BRENNEN

Industries / Transport and vehicles / Trucking and freight / Moving and storage

Damage and claims

Damage and claims is what happens when goods arrive broken or do not arrive: who is liable, for how much, and how the owner gets paid or settles a dispute.

6

Milestones achieved, from 1906 to 2023.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1906

    One federal rule for loss

    The Carmack amendment, section 20 of the Hepburn Act of 29 June 1906, made a carrier's liability for loss or damage on shipments between US states a matter of federal law, in place of differing state laws. In 1913 the Supreme Court, in Adams Express Co. v. Croninger, applied it to a diamond ring sent from Cincinnati to Augusta, Georgia, that was never delivered. The receipt limited the express company's liability to $50 unless a higher value was declared, and the Court held that a carrier may limit what it pays to an agreed value in return for a lower rate. The same rule, now 49 U.S.C. 14706, holds carriers, movers among them, liable for "the actual loss or injury to the property."

    LessonA lower price in return for a lower payout is lawful when the customer openly agrees to it, which is the root of the cheap "released value" option movers still offer.

    govinfo.govlaw.cornell.edu

    Credit

    US Congress; US Supreme Court

  2. 1995

    Arbitration for moving disputes

    A federal law of December 1995 (Public Law 104-88) requires every interstate household-goods mover to offer customers neutral arbitration for disputes over loss and damage. The mover may not require it before a dispute arises or charge the customer more than half the cost of starting it, and the arbitrator must decide within 60 days. Arbitration is binding if the customer asks for it on a claim up to a limit, set at $1,000, raised to $5,000 in 1999 and to $10,000 in 2005. Before that stage, separate federal claims rules require a carrier to acknowledge a written claim within 30 days and to pay, decline or make a firm offer within 120 days.

    law.cornell.eduecfr.govecfr.gov

    Credit

    US Congress; FMCSA, which enforces the rules

  3. 2005

    Full value by default

    A transport law signed on 10 August 2005 (SAFETEA-LU, Public Law 109-59) made a mover liable for the full value of household goods, meaning their replacement value, up to the value declared for the shipment. The cheaper option, which the Interstate Commerce Commission and its successor, the Surface Transportation Board (STB), had let movers offer, pays 60 cents per pound per article, and since 2005 it applies only if the customer waives full value in writing. By the STB's own example, a lost 10-pound article is worth $6.00 under that option.

    law.cornell.edustb.gov

    Credit

    US Congress; Surface Transportation Board

  4. 2008

    UK code with an ombudsman

    The consumer code of practice of the British Association of Removers (BAR), the UK removals trade body, was approved in 2008 under the Consumer Codes Approval Scheme, now run by the Chartered Trading Standards Institute (CTSI). Under the 2022 version of the code, members must acknowledge a complaint within 3 working days and try to resolve it within 8 weeks; after that the customer may take the dispute to the Furniture and Home Improvement Ombudsman, whose award binds the member but not the customer. For goods taken into storage, members must give a detailed inventory or receipt and keep each lot protected "from damage, pilferage and confusion with other consignments." CTSI's June 2026 audit counted 354 members and found the code working.

    approvedcode.tradingstandards.uktradingstandards.ukapprovedcode.tradingstandards.uk

    Credit

    British Association of Removers; CTSI

  5. 2012

    The warning moves earlier

    The STB found that "consumers do not always realize that they have arranged a move under the 60-cents option until they experience damage to or loss of their goods," and a consultant told it that most household-goods arbitration cases were of that kind. In January 2011 it required movers to describe the two liability options on the written estimate, the first form a customer gets, instead of only on later forms, and in January 2012 it adjusted that requirement. It also raised the default full value, used when a customer picks full value but declares no figure, to the higher of $6.00 per pound of shipment weight or $6,000, from $4.00 per pound and $5,000.

    LessonA choice signed on a later form is easy to miss; the warning has to come with the price.

    stb.gov

    Credit

    Surface Transportation Board

  6. 2023

    Complaint records found wanting

    The US Government Accountability Office (GAO) reviewed the National Consumer Complaint Database, where FMCSA collects complaints about truck, bus and moving companies. It reported in September 2023 that FMCSA published "some but not all" of its complaint data, sorted complaints into seven categories without defining key terms or linking them to more than 100 possible allegations, and had no outreach plan to make the site known. GAO made 14 recommendations; by GAO's tracking, 4 have been carried out, including publishing data on all complaint categories, and 10 remain open.

    LessonComplaints that are not sorted the same way each time cannot show which problems are growing.

    gao.gov

    Credit

    GAO

Watch for

  1. Before-and-after video for claims

    Graebel, a relocation company, and Yembo, which makes AI software for surveying a home's contents, say their new claims system links a damage claim to the video taken in the pre-move survey. The customer films the item at delivery through a text-message link, and the claims team sees "before" and "after" video of the same item side by side. They call it "industry-first" and give no figures for speed or accuracy.

    Achieved whenan outside party measures claim times or dispute rates with and without the system, or tests how often the side-by-side view settles a claim correctly.

    graebel.com

    Claimed by

    Graebel and Yembo, February 2026

  2. New UK removal terms

    BAR has written revised model terms and conditions for its members' contracts. CTSI's June 2026 audit says members have until October 2026 to adopt them, or terms BAR judges equivalent, and that failing to do so will then be recorded as a non-conformance. The audit does not say what the new terms change.

    Achieved whenCTSI's next audit reports how many members have adopted the terms.

    approvedcode.tradingstandards.uk

    Claimed by

    BAR, reported by CTSI, June 2026

Open

  1. 01

    A before-and-after damage test

    A public set of paired photos of furniture taken before and after a staged move, where some pairs show new damage made on purpose on second-hand pieces (scratches, dents, chips, torn fabric) and some show none. Then publish how often open AI vision models, and any commercial tool that agrees to be tested, spot the new damage and point to where it is.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Test the valuation wording

    A test of whether people understand the choice between full-value protection and the 60-cents-per-pound option when they read the wording movers use, run against two plain-language rewrites.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

A before-and-after damage test

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public set of paired photos of furniture taken before and after a staged move, where some pairs show new damage made on purpose on second-hand pieces (scratches, dents, chips, torn fabric) and some show none. Then publish how often open AI vision models, and any commercial tool that agrees to be tested, spot the new damage and point to where it is.

Why it is still open

Graebel and Yembo's February 2026 system puts the before and after video side by side for a person to judge, and publishes no accuracy figures. Public furniture-damage projects on GitHub, such as FurniScanAI, look for damage in a single photo and publish no test on before-and-after pairs. The nearest research set, Fantastic Breaks (Nikolas Lamb and colleagues, CVPR 2023), pairs 3D scans of 150 broken objects with whole counterparts for shape-repair research, not photos of new scratches and dents. This research found no public paired photo set.

graebel.comgithub.comarxiv.org

Built with what exists

Phone cameras on a tripod with fixed lighting; second-hand furniture; CVAT, an open-source labeling tool, to mark each damaged area; open vision models such as Qwen-VL; a service that scores yes-or-no questions about an image, such as Gemini Decision 1 (see the Note "A thousand questions, one pass").

  1. First step

    Buy ten second-hand pieces, photograph each from six fixed angles, add one measured scratch or dent to five of them, photograph them again, and score one open model on the 60 pairs.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 1,000 photo pairs of at least 100 items, half with new damage of measured size, released under an open license, with a table of hits and false alarms for at least three models by damage type and size.

Open 02 · the brief

Test the valuation wording

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A test of whether people understand the choice between full-value protection and the 60-cents-per-pound option when they read the wording movers use, run against two plain-language rewrites.

Why it is still open

The STB moved the warning onto the estimate in 2011 and 2012 because customers did not realize what they had chosen, but its decision cites no test of whether readers understand the new wording. FMCSA's 2022 rule, which put an updated consumer booklet in place and required movers to hand it over with the estimate, reports no reader testing either. This research found no published comprehension study, only movers' blog posts.

stb.govfederalregister.gov

Built with what exists

An online survey platform that pays volunteer participants, such as Prolific; the valuation wording from the STB decision; a language model to draft rewrites, checked by a person; R or Python for the statistics.

  1. First step

    Copy the current valuation wording, write the five questions and their answers, and run a 30-person pilot.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 600 adults, split at random among the current wording and two rewrites, answer five questions with known answers, such as the most a customer receives under the 60-cents option for a destroyed 50-pound television ($30). The share answering correctly under each wording is published with the questions and the raw data.