Industries / Technology / IT hardware recycling
Certification
Certification is how a recycler or IT asset disposition firm shows customers that it handles equipment, data and exports as promised: written standards, audits by accredited bodies, and the cases where a firm's claims and its conduct parted.
6
Milestones achieved, from 2008 to 2021.
1
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
2008
Two standards for recyclers
Two standards began to be used to certify US electronics recyclers: R2 (Responsible Recycling), owned today by Sustainable Electronics Recycling International (SERI), and e-Stewards, owned by the Basel Action Network (BAN), a campaign group against exports of hazardous waste. Accredited certification bodies, not the standards' owners, audit each facility, and the ANSI-ASQ National Accreditation Board (ANAB) oversees those bodies; it has worked with R2 since 2008 and e-Stewards since 2009. By SERI's figures, 27 facilities in two countries were R2 certified in 2010 and 719 in 31 countries in 2017.
Credit
SERI; BAN; ANAB
2013
Recycler jailed over exports
Executive Recycling of Englewood, Colorado, told customers it recycled their electronics "properly, right here in the U.S." Between 2005 and 2008 it was the exporter of record on more than 300 shipments abroad, including about 160 containers holding more than 100,000 cathode ray tubes (CRTs), the leaded picture tubes of old monitors and TVs, to countries including China. A jury convicted the company, its owner and its vice president of operations of fraud, environmental crimes, smuggling and obstruction in December 2012. In July 2013 the company was fined $4.5 million and its owner, Brandon Richter, was sentenced to 30 months in prison, reduced to 22 months after an appeal and a 2016 plea agreement.
LessonCustomers relied on the claims on the company's website; BAN and CBS's 60 Minutes had tracked one of its containers to China, by Resource Recycling's account. EPA rules now require exporters of CRTs for recycling to notify EPA and obtain the receiving country's written consent first.
Credit
US Attorney for Colorado; ICE Homeland Security Investigations; EPA Criminal Investigation Division
2013
Europe asks for treatment standards
On 24 January 2013 the European Commission asked the European standards bodies to write standards for treating waste electrical and electronic equipment under the 2012 WEEE directive. CENELEC, the European body for electrical standards, answered with the EN 50625 series and EN 50614, which cover collection, transport, preparation for reuse and treatment, including depollution, the removal of hazardous parts.
LessonThe standards bind only where a country writes them into law. In December 2019 a group of industry bodies (APPLiA, DIGITALEUROPE, EERA, Orgalim and the WEEE Forum) counted five member states using them in law and more than 150 facilities audited to them, and the WEEE Forum says it takes part in the debate on making treatment standards mandatory in Europe.
ec.europa.eucencenelec.eucdn.digitaleurope.orgweee-forum.org
Credit
European Commission; CENELEC
2016
EPA watches nine audits
Between August 2013 and April 2015 the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) sat in on nine audits of recyclers to R2 and e-Stewards, run by five of the six accredited certification bodies, and interviewed auditors, recyclers and the standards' owners. Its February 2016 report found the programs "generally being implemented well" and recommended more audit time, more training and action on perceived conflicts of interest. Of those interviewed, 85%, including all the certification bodies and 91% of auditors, said training needed strengthening.
LessonEPA saw an auditor fail to flag a facility that tested equipment for reuse only by switching it on, and every facility it watched had agreed in advance to be observed.
Credit
US EPA, with the General Services Administration and ANAB
2020
R2 rewritten as R2v3
In June 2020 SERI's board adopted R2v3, the third version of the R2 standard, which ANSI approved as an American National Standard. It lets a facility be certified for specialty processes, such as data sanitization, so that customers can choose a facility by the work it does. SERI's site counts about 1,200 R2 facilities in 43 countries.
Credit
SERI and its Technical Advisory Committee
2021
Privacy regulator approves ITAD scheme
On 19 August 2021 the UK Information Commissioner's Office (ICO) approved ADISA's ICT Asset Recovery Certification 8.0 as one of the first three certification schemes under the UK General Data Protection Regulation. The scheme is for firms that remove personal data from IT equipment, such as computer hard drives or photocopiers, before it is reused or destroyed.
LessonWhen the ICO approved it, no certification body was yet accredited to issue it, the law firm Hunton Andrews Kurth reported; ADISA now says the UK Accreditation Service has added the scheme, in a later version also approved by the ICO, to ADISA's scope.
Credit
ADISA; UK Information Commissioner's Office
Watch for
R2 revision for connected devices
SERI began the required five-year review of R2v3 in 2025. Its committee is studying how to remove data from connected devices, such as household gadgets linked to a phone app, many of which have no standard erasure software. SERI's estimated timeline puts a public draft in early to mid 2027 and a new version in late 2027 or early 2028.
Achieved whenthe new version is published and certification bodies audit facilities against it.
Claimed by
SERI, 2025
Open
01
Certificates against court records
A public table of every US federal and state enforcement case since 2005 against electronics recyclers and IT asset disposition firms, for illegal exports, abandoned stockpiles, fires or false claims to customers. For each case it records whether the firm held R2, e-Stewards or another certificate at the time and what the certification body did afterwards.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Map certified recyclers worldwide
One open map and table of every facility certified to R2, e-Stewards, WEEELABEX or ADISA's ITAD scheme, joined to each country's e-waste generation in the Global E-waste Monitor 2024, so that each country shows certified facilities per million kilograms of e-waste generated.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
Certificates against court records
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
A public table of every US federal and state enforcement case since 2005 against electronics recyclers and IT asset disposition firms, for illegal exports, abandoned stockpiles, fires or false claims to customers. For each case it records whether the firm held R2, e-Stewards or another certificate at the time and what the certification body did afterwards.
Why it is still open
Single cases are well known, such as Executive Recycling's 2012 conviction. EPA's 2016 study examined nine audits and did not compare certification with enforcement outcomes. Searches found no dataset that matches enforcement cases to certification status.
Built with what exists
EPA's ECHO enforcement database; US Department of Justice and state attorney general press releases; court records through CourtListener; the current R2 directory and e-Stewards processor list, with archived copies of both for past status; an agent that cites the page behind each row (see the Note "Findings that cite notes"); a spreadsheet; a second coder.
First step
Collect every Department of Justice press release since 2005 that mentions electronic waste or CRTs and code the first 20.
Done looks like
At least 100 cases from at least 20 states, each with its source and the firm's certification status at the time, checked by a second person, with published counts of cases at certified and uncertified firms.
Open 02 · the brief
Map certified recyclers worldwide
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
One open map and table of every facility certified to R2, e-Stewards, WEEELABEX or ADISA's ITAD scheme, joined to each country's e-waste generation in the Global E-waste Monitor 2024, so that each country shows certified facilities per million kilograms of e-waste generated.
Why it is still open
Each scheme keeps its own list: SERI counts about 1,200 R2 facilities in 43 countries, WEEELABEX publishes its own operator list, and ADISA its own search. The Global E-waste Monitor counts 81 countries with e-waste laws but does not count certified facilities. Searches found no combined list and no comparison with e-waste generated.
sustainableelectronics.orgweeelabex.orgadisacertification.comewastemonitor.info
Built with what exists
The four public directories, used within each site's terms; the Global E-waste Monitor 2024 country tables; OpenStreetMap's Nominatim for geocoding; Muse Ember to clean names and addresses into fixed fields (see the Note "The jobs agents repeat"); QGIS or a web map library.
First step
Copy the R2 and WEEELABEX lists for five countries, join them by address, and count the facilities that hold both.
Done looks like
Every listed facility in the four directories on one map with its scheme and listing date, and a table for every country with the ratio, published under an open license and refreshed every quarter.