BRENNEN

Industries / Technology / Software and SaaS / Field service software

Quotes and invoices

Pricing a job, writing the quote, and billing and collecting payment when the work is done.

5

Milestones achieved, from 2002 to 2026.

2

To watch for: announced, not yet confirmed outside.

2

Open deliverables. Nobody has shipped them.

The road

AchievedWatch forOpen

Achieved

  1. 2002

    Prices fixed before work

    Under flat-rate pricing the technician quotes a set price for the job from a price book before starting, instead of charging for hours and materials afterwards. Plumbing & Mechanical magazine calls Frank Blau "one of the industry's pioneers of flat rate pricing for residential service work". A 2000 column in the same magazine said fewer than 10% of contractors charged a flat rate. In a 2002 ACHR News survey of 1,500 subscribers, with a 36% response, one third favoured flat-rate pricing, and 34% of those used a national price book.

    pmmag.compmmag.comachrnews.com

    Credit

    Frank Blau

  2. 2012

    A price claim tested

    Washington State's Attorney General said that Dick's Heating and Air Conditioning, of Sumner, claimed its pricing gave customers lower prices when it charged more than competitors, using flat rates whatever the length of the job. Under a consent decree the firm must disclose its prices before work begins, and it paid $33,295 in costs and fees and $8,000 in penalties.

    LessonA set price is a claim, and the customer has to be able to see it and compare it before the work starts.

    atg.wa.gov

    Credit

    Washington State Office of the Attorney General

  3. 2019

    Invoices through the tax office

    From 1 January 2019 Italy required VAT-registered businesses to issue invoices electronically through the tax agency's exchange system, the SdI, including invoices to private consumers. In March 2025 the Council of the European Union adopted the VAT in the Digital Age package, which requires electronic invoicing and near real-time reporting for trade between EU countries from 1 July 2030.

    agenziaentrate.gov.itec.europa.eu

    Credit

    Agenzia delle Entrate, Italy's tax agency; Council of the European Union

  4. 2021

    Loans entered by the seller

    GreenSky's loans were offered at the point of sale by merchants, mostly home-improvement firms, which submitted applications for customers through GreenSky's website or app; the US Consumer Financial Protection Bureau said some entered their own email addresses as the customer's. The bureau counted at least 6,000 complaints from 2014 to 2019, ordered up to $9 million in refunds and cancellations, and fined GreenSky $2.5 million. In 2025 the Federal Trade Commission sent more than $2.9 million to 960 people harmed by Ygrene, whose door-to-door home-improvement contractors sold its financing with high-pressure tactics and, in some cases, forgery.

    LessonWhen the contractor's device fills in the customer's loan papers, the customer has to confirm them independently.

    consumerfinance.govconsumerfinancemonitor.comftc.gov

    Credit

    CFPB; FTC

  5. 2026

    Records behind each recommendation

    Pennsylvania prosecutors alleged that technicians at Gillece Services used warnings about gas leaks and cracked heat exchangers to persuade homeowners to authorize repairs. Under a consent order that admits no unlawful conduct, Gillece agreed to pay $700,000 in restitution and to "maintain detailed records supporting certain repair and replacement recommendations", to be shown to the Attorney General on request.

    LessonA quote for a repair can be required to carry its own evidence.

    mychesco.com

    Credit

    Pennsylvania Office of Attorney General

Watch for

  1. A 20% larger ticket

    ServiceTitan says that with Sales Pro, its app for quoting and selling in the customer's home, now called Field Pro, firms "saw a 20% increase in average tickets", the average invoice per job. It gives no period, baseline or sample.

    Achieved whenan outside party compares average invoices, cancellations and complaints at firms using it and at similar firms that do not.

    servicetitan.com

    Claimed by

    ServiceTitan, October 2025

  2. AI drafts the quote

    Jobber says its AI can "draft quotes for service pros to review". Housecall Pro launched invoicing by voice, so that, in the words of its co-founder Roland Ligtenberg, "you can bill while your hands are still dirty." Neither publishes how often the drafts are right.

    Achieved whenan outside party compares a sample of AI-drafted quotes and invoices with what the firms finally charged, and publishes how often the line items and totals were right.

    cleanfax.comachrnews.com

    Claimed by

    Jobber, September 2025; Housecall Pro, November 2025

Open

  1. 01

    AI quotes against real ones

    A public test that gives AI tools the same job descriptions and photos that real contractors quoted on, and compares the AI's price and line items with the contractors' quotes, in several countries.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed
  2. 02

    The record behind a recommendation

    An open format for the evidence a technician attaches to a repair or replacement recommendation (photos, readings, the equipment's model and age), a form that fills it in an existing field service app, and a blind test: two independent technicians, seeing only the record, say whether they agree with the call.

    The brief
    Credit · unclaimed

Open 01 · the brief

AI quotes against real ones

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

A public test that gives AI tools the same job descriptions and photos that real contractors quoted on, and compares the AI's price and line items with the contractors' quotes, in several countries.

Why it is still open

An Australian plumbing firm said in November 2026 that customers who priced jobs with AI got figures based on "American or British standards and pricing", at "only 50 to 70 per cent of the actual cost". Jobber and Housecall Pro publish no accuracy for their quote drafts. This research found no independent test.

region.com.augetjobber.com

Built with what exists

general AI models that read photos, from Anthropic, Google and OpenAI; Jobber's and Housecall Pro's quoting tools on trial accounts; real quotes collected from homeowners and contractors with their consent; a spreadsheet for scoring.

  1. First step

    Collect 20 recent quotes, with photos and descriptions, from friends and neighbours who agree to share them, and run them through three AI models.

  2. Done looks like

    200 jobs in at least three countries, each with at least two contractor quotes; for each AI tool, the median gap from the median contractor quote and the share of its quotes within 20% of it, with all prompts and answers published.

Open 02 · the brief

The record behind a recommendation

Credit · unclaimed

The first to publish is credited on this line, and the deliverable moves from Open to Achieved.

What to build

An open format for the evidence a technician attaches to a repair or replacement recommendation (photos, readings, the equipment's model and age), a form that fills it in an existing field service app, and a blind test: two independent technicians, seeing only the record, say whether they agree with the call.

Why it is still open

Regulators in Pennsylvania (2026) and Utah (2025, allegations not yet proven) have accused firms of pressing homeowners into repairs they did not need, and Pennsylvania's order requires one firm to keep records supporting its recommendations. This research found no shared format for such records and no test of whether they let an outsider check the call.

mychesco.comcommerce.utah.gov

Built with what exists

the custom forms and photo capture in field service apps; test instruments that send readings to a phone by Bluetooth; a JSON schema for the record; Cohen's kappa, a standard measure of how often two reviewers agree beyond chance.

  1. First step

    Draft the record for three common calls, such as replacing a capacitor, a water heater or a garbage disposal, and try it at one firm for a week.

  2. Done looks like

    200 real recommendations recorded at three or more firms, each reviewed blind by two technicians, with their agreement rate and kappa published and the format released under an open license.