BRENNEN

Industries / Technology / Marketplaces and gig platforms

Holding and paying out money

A marketplace takes the buyer's payment, holds it until the sale or the job is done, keeps its fee, pays the rest to the seller or freelancer, and in many countries collects the tax on the sale.

5

Milestones achieved, from 2002 to 2021.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 2002

    Sellers pick the payment tool

    PayPal, launched in October 1999, let anyone with an email address send money, and eBay sellers took it up ahead of eBay's own service, Billpoint. By 30 September 2001, 69.4% of eBay auctions accepted PayPal against 29.5% for Billpoint, and online auctions, mainly on eBay, made up 68.3% of PayPal's payment volume, by PayPal's own count in its filing to the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). eBay bought PayPal on 3 October 2002 in an exchange of shares and said it would close Billpoint in the first half of 2003.

    LessonA marketplace's own payment service can lose to an outside one that its buyers and sellers already prefer.

    sec.govsec.gov

    Credit

    Confinity (Peter Thiel, its chief executive, and Max Levchin, its chief technology officer), which merged with X.com in March 2000; eBay

  2. 2004

    Escrow wins trust in China

    Alibaba set up Alipay in December 2004 because, it later told US investors, Chinese buyers would not pay before they had inspected their goods and sellers would not ship before they were sure of payment. Alipay held the buyer's money in escrow, an account that a third party holds for both sides, and released it to the seller only after the buyer confirmed the goods arrived in good condition or let a set time pass without objecting. In the year to 30 June 2014, 78.1% of the value of goods sold on Alibaba's China retail marketplaces was settled through Alipay, and the research firm iResearch ranked Alipay China's largest online payment provider by volume in 2013.

    LessonHolding buyers' money makes a marketplace a payments business; after China's central bank required non-bank payment firms to hold a license in 2010, Alibaba gave up its ownership of Alipay in 2011.

    sec.gov

    Credit

    Alibaba Group; Jonathan Zhaoxi Lu, who led the team that set up Alipay and was its first president

  3. 2015

    Holding money needs a license

    The EU's second Payment Services Directive (PSD2) of 25 November 2015 closed a gap that some marketplaces had used. Payment law did not apply to a "commercial agent" paying on someone's behalf, and some EU countries let e-commerce platforms that acted for both buyer and seller use that exclusion; the directive says this "goes beyond the intended scope" and "has the potential to increase risks for consumers". From 13 January 2018, a platform acting for both sides stays outside payment law only if it never takes possession or control of the money, so one that holds buyers' payments has to be licensed or leave the money to a licensed payment firm.

    legislation.gov.uklegislation.gov.uklegislation.gov.uk

    Credit

    European Parliament and Council of the EU

  4. 2021

    Marketplaces collect the tax

    On 21 June 2018 the US Supreme Court, in South Dakota v. Wayfair, ended the rule that a state could make only sellers with a physical presence in it collect its sales tax. By the count of the sales tax firm TaxJar, every US state with a state sales tax now has a law making marketplaces collect and pay the tax on their third-party sellers' sales. In the EU, from 1 July 2021, a marketplace is treated as if it had bought and resold the goods itself, and so owes the VAT, for imports in parcels worth up to EUR 150 and for sales to consumers by sellers based outside the EU. VAT declared through the EU's one-stop-shop schemes, which marketplaces and other sellers use, came to EUR 33.1 billion in 2024, EUR 6.3 billion of it on imports, by the European Commission's count.

    LessonTax offices found that they could collect more tax from fewer firms by making the platform, not each small seller, responsible for it.

    law.cornell.edutaxjar.comlegislation.gov.ukvat-one-stop-shop.ec.europa.eu

    Credit

    US Supreme Court; US state legislatures; Council of the EU (Directive (EU) 2017/2455)

  5. 2021

    eBay takes over its checkout

    eBay spun off PayPal on 17 July 2015. In 2018 it began handling buyers' payments itself, which it calls managed payments, under a commercial agreement with the payment company Adyen; by the end of 2019 it had processed more than $2.0 billion for nearly 25,000 sellers, and in 2021 it finished the move in all its markets. eBay's net revenue rose 17% to $10.4 billion in 2021, mainly, it said, because of managed payments and a higher take rate, the share of each sale's value that the marketplace keeps. Its losses from chargebacks, payments that card holders dispute and have reversed, rose by $81 million that year as the system grew.

    LessonRunning the checkout raised the share of each sale eBay keeps, and also moved the losses from disputed payments onto eBay.

    sec.govsec.gov

    Credit

    eBay; Adyen

Watch for

  1. Payouts in stablecoins

    Stablecoins are crypto tokens meant to hold a fixed value against a currency such as the dollar. On 12 November 2025 Visa launched a pilot in which US businesses and platforms using Visa Direct, its service for sending money to cards, accounts and wallets, pay in dollars while creators, freelancers and gig workers can choose to receive USDC, Circle's dollar stablecoin, in a compatible wallet. Visa's Chris Newkirk said the aim is access to money "in minutes — not days", and Visa planned a wider rollout in 2026; on 5 August 2026 the firm zerohash said Visa Direct's stablecoin payouts would become available to eligible Visa Direct clients.

    Achieved whenAn outside party, such as a regulator or an independent survey, reports how many marketplace sellers or gig workers are paid this way and how the time and cost compare with bank payouts.

    dlnews.comtheblock.cozerohash.com

    Claimed by

    Visa, November 2025; zerohash with Visa, August 2026

Open

  1. 01

    A table of payout delays

    A public table, checked every month, of when 30 marketplaces and freelance platforms release money to sellers and freelancers, read only from their published terms and help pages. For each platform and country it gives the days from payment or approval to money available, extra holds on new sellers, reserves, holds during disputes, the payout schedule and any fee for faster payout. Each cell links to the clause it comes from, and every change is logged.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Tests for marketplace money

    A public set of 100 money cases a marketplace has to handle, each with the expected entries in a double-entry ledger, a record in which every movement is written once as a debit and once as a credit. Cases include one order split among three sellers, a refund after the seller has been paid out, a milestone approved in part, a dispute lost after payout, a seller whose balance goes below zero and a payout in another currency. A harness runs every case in the test modes of Stripe Connect, Adyen for Platforms and the PayPal sandbox, which move no real money, and publishes which cases each handles as built, which need custom code, and where the ledger fails to balance.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

A table of payout delays

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public table, checked every month, of when 30 marketplaces and freelance platforms release money to sellers and freelancers, read only from their published terms and help pages. For each platform and country it gives the days from payment or approval to money available, extra holds on new sellers, reserves, holds during disputes, the payout schedule and any fee for faster payout. Each cell links to the clause it comes from, and every change is logged.

Why it is still open

Each platform states its rules in its own pages and words. eBay's help page says new private sellers typically get their money 2 days after delivery for items sent with an eBay label, 7 days with another label, or 31 days after the buyer pays when there is no tracking. Upwork's escrow terms add a five-day "security period" after a client approves work, and release fixed-price work if a client does nothing for 14 days. Searches found blog posts on single platforms and a table of resale fees (FLUF-io's), but no table of payout timing across platforms with clause citations.

ebay.comupwork.comgithub.com

Built with what exists

Open Terms Archive's open-source engine, which records each version of a web page of terms; Python and pandas; an AI model to draft each extraction, checked by a person; Browser Use, an open-source browser agent, for pages that need a full browser (Note: "Deleting 80% to start over").

  1. First step

    Write the eight field definitions and fill them by hand for eBay, Etsy, Amazon, Upwork and Fiverr in the US and the UK.

  2. Done looks like

    30 platforms and 8 fields in at least 3 countries, every value linked to its clause, two people agreeing on at least 95% of cells, and six monthly updates with a change log.

Open 02 · the brief

Tests for marketplace money

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public set of 100 money cases a marketplace has to handle, each with the expected entries in a double-entry ledger, a record in which every movement is written once as a debit and once as a credit. Cases include one order split among three sellers, a refund after the seller has been paid out, a milestone approved in part, a dispute lost after payout, a seller whose balance goes below zero and a payout in another currency. A harness runs every case in the test modes of Stripe Connect, Adyen for Platforms and the PayPal sandbox, which move no real money, and publishes which cases each handles as built, which need custom code, and where the ledger fails to balance.

Why it is still open

Providers, and the open-source payments platform Hyperswitch from Juspay, document how splits and refunds work on Stripe Connect and Adyen for Platforms one provider at a time, but searches of the web and GitHub found no public suite that runs the same marketplace cases across providers and reports the results. The risk is real: eBay's chargeback losses rose by $81 million in the year it finished taking over its own payments.

github.comsec.gov

Built with what exists

Stripe's test mode and API; Adyen's test environment; the PayPal sandbox; an open-source ledger such as Formance Ledger or TigerBeetle; pytest.

  1. First step

    Write 20 cases from Upwork's escrow terms and eBay's payment-hold rules and run them in Stripe's test mode.

  2. Done looks like

    100 cases, each run on the three providers, with a results table that anyone can reproduce from the repository with their own test keys, and each failure written up with the steps that cause it.