BRENNEN

Industries / Industrial equipment and services / Industrial services / Leak detection

Repair and recheck

Repair and recheck is the work after a leak is found: fixing it within a deadline, checking that the fix held, and deciding which leaks to fix first.

7

Milestones achieved, from 1981 to 2023.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1981

    Tightened valves, measured

    In a study for EPA's Office of Research and Development, the agency's research arm, the bolts on the packing glands of leaking in-line valves were tightened while the valves stayed in service, the quickest repair there is. Emissions from the valves fell by about 70% overall, and the cut held for up to about six months. The study also counted how often new leaks started and old ones came back, and timed the work.

    LessonA quick repair works but can wear off within months, so a fixed leak has to be checked again.

    osti.gov

    Credit

    G. J. Langley and R. G. Wetherold, report for EPA, May 1981

  2. 1999

    A few leaks, most gas

    Directed inspection and maintenance (DI&M) means surveying every component once, measuring each leak, fixing first the leaks whose lost gas is worth more than the repair, and aiming later surveys at the parts that leak most. A 1999 study for the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), the Gas Research Institute (GRI) and Pipeline Research Council International (PRCI) surveyed 34,400 components at 13 US gas transmission compressor stations. On average 5% were leaking, and the largest 10% of leaks gave more than 90% of the emissions; at one station a single vent, on the gas system that worked the compressors' unloaders, gave 142,000 of the station's 200,000 thousand cubic feet (Mcf) a year. A later survey of four gas processing plants by the Gas Technology Institute and Clearstone Engineering found 3% of components leaking, and those leaks gave 82% of the plants' methane emissions. EPA's Natural Gas STAR program, a voluntary partnership with gas companies, published both studies as guides for its members.

    LessonBecause a small share of leaks carries most of the gas, measuring leaks before fixing them shows a crew where repair pays.

    19january2021snapshot.epa.gov19january2017snapshot.epa.gov

    Credit

    Indaco Air Quality Services (the 1999 study, report PRC-246-9526); Gas Technology Institute and Clearstone Engineering; EPA's Natural Gas STAR program

  3. 2000

    Refinery settlements tighten repairs

    Starting in March 2000, EPA's National Petroleum Refinery Initiative settled Clean Air Act cases with refining companies. By EPA's count, 37 settlements now cover 112 refineries in 32 states and territories and more than 95% of US refining capacity, and leak detection and repair requirements are among their terms; ExxonMobil's 2005 settlement, for one, committed it to "enhanced procedures" for leaks from valves and other equipment at all seven of its US refineries. EPA's 2007 best practices guide set out the elements of a stronger program: an internal leak definition of 500 parts per million (ppm) or lower for valves and 2,000 ppm for pumps, well under the 10,000 ppm of the federal rules; repair within 30 days of leaks between the internal and the regulatory limit; for a valve leaking at 10,000 ppm or more that cannot be fixed without shutting the unit down, up to two "drill and tap" attempts within 30 days, in which a hole is drilled into the packing gland and new packing is pumped in while the valve stays in service, before the valve may go on the "delay of repair" list of parts left until the next shutdown; regular third-party audits; and data loggers that stamp each reading with the time, the technician and the instrument.

    epa.govepa.govepa.gov

    Credit

    EPA's Office of Enforcement and Compliance Assurance, with the US Department of Justice

  4. 2014

    A state rules on methane

    On 23 February 2014, after four days of hearings, Colorado's Air Quality Control Commission adopted rules requiring oil and gas companies to find and fix methane leaks. Scientific American reported that no other state had regulated methane leaks from oil and gas. The rules came out of negotiations between the Environmental Defense Fund (EDF) and companies, and Encana, Anadarko, Noble Energy and DCP Midstream supported them. Operators file an annual leak detection and repair report, and the state publishes the reports for every year from 2014. In December 2019 the state's Air Pollution Control Division noted that the reports give the number of facilities inspected and leaks found but not the number of components, so it used an EPA leak frequency of 1.18% instead; it also observed that more site visits find and repair more leaks.

    LessonA report that counts leaks but not the parts inspected cannot show whether leaks are becoming rarer.

    scientificamerican.comcdphe.colorado.govcoloradosos.gov

    Credit

    Colorado Air Quality Control Commission; EDF and the four companies, for the negotiated rule

  5. 2018

    Canada inspects three times yearly

    Canada's first federal methane regulations for upstream oil and gas, made in April 2018, apply to facilities that produce or receive more than 60,000 cubic meters of hydrocarbon gas a year. From 2020 they required components to be inspected for leaks three times a year, a yearly maintenance check of compressor seals, and a venting limit of 15,000 cubic meters a year for most covered facilities. They were meant to help cut oil and gas methane 40% to 45% below 2012 levels by 2025.

    gazette.gc.ca

    Credit

    Environment and Climate Change Canada

  6. 2020

    Repairs hold, new leaks appear

    Arvind Ravikumar and colleagues studied leak surveys at 36 facilities of Seven Generations Energy in northwest Alberta, 30 well pads and 6 processing plants, surveyed every quarter in 2016 and 2017 with optical gas imaging (OGI), a camera that shows hydrocarbon gas as a visible plume. The first surveys found 969 leaks and 686 vents. When the same team returned 0.5 to 2 years later, more than 90% of the leaks found the first time were no longer emitting and total emissions were 44% lower, but fugitive emissions, those from leaks, fell only 22%, because new leaks had started in between.

    LessonRepairs mostly work, so how often a site is surveyed decides how much new leaking goes unfound.

    iopscience.iop.org

    Credit

    Arvind P. Ravikumar (Harrisburg University of Science and Technology), Adam R. Brandt (Stanford University) and co-authors at the University of Calgary and the University of British Columbia

  7. 2023

    Leaks found, not fixed

    Alberta's Directive 060 lets an operator replace the default program of OGI surveys with an alternative approved by the Alberta Energy Regulator (AER), if modeling shows it cuts emissions at least as much. The Sundre Petroleum Operators Group's two-year area program, from April 2021 to April 2023, covered about 1,200 sites with one aircraft survey and one truck survey a year, and was modeled to cut fugitive emissions 50.4% from a baseline with no surveys. The group's own final report counted 697 leaks found, 316 repaired, 87 with repair formally delayed and 91 recurring, with 47.3 days on average between survey and repair, and estimated the cut at 14.4%. Three member companies repaired no leaks (one had found none), and five repaired 70 of 250.

    LessonA survey plan's modeled benefit assumes the leaks it finds get fixed, and the report has to count the repairs to show whether they were.

    static.aer.castatic.aer.ca

    Credit

    Sundre Petroleum Operators Group (report by Tracey McCrimmon, March 2023), with modeling by Arolytics; Alberta Energy Regulator

Watch for

  1. Repair time set by size

    Canada's amended methane regulations, registered in December 2025, set the time allowed to repair a leak by its measured flow: within 24 hours for 100 kg/h or more, 7 days for 10 to 100 kg/h, 30 days for 1 to 10 kg/h and 90 days below 1 kg/h, or 24 hours if the flow was not measured. A repair counts only when the leak can no longer be detected by a method sensitive to 60 g/h or 500 parts per million by volume (ppmv). Each facility also needs a comprehensive inspection every quarter or every year, depending on its type, and a yearly inspection by an outside auditor using a method with at least a 90% chance of finding a 10 kg/h leak. The leak rules apply from 1 January 2028. Environment and Climate Change Canada estimates that the amendments will bring oil and gas methane to about 0.8 million tonnes in 2030, 72% below 2012.

    Achieved whenthe rules are in force and inspection records or audits published by the government show leaks repaired within these periods and emissions falling toward the estimate.

    gazette.gc.ca

    Claimed by

    Environment and Climate Change Canada, December 2025

Open

  1. 01

    Twelve years of Colorado leaks

    A public table built from every annual leak detection and repair report filed with Colorado's Air Pollution Control Division from 2014 to 2025: for each company and year, the facilities inspected, inspections by required frequency, leaks found, leaks repaired on time and repairs delayed. From it, publish leaks found per inspection for each frequency tier, and how that number changes at companies that report year after year.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Tightened glands, life tested

    A bench life test of the usual first repair on a leaking valve stem. Small used gate valves with worn graphite packing are pressurized with nitrogen at low pressure, and the gland nuts are tightened until the stem leak falls below a set rate; a motor then opens and shuts each valve again and again, and the leak is measured every 100 cycles. The same test runs on valves that were repacked instead and on valves fitted with low-emission packing, so the three repairs can be compared.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Twelve years of Colorado leaks

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public table built from every annual leak detection and repair report filed with Colorado's Air Pollution Control Division from 2014 to 2025: for each company and year, the facilities inspected, inspections by required frequency, leaks found, leaks repaired on time and repairs delayed. From it, publish leaks found per inspection for each frequency tier, and how that number changes at companies that report year after year.

Why it is still open

The division posts each company's report and a yearly summary, but as separate documents in a web viewer: a plain download of the 2025 summary returned only the viewer page, not the document. In December 2019 the division said the reports show facilities inspected and leaks found but not components, and used an EPA leak frequency instead of its own data. A search in November 2026 found the reports and the division's rule analyses but no published analysis of the reports by inspection frequency.

cdphe.colorado.govcoloradosos.gov

Built with what exists

Playwright driving headless Chrome to save the reports from the viewer; pdfplumber, with Tesseract for scanned pages; a model that answers a fixed list of questions about each document, such as Gemini Decision 1 (see the Note "A thousand questions, one pass"); DuckDB for the table.

  1. First step

    Save the 2025 reports and summary by hand and code 20 of them to settle the fields.

  2. Done looks like

    Every report from 2014 to 2025 coded, one row per company and year; a second person rechecks 50 reports field by field, with at least 98% agreement; leaks per inspection published for each tier with 95% confidence intervals, and the year-on-year trend for companies present in at least five years.

Open 02 · the brief

Tightened glands, life tested

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A bench life test of the usual first repair on a leaking valve stem. Small used gate valves with worn graphite packing are pressurized with nitrogen at low pressure, and the gland nuts are tightened until the stem leak falls below a set rate; a motor then opens and shuts each valve again and again, and the leak is measured every 100 cycles. The same test runs on valves that were repacked instead and on valves fitted with low-emission packing, so the three repairs can be compared.

Why it is still open

The only study found that measured how long tightening lasts is EPA's 1981 report, which found the cut held for up to about six months; OSTI, which catalogs it, holds no digital copy. API 622 tests new packing over 1,510 cycles, not worn packing that has been retightened. EPA's guide lists tightening the gland nuts as a first attempt at repair, and EPA proposed in October 2026 to let gas plants try such a repair before repacking or fitting low-emission parts (see valves.md), so how long a first repair holds now bears on a rule. A search in November 2026 found trade articles saying that the force on the packing fades through relaxation and wear, but no published life test of retightened packing.

osti.govepa.gov

Built with what exists

1/2-inch to 2-inch used gate valves with graphite packing; a nitrogen cylinder and regulator held at no more than 1.7 bar (25 psi); a mass flow meter, such as Alicat's, measuring the gas fed in to replace what leaks at the stem; a torque wrench; a hobby gear motor or stepper motor driven by an Arduino to cycle each stem; a Raspberry Pi to log flow and cycle counts.

  1. First step

    Loosen the packing on one used gate valve, pressurize it with nitrogen at 1 bar, tighten the gland nuts until the leak stops, and log the leak over 200 cycles.

  2. Done looks like

    10 valves for each of the three repairs, each cycled 2,000 times or until its stem leak passes 10 standard cubic centimeters a minute; the median cycles to failure for each repair with 95% confidence intervals; torque, flow and cycle logs published.