BRENNEN

Industries / Media, arts and recreation / Media and entertainment / Music recording

Rights and royalties

Rights and royalties is the work of recording who owns each song and each recording, licensing their use, and sending the money from every play, copy and stream back to the writers, artists, labels and publishers.

7

Milestones achieved, from 1851 to 2026.

3

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1851

    Composers form a collecting society

    In 1847 the composer Ernest Bourget sued a Paris café-concert that played his songs without paying him, and the courts ruled for him; appeals in 1848 and 1849 confirmed a "performing right", the right to be paid when a work is played in public. Because one writer could not watch every venue, French writers and publishers set up SACEM in 1851 to license the right and collect the money for all of them. CISAC, the world body of these societies, calls SACEM the first collective management organization in music. By CISAC's count, its 228 member societies in 111 countries collected €14.06 billion for music creators in 2025.

    Lessona right enforced one café at a time did not pay; pooling rights did.

    cisac.orgsacem.lumusicweek.com

    Credit

    Ernest Bourget, lyricist Paul Henrion and publisher Victor Parizot; SACEM

  2. 1909

    A set rate for records

    In 1908 the US Supreme Court held that piano rolls were not "copies" of a song, so roll makers owed composers nothing. Congress answered in the 1909 Copyright Act: it gave composers control over "mechanical" copies such as rolls and records, and created the first compulsory licence in US copyright law, under which anyone could record a song without asking by paying a set rate of 2 cents a copy.

    Lessona rate written into law can stand still for generations; by the US Copyright Office's account the 2-cent rate held until the 1976 Act raised it to 2.75 cents.

    copyright.govcopyright.gov

    Credit

    the US Congress, answering White-Smith Music Publishing Co. v. Apollo Co.

  3. 1961

    Performers and labels gain rights

    The Rome Convention gave performers and record producers "neighbouring rights", rights next to copyright that belong to the people who perform and record a song rather than those who write it. They include a single "equitable remuneration", a fair payment, when a commercial record is broadcast or played to the public, though WIPO notes that countries may opt out of that rule or limit it.

    Lessonthese rights are still not universal; WIPO lists 100 member countries, and the United States is not one of them.

    wipo.intwipo.int

    Credit

    the states that signed at Rome on 26 October 1961; WIPO, with the ILO and UNESCO

  4. 1986

    Every recording gets a code

    The standards body ISO adopted the International Standard Recording Code (ISRC, ISO 3901), a 12-character code that stays with a recording across services and borders. IFPI, the record industry's international body, has recommended it since 1988 and has run the system for ISO since 1989, and its database now holds over 150 million codes.

    Lessonan ISRC names the recording, not the song on it; the song has its own code, the ISWC, run by CISAC, and someone has to link the two.

    cott.org.ttisrc.ifpi.org

    Credit

    ISO; IFPI

  5. 2014

    The global song database collapses

    The Global Repertoire Database was meant to be one shared record of who owns which songs worldwide. It collapsed in July 2014 after participants had invested £8 million, when societies including ASCAP, SOCAN, PRS for Music, SACEM and SGAE pulled their future funding, with rival projects already under way, by Music Ally's account.

    Lessona shared registry fails when its funders leave; PRS said it still backed "a single point of works registration".

    musically.com

    Credit

    the participating collecting societies

  6. 2021

    A home for unmatched royalties

    The US Music Modernization Act of 2018 created the Mechanical Licensing Collective (The MLC), which began running a blanket licence for streaming services in January 2021. It then received US$424.4 million from 20 services in "black box" royalties, money the services could not pay because they did not know who owned the song. The MLC says that by September 2026 it had paid out nearly US$239 million of that money and more than US$4.2 billion in all, and in June 2026 the US Register of Copyrights renewed its appointment after its first five-year review.

    Lessonmatching shrinks the black box but does not empty it; by its own count The MLC still held about US$328.2 million in unmatched royalties in early 2026, 7.8% of what it had processed.

    themlc.comthemlc.compages.themlc.com

    Credit

    the US Congress; The MLC; the US Copyright Office

  7. 2026

    Prison for fake streams

    In March 2026 Michael Smith of North Carolina pleaded guilty to conspiracy to commit wire fraud. From 2017 to 2024 he used bot accounts to stream hundreds of thousands of AI-generated songs billions of times and collected more than US$8 million in royalties. In October 2026 Judge John G. Koeltl sentenced him to 18 months in prison and ordered him to repay almost US$8.1 million; WUNC calls it the first-ever federal criminal case of music streaming fraud.

    Lessonstreaming services pay from a shared pool, so fake plays take money from real artists; Smith spread his plays thinly over thousands of tracks, the tactic Spotify says its April 2024 rule against paying recording royalties on tracks under 1,000 streams a year was meant to stop.

    wunc.orgtherecord.mediaartists.spotify.com

    Credit

    the US Attorney's Office for the Southern District of New York; Judge John G. Koeltl

Watch for

  1. Tangled links on classic hits

    AIMi Labs ran its AI rights-research tool on The MLC's public data and reports that 56 of 111 tracks (50.5%) from ten of the best-selling albums of all time were tied to more than one song record, even though recorded ownership shares averaged 99.3% complete. It says it cannot tell whether any wrong payments resulted.

    Achieved whensomeone outside AIMi re-runs the check on the same 111 tracks and publishes a matching count, or AIMi publishes its track list and method openly; the paper is behind an email sign-up.

    hypebot.com

    Claimed by

    AIMi Labs, in the white paper "Who's Eating Your Lunch?", October 2026

  2. Song codes attached at release

    CISAC says its pilot to attach each song's ISWC to the recording's ISRC when the recording is released moved into a soft launch with selected record labels in 2025, after a PRS for Music proof of concept and tests with partners in 2024, and that a wider rollout is expected.

    Achieved whenan outside party, such as a streaming service, The MLC or a government study, reports the share of new releases that arrive carrying an ISWC. The baseline, from a study the UK IPO published in April 2026: fewer than 0.1% of recordings arrived with one.

    ciamcreators.orggov.uk

    Claimed by

    CISAC, May 2025

  3. Leftover song money, shared out

    The MLC says it will start "market share" distributions with its April 2027 payout: royalties for 2021 that it still cannot match, or that no owner has claimed, will be paid one month at a time, with interest, to the songs that earned royalties from the same service and plan that month, in proportion to what each earned. It says less than US$7 million remains for January 2021.

    Achieved whenthe April 2027 distribution is paid, and an outside party such as the US Copyright Office, an auditor or reporters reading members' statements confirms the amounts.

    themlc.compages.themlc.com

    Claimed by

    The MLC, September 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Measure public song–recording links

    A hand-checked audit of the free public links between recordings (ISRC) and songs (ISWC). Draw a random sample of 500 ISRCs; for each, record which song it is linked to in MusicBrainz, credits.fm and The MLC's public database; check each link by hand against the song's title and writers, with their IPI numbers (the ID a society gives each writer and publisher) where shown; and publish, for each source, precision (the share of links that are right), coverage (the share of ISRCs with any link) and every disagreement.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Count Europe's unpaid royalties

    An open table of money that European collecting societies hold but have not paid out, taken from their own annual transparency reports. For each society and year, record three figures: money collected but not yet assigned to anyone, money assigned but not yet paid, and "non-distributable" money, for which no owner was found within three years. Give each with its page reference and as a share of that society's collections.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Measure public song–recording links

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A hand-checked audit of the free public links between recordings (ISRC) and songs (ISWC). Draw a random sample of 500 ISRCs; for each, record which song it is linked to in MusicBrainz, credits.fm and The MLC's public database; check each link by hand against the song's title and writers, with their IPI numbers (the ID a society gives each writer and publisher) where shown; and publish, for each source, precision (the share of links that are right), coverage (the share of ISRCs with any link) and every disagreement.

Why it is still open

Linking recordings to songs is the known weak point. The study the UK IPO published in April 2026 found that ISRC–ISWC matching "ranged from 0% to 85%, depending on source", and that less than 0.1% of recordings reached streaming services already linked to an ISWC. Open link tables exist, but none found publishes a measured error rate: credits.fm marks a link "Verified" when two sources agree and gives no accuracy figures, BMAT researchers published a synthetic benchmark rather than a check of real public links, and Luminate's WorksMatch is a paid service.

gov.ukcredits.fm

Built with what exists

MusicBrainz database downloads (core data CC0, public domain), including its links between works and recordings; credits.fm; The MLC's public API or bulk download, whose terms allow use "for any legal purpose" but bar scraping its website; CISAC's public ISWC lookup; a spreadsheet set up for two people to check blind. Optionally, Gemini Decision 1 to sort candidate pairs before the hand check (see the Note "A thousand questions, one pass") and Claude to review rows the checkers dispute (see the Note "Seven more flagged"); people make every published verdict.

  1. First step

    Download the latest MusicBrainz dump, draw 500 random recordings that carry an ISRC, and hand-check the first 50 to settle what counts as "the right song" for covers, remixes and medleys.

  2. Done looks like

    500 ISRCs, each judged by two independent checkers; precision and coverage for each source with 95% confidence intervals; the agreement rate between the checkers; the sheet and the sampling script published under CC0.

Open 02 · the brief

Count Europe's unpaid royalties

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An open table of money that European collecting societies hold but have not paid out, taken from their own annual transparency reports. For each society and year, record three figures: money collected but not yet assigned to anyone, money assigned but not yet paid, and "non-distributable" money, for which no owner was found within three years. Give each with its page reference and as a share of that society's collections.

Why it is still open

EU law requires every collecting society to publish these three figures each year, within eight months of the year's end, and keep them online for five years (Directive 2014/26/EU, Article 22 and Annex). The European Commission's 2021 review of the law relied on a survey instead of totals: "less than half" of the societies surveyed said they paid out more than 90% of the money due within the nine months the law allows. CISAC's Global Collections Report counts money collected, and its 2025 edition gives no figures on undistributed or unmatched money. No compiled table was found.

eur-lex.europa.euparlament.gv.atteosto.fi

Built with what exists

The societies' published transparency reports (PDF); pdftotext, from the Poppler tools, to pull out the text; Claude to suggest each figure with its page number, with a person checking every figure (see the Note "Seven more flagged"); a spreadsheet; one stated source for exchange rates.

  1. First step

    Download the 2024 transparency reports of five large societies, for example SACEM, GEMA, SIAE, SGAE and STIM, copy out the three figures by hand, and note how each report labels them.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 25 EU music societies covered for financial year 2024, every figure linked to its report and page, 10% of figures re-keyed by a second person with no differences left unresolved, a published total and an openly licensed CSV, and a list of societies whose reports leave out any of the three figures.