BRENNEN

Industries / Transport and vehicles / Trucking and freight / Freight brokerage and 3PLs

Billing and payment

After delivery, the broker bills the shipper, pays the trucking company and keeps the difference; this work covers who can see those amounts, how the money moves, and who pays when a party in the chain does not.

4

Milestones achieved, from 1980 to 2010.

1

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 1980

    Carriers may see the books

    In October 1980, months after the Motor Carrier Act opened US trucking to competition, the Interstate Commerce Commission (ICC) dropped rules that made brokers publish their maximum fees and replaced them with a simpler one: a broker keeps a record of each deal, and each party to it may review that record, so a carrier can see what the shipper paid. The rule is still in force as 49 CFR 371.3. In 2024 FMCSA said it had heard in listening sessions and comments that such "broker transparency is rare in practice," because broker contracts often make carriers waive the right.

    LessonA right that can be signed away in a contract is seldom used.

    federalregister.gov

    Credit

    Interstate Commerce Commission (45 FR 68941); FMCSA

  2. 1990

    Bankrupt carriers rebill shippers

    US law required a trucking company to charge the rate it had filed with the ICC. After 1980 many carriers agreed lower rates with shippers and never filed them, and when those carriers went bankrupt, their estates billed the shippers for the difference, called "undercharges." The estate of Quinn Freight Lines sought $187,923.36 from Primary Steel for 1,081 shipments, and on June 21, 1990, the Supreme Court held that the ICC could not excuse such bills. Congress answered with the Negotiated Rates Act of December 3, 1993, which let a shipper settle for 20% of the difference on shipments of 10,000 pounds or less and 15% on heavier ones, and freed small businesses and charities from paying at all.

    LessonA price that is agreed but not properly recorded can come back as a bill years later.

    law.cornell.edugovinfo.gov

    Credit

    US Supreme Court (Maislin Industries v. Primary Steel, 497 U.S. 116); US Congress (Public Law 103-180)

  3. 1998

    Unpaid truckers can bill shippers

    In France, a 1998 change to article L. 132-8 of the Commercial Code, known as the Gayssot direct action, made the shipper and the receiver guarantors of the price of carriage: the trucking company that actually moved the load can claim payment from either of them, and any contract clause to the contrary is void. When a freight intermediary (a commissionnaire de transport) fails, a shipper that has already paid it can be made to pay a second time. The French government said in 2009 that the rule was meant to protect road hauliers against the failure of the firms that hire them, and in 2012 it advised shippers to check the finances of those firms before contracting.

    LessonMaking the shipper the last payer moves the risk of an intermediary's failure onto the party that chose it.

    questions.assemblee-nationale.frquestions.assemblee-nationale.frcms.law

    Credit

    French Parliament; French transport ministry

  4. 2010

    Brazil bans freight vouchers

    For about five decades Brazilian shippers paid self-employed truckers with a "carta-frete," a voucher that could be cashed only at partner fuel stations, which usually made drivers spend around 30% of its value there and sometimes 50%, the trade magazine Mundo Logística reported. Law 12.249 of June 11, 2010, required freight payments to self-employed truckers to go into a bank account or another method approved by the land transport agency ANTT, and banned every other method; ANTT's Resolution 3,658 of April 19, 2011, set the rules and licensed electronic payment firms. ANTT said the vouchers kept truckers informal and unable to prove income for truck loans. In January 2012 ANTT postponed fines again. Since 2021 each payment must be recorded in an electronic transport document, the DT-e.

    LessonBanning a payment method took licensed replacements and repeated enforcement deadlines, not only a law.

    gov.brplanalto.gov.brcontabeis.com.brmundologistica.com.br

    Credit

    ANTT; Brazil's National Congress; nine truckers' groups whose 2009 manifesto, sent by the union Unicam, asked for the change

Watch for

  1. Broker records on request

    FMCSA proposed in November 2024 that brokers keep their transaction records electronically and give them to a shipper or carrier in the deal within 48 hours of a request, recasting the right to see them as a duty on the broker. The proposal drew nearly 7,000 comments, and Land Line, OOIDA's news outlet, reported in January 2026 that FMCSA planned a second proposal for May. A search of the Federal Register's records found no second proposal by November 20, 2026.

    Achieved whena final rule is in force and carriers report receiving records within 48 hours.

    federalregister.govlandline.media

    Claimed by

    FMCSA, November 2024

Open

  1. 01

    An open broker record format

    An open file format, with a checker and a generator of made-up loads, for the record a US broker must keep and show under 49 CFR 371.3: who shipped, who hauled, what the shipper paid, what the carrier was paid and what extra charges were added. Add converters from the export files of common broker software and from electronic invoice messages.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    Check bills against the deal

    A public test set of made-up loads, each with a rate confirmation (the broker's written offer to the carrier), the carrier's invoice and the records behind any extra charge, such as timestamped arrival and departure events or a receipt for paid unloading, all as plain text and data files. Plant errors in waiting-time (detention), overnight, unloading, fuel surcharge and cancelled-truck charges, and use the set to score AI models and audit software on catching each error and working out the right amount. The test is of the arithmetic and the reading of contract terms, not of reading photographed paper, which the Trucking and freight page's "Photographed freight papers test set" covers.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

An open broker record format

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An open file format, with a checker and a generator of made-up loads, for the record a US broker must keep and show under 49 CFR 371.3: who shipped, who hauled, what the shipper paid, what the carrier was paid and what extra charges were added. Add converters from the export files of common broker software and from electronic invoice messages.

Why it is still open

FMCSA's 2024 proposal would require electronic records within 48 hours but sets no file format. Brokers told FMCSA they already use email, spreadsheets, fax, EDI (computer-to-computer business messages) and web APIs. Commenters estimated $2,500 to $10,000 per carrier to set up electronic delivery, and TIA put the cost for a broker with 5,000 carriers at $12.5 million to $50 million. A search for an open format or API for these records found none.

federalregister.gov

Built with what exists

JSON Schema; Python; an AI model to map each broker's field names to the format, with a person checking every mapping (see the Note "The jobs agents repeat"); made-up company names only.

  1. First step

    List every data element named in the current rule and in the 2024 proposal, and write version 0.1 of the format from that list.

  2. Done looks like

    The format published with at least 500 made-up loads that pass its checker, converters for at least three export layouts supplied by brokers or published by software vendors, and a test in which 20 records from each converter are checked field by field against the source loads.

Open 02 · the brief

Check bills against the deal

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public test set of made-up loads, each with a rate confirmation (the broker's written offer to the carrier), the carrier's invoice and the records behind any extra charge, such as timestamped arrival and departure events or a receipt for paid unloading, all as plain text and data files. Plant errors in waiting-time (detention), overnight, unloading, fuel surcharge and cancelled-truck charges, and use the set to score AI models and audit software on catching each error and working out the right amount. The test is of the arithmetic and the reading of contract terms, not of reading photographed paper, which the Trucking and freight page's "Photographed freight papers test set" covers.

Why it is still open

Guides to the job describe auditors checking invoices against contracts, rate agreements and shipment records, and recommend software, but give no measured accuracy for it. FMCSA expects broker records to help settle "issues around service or payment." A search for a public test set for this job found none; one paid listing seen in search results could not be opened.

freightwaves.comfederalregister.gov

Built with what exists

Python to generate the loads and their event records; EIA's weekly diesel price for the fuel surcharges; small, low-cost models built for extraction and tool calls (see the Note "The jobs agents repeat"); repeated runs of each case to count how often a tool gets it right every time (see the Note "All twenty times").

  1. First step

    Write 50 loads by hand that cover detention and unloading disputes, and run one general-purpose AI model on them.

  2. Done looks like

    At least 1,000 made-up loads with at least 300 planted errors of at least six kinds, released openly with the answers, and a published table of catch rates and dollar errors for at least three tools, each run 20 times on every case.