with European Commission Thermie funding from 1994, and the spin-out company Guided Ultrasonics Ltd was formed in 1999. In 2011 the British Standards Institution (BS 9690) and ASTM (E2775) published standards for the method. Imperial's impact case study for the UK's 2014 research assessment counted over 300 systems in service worldwide.

    impact.ref.ac.uk

    Credit

    Peter Cawley and Michael Lowe, Imperial College London; Guided Ultrasonics Ltd

  5. 2012

    An unexpected find at Doel

    During a 2012 outage at Doel 3, a nuclear reactor in Belgium, an ultrasonic inspection of the reactor vessel looked for underclad cracks, cracks just beneath its stainless steel lining. It found none, but it found a large number of "quasilaminar indications", flat flaws lying roughly parallel to the wall, in the vessel's upper and lower core shells. Similar flaws turned up at Tihange 2. Both reactors stopped, restarted in June 2013, and stopped again in March 2014 after unexpected results from further tests. On 17 November 2015 the regulator, FANC, allowed them to restart, saying that the flaws, which it called hydrogen flakes, had no "unacceptable impact" on safety.

    LessonAn inspection can turn up a kind of flaw it was not designed to look for, and proving such flaws harmless can keep a plant shut for years.

    nucnet.org

    Credit

    Electrabel, the owner; Belgium's Federal Agency for Nuclear Control (FANC)

  6. 2021

    Cracks dismissed as spurious

    At the end of 2021 EDF found stress corrosion cracking, cracks grown by stress in a corrosive setting, near welds in the safety injection pipes of Civaux 1, a reactor in France, and cut out pipe sections for laboratory analysis. When EDF reviewed earlier inspections across its fleet, it found ultrasonic indications that had been "classified as spurious, but which could in fact correspond to" stress corrosion, in the words of the regulator, ASN. EDF developed a new ultrasonic method to detect these cracks and estimate their depth, for use from the second half of 2022. By July 2022 the checks had closed 12 reactors for investigation or repair, by World Nuclear News' count, and on 26 July 2022 ASN judged EDF's inspection strategy appropriate.

    LessonA procedure tuned for one kind of damage can explain away the signals of another.

    regulation-oversight.asnr.frregulation-oversight.asnr.frworld-nuclear-news.org

    Credit

    EDF; France's nuclear safety authority, ASN

Watch for

  1. Robot scans inside risers

    Engineers at the ROSEN Group describe a robot, pulled on a tether into liquid-filled pipelines that ordinary inspection pigs cannot pass, such as the risers that hang from offshore platforms. It carries phased array probes that record full matrix capture data, every combination of sending and receiving element, and turns the data into images by the total focusing method, which focuses the sound at every point in the weld. On 10-inch and 18-inch test spools with machined notches and manufactured weld flaws, they report depth errors mostly under a millimeter.

    Achieved whenan operator publishes results from a riser inspected in service, with the robot's crack calls checked by another method or by cutting.

    pgjonline.com

    Claimed by

    Markus Ginten and three ROSEN colleagues, in Pipeline & Gas Journal, June 2026

  2. Plane waves instead of X-rays

    An article on the news page of BINDT, the British NDT institute, drawing on Eddyfi Technologies' products, argues that plane wave imaging, which sends one broad pulse across the whole region instead of firing each element in turn, makes ultrasound a full replacement for X-ray pictures of welds when combined with the total focusing method. It says data collection is three to five times faster than with full matrix capture.

    Achieved whenan independent comparison on the same welds, with flaws confirmed by cutting, shows plane wave imaging finding at least as many rejectable flaws as radiography.

    bindt.org

    Claimed by

    Eddyfi Technologies, via BINDT, March 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Teach a cobot the scan

    A robot arm that learns a manual contact ultrasonic scan from a few human demonstrations: moving an angle probe back and forth along a weld in a raster pattern, pressed flat on a film of couplant gel, on test plates it has not seen before. Score it against a certified technician who scans the same plates.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Guided waves on scrapped pipe

    An open set of guided wave recordings taken on retired, corroded steel pipe spools, each spool then cut open and its inner wall scanned in 3D, so the true wall loss behind every signal is known. Add a script that scores anyone's corrosion calls, by a person or by software, against the true loss.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Teach a cobot the scan

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A robot arm that learns a manual contact ultrasonic scan from a few human demonstrations: moving an angle probe back and forth along a weld in a raster pattern, pressed flat on a film of couplant gel, on test plates it has not seen before. Score it against a certified technician who scans the same plates.

Why it is still open

TWI's core research project on cobots for ultrasonic testing of unknown shapes steers the robot from force and ultrasonic feedback with goal-oriented planning, not from demonstrations. Learning how hard to press a probe from experts' demonstrations has been shown in medicine: a 2024 study recorded sonographers' force and position and had a robot repeat their vein scans on models and volunteers. Searches of arXiv and the web in November 2026 found no published test of a robot that learned an industrial ultrasonic scan from demonstrations and was scored against a person.

twi-global.comarxiv.org

Built with what exists

A cobot with a force-torque sensor, such as a Universal Robots UR5e; Hugging Face's LeRobot software to record demonstrations and train (see the Note "No download"); NVIDIA's GR00T 2 robot model, which NVIDIA says reaches 95% success after five demonstrations of a task (see the Note "Five demonstrations per task"), or Runway's openly released Praxis-1 (see the Note "Open robot model weights"); a portable ultrasonic flaw detector with a wheel encoder that logs where the probe was; flawed weld training plates of the kind NDT schools buy.

  1. First step

    Book a week on a university's cobot, record ten demonstrations of a raster scan over a flat steel plate with an unpowered probe, and train a first policy with LeRobot.

  2. Done looks like

    20 filmed scans on five plates the robot has not seen, with three figures published beside the same figures for a Level 2 technician on the same plates: the share of the required area covered, the share of the scan with good contact, and the planted flaws found.

Open 02 · the brief

Guided waves on scrapped pipe

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An open set of guided wave recordings taken on retired, corroded steel pipe spools, each spool then cut open and its inner wall scanned in 3D, so the true wall loss behind every signal is known. Add a script that scores anyone's corrosion calls, by a person or by software, against the true loss.

Why it is still open

Guided wave testing is a screening method, valued for covering a large area from one position, and the inspector decides from its echoes which stretches to check with other methods. The public guided wave data found on Zenodo in November 2026 covers wave losses in buried and concrete-embedded pipe (Imperial College, 2015 and 2016) and corrosion pits grown on a steel plate (the COQTEL set, 2024), not screening calls on real corroded pipe checked against the opened wall. A joint industry project run by HOIS held blind trials of electromagnetic methods for corrosion under insulation on test pipes, but published its findings as guidance documents, not data. TWI's own blind trials of the method, reported by Peter Mudge and Julian Speck in 2004, found every flaw at or above the usual reporting level of 9% of the pipe wall's cross-section, and published the results only as a plot.

impact.ref.ac.ukzenodo.orgzenodo.orgzenodo.orgnetzerotc.comtwi-global.com

Built with what exists

Corroded spools from plant demolition contractors or scrap dealers; a guided wave system such as Guided Ultrasonics' Wavemaker G5, rented with a certified operator; a band saw; a handheld structured-light 3D scanner for the cut inner walls; Python to line up each signal with the scanned wall.

  1. First step

    Ask a demolition contractor or scrap dealer for five corroded spools 6 to 12 inches across, and price a one-day guided wave test with an inspection company.

  2. Done looks like

    30 spools and at least 100 mapped areas of wall loss released under an open license, with raw recordings and 3D scans, and the operator's hit rate and false calls published for two wall-loss thresholds stated before the cutting.