BRENNEN

Industries / Media, arts and recreation / Media and entertainment / Music recording

Recording

Recording means capturing a performance as a sound recording, on machines and media from tinfoil and tape to computer files, and then keeping the master copies safe and playable.

7

Milestones achieved, from 1877 to 2020.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1877

    Edison's machine plays sound back

    Thomas Edison's tinfoil phonograph recorded sound and played it back; the US National Park Service calls it "the first machine to both record sounds and play them back". Édouard-Léon Scott de Martinville had recorded sound as visible traces since his 1857 patent, but he did not mean them to be heard.

    Lessonin 2008 Carl Haber and Earl Cornell at Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory turned an 1860 Scott trace into sound, and First Sounds says the 250 Hz tuning-fork traces Scott recorded beside his voice let it correct his uneven hand-cranked speed, so a reference tone kept with a recording lets later people repair it.

    nps.govnps.govfirstsounds.org

    Credit

    Thomas Edison and his mechanic John Kruesi, Menlo Park, New Jersey

  2. 1925

    Microphones replace the horn

    Before 1925, musicians played into a large horn that drove a cutting needle, which the Birthplace of Country Music museum says captured 100 to 2,500 Hz. The electrical system from Bell Labs and Western Electric used microphones and valve amplifiers, and the museum says it widened the range to 60 to 6,000 Hz. Columbia and Victor both signed for it in 1925, and the lighter gear let labels record away from their studios, in places such as Bristol, Tennessee.

    LessonColumbia's own electrical trials in 1920 and 1921 "were disappointing", by the account of the Discography of American Historical Recordings at UC Santa Barbara.

    adp.library.ucsb.edubirthplaceofcountrymusic.org

    Credit

    Bell Labs and Western Electric engineers; Columbia and Victor as the first licensees

  3. 1948

    Tape makes recordings editable

    BASF says AEG showed a tape recorder to the public in 1935, using BASF tape. After the war John (Jack) Mullin brought two German Magnetophon recorders to the US, and Ampex built its Model 200A from them. Units 1 and 2 arrived in April 1948 to record and edit Bing Crosby's radio show; Mix gives the 200A's response as flat within 0.5 dB from 30 Hz to 15 kHz, and its price as US$4,000.

    Lessonthe IEEE history site says cutting small mistakes out of the tape left short gaps, which Crosby's team filled with recorded laughter, so editing brought new problems of its own.

    ethw.orgmixonline.combasf.com

    Credit

    AEG and BASF; Jack Mullin; Ampex; Bing Crosby, who sent Ampex US$50,000

  4. 1955

    One machine, eight tracks

    Les Paul had layered parts by "sound-on-sound" since 1949, copying the whole recording again with each new part, so one bad pass ruined everything and each pass added noise. Ampex's Sel-Sync let the record head also play back in step with the tape, so a musician could add one track while hearing the others. Mix says the first Sel-Sync machine, a 1-inch 8-track, was sold to Paul for US$10,000.

    LessonSnyder expected "a few dozen at the absolute most" buyers, and Ampex never patented the idea after its lawyer called it "obvious".

    mixonline.com

    Credit

    Ross Snyder, who had the idea; Mort Fujii and Ampex engineers; Les Paul

  5. 1991

    Recording moves into the computer

    Digidesign's Pro Tools put multitrack recording, editing and mixing on a Mac with a hard disk. Mix says the first systems had 4 to 16 inputs and outputs and cost from US$5,995, not counting the computer.

    Lessonthe session file holds every edit, and its format is closed; the Library of Congress rates its disclosure "Poor" and says no information about its structure is public.

    mixonline.comloc.gov

    Credit

    Digidesign, founded by Evan Brooks and Peter Gotcher

  6. 2008

    Fire destroys a master vault

    In June 2008 a fire on the Universal Studios Hollywood backlot burned a warehouse where Universal Music Group (UMG) kept master recordings. In June 2019 Jody Rosen's New York Times Magazine investigation put the loss at 120,000 to 175,000 masters, and reported that a confidential UMG report from 2009 counted about 500,000 song titles lost. UMG disputed the story, and its archive chief, Patrick Kraus, said some masters named as destroyed were in its archives.

    Lessonthe vault's inventory was kept on 5-by-7-inch cards, so nobody could count the loss exactly; the Recording Academy's delivery guide repeats the rule "If you keep it in three places, you own it.".

    npr.orgclaimsjournal.commedia.grammy.net

    Credit

    reported by Jody Rosen, New York Times Magazine

  7. 2020

    A bedroom album wins Grammys

    Mix reports that Billie Eilish's "When We All Fall Asleep, Where Do We Go?" was recorded in her brother Finneas O'Connell's bedroom at the family home, on Logic Pro X, a Universal Audio Apollo 8 interface and Yamaha HS5 speakers. It won the 2020 Grammys for Album of the Year and Best Engineered Album, Non-Classical.

    Lessona home room still has its own sound; Finneas said everything left the bedroom "with too much bass", and the mixer evened it out.

    mixonline.comgrammy.comgrammy.com

    Credit

    Finneas O'Connell and Rob Kinelski (engineers), John Greenham (mastering engineer), Billie Eilish

Watch for

  1. Earbuds as vocal microphones

    Apple says a software update for AirPods 4 and AirPods Pro 2 lets "singers, and other creators" "record studio-quality vocals on the go", including in noisy places, using its H2 chip, beamforming microphones and "computational audio". Apple said it would ship free with iOS 26 in autumn 2025. It published no measurements, and no independent lab test was found.

    Achieved whenan independent lab or audio magazine measures AirPods vocal recordings against a standard studio vocal microphone, for frequency response, noise and distortion, and finds them comparable.

    apple.com

    Claimed by

    Apple, June 2025

  2. Glass for 10,000-year masters

    Microsoft Research reported in Nature that data written by laser into ordinary borosilicate glass "should remain intact for at least 10,000 years", a figure taken from accelerated ageing tests. Microsoft lists a proof of concept with Global Music Vault "to preserve music under ice", says "The research phase is now complete", and announces no product.

    Achieved whena music archive or label keeps master recordings on glass as routine practice, and an outside party reads a stored master back bit for bit.

    microsoft.com

    Claimed by

    Microsoft Research (Project Silica), February 2026

Open

  1. 01

    Test tape-transfer error detectors

    An openly licensed test set of tape transfers in which every fault is known and logged by hand: wrong playback speed, wrong equalization (the treble and bass correction each tape standard needs), sections played in reverse, dropouts, and a tilted playback head. Add a scoring script, and publish scores for the MPAI CAE-ARP Audio Analyzer and at least one other method.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Read old Pro Tools sessions

    A batch tool, built on the free ptformat library, that reads Pro Tools session files (.pts,.ptf,.ptx) and writes one continuous Broadcast Wave file (BWF, a WAV file stamped with its start time) per track, with every clip at its original position, plus a plain-text edit list and optionally a DAWproject file. Publish a tally of how well it works across Pro Tools versions.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Test tape-transfer error detectors

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An openly licensed test set of tape transfers in which every fault is known and logged by hand: wrong playback speed, wrong equalization (the treble and bass correction each tape standard needs), sections played in reverse, dropouts, and a tilted playback head. Add a scoring script, and publish scores for the MPAI CAE-ARP Audio Analyzer and at least one other method.

Why it is still open

The software exists but has been tested only by its makers, on small samples. Its developers say the analyzer "combines AI techniques with traditional analytical algorithms to automatically detect common digitization errors, such as misinterpretations of the original equalization and speed variations". MPAI's own test plan calls for 5 to 10 files, and the University of Padua team's 2024 test used four tapes totalling 63 minutes, writing that large labelled datasets "are difficult to obtain". No independent published score was found. UNESCO and IASA, the sound archives association, estimated that routine transfer of magnetic tape would end "around 2025", as machines and skills run out.

mpai.communityceur-ws.orgiasa-web.org

Built with what exists

Your own recordings dubbed to open-reel or cassette tape on a working deck; the MPAI CAE-ARP reference software (IEEE standard 3302-2022), whose machine-learning classifiers are the advance that makes automatic checking possible; MPAI's JSON "Irregularity File" format for the labels; SoX for scripted speed changes; the Padua tape-video dataset on Zenodo (DOI 10.5281/zenodo.14028922).

  1. First step

    Record 10 minutes of your own playing to tape, transfer it once correctly and again at the wrong speed and with the wrong equalization, log each change by hand, and run the MPAI Audio Analyzer on the files.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 100 transfer files, 10 hours or more, with at least 300 time-stamped faults across five fault types, released under an open licence; precision (the share of flags that are real faults) and recall (the share of real faults flagged) for each method and fault type, set against MPAI's own pass mark of 0.9 on both.

Open 02 · the brief

Read old Pro Tools sessions

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A batch tool, built on the free ptformat library, that reads Pro Tools session files (.pts,.ptf,.ptx) and writes one continuous Broadcast Wave file (BWF, a WAV file stamped with its start time) per track, with every clip at its original position, plus a plain-text edit list and optionally a DAWproject file. Publish a tally of how well it works across Pro Tools versions.

Why it is still open

The Library of Congress says "No information about the structure of proprietary Pro Tools session files is publicly available." The Recording Academy's guide asks engineers to consolidate every track to BWF because "digital formats change", so a session that was never consolidated keeps its edits only in the session file. ptformat's own table shows gaps, such as no support for grouped clips in Pro Tools 10 to 12, and the Ardour manual says its Pro Tools import works "with varying degrees of success". No published tally of how many old sessions open correctly was found.

loc.govgithub.commanual.ardour.org

Built with what exists

ptformat (C++, LGPL-2.1) and its ptftool; Ardour's "Import PT Session" as a cross-check; SoX or FFmpeg to render tracks; DAWproject (MIT licence, read by Bitwig Studio 5.0.9, Studio One 6.5 and Cubase 14) as an open target format.

  1. First step

    Build ptformat, run ptftool on the test sessions in its repository and on five of your own sessions, and write down which fields come out for each version. Use only your own sessions, or ones whose owners agree in writing.

  2. Done looks like

    A public table of at least 50 sessions from at least six Pro Tools versions, with one row per session: tracks and clips found, tracks rendered, and whether each rendered track cancels to silence against a render made in Pro Tools or Ardour (a "null test"), with timing within one sample. Release the code and send the findings to the Library of Congress format page, which invites comments.