BRENNEN

Industries / Technology / IT hardware recycling

Testing and resale

Testing and resale is the work of checking that a used device works, grading its condition, repairing it where that pays, and selling it, or its parts, again.

6

Milestones achieved, from 2002 to 2025.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 2002

    Cheap Windows for used PCs

    Around 2000, refurbishers paid more than $100 for each retail Windows licence or installed pirated copies, by the account of Jim Lynch of TechSoup, a technology charity. Microsoft tried a refurbisher licence in the UK, and from December 2002, with TechSoup, its Microsoft Authorized Refurbisher program offered unlimited $5 Windows licences to non-profit refurbishers supplying charities, schools, libraries and people on low incomes; Lynch dates the partnership to 2001. By 2020 the programs that grew from it supplied more than 1 million low-cost licences a year.

    LessonMicrosoft ended its program for small refurbishers, those handling fewer than 1,000 machines a month, in 2020, by iFixit's account; the program that remains requires at least 20,000 refurbished PCs a year.

    resource-recycling.comifixit.com

    Credit

    Microsoft; TechSoup

  2. 2012

    E-waste parts sold as new

    A year-long investigation by the US Senate Armed Services Committee, led by Senators Carl Levin and John McCain and reported on 21 May 2012, found about 1,800 cases of suspect counterfeit electronic parts in the US defense supply chain, involving more than 1 million parts, with more than 70% of the suspect parts traced to China. One witness described public sidewalks there covered with electronic components harvested from e-waste.

    LessonThe committee found that some companies accepted parts after only basic functional tests, a gap counterfeiters used.

    armed-services.senate.gov

    Credit

    US Senate Armed Services Committee

  3. 2022

    Iron Mountain buys ITRenew

    On 25 January 2022 Iron Mountain, the records storage company, bought about 80% of ITRenew for an agreed $725.0 million. Iron Mountain's asset lifecycle business, which ITRenew joined, takes servers out of hyperscale and corporate data centers, erases them, and recycles or resells the hardware and its parts; ITRenew brought it $213.1 million of service revenue in 2022.

    sec.gov

    Credit

    Iron Mountain; ITRenew

  4. 2022

    Testers open refurbished iPhones

    Test Achats/Test Aankoop, the Belgian consumer organization, examined 44 refurbished iPhone X and iPhone 11 phones sold in the top grade, "as good as new". Six looked too damaged on the outside to be sold as new. Opened up, eight had serious defects, such as corrosion from earlier water damage, a faulty touchscreen or an imitation case, and 13 more had minor faults, such as seals against water not replaced. In all 18% failed, against half the phones in the group's 2016 test.

    LessonGrading the outside missed defects that showed only when the phones were opened.

    euroconsumers.org

    Credit

    Test Achats/Test Aankoop; Euroconsumers

  5. 2024

    More phones resold as is

    Counterpoint Research counted 5% growth in refurbished smartphone sales in 2024, with Apple's share rising to 56% from 51%, while sales of phones sold "as is", cleaned and repackaged with no technical work, grew 13%. Its analyst Glen Cardoza tied this to sturdier phones coming back in better condition and to rising costs of spare parts, labor and equipment. In the first half of 2025 refurbished sales grew 3% and as-is sales 10%, by Counterpoint's count.

    counterpointresearch.comcounterpointresearch.com

    Credit

    Counterpoint Research

  6. 2025

    Parts for seven years

    Since 20 June 2025, makers of smartphones sold in the EU must offer repairers spare parts, among them the battery, display assembly and back cover, until at least seven years after a model leaves the market, and deliver them within five working days for the first five years. Any operating system update a maker releases must reach every unit of the model, free, until at least five years after the model stops being placed on the market.

    LessonA year later iFixit and Right to Repair Europe found that of 2,334 smartphone records in the EU's product database, only about 18% listed websites where spare part prices or repair instructions could readily be found.

    publications.europa.euifixit.com

    Credit

    European Commission, Regulation (EU) 2023/1670

Watch for

  1. Servers 91% reused or recycled

    Microsoft says its Circular Centers, six sites in places including the United States, Amsterdam, Dublin and Singapore, reused or recycled 90.9% of the servers and components from its cloud in fiscal year 2024, beating a 90% target set for 2025, partly by "harvesting and recertifying decommissioned server components no longer available on the market". It plans centers in Cardiff (2025), Sydney (2026) and San Antonio, Texas (2028). The figure counts reuse and recycling together.

    Achieved whenMicrosoft reports reuse apart from recycling and an outside party reviews the figure.

    cdn-dynmedia-1.microsoft.com

    Claimed by

    Microsoft, in its 2025 Environmental Sustainability Report, June 2025

Open

  1. 01

    Grade the phone graders

    An open set of photographs of used phones, each graded for cosmetic condition on CTIA's grading scale by at least five professional graders from different refurbishers, twice, a week apart. Then a scored test of how often human graders, grading machines and AI models agree with each other and with themselves.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Map paired parts on Android

    A public table, for current Android phone models, of which parts are paired to the phone by software and what happens when a genuine part from another unit of the same model is fitted: a warning, a lost function, or nothing. Swap the display, cameras, fingerprint sensor, charging port and back cover between two new phones of each model, first without and then with the maker's pairing procedure.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Grade the phone graders

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An open set of photographs of used phones, each graded for cosmetic condition on CTIA's grading scale by at least five professional graders from different refurbishers, twice, a week apart. Then a scored test of how often human graders, grading machines and AI models agree with each other and with themselves.

Why it is still open

CTIA, the US wireless industry association, published a common grading standard in 2019, yet an industry adviser says one firm may call a phone grade A that another calls grade B. Phonecheck says its grading robot removes the subjectivity of human grading but gave no accuracy figures. Belgian testers found 6 of 44 top-grade refurbished iPhones too damaged to be sold as new. Searches found no independent test of how well graders agree.

telecomtv.comapkudo.comresource-recycling.comeuroconsumers.org

Built with what exists

A photo booth with fixed lighting and a color card; phones photographed while switched off, never powered on or connected; Label Studio for grading; Krippendorff's alpha, a standard measure of agreement between raters; a vision model from Liquid AI's LFM3 family, fine-tuned on one graphics card (see the draft Note "One GPU to fine-tune"); Gemini Decision 1 to score the fixed grade choices (see the draft Note "A thousand questions, one pass"); a count of the phones each machine grades the same on all 20 re-shot photo sets (see the Note "All twenty times").

  1. First step

    Borrow 50 graded phones from one refurbisher, photograph both sides of each, and have three of its graders grade first the photos and then the phones.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 300 phones and five graders from at least three firms, each phone graded twice; published agreement between graders and within each grader, the same figures for at least two machine or AI graders, and the photos and grades under an open license.

Open 02 · the brief

Map paired parts on Android

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public table, for current Android phone models, of which parts are paired to the phone by software and what happens when a genuine part from another unit of the same model is fitted: a warning, a lost function, or nothing. Swap the display, cameras, fingerprint sensor, charging port and back cover between two new phones of each model, first without and then with the maker's pairing procedure.

Why it is still open

Refurbishers rebuild phones with parts taken from other phones, and pairing can stop such parts from working. Since June 2025 the EU requires makers to give repairers access to the software tools needed to make paired ("serialised") parts work. A 2023 paper published by CLASP, a policy group, says the data available focus on Apple's iPhones, though pairing has also been seen on Samsung phones. Single swaps have been filmed: in 2021 the repair YouTuber Hugh Jeffreys swapped genuine parts between two Samsung Galaxy A51 phones, and both lost fingerprint functions until he rolled back a security update, by iFixit's account. No model-by-model table for Android phones was found.

publications.europa.euclasp.ngoifixit.com

Built with what exists

Two new phones of each model, bought at retail and never given anyone's data; iFixit's repair guides and tools; the makers' published pairing procedures; a camera to film each swap; a checklist of functions to test after each swap; a spreadsheet published with the videos. Batteries are left out, since opening and swapping them carries a fire risk outside a repair shop.

  1. First step

    Buy two new units of one Samsung model, swap their displays and rear cameras, and film what each phone reports.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 20 models from at least six makers, each listed part swapped both ways, with a filmed result and a published row for every part.