Industries / Transport and vehicles / Trucking and freight / Freight brokerage and 3PLs
Vetting carriers and fraud
Before a broker hands a load to a trucking company it does not own, it checks that the company is licensed, insured and safe to hire, and that the people it is dealing with really work for that company.
6
Milestones achieved, from 1997 to 2026.
1
To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.
2
Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.
The road
AchievedWatch forOpen
Achieved
1997
Shippers write security rules
Manufacturers and the logistics firms that move their goods founded the Transported Asset Protection Association (TAPA) in 1997 to cut losses from cargo theft. Its Trucking Security Requirements (TSR) set minimum security measures for trucking firms, checked by audit bodies that TAPA approves, and members can look up which firms hold the certificate. TAPA says more than 90% of the cargo losses reported to its incident service involve criminal attacks on vehicles, and its Europe, Middle East and Africa branch says the region needs another 400,000 secure truck parking places.
Credit
TAPA and its regional branches
2013
Broker bonds rise to $75,000
A US broker must hold a surety bond or trust fund that pays trucking companies if the broker does not pay them. The highway law known as MAP-21 raised the amount for property brokers from $10,000 to $75,000 from October 1, 2013, and required it of freight forwarders for the first time. By early December about 2,000 brokers, nearly 10% of the total, had lost their licences, Heavy Duty Trucking reported, citing DC Velocity; the bond seller JW Surety Bonds counted about 3,800 revocations in the first three days, and it was unclear how many brokers had given up their licences voluntarily.
LessonA larger bond cleared out thinly funded brokers at once, but the rules said little about whether the money could actually be reached when a broker failed.
Credit
US Congress (MAP-21, section 32918); the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA)
2023
Dispatchers and brokers told apart
Congress's 2021 infrastructure law told FMCSA to say when a "dispatch service," a firm that finds loads for trucking companies, needs a broker's licence. FMCSA's final guidance of June 16, 2023, says a dispatcher that works under a written contract with a carrier and is paid only by that carrier generally does not, but one that takes payment from a broker or a factoring company (a firm that buys a carrier's unpaid bills), or hands a load on to another carrier, does. FMCSA noted that "double brokering," in which a load is secretly passed to another hauler, is not a term defined in law, and that it cannot fine unlicensed brokering itself; only the Justice Department can, in federal court.
LessonGuidance can describe a fraud, but without the power to fine, enforcement waits on federal lawsuits.
Credit
FMCSA; US Congress (Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act, section 23021)
2025
Thieves turn to deception
CargoNet, a Verisk business that has collected reports of cargo theft in the US and Canada since 2010, counted 3,594 supply chain crime incidents in 2025, about the same as the 3,607 in 2024, while confirmed cargo thefts rose 18% to 2,646 and estimated losses rose 60% to about $725 million. In the third quarter of 2026, "fictitious pickups," in which a thief poses as the hired trucking company to collect a load, made up about a quarter of reported incidents, against 18% a year earlier. CargoNet reported schemes that used hijacked business email accounts, internet phone systems and freight apps to impersonate real companies.
Credit
Verisk CargoNet
2026
Lost bond money means suspension
From January 16, 2026, FMCSA can suspend a broker's or freight forwarder's operating authority when its bond or trust fund falls below $75,000 and is not restored within seven business days of FMCSA's notice. A trust fund may now hold only assets that can be turned into cash quickly, which Land Line lists as cash, irrevocable letters of credit from federally insured banks and US Treasury bonds, and loan and finance companies may no longer act as trustees. Congress had ordered the trust fund rule in MAP-21 in 2012; FMCSA moved the compliance date back a year because its new registration system was not ready.
Credit
FMCSA; the Owner-Operator Independent Drivers Association (OOIDA), which says it pushed for the change for nearly 15 years
2026
Brokers answer for carrier choice
Shawn Montgomery lost a leg when a truck hauling for Caribe Transport II struck his truck in Illinois. C.H. Robinson had brokered the load, and he said it should have known from Caribe's "conditional" federal safety rating that hiring it was likely to lead to crashes. Federal appeals courts had split over whether federal trucking law blocks such negligent-selection claims against brokers. On May 14, 2026, the US Supreme Court ruled unanimously that it does not, because states keep their authority over safety "with respect to motor vehicles." A concurring opinion noted that FMCSA requires a broker only to pick a registered carrier and sets no other safety standard for the choice.
LessonWhere federal rules set no standard for choosing a carrier, state courts and juries set it case by case.
Credit
US Supreme Court, opinion by Justice Amy Coney Barrett (Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II, 608 U.S. 219)
Watch for
A federal carrier-selection standard
After the Montgomery ruling, the Transportation Intermediaries Association (TIA), the brokers' trade group, petitioned FMCSA in June 2026 for a federal standard saying when a broker's choice of carrier is reasonable, and for a published list of carriers FMCSA considers high risk. TIA says only about 10% of carriers have a federal safety rating. It also backs the Motor Carrier Safety Selection Standard Act of 2025, which, by TIA's description, would let brokers and shippers hire only carriers that are registered, hold valid authority and meet insurance minimums, and would fund an FMCSA web page listing fully compliant carriers. An FMCSA deputy administrator said in May 2026 that the agency is not a "ratings agency."
Achieved whensuch a standard is in force, by FMCSA rule or by law.
Claimed by
TIA, June 2026
Open
01
What public records predict crashes
An open, rerunnable test of which facts anyone can look up free about a US trucking company predict whether it will crash in the following year: its out-of-service rates at roadside inspections, its safety rating if it has one, how long it has held its authority, its insurance history and its past crashes. Publish the code and the accuracy for each signal by fleet size, not scores for named companies.
The briefCredit · unclaimed02
Measure the bond rule
An open monthly count of US brokers suspended because their bond or trust fund fell below $75,000, how many days passed between the bond's cancellation filing and the suspension, and how many brokers were later reinstated, before and after the rule took effect on January 16, 2026.
The briefCredit · unclaimed
Open 01 · the brief
What public records predict crashes
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
An open, rerunnable test of which facts anyone can look up free about a US trucking company predict whether it will crash in the following year: its out-of-service rates at roadside inspections, its safety rating if it has one, how long it has held its authority, its insurance history and its past crashes. Publish the code and the accuracy for each signal by fleet size, not scores for named companies.
Why it is still open
Under the 2015 FAST Act, FMCSA removed property carriers' percentile scores from its public website, while inspection, crash and registration data stayed public. FMCSA chose not to adopt the statistical model that the National Academies recommended in its review of the scores. After Montgomery, TIA told FMCSA that brokers must judge carriers "using potentially suspect data." Open projects such as fmcsa-safety-profiler score carriers from the same public files but do not test whether their scores predict later crashes, and no open, tested model was found.
Built with what exists
FMCSA's public census, inspection and crash files and its Motus authority and insurance history files on the US DOT open data portal; Python with pandas and scikit-learn; survival models for time to first crash; an AI coding agent to write and test the joins.
First step
Join one year of the public inspection file to the census on USDOT number and measure how well vehicle out-of-service rate alone ranks the next year's crashes in FMCSA's crash file.
Done looks like
For every interstate property carrier with at least one roadside inspection in a base year, a published table of how well each public signal, alone and combined, ranks next-year crashes per truck, by fleet size band, with code that rebuilds it from the public files.
Open 02 · the brief
Measure the bond rule
The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.
What to build
An open monthly count of US brokers suspended because their bond or trust fund fell below $75,000, how many days passed between the bond's cancellation filing and the suspension, and how many brokers were later reinstated, before and after the rule took effect on January 16, 2026.
Why it is still open
FMCSA's public "Motus RevokeSuspend – All With History" file lists 1,086 involuntary suspension notices served to property brokers between May 18 and November 20, 2026, by a count made for this research, but it has no column giving the reason, so bond cases cannot be told from others without matching each one to the insurance history. Services that read the same files, such as Carrier Ledger, alert users to changes day by day but publish no before-and-after measure, and a search for such an analysis found none.
datahub.transportation.govdatahub.transportation.govmcpservers.org
Built with what exists
The Socrata API of data.transportation.gov for the Motus suspension, insurance and insurance history files and the older revocation files; Python; a public notebook; an AI coding agent to write the matching code.
First step
Pull every 2026 cancellation of a broker bond (form BMC-84) or trust fund (form BMC-85) from the insurance history file and match each to suspension notices by docket number.
Done looks like
A published monthly series from January 2024 to the present of bond-related broker suspensions, the median days from cancellation filing to suspension, and reinstatements, with the code and a hand check of 50 random cases against FMCSA's public pages.