Industries / Media, arts and recreation / Marinas
Environmental rules
Environmental rules cover what a marina and the boats in it may put into the water, from toilet waste and hull paint to old boats that nobody wants.
7
Milestones achieved, from 1972 to 2019.
2
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1972
Boat toilets come under law
Section 312 of the US Clean Water Act, added on 18 October 1972, told regulators to set standards for marine sanitation devices, the equipment on a boat that holds or treats toilet waste. It also lets a state ban all sewage discharge from boats in named waters, treated or not, once the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) finds there are enough pump-out stations, the shore pumps that empty a boat's holding tank. Such a water is called a no-discharge zone. The earliest dated entries on EPA's list are from January 1976 and include all of Michigan's waters and Newport Bay in California.
LessonA ban on dumping only works where there is somewhere to pump out, so the law ties the two together.
Credit
US Congress; EPA and the US Coast Guard, which carry the section out
1987
Blue Flag spreads across Europe
Blue Flag is a voluntary award for beaches and marinas that meet set criteria on water quality, environmental management, education and safety. It began in France in 1985, and in 1987, the European Year of the Environment, the first sites were awarded in ten European countries. It moved beyond Europe in 2001 and added tourism boats in 2016. Its operator, the Foundation for Environmental Education, says it now runs in more than 50 countries, with national operators, an international jury and visiting controllers.
Credit
Foundation for Environmental Education
1992
A fuel tax funds pump-outs
The US Clean Vessel Act of 1992 lets the Secretary of the Interior give grants to states to build, renovate and run pump-out stations for recreational boats. The money comes from a trust fund fed by excise taxes on fishing equipment and on motorboat and small engine fuels, and a state must put up at least 25 percent of a project's cost. The US Fish and Wildlife Service said in June 2024 that the grants had come to more than $359 million since the first awards in 1993.
Credit
US Congress; US Fish and Wildlife Service; state boating agencies
1999
Maryland certifies clean marinas
A 1990 US law on coastal runoff named marinas as a source of water pollution, and EPA's guidance of January 1993 listed the practices expected of them. Maryland chose not to write new rules. Its Department of Natural Resources wrote a guidebook with marina operators and certified any marina that met the law and adopted enough of the listed practices, with a fresh inspection every three years. Port Annapolis Marina was the first, in January 1999. The department calls Maryland the first state to launch such a program and said in 2020 that a quarter of the state's roughly 600 marinas were certified. The Bay Journal counted programs in 32 states by 2019.
LessonThe programs count practices adopted, not water quality; the Bay Journal found "virtually no tracking" of how the water responds.
Credit
Maryland Department of Natural Resources
2005
A yacht basin's copper cap
Antifouling paint keeps weed and barnacles off a hull, most often by leaching copper into the water. In February 2005 the San Diego Regional Water Board set a total maximum daily load, a cap on how much of a pollutant a water body may take, for dissolved copper in Shelter Island Yacht Basin. It required a 76 percent cut from 2,100 kg a year by 2022. The board's 2022 report card says the first targets, 10 percent by 2012 and 40 percent by 2017, were met, and that cuts reached 48 and 45 percent in 2020 and 2021. It rates the basin "Improvement Needed": copper in the water still exceeds the objective. The loads are calculated from the number of boats repainted and a passive leach rate, not measured, and the board now points to hull cleaning in the water as a source the first sums left out.
LessonA load worked out from paint conversions can fall while the copper measured in the water does not.
Credit
San Diego Regional Water Quality Control Board; Port of San Diego
2011
Washington's copper ban stalls
In 2011 Washington State passed a law to phase out copper-based antifouling paint. The Department of Ecology then reviewed the substitutes in reports in 2017, 2019 and 2024, and found that the non-copper biocides, the chemicals that kill fouling growth, might do more harm than copper. Only one, DCOIT, met its test for "safer", and Ecology lacked data on how well it works. The restriction will not take effect in 2026, and a new report is due by 30 June 2029. One ingredient, Irgarol, has been banned on recreational boats since 1 January 2023.
LessonA ban written before the substitutes were tested had to wait for the testing.
Credit
Washington State Legislature; Washington Department of Ecology
2019
France funds boat dismantling
Since 2019 the owner of a worn-out French pleasure boat between 2.5 m and 24 m long can hand it to an approved center to be taken apart at no charge. Builders and importers pay for it through a fee on each new boat sold in France, an arrangement called extended producer responsibility, set up by a 2015 law and run by the approved body APER. The French maritime directorate counted 13,148 boats dismantled from 2019 to the end of 2024, 3,175 of them in 2024, at 35 approved centers. Getting the boat to the center was left to the owner; APER began taking on transport costs in 2025.
Credit
APER (Association pour la plaisance éco-responsable); French Directorate General for Maritime Affairs, Fisheries and Aquaculture (DGAMPA), whose count this is
Watch for
Fiberglass recycling at landfill cost
Most boat hulls are fiberglass, glass fiber set in plastic resin, which cannot be melted down. The Rhode Island Marine Trades Association Foundation says a pilot shredded 60 tons of fiberglass from old boats and sent it to a cement kiln, where it served as both fuel and raw material. Its WAVES Initiative, running from June 2025 to May 2027 with support from NOAA's Marine Debris Program, aims to bring the cost down far enough to compete with landfill, partly by adding scrap from boat builders and worn-out wind turbine blades.
Achieved whenthe project publishes a cost per ton at or below local landfill disposal and a party outside the project confirms it.
Claimed by
Rhode Island Marine Trades Association Foundation and the NOAA Marine Debris Program, project page updated March 2026
France's 2025 dismantling count
The French boating magazine Bateaux reported that 3,079 boats were dismantled in 2025 and 16,183 since 2019, citing APER's annual review. The figures do not yet match the ministry's: its count to the end of 2024 was 13,148, which with 3,079 more gives 16,227, and its 2024 figure of 3,175 is higher than the 2025 one.
Achieved whenthe maritime directorate's yearly tally gives the 2025 count and the running total.
Claimed by
APER, as reported by Bateaux, March 2026
Open
01
Test Clean Marina certification
A comparison of certified and uncertified marinas in two or more US states, using records regulators already keep: permit inspections and violations for each marina, and any water samples taken nearby, before and after the date of certification.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Spot abandoned boats from above
A test of whether free aerial and satellite images can flag boats at anchor or on moorings that have not moved for a year, scored against a state's own list of derelict vessels, meaning boats left to rot or sink.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
Test Clean Marina certification
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A comparison of certified and uncertified marinas in two or more US states, using records regulators already keep: permit inspections and violations for each marina, and any water samples taken nearby, before and after the date of certification.
Why it is still open
The Bay Journal reported in 2019 that there is "virtually no tracking" of how water quality responds to the program and that scholarly databases hold little research on it. The nearest studies look at certified marinas alone: Rachel Krasna's 2013 Nova Southeastern capstone related boat density at Florida's clean marinas to fecal bacteria, and Brenda Clark's 2009 Michigan State thesis surveyed harbormasters' views of the program. Searches in November 2026 found program descriptions and state tallies of certified marinas, but no study that sets certified marinas beside uncertified ones.
southernmarylandchronicle.comnews.maryland.govnsuworks.nova.edud.lib.msu.edu
Built with what exists
State lists of certified marinas and their dates; EPA's Enforcement and Compliance History Online (ECHO) downloads, filtered to SIC industry code 4493, marinas; the Water Quality Portal for samples near each site; Python and pandas; QGIS; an AI model to match marina names across the lists, with every match checked by a person.
First step
Download Maryland's list of certified marinas and the ECHO records for code 4493 in Maryland, and count how many certified marinas appear in ECHO.
Done looks like
Every marina in two states matched to its certification status and date; inspections and violations per marina per year published for both groups, with the code; and a plain count of how many marinas have any water samples nearby at all.
Open 02 · the brief
Spot abandoned boats from above
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A test of whether free aerial and satellite images can flag boats at anchor or on moorings that have not moved for a year, scored against a state's own list of derelict vessels, meaning boats left to rot or sink.
Why it is still open
State lists are built from reports by officers on the water; Florida's wildlife agency publishes its derelict vessels on a map and pays to take at-risk boats before they sink. NOAA staff have trained a detector that finds vessels in aerial photos after hurricanes, and they list judging a vessel's condition as a later step. A NOAA project of 2020 to 2022 used drones and machine learning to find debris on shorelines, not boats left at anchor. Searches of papers, GitHub and Hugging Face in November 2026 found no test of image-based flagging against a state list.
Built with what exists
USDA NAIP aerial imagery and Sentinel-2 satellite images, both free; county aerial photos where they are public; an open object detector such as YOLO, or a small vision model trained for the job (see the Note "One GPU to fine-tune"); QGIS; Florida's derelict vessel map or Washington's inventory as the answer key.
First step
Pick one Florida anchorage, pull every NAIP image date for it, mark by hand the boats that have not moved, and compare them with the state's map.
Done looks like
For at least five anchorages, a list of boats found in the same spot on three or more image dates; the share of the state's listed derelict vessels that the method flagged before the state listed them; the share of flags that a person judges false; all published with the image clips.