BRENNEN

Industries / Media, arts and recreation / Hunting and fishing outfitters

Safety

Safety is keeping clients and guides from harm far from help: falls from tree stands, bears at a kill, and cold water.

6

Milestones achieved, from 2008 to 2024.

0

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 2008

    Bear spray, case by case

    Tom Smith of Brigham Young University, Stephen Herrero and colleagues analyzed 83 bear spray incidents in Alaska from 1985 to 2006. Red pepper spray stopped the bear's unwanted behavior in 92% of uses on brown bears, 90% on black bears and both uses on polar bears, and 98% of people carrying spray were unhurt in close encounters.

    LessonSmith said many professionals resisted bear spray because "there was no good, clean data set" showing it worked, so his team built one from the cases.

    agris.fao.orgsciencedaily.com

    Credit

    Tom S. Smith, Stephen Herrero, Terry DeBruyn and James Wilder (Journal of Wildlife Management, 2008)

  2. 2015

    A harness with every stand

    Makers formed the Treestand Manufacturer's Association in 1995 to write performance standards for the elevated seats deer hunters strap to trees. In 2015 ASTM International set up a treestand subcommittee (F08.18). Its specification F3249 requires every treestand to include a full-body harness, and its fall-arrest test, F2337, limits a fall to 24 inches. From 1 January 2016 the association's members must meet the current ASTM standards.

    tmastands.comastm.org

    Credit

    Treestand Manufacturer's Association; ASTM subcommittee F08.18, chaired by John Louk

  3. 2018

    Guide killed at an elk

    On 14 September 2018 a female grizzly and her cub attacked guide Mark Uptain of Martin Outfitters and his bowhunting client as they butchered an elk in the Teton Wilderness of Wyoming, and Uptain died. His pistol lay with the packs a short distance away and the client's bear spray was in a pack; Uptain's own emptied canister was found by his body. Wyoming's OSHA treated it as a workplace death and told the outfitter to "evaluate its operating procedures for bear country" and its "training policy on bear spray use".

    LessonA guide's death in the field is a workplace death, so the outfitter's procedures and training come under review as an employer's.

    newslj.com

    Credit

    Wyoming Game and Fish Department and Wyoming OSHA investigations; reported by WyoFile

  4. 2021

    Cold, wind and old cans

    Smith and colleagues tested bear spray in the lab and the field. Canister pressure rose with temperature, yet at −23 °C the spray still reached more than 4 m; in modeled headwinds and crosswinds over 10 m/s it still reached a target about 2 m ahead; unused cans up to 18 years old lost 0.65 to 1.92 g a year; and over half of a new canister's pressure was gone in the first second of spraying. They advised against test-firing cans and for keeping them warm.

    ebi.ac.uk

    Credit

    Tom S. Smith, James Wilder, Geoff York, Martyn Obbard and Brad Billings (Journal of Wildlife Management, 2021)

  5. 2022

    Falls overtake shootings

    From Pennsylvania's statewide trauma registry, researchers counted 1,229 people hurt falling from tree stands while deer hunting from 1990 to 2017, against 560 victims of hunting-related shootings. The fall rate rose from 1.5 to 10.4 per million deer hunting days and passed the shooting rate in 1999; 26% of fall victims left hospital needing help with daily life. Arkansas Game and Fish Commission records for 1993 to 2022 show the same turn: treestand injuries rose while projectile injuries fell.

    ebi.ac.ukebi.ac.uk

    Credit

    K. A. Young and colleagues (Southern Medical Journal, 2022); Dirk Haselow (Wilderness & Environmental Medicine, 2024)

  6. 2024

    Fishing, a third of deaths

    The US Coast Guard counted 556 recreational boating deaths in 2024. 178 of them, about 32%, were on boats that were out fishing, and 7 on boats used for hunting. Where the cause was known, 76% of all victims drowned, and where life jacket use was known, 87% were not wearing one.

    uscgboating.org

    Credit

    US Coast Guard, Recreational Boating Statistics 2024

Open

  1. 01

    Weathered tree straps, pull-tested

    Public breaking-strength tests of the straps, tethers and lifelines that hold hunters to trees, after one, two and three seasons hanging in the woods, against new ones of the same models.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Bear spray draw times, filmed

    A filmed, timed test of how fast people can draw and fire bear spray from where they carry it, such as a chest holster, a belt holster, a pack strap or inside the pack, using inert training canisters.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

Weathered tree straps, pull-tested

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

Public breaking-strength tests of the straps, tethers and lifelines that hold hunters to trees, after one, two and three seasons hanging in the woods, against new ones of the same models.

Why it is still open

Makers set replacement dates for this gear: Summit says to discard its tether strap two years after purchase and its harness after five, and other makers note that moisture and UV light age it. The ASTM fall-arrest test is run on new gear. In a Rochester series of 54 tree stand falls from 2003 to 2011, three of the 13 falls with a recorded cause were put down to a broken safety harness, and the hospital records said nothing about harness use in the rest. A search found no published strength tests of straps used in the field.

summitstands.combowhunting.compmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

Built with what exists

a universal tensile testing machine in a university materials lab; ASTM D6775, the standard test for the breaking strength of textile webbing; an accelerated weathering chamber such as Q-Lab's QUV for a lab-aged comparison; straps donated by hunters with known purchase dates.

  1. First step

    Collect 20 used tree straps with known purchase years from a hunting club and pull-test them beside five new ones.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 60 straps and tethers from three or more makers, new and after one to three seasons outdoors, each pulled to failure in the lab, with break loads, failure points and photos published beside each maker's rated strength and replacement date.

Open 02 · the brief

Bear spray draw times, filmed

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A filmed, timed test of how fast people can draw and fire bear spray from where they carry it, such as a chest holster, a belt holster, a pack strap or inside the pack, using inert training canisters.

Why it is still open

The studies so far measure what spray does once it is fired, in real encounters (2008) and in cold, wind and old cans (2021), not how long it takes to get it out. In the 2018 Wyoming death the client's spray was in a pack. The US Geological Survey trains its staff with inert spray but publishes no timings, and searches of Europe PMC and Crossref found no study of draw time by carry position.

pubs.usgs.govnewslj.comebi.ac.uk

Built with what exists

inert training canisters and holsters sold by bear spray makers; a phone camera filming at 120 frames per second or more; a sound cue played at a random moment; a target 7 m away; a spreadsheet or Python to read times off the video.

  1. First step

    Time 10 people drawing inert canisters from four positions in a park and publish the clips.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 60 volunteers, guides among them, each tested from four carry positions in random order, with median and slowest times to a hit on the target for each position and all video published.